SlowingoTata Bahasa
B2 6 / 30

Must Have, Can't Have, Might Have: Menduga Masa Lalu dalam Bahasa Inggris

Must Have, Can't Have, Might Have: Past Deduction

Di halaman ini
  1. Tujuan
  2. Ide Utama
  3. Bahasa Indonesia vs Bahasa Inggris
  4. Struktur
  5. Penggunaan
  6. Kesalahan Umum
  7. Jebakan bagi Penutur Bahasa Indonesia
  8. Jangan Tertukar
  9. Ejaan dan Pelafalan
  10. Aturan Emas
  11. Latihan

Tujuan

Setelah pelajaran ini, kamu bisa membuat dugaan yang logis tentang apa yang terjadi di masa lalu — must have (hampir pasti), can't / couldn't have (hampir pasti tidak), might / may / could have (mungkin), might not / may not have (mungkin tidak) — dan memakai bentuk continuous must have been doing.

Ide Utama

Pagi hari kamu membuka pintu dan melihat jejak kaki di salju yang masih baru, dari pagar ke pintumu lalu kembali lagi. Kamu tidak melihat siapa pun, tetapi kamu bisa menyimpulkannya: Someone must have come to the door during the night. (Pasti ada orang yang datang ke pintu tadi malam.)

Past deduction (dugaan tentang masa lalu) adalah tentang seberapa yakin kamu sekarang, berdasarkan bukti, tentang sesuatu yang tidak kamu lihat terjadi. Di B1-16 kamu membuat dugaan tentang masa sekarang: She must be at home. Untuk memindahkan dugaan itu ke masa lalu, pertahankan modal-nya dan tambahkan have + past participle.

Kedua bagian itu punya tugas yang berbeda. Modal menjawab “Seberapa yakin saya sekarang?”. Have + past participle menjawab “Kapan?” — sebelum sekarang. Hasilnya adalah skala keyakinan untuk masa lalu:

must have (hampir yakin: ya) → might / may / could have (mungkin) → might not / may not have (mungkin tidak) → can't / couldn't have (hampir yakin: tidak).

Bahasa Indonesia vs Bahasa Inggris

Bahasa Indonesia memakai kata yang sama untuk dugaan tentang sekarang dan masa lalu (pasti, mungkin, tidak mungkin), lalu menambahkan sudah, tadi, atau kemarin untuk menunjukkan waktu; kata kerjanya tidak berubah. Bahasa Inggris menunjukkan masa lalu di dalam bentuk kata kerjanya: modal + have + past participle. Satu hal lagi: pasti dan harus adalah dua kata yang berbeda dalam bahasa Indonesia, tetapi bahasa Inggris memakai must untuk keduanya. Dugaan tentang masa lalu adalah must have; kewajiban di masa lalu adalah had to.

Bahasa IndonesiaBahasa InggrisSeberapa yakin?
Mereka pasti sudah tidur.They must have gone to bed.hampir pasti ya
Dia mungkin tadi ke gym.She might have gone to the gym.mungkin
Mereka mungkin belum menerima pesan kita.They might not have received our message.mungkin tidak
Tidak mungkin dia yang mencuri uang itu.He can't have stolen the money.hampir pasti tidak
Kamu pasti habis menangis.You must have been crying.dugaan tentang kegiatan yang berlangsung
Dia harus lembur.She had to work late.bukan dugaan: kewajiban

Struktur

Pola dasar

SubjekModalhavePast participle
Shemusthaveforgottenour meeting.
Theycan'thaveseenus.
Hemighthavemissedthe bus.

Have tidak pernah berubah: selalu have, tidak pernah has atau had, karena letaknya sesudah modal.

Skala keyakinan

KeyakinanBentukContoh
hampir pasti: yamust have + past participleHe must have left early.
mungkin: yamight / may / could have + past participleHe might have left early.
mungkin: tidakmight not / may not have + past participleHe might not have heard the phone.
hampir pasti: tidakcan't / couldn't have + past participleHe can't have left — his coat is here.

Continuous dan pasif

BentukPolaContoh
continuousmodal + have been + -ingShe must have been sleeping.
pasifmodal + have been + past participleThe window might have been broken by the wind.

Kalimat tanya — pakai could atau might, atau ungkapan dengan do you think:

  • Could they have got lost? (US juga: gotten)
  • Where do you think she might have gone?

Penggunaan

1Must Have: Hampir Pasti Sudah Terjadi

Pakai must have kalau buktinya membuatmu hampir yakin bahwa sesuatu sudah terjadi.

The lights are off. They must have gone to bed.
Lampunya mati. Mereka pasti sudah tidur.
I can't find my wallet. I must have left it in the taxi.
Dompet saya tidak ada. Pasti ketinggalan di taksi.
bahasa Indonesia sering tanpa subjek; bahasa Inggris: I must have left it
The ground is white. It must have snowed all night.
Tanahnya putih. Pasti semalaman turun salju.
She looks exhausted — she must have had a long day.
Dia kelihatan capek sekali. Harinya pasti panjang dan melelahkan.
You must have been so proud when your daughter graduated.
Kamu pasti bangga sekali waktu putrimu lulus.
dugaan yang penuh simpati tentang perasaan

2Can't Have / Couldn't Have: Hampir Pasti Tidak Terjadi

Pakai can't have atau couldn't have kalau buktinya membuat sesuatu tampak mustahil. Keduanya umum; couldn't have lebih sering dipakai kalau seluruh ceritanya ada di masa lalu.

He can't have stolen the money — he was with me all evening.
Tidak mungkin dia yang mencuri uang itu; sepanjang malam dia bersama saya.
You can't have finished already! You only started ten minutes ago.
Masa kamu sudah selesai? Kamu baru mulai sepuluh menit yang lalu!
She couldn't have known about the surprise; nobody had told her.
Dia tidak mungkin tahu soal kejutan itu; tidak ada yang memberi tahu dia.
That can't have been Tom you saw. He's in Australia.
Yang kamu lihat itu tidak mungkin Tom. Dia sedang di Australia.

3Might / May / Could Have: Mungkin Sudah Terjadi

Pakai might have, may have, atau could have kalau sesuatu mungkin terjadi, tetapi kamu tidak yakin. May sedikit lebih formal. Untuk bentuk negatif, pakai might not have atau may not have (bukan couldn't have, yang berarti “tidak mungkin”).

I'm not sure where Jo is. She might have gone to the gym.
Saya tidak tahu Jo di mana. Mungkin dia tadi pergi ke gym.
The email may have gone into your spam folder.
Mungkin emailnya masuk ke folder spam.
Someone could have taken your umbrella by mistake.
Bisa jadi ada orang yang tidak sengaja membawa payungmu.
Could the parcel have been delivered to a neighbour?
Mungkinkah paketnya diantar ke tetangga?
kalimat tanya + pasif
They might not have received our message.
Mungkin mereka belum menerima pesan kita.
mungkin tidak: might not have

4Continuous: Must Have Been Doing

Pakai modal + have been + -ing untuk dugaan tentang kegiatan yang sedang berlangsung pada suatu saat di masa lalu, atau tentang kegiatan panjang yang menjelaskan apa yang kamu lihat sekarang.

Your eyes are red. You must have been crying.
Matamu merah. Kamu pasti habis menangis.
He didn't answer my call. He might have been driving.
Dia tidak mengangkat telepon saya. Mungkin waktu itu dia sedang menyetir.
sedang di masa lalu: might have been + -ing
She can't have been listening — she asked the same question twice.
Dia pasti tidak mendengarkan; dia menanyakan hal yang sama dua kali.
can't have = hampir pasti tidak
The neighbours must have been having a party; there's rubbish everywhere.
Tetangga pasti habis berpesta; sampah di mana-mana.
rubbish (UK) = trash, garbage (US)

Kesalahan Umum

❌He must went home.
✅He must have gone home.
Dugaan masa lalu: modal + have + past participle.
❌It must had rained.
✅It must have rained.
Sesudah modal selalu have, tidak pernah had.
❌You must have be tired.
✅You must have been tired.
been adalah past participle dari be.
❌He can have forgotten.
✅He may have forgotten. atau He could have forgotten.
can have tidak dipakai untuk dugaan positif tentang masa lalu.
❌Somebody must have stole it.
✅Somebody must have stolen it.
Pakai past participle, bukan past simple.
⚠️She mustn't have seen the message.
✅She can't have seen the message.
must not have dipakai dalam bahasa Inggris Amerika, tetapi mustn't have kurang umum dalam bahasa Inggris British, yang lebih memilih can't have; can't have wajar di mana saja.
⚠️They couldn't have been here. (maksudnya: mungkin mereka tidak di sini)
✅They might not have been here.
Benar secara tata bahasa, tetapi couldn't have = hampir pasti tidak; untuk “mungkin tidak”, pakai might not have.

Jebakan bagi Penutur Bahasa Indonesia

1. Pasti sudah → must already. Dalam bahasa Indonesia, sudah menunjukkan bahwa sesuatu terjadi sebelum sekarang. Pelajar sering menerjemahkannya dengan already dan membiarkan kata kerjanya dalam bentuk dasar. Dalam bahasa Inggris, waktu lampau ditunjukkan oleh have + past participle.

⚠️He must already go home.
✅He must have gone home.
Bentuknya mungkin, tetapi artinya kewajiban (“dia harus sudah pulang”), bukan dugaan tentang masa lalu.
❌He must already gone home.
✅He must have gone home.
have tidak boleh hilang; already tidak menggantikannya.

2. Pasti + kemarin tanpa have. Karena Dia pasti capek kemarin memakai kata yang sama dengan dugaan tentang sekarang, pelajar memakai pola masa sekarang dari B1-16 dengan keterangan waktu lampau.

❌She must be tired yesterday.
✅She must have been tired yesterday.
❌He must went home early.
✅He must have gone home early.

3. Harus dan pasti dalam satu kata. Kalau kamu ingin mengatakan bahwa seseorang harus melakukan sesuatu di masa lalu (kewajiban), bahasa Inggrisnya had to, bukan must have. Must have selalu berarti dugaan.

⚠️(maksudnya: dia wajib lembur) She must have worked late yesterday.
✅She had to work late yesterday.
Benar secara tata bahasa, tetapi artinya “dia pasti lembur” (dugaan), bukan kewajiban.

4. Bisa jadi → can have. Bisa jadi dia lupa membuat pelajar memakai can. Untuk dugaan positif tentang masa lalu, can have tidak dipakai.

❌He can have forgotten.
✅He could have forgotten. atau He may have forgotten.

5. Mungkin tidak → couldn't have. Couldn't have jauh lebih kuat daripada mungkin tidak: artinya “tidak mungkin”.

⚠️(maksudnya: mungkin dia tidak dengar) He couldn't have heard the phone.
✅He might not have heard the phone.
Benar secara tata bahasa, tetapi artinya “dia tidak mungkin mendengarnya”.

Jangan Tertukar

must have done dan had to do — Must have adalah dugaan tentang masa lalu; had to adalah kewajiban di masa lalu. Lihat A2-20.

She must have worked late.
Dia pasti lembur.
saya kira begitu
She had to work late.
Dia harus lembur.
memang wajib

might not have dan can't have — kekuatannya berbeda.

He might not have got my text.
Mungkin dia belum menerima pesan saya.
mungkin tidak
He can't have got my text — his phone was off.
Tidak mungkin dia sudah menerima pesan saya; ponselnya mati.
pasti tidak

could have: dugaan dan sesuatu yang tidak terjadi — could have dan might have juga bisa menggambarkan kemungkinan yang kita tahu tidak terjadi, atau mengkritik seseorang. Lihat B1-09.

The keys could have fallen out of your bag.
Bisa jadi kuncinya jatuh dari tasmu.
dugaan: mungkin itu yang terjadi
You could have been hurt!
Kamu bisa saja terluka!
mungkin saja, tetapi kamu tidak terluka
You could have told me you were coming!
Kamu kan bisa bilang kalau mau datang!
kritik: kamu tidak bilang

dugaan sekarang dan dugaan masa lalu — sekarang: modal + base form B1-16; masa lalu: modal + have + past participle.

She must be at work.
Dia pasti sedang di kantor.
sekarang
She must have been at work.
Tadi dia pasti di kantor.
sebelumnya

Ejaan dan Pelafalan

  • have dalam pola ini diucapkan lemah: /əv/, kira-kira “ev” dengan e seperti dalam besar. must have → /ˈmʌstəv/ “MAS-tev”; might have → /ˈmaɪtəv/ “MAI-tev”; could have → /ˈkʊdəv/ “KU-dev”; can't have → /ˈkɑːntəv/ (UK), /ˈkæntəv/ (US). Jangan mengucapkan have dengan penuh dan keras seperti “hef”.
  • Dalam percakapan cepat, t dalam must've sering hilang: /ˈmʌsəv/, “MA-sev”.
  • Tulislah must've, might've, could've hanya dalam tulisan informal. Jangan pernah menulis must of, might of, could of: bunyinya sama, tetapi salah.
  • been dalam pola ini juga lemah: /bɪn/, pendek seperti “bin”. must have been terdengar seperti “MAS-tev-bin”.
  • Ucapkan akhir past participle dengan jelas: must have stopped /stɒpt/, might have missed /mɪst/. Penutur bahasa Indonesia sering menghilangkan bunyi /t/ atau /d/ di akhir kata, sehingga must have missed terdengar seperti must have miss.

Aturan Emas

Dugaan tentang masa lalu = modal + have + past participle. Pilih modal-nya sesuai keyakinanmu: must (hampir yakin: ya), might / may / could (mungkin), might not / may not (mungkin tidak), can't / couldn't (hampir yakin: tidak). Jangan menerjemahkan sudah dengan already: masa lalunya ada di have + past participle.

Latihan

A. Bentuk

Lengkapi dengan bentuk yang benar dari kata dalam kurung, atau tulis ulang sesuai petunjuk.

  1. The door's open. Someone (must forget) to lock it.
  2. She (can't see) me — I was hiding behind the tree.
  3. I'm not sure. He (might miss) the train.
  4. You're covered in paint! You (must decorate) all day.
  5. Tulis ulang dengan may have: Perhaps the meeting was cancelled.
  6. Tulis ulang dengan couldn't have: It's impossible that she drove — she doesn't have a car.

B. Makna

Pilih jawaban yang sesuai dengan maknanya.

  1. Pilih jawaban yang benar: He passed the exam easily. He … have studied a lot.
  2. Pilih jawaban yang benar: She speaks no English. She … have written this letter in perfect English.
  3. Pilih jawaban yang benar: I don't know why Leo is late. He … have overslept.
  4. Mungkin Kate tidak melihat papan itu. Pilih jawaban yang benar: Kate … have seen the sign.
  5. Kalimat mana yang tentang kewajiban, bukan dugaan?

C. Temukan Kesalahan

Perbaiki kesalahannya. Kalau kalimatnya sudah benar, tulis correct.

  1. They must had a great time at the wedding.
  2. Somebody might have took my seat.
  3. He can have forgotten our appointment.
  4. The thief must have come in through the window.

D. Dalam Konteks

Lengkapi percakapan dengan modal dalam kurung + have + past participle.

Kulkas yang Kosong
Dad: Who ate all the cheese? It was here this morning.
Eva: Don't look at me! I 16 (can't / eat) it — I was at school all day.
Dad: Then your brother 17 (must / take) it. He came home at lunchtime.
Eva: Or the cat 18 (might / get) into the fridge again.
Dad: The cat can't open the fridge, Eva!
Eva: Well, you 19 (might not / close) it properly this morning.
Dad: Hmm. And who 20 (could / leave) these crumbs everywhere?

E. Giliranmu

Tulis dugaanmu dalam bahasa Inggris.

  1. Temanmu tidak datang ke pestamu dan tidak menelepon. Tulis dua dugaan: satu dengan might have dan satu dengan must have.
  2. Kamu pulang dan jendela dapur pecah. Tulis satu dugaan dengan can't have dan satu dengan must have been + -ing.

F. Ulasan Campuran

Ulangi materi dari pelajaran sebelumnya.

  1. B1-16 Must Be, Can't Be, Might Be: Menebak dengan Logika dalam Bahasa Inggris
    Her car isn't outside. She ___ … be at home.
  2. B1-09 Should Have, Could Have, Might Have dalam Bahasa Inggris: Menyesal dan Mengkritik
    I failed the test. I (study) harder.
  3. B2-04 Wish, If Only, dan Regret dalam Bahasa Inggris: Menyesali Masa Lalu
    I wish I (not eat) that last piece of cake.
  4. B2-05 Would Rather, Had Better, dan Prefer dalam Bahasa Inggris: Lebih Suka dan Lebih Baik
    It's going to rain. You'd better (take) an umbrella.
Kunci jawaban

A. Bentuk

  1. must have forgotten
  2. can't have seen / cannot have seen
  3. might have missed
  4. must have been decorating
  5. The meeting may have been cancelled.
  6. She couldn't have driven — she doesn't have a car. / She couldn't have driven because she doesn't have a car. / She couldn't have driven; she doesn't have a car. / She couldn't have driven. She doesn't have a car. / She couldn't have driven, because she doesn't have a car.

B. Makna

  1. must
  2. can't
  3. might
  4. might not
  5. She had to leave early.

C. Temukan Kesalahan

  1. They must have had a great time at the wedding.
  2. Somebody might have taken my seat.
  3. He may have forgotten our appointment. / He might have forgotten our appointment. / He could have forgotten our appointment. / He must have forgotten our appointment. / He can't have forgotten our appointment.
  4. ✓ The thief must have come in through the window.

D. Dalam Konteks

  1. can't have eaten / couldn't have eaten
  2. must have taken
  3. might have got / might have gotten
  4. might not have closed
  5. could have left

E. Giliranmu

  1. She might have forgotten the date. She must have been very busy at work.
  2. It can't have been the wind — there was no wind last night. The kids next door must have been playing football again.

F. Ulasan Campuran

  1. can't
  2. should have studied / ought to have studied
  3. hadn't eaten
  4. take
Aplikasi AndroidBelajar Di Mana Saja Google Play