SlowingoGramatika
B2 7 / 30

Need, needn't have i be supposed to: obveza i potreba na engleskom

Need, Needn't Have, Be Supposed To: Obligation in Depth

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete reći što je potrebno, a što nije (need to, don't need to, needn't), reći da prošla radnja nije bila potrebna (needn't have done i didn't need to do), govoriti o očekivanjima i pravilima koja ljudi često krše (be supposed to), upotrijebiti formalnu obvezu (be required to, be obliged to) i birati između should, need to, have to i must.

Osnovna ideja

U A2-20 naučili ste must, have to, mustn't i don't have to. Stvarne obveze imaju mnogo nijansi, pa si postavite dva pitanja:

  1. Koliko je jaka? Savjet, potreba ili pravilo s posljedicama?
  2. Odakle dolazi? Od vas, iz pravila ili zakona, ili samo iz onoga što ljudi očekuju?

Zamislite toplomjer. Na dnu je should – preporuka. Više je need to – potrebno da se postigne neki rezultat. Zatim have to i must – prava obveza. Na vrhu su be required to i be obliged to – pravila, zakoni i ugovori.

Pokraj toplomjera stoji poseban znak: be supposed to. Kaže što se očekuje – i često nagovješćuje da se to ne radi.

I na kraju, need ima trik u prošlosti. I needn't have taken a taxi znači da sam uzeo taksi, a bilo je nepotrebno. I didn't need to take a taxi obično znači da ga nisam uzeo.

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski glagol trebati pokriva gotovo cijelu ovu lekciju. „Trebam produžiti putovnicu“ je need to, a „ne trebaš donositi ništa“ je don't need to / needn't. U prošlosti je hrvatski višeznačan: „Nisi trebao kupiti poklon“ može značiti „bilo je nepotrebno“ (needn't have bought) i „bilo je pogrešno“ (shouldn't have bought). Engleski ta dva značenja razdvaja.

I hrvatsko „nisam trebao“ ne kaže je li se radnja dogodila. Engleski to pokazuje oblikom: needn't have taken (uzeo sam, a nije trebalo) ili didn't need to take (nije trebalo, pa obično nisam).

Za dogovor ili plan koji se nije ostvario kažemo „trebao sam se naći sa Samom u šest“. To nije obveza (had to), nego was supposed to. Za pravila: „ne bi se smjelo jesti u knjižnici“ ili „ovdje se ne smije parkirati“ – na engleskom često you're not supposed to.

Formalno, „zaposlenici su dužni…“ ili „od putnika se traži da…“ odgovara izrazima be obliged to i be required to, s osobom kao subjektom.

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Trebam završiti izvještaj do petka.I need to finish this report before Friday.ovdje je isto: potreba → need to
Ne trebate izuvati cipele.You don't need to take your shoes off.nije potrebno → don't need to / needn't
Nisam trebao kuhati toliko, pola gostiju nije došlo.I needn't have cooked so much — half the guests didn't come.kuhao sam, a nije trebalo → needn't have + particip prošli
Nije trebalo rezervirati, restoran je bio gotovo prazan.We didn't need to book; the restaurant was almost empty.nismo rezervirali → didn't need to
Trebao sam se naći sa Samom u šest, ali sam zaboravio.I was supposed to meet Sam at six, but I forgot.plan koji se nije ostvario → was supposed to
Za vrijeme ispita ne smijete upotrebljavati mobitel.You're not supposed to use your phone during the exam.pravilo → not supposed to
Putnici su dužni pokazati valjanu kartu.Passengers are required to show a valid ticket.osoba je subjekt + are required to

Ukratko: „trebam“ = need to; „ne trebaš“ = don't need to / needn't; „nisam trebao (a jesam)“ = needn't have done; „trebao sam (po dogovoru)“ = was supposed to; „dužni su / traži se od…“ = be required / obliged to.

Oblik

Need (sadašnjost)

OblikVrstaPrimjer
need to + osnovni oblikobičan glagol (sva vremena)You need to renew your passport.
don't / doesn't need to + osnovni oblikobičan glagol, niječnoYou don't need to bring anything.
needn't + osnovni oblik (bez to, bez -s)modalni glagol; uglavnom UK, malo formalnoYou needn't bring anything.
Do I need to…?pitanjeDo I need to book?

Nepotrebne prošle radnje: dva obrasca

ObrazacJe li se dogodilo?Primjer
needn't have + particip prošliDa – ali nije bilo potrebno.I needn't have taken a taxi. (Uzeo sam ga.)
didn't need to + osnovni oblikObično ne – nije bilo potrebno, pa nisam.I didn't need to take a taxi. (Obično: nisam.)

Needn't have je uglavnom britanski. Američki engleski obično kaže didn't need to ili didn't have to u obje situacije, a kontekst pokazuje značenje. Didn't need to može opisivati i radnju koja se dogodila ako je to jasno iz konteksta.

Be supposed to

Primjer
sadašnjost +We're supposed to check in by three.
sadašnjost −You're not supposed to park here.
sadašnjost ?What are we supposed to do with these forms?
prošlost +He was supposed to call me. (Nije nazvao.)
prošlost −You weren't supposed to open it! (Otvorio si.)

Formalna obveza

OblikPrimjer
be required to + osnovni oblikStaff are required to wear ID badges.
be obliged to + osnovni oblikLandlords are obliged to carry out repairs.

Ljestvica jačine

Slabo → jakoZnačenjePrimjer
should / ought tosavjet, ono što je ispravnoYou should back up your files.
need topotrebno za rezultatYou need to back up your files before the update.
have tovanjsko pravilo ili situacijaWe have to back up all files on Fridays — it's company policy.
mustjako; osjećaj govornika ili pisano praviloAll files must be backed up daily.
be required to / be obliged toformalno, službenoEmployees are required to back up all files.

Uporaba

1Need to, don't need to, needn't

Need to izriče potrebu – ono što je potrebno da se postigne rezultat, kao „trebati“. Don't need to i needn't znače da radnja nije potrebna (možete je učiniti ako želite) – „ne trebaš“. Needn't je modalni glagol: bez to, bez -s. Uglavnom je britanski i malo formalan; don't need to čest je posvuda.

I need to finish this report before Friday.
Trebam završiti ovaj izvještaj do petka.
potrebno za rezultat
You don't need to take your shoes off.
Ne trebate izuvati cipele.
nije potrebno
You needn't worry — everything's under control.
Ne trebate se brinuti, sve je pod kontrolom.
uglavnom UK, malo formalno; iza needn't nema to
Does she need to bring her passport?
Treba li ponijeti putovnicu?
We'll need to leave early to avoid the traffic.
Trebat ćemo krenuti rano da izbjegnemo gužvu.
need to u budućnosti: will need to

2Needn't have i didn't need to – nepotrebne prošle radnje

Needn't have + particip prošli: učinili ste nešto, a onda shvatili da nije bilo potrebno – uzaludan trud. Didn't need to + osnovni oblik: nije bilo potrebno i obično to niste učinili. Hrvatsko „nisam trebao“ ne pokazuje tu razliku, pa pazite na kontekst.

I needn't have cooked so much — half the guests didn't come.
Nisam trebao kuhati toliko, pola gostiju nije došlo.
kuhao sam
You needn't have bought me a present!
Nisi mi trebao kupiti poklon!
ali hvala ti
We didn't need to book; the restaurant was almost empty.
Nije trebalo rezervirati, restoran je bio gotovo prazan.
nismo rezervirali
I didn't need to wake up early, so I slept until ten.
Nije bilo potrebe da rano ustanem, pa sam spavao do deset.
nisam rano ustao
I didn't need to take the exam again, but I took it anyway to improve my grade.
Nije bilo potrebe da ponovno polažem ispit, ali sam ga ipak polagao da popravim ocjenu.
kontekst pokazuje da sam ga polagao

3Be supposed to – očekivanja i pravila (koja se često krše)

Be supposed to kaže što se od nekoga očekuje zbog pravila, dogovora ili onoga što je uobičajeno. Često nagovješćuje da se očekivanje ne ispunjava. Not supposed to = protivno pravilima, nije dopušteno. U prošlosti was / were supposed to opisuje plan ili očekivanje koje se nije ostvarilo – naše „trebao sam…“, „trebalo je…“.

I'm supposed to be on a diet, but I couldn't say no to cake.
Trebala bih biti na dijeti, ali nisam mogla odbiti kolač.
očekivanje koje ne ispunjavam
You're not supposed to use your phone during the exam.
Za vrijeme ispita ne smijete upotrebljavati mobitel.
pravilo
You're supposed to take this medicine with food.
Ovaj lijek treba uzimati uz hranu.
pravilan način uporabe
The parcel was supposed to arrive yesterday.
Paket je trebao stići jučer.
ali nije stigao
I was supposed to meet Sam at six, but I forgot.
Trebao sam se naći sa Samom u šest, ali sam zaboravio.
„trebao sam“ po dogovoru → was supposed to
The new system was supposed to save time, but it's made everything slower.
Novi sustav trebao je uštedjeti vrijeme, a sve je usporio.

Be supposed to može značiti i „kažu da…“: This café is supposed to be very good. To se značenje obrađuje u B2-12.

4Be required to / be obliged to – formalna obveza

Be required to i be obliged to upotrebljavaju se za pravila, zakone, ugovore i službene dokumente – kao naše „dužni su“ ili „obvezni su“. Be obliged to često nagovješćuje dužnost koju ne možete izbjeći – zakonsku ili moralnu. Not required to = nije potrebno (formalno).

Passengers are required to show a valid ticket.
Putnici su dužni pokazati valjanu kartu.
osoba je subjekt
Applicants are required to have at least two years' experience.
Od kandidata se traži najmanje dvije godine iskustva.
„od… se traži“ → are required to
Companies are legally obliged to protect customer data.
Tvrtke su zakonski obvezne štititi podatke kupaca.
I felt obliged to help, even though I was exhausted.
Osjećao sam se dužnim pomoći, iako sam bio iscrpljen.
moralna dužnost
You are not required to answer every question.
Ne morate odgovoriti na svako pitanje.
nije potrebno (formalno)

5Should, need to, have to, must – izbor na ljestvici

Birajte prema jačini i izvoru. Should = savjet. Need to = potrebno za cilj. Have to = obveza izvana (pravila, drugi ljudi, okolnosti). Must = jaka obveza, često osjećaj samoga govornika, ili u pisanim pravilima i obavijestima. Hrvatski za sve to često ima samo „trebati“ i „morati“.

You should drink more water.
Trebao bi piti više vode.
savjet
You need to drink more water — you're dehydrated.
Trebaš piti više vode, dehidrirao si.
potrebno
I have to wear a suit at work.
Na poslu moram nositi odijelo.
pravilo tvrtke
I must call my mum — it's her birthday.
Moram nazvati mamu, rođendan joj je.
osjećaj dužnosti samoga govornika; mum (UK) = mom (US)
Seatbelts must be worn at all times.
Pojas mora biti vezan cijelo vrijeme.
pisano pravilo

Česte pogreške

❌You needn't to come.
✅You needn't come. ili You don't need to come.
Modalni needn't nema to.
❌She needs not come.
✅She needn't come. ili She doesn't need to come.
Odaberite jedan oblik; nemojte ih miješati.
❌You needn't have to bring anything.
✅You needn't have brought anything.
needn't + have + particip prošli.
❌I'm suppose to be at work.
✅I'm supposed to be at work.
Uvijek supposed, s -d.
❌We supposed to leave at six.
✅We were supposed to leave at six.
be je obavezan.
❌Employees are required wearing a badge.
✅Employees are required to wear a badge.
be required to + osnovni oblik.
⚠️I needn't have gone, so I stayed at home.
✅I didn't need to go, so I stayed at home.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali proturječi samo sebi: needn't have gone znači da ste otišli.
⚠️You mustn't bring food — there's plenty here.
✅You don't need to bring food — there's plenty here.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali mustn't znači „zabranjeno je“; za „nije potrebno“ upotrijebite don't need to / needn't.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Rekao je da ne trebamo donositi…“ → needn't to. Iza hrvatskog „trebati“ dolazi infinitiv, a engleski infinitiv pamtimo s to. Kod need to to je točno, ali modalni needn't nema to. Odaberite jedan obrazac: needn't bring ili don't need to bring.

❌The swimming coach in Rijeka told us that we needn't to bring our own towels to training, because the club washes and hands out fresh ones.
✅The swimming coach in Rijeka told us that we needn't bring our own towels to training, because the club washes and hands out fresh ones. ili The swimming coach in Rijeka told us that we didn't need to bring our own towels to training, because the club washes and hands out fresh ones.
needn't bez to

2. „Nisam trebao kupiti toliko…“ → needn't + osnovni oblik za prošlost. U hrvatskom prošlost nosi „trebao sam“, a glavni glagol ostaje infinitiv. Ako to prenesete riječ po riječ, needn't buy uz prošlo razdoblje nema znaka prošlosti. Za nepotrebnu radnju koja se dogodila treba needn't have + particip prošli.

❌I needn't buy six loaves of bread for the picnic last Saturday, because half of them were still in the bag on Monday.
✅I needn't have bought six loaves of bread for the picnic last Saturday, because half of them were still in the bag on Monday.
prošlost: needn't have + particip prošli

3. „Trebao sam se naći s…“ (dogovor) → had to. Hrvatsko „trebao sam“ često znači plan ili dogovