SlowingoGramatika
B2 6 / 30

Must have, can't have, might have: nagađanje o prošlosti na engleskom

Must Have, Can't Have, Might Have: Past Deduction

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete logično nagađati o tome što se dogodilo u prošlosti – must have (gotovo sigurno), can't / couldn't have (gotovo sigurno nije), might / may / could have (moguće), might not / may not have (možda nije) – i upotrijebiti oblik u tijeku must have been doing.

Osnovna ideja

Ujutro otvorite vrata i vidite tragove u svježem snijegu, od vrtnih vrata do vaših vrata i natrag. Niste nikoga vidjeli, ali možete zaključiti: Someone must have come to the door during the night.

Nagađanje o prošlosti govori o tome koliko ste sada sigurni, na temelju dokaza, u nešto što niste vidjeli da se dogodilo. U B1-16 nagađali ste o sadašnjosti: She must be at home. Da nagađanje premjestite u prošlost, zadržite modalni glagol i dodajte have + particip prošli.

Ta dva dijela imaju dva različita zadatka. Modalni glagol odgovara na pitanje „Koliko sam siguran sada?“. Have + particip prošli odgovara na pitanje „Kada?“ – prije sada. Tako dobivate ljestvicu sigurnosti za prošlost:

must have (gotovo sigurno: da) → might / may / could have (možda) → might not / may not have (možda nije) → can't / couldn't have (gotovo sigurno: ne).

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski nagađanje o prošlosti izriče riječima i perfektom: „Mora da je otišao“, „Sigurno je otišao“, „Možda je otišao“, „Sigurno nije otišao“. Glagol je običan perfekt („otišao je“), a sigurnost nosi riječ ispred njega. Zato se u engleskoj rečenici lako pojavi Past Simple (jednostavno prošlo vrijeme) iza modalnog glagola: must went. Engleski prošlost pokazuje dijelom have + particip prošli, a modalni glagol ostaje isti.

Hrvatsko „nije mogao“ ima dva značenja: „nije bio u stanju“ i „nemoguće je da je…“. Engleski ih razdvaja: He couldn't open the door (nije uspio) ili He can't have opened the door (zaključujem da nije). Slično vrijedi za „mogao je“ – za nagađanje treba could / might have.

„Mora da nije“ prevodi se kao can't have, a ne mustn't have – baš kao u sadašnjosti (B1-16).

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Mora da su legli. Svjetla su ugašena.The lights are off. They must have gone to bed.„mora da“ + perfekt → must have + particip prošli
Sigurno sam ga ostavio u taksiju.I must have left it in the taxi.„sigurno“ + perfekt → must have
Nije mogao ukrasti novac, bio je sa mnom.He can't have stolen the money — he was with me all evening.zaključak „nemoguće“ → can't have
E-mail je možda završio u neželjenoj pošti.The email may have gone into your spam folder.„možda“ + perfekt → may / might have
Možda nisu dobili našu poruku.They might not have received our message.„možda nije“ → might not have
Oči su ti crvene. Sigurno si plakala.Your eyes are red. You must have been crying.dugotrajna radnja → must have been + -ing
Morala je raditi do kasno.She had to work late.ovdje je isto: obveza → had to, a ne nagađanje

Ukratko: „mora da je / sigurno je…“ = must have; „možda je…“ = might / may / could have; „sigurno nije / nije mogao (zaključak)“ = can't / couldn't have; iza modalnog glagola uvijek have + particip prošli.

Oblik

Osnovni obrazac

SubjektModalni glagolhaveParticip prošli
Shemusthaveforgottenour meeting.
Theycan'thaveseenus.
Hemighthavemissedthe bus.

Have se nikad ne mijenja: uvijek je have, nikad has ni had, jer stoji iza modalnog glagola.

Ljestvica sigurnosti

SigurnostOblikPrimjer
gotovo sigurno: damust have + particip prošliHe must have left early.
moguće: damight / may / could have + particip prošliHe might have left early.
moguće: nemight not / may not have + particip prošliHe might not have heard the phone.
gotovo sigurno: necan't / couldn't have + particip prošliHe can't have left — his coat is here.

Oblik u tijeku i pasiv

OblikObrazacPrimjer
u tijekumodalni glagol + have been + -ingShe must have been sleeping.
pasivmodalni glagol + have been + particip prošliThe window might have been broken by the wind.

Pitanja – upotrijebite could ili might, ili izraz s do you think:

  • Could they have got lost? (US i: gotten)
  • Where do you think she might have gone?

Uporaba

1Must have – gotovo sigurno se dogodilo

Must have upotrijebite kad ste na temelju dokaza gotovo sigurni da se nešto dogodilo. Na hrvatskom: „mora da je…“, „sigurno je…“.

The lights are off. They must have gone to bed.
Svjetla su ugašena. Mora da su legli.
„mora da“ + perfekt → must have gone
I can't find my wallet. I must have left it in the taxi.
Ne mogu naći novčanik. Sigurno sam ga ostavio u taksiju.
The ground is white. It must have snowed all night.
Tlo je bijelo. Mora da je cijelu noć padao snijeg.
She looks exhausted — she must have had a long day.
Izgleda iscrpljeno, sigurno je imala naporan dan.
You must have been so proud when your daughter graduated.
Sigurno ste bili jako ponosni kad je vaša kći diplomirala.
suosjećajno nagađanje o osjećajima

2Can't have / couldn't have – gotovo sigurno se nije dogodilo

Can't have ili couldn't have upotrijebite kad se na temelju dokaza nešto čini nemogućim. Oba su česta; couldn't have je uobičajeniji kad je cijela priča u prošlosti. Hrvatsko „nije mogao“ ovdje znači zaključak, a ne nesposobnost.

He can't have stolen the money — he was with me all evening.
Nije mogao ukrasti novac, cijelu je večer bio sa mnom.
zaključak, a ne sposobnost
You can't have finished already! You only started ten minutes ago.
Nemoguće da si već gotov! Počeo si prije samo deset minuta.
iznenađenje: to je nemoguće
She couldn't have known about the surprise; nobody had told her.
Nije mogla znati za iznenađenje, nitko joj nije rekao.
priča u prošlosti → couldn't have
That can't have been Tom you saw. He's in Australia.
Onaj koga si vidio sigurno nije bio Tom. On je u Australiji.
„sigurno nije“ → can't have been

3Might / may / could have – možda se dogodilo

Might have, may have ili could have upotrijebite kad je nešto moguće, ali niste sigurni – kao „možda je…“ ili „mogao je…“. May je malo formalniji. Za niječno značenje upotrijebite might not have ili may not have (ne couldn't have, koji znači „nemoguće“).

I'm not sure where Jo is. She might have gone to the gym.
Nisam siguran gdje je Jo. Možda je otišla u teretanu.
The email may have gone into your spam folder.
E-mail je možda završio u neželjenoj pošti.
may: malo formalnije
Someone could have taken your umbrella by mistake.
Netko je mogao greškom uzeti tvoj kišobran.
„mogao je“ kao nagađanje → could have taken
Could the parcel have been delivered to a neighbour?
Je li paket možda dostavljen susjedu?
pitanje + pasiv
They might not have received our message.
Možda nisu dobili našu poruku.
možda nije

4Oblik u tijeku – must have been doing

Modalni glagol + have been + -ing upotrijebite za nagađanje o radnji koja je bila u tijeku u nekom trenutku u prošlosti, ili o dugotrajnoj aktivnosti koja objašnjava ono što sada vidite. Hrvatski perfekt („plakala si“, „vozio je“) to ne pokazuje posebnim oblikom, pa razmislite o značenju.

Your eyes are red. You must have been crying.
Oči su ti crvene. Sigurno si plakala.
dugotrajna radnja objašnjava ono što vidim
He didn't answer my call. He might have been driving.
Nije se javio na mobitel. Možda je baš vozio.
radnja u tijeku u trenutku poziva
She can't have been listening — she asked the same question twice.
Sigurno nije slušala, dvaput je postavila isto pitanje.
The neighbours must have been having a party; there's rubbish everywhere.
Susjedi su sigurno imali zabavu, posvuda je smeće.
rubbish (UK) = trash, garbage (US)

Česte pogreške

❌He must went home.
✅He must have gone home.
Nagađanje o prošlosti: modalni glagol + have + particip prošli.
❌It must had rained.
✅It must have rained.
Iza modalnog glagola uvijek have, nikad had.
❌You must have be tired.
✅You must have been tired.
been je particip prošli glagola be.
❌He can have forgotten.
✅He may have forgotten. ili He could have forgotten.
can have se ne upotrebljava za potvrdno nagađanje o prošlosti.
❌Somebody must have stole it.
✅Somebody must have stolen it.
Upotrijebite particip prošli, a ne Past Simple.
⚠️She mustn't have seen the message.
✅She can't have seen the message.
must not have upotrebljava se u američkom engleskom, ali mustn't have je u britanskom engleskom rjeđi; ondje se više voli can't have, a can't have prolazi svugdje.
⚠️They couldn't have been here. (meaning: maybe they weren't)
✅They might not have been here.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali couldn't have = gotovo sigurno nije; za „možda nije“ upotrijebite might not have.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Mora da je ostavio…“ → must + Past Simple. U hrvatskom sigurnost nosi „mora da“ ili „sigurno“, a glagol je običan perfekt. Kad se to prenese u engleski, iza must stane Past Simple. Iza modalnog glagola prošlost se izriče samo s have + particip prošli.

❌Marko must left his phone charger in the apartment in Zadar, because it isn't in any of his bags.
✅Marko must have left his phone charger in the apartment in Zadar, because it isn't in any of his bags.
must have + particip prošli

2. „Mora da nije čuo…“ → mustn't have. Iz „mora da je“ učenici izvedu „mora da nije“ i prevedu ga s mustn't have. U američkom engleskom čuje se must not have, ali u britanskom se za „sigurno nije“ normalno kaže can't have – a can't have prolazi svugdje.

⚠️Our neighbour mustn't have heard the doorbell, because the television in his living room was so loud.
✅Our neighbour can't have heard the doorbell, because the television in his living room was so loud. ili Our neighbour couldn't have heard the doorbell, because the television in his living room was so loud.
Gramatički je ispravno (čuje se u američkom engleskom), ali za „sigurno nije“ siguran izbor je can't have.

3. „Nije mogao…“ (zaključak) → couldn't + osnovni oblik. Hrvatsko „nije mogao“ znači i „nije bio u stanju“ i „nemoguće je da je“. He couldn't do it na engleskom znači samo „nije uspio, nije bio u stanju“. Kad iz dokaza zaključujete da se nešto nije dogodilo, treba can't have / couldn't have + particip prošli.

⚠️Nika couldn't write that angry comment under my photo, because she was on a plane to Dublin at the time.
✅Nika can't have written that angry comment under my photo, because she was on a plane to Dublin at the time. ili Nika couldn't have written that angry comment under my photo, because she was on a plane to Dublin at the time.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali znači „nije bila u stanju napisati“, a ne zaključak „sigurno nije ona napisala“.

4. „Sigurno je gledao utakmicu kad sam ga nazvao“ → must have watched. Hrvatski perfekt „gledao je“ ne pokazuje posebnim oblikom je li radnja bila u tijeku baš u tom trenutku. Must have watched zvuči kao završena radnja. Za radnju u tijeku u nekom trenutku engleski ima must have been + -ing.

⚠️When I rang Jakov at nine, he must have watched the basketball game, because I could hear the commentator shouting.
✅When I rang Jakov at nine, he must have been watching the basketball game, because I could hear the commentator shouting.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali opisuje završenu radnju; za radnju u tijeku u trenutku poziva treba must have been watching.

Ne miješajte

must have done i had to do – must have je nagađanje o prošlosti („mora da je…“); had to je obveza u prošlosti („morala je…“). Pogledajte A2-20.

She must have worked late.
Mora da je radila do kasno.
mislim da jest
She had to work late.
Morala je raditi do kasno.
bilo je potrebno

might not have i can't have – važna je jačina.

He might not have got my text.
Možda nije dobio moju poruku.
možda nije
He can't have got my text — his phone was off.
Sigurno nije dobio moju poruku, mobitel mu je bio isključen.
sigurno nije

could have: nagađanje ili nešto što se nije dogodilo – could have i might have mogu opisivati i mogućnost za koju znamo da se nije ostvarila, ili kritizirati nekoga. Pogledajte B1-09.

The keys could have fallen out of your bag.
Ključevi su ti možda ispali iz torbe.
nagađanje: možda se to dogodilo
You could have been hurt!
Mogao si se ozlijediti!
bilo je moguće, ali nisi se ozlijedio
You could have told me you were coming!
Mogao si mi reći da dolaziš!
kritika: nisi mi rekao

nagađanje o sadašnjosti i o prošlosti – sadašnjost: modalni glagol + osnovni oblik (B1-16); prošlost: modalni glagol + have + particip prošli.

She must be at work.
Sigurno je na poslu.
sada
She must have been at work.
Sigurno je bila na poslu.
ranije

Pravopis i izgovor

  • have je u ovim strukturama slab: /əv/. must have → /ˈmʌstəv/; might have → /ˈmaɪtəv/; could have → /ˈkʊdəv/; can't have → /ˈkɑːntəv/ (UK), /ˈkæntəv/ (US). Hrvatski svaki samoglasnik izgovara punim glasom, pa je ovaj kratki, opušteni /ə/ težak: usta su jedva otvorena, a h se gubi.
  • U brzom govoru t u must've često nestane: /ˈmʌsəv/.
  • must've, might've, could've pišite samo u neformalnom tekstu. Nikad ne pišite must of, might of, could of: zvuče isto, ali su pogrešni.
  • been je u ovim strukturama slab: /bɪn/, kratko i – a ne dugo /iː/.
  • /ʌ/ u must nov je glas: kratak, sličan kratkom hrvatskom a, ali usta su malo manje otvorena. Slovo u ovdje ne čitajte kao hrvatsko u.

Zlatno pravilo

Nagađanje o prošlosti = modalni glagol + have + particip prošli. Modalni glagol birajte prema tome koliko ste sigurni: must (gotovo sigurno: da), might / may / could (možda), might not / may not (možda nije), can't / couldn't (gotovo sigurno: ne). I zapamtite: „mora da je otišao“ nije must went, nego must have gone.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite rečenice glagolima iz zagrade u točnom obliku.

  1. The door's open. Someone (must forget) to lock it.
  2. She (can't see) me — I was hiding behind the tree.
  3. I'm not sure. He (might miss) the train.
  4. You're covered in paint! You (must decorate) all day.
  5. Preoblikujte rečenicu tako da upotrijebite may have: Perhaps the meeting was cancelled.
  6. Preoblikujte rečenicu tako da upotrijebite couldn't have: It's impossible that she drove — she doesn't have a car.

B. Značenje

Odaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. Odaberite točan odgovor: He passed the exam easily. He … have studied a lot.
  2. Odaberite točan odgovor: She speaks no English. She … have written this letter in perfect English.
  3. Odaberite točan odgovor: I don't know why Leo is late. He … have overslept.
  4. Možda Kate nije vidjela znak. Odaberite točan odgovor: Kate … have seen the sign.
  5. Koja rečenica govori o obvezi, a ne o nagađanju?

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. They must had a great time at the wedding.
  2. Somebody might have took my seat.
  3. He can have forgotten our appointment.
  4. The thief must have come in through the window.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite razgovor riječima iz zagrade u točnom obliku.

The empty fridge
Dad: Who ate all the cheese? It was here this morning.
Eva: Don't look at me! I 16 (can't / eat) it — I was at school all day.
Dad: Then your brother 17 (must / take) it. He came home at lunchtime.
Eva: Or the cat 18 (might / get) into the fridge again.
Dad: The cat can't open the fridge, Eva!
Eva: Well, you 19 (might not / close) it properly this morning.
Dad: Hmm. And who 20 (could / leave) these crumbs everywhere?

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom svoja nagađanja o prošlosti.

  1. Prijateljica nije došla na vašu zabavu i nije se javila. Napišite dva nagađanja: jedno s might have, a jedno s must have.
  2. Dolazite kući i kuhinjski prozor je razbijen. Napišite jedno nagađanje s can't have i jedno s must have been + -ing.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. B1-16 Must be, can't be, might be: zaključivanje o sadašnjosti na engleskom
    Her car isn't outside. She ___ … be at home.
  2. B1-09 Should have, could have, might have: žaljenje i kritika na engleskom
    I failed the test. I (study) harder.
  3. B2-04 I wish I had… i regret: žaljenje za prošlošću na engleskom
    I wish I (not eat) that last piece of cake.
  4. B2-05 Would rather, had better i prefer: radije bih i bolje da na engleskom
    It's going to rain. You'd better (take) an umbrella.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. must have forgotten
  2. can't have seen / cannot have seen
  3. might have missed
  4. must have been decorating
  5. The meeting may have been cancelled.
  6. She couldn't have driven — she doesn't have a car. / She couldn't have driven because she doesn't have a car. / She couldn't have driven; she doesn't have a car. / She couldn't have driven. She doesn't have a car. / She couldn't have driven, because she doesn't have a car.

B. Značenje

  1. must
  2. can't
  3. might
  4. might not
  5. She had to leave early.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. They must have had a great time at the wedding.
  2. Somebody might have taken my seat.
  3. He may have forgotten our appointment. / He might have forgotten our appointment. / He could have forgotten our appointment. / He must have forgotten our appointment. / He can't have forgotten our appointment.
  4. ✓ The thief must have come in through the window.

D. U kontekstu

  1. can't have eaten / couldn't have eaten
  2. must have taken
  3. might have got / might have gotten
  4. might not have closed
  5. could have left

E. Vaš red

  1. She might have forgotten the date. She must have been very busy at work.
  2. It can't have been the wind — there was no wind last night. The kids next door must have been playing football again.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. can't
  2. should have studied / ought to have studied
  3. hadn't eaten
  4. take
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play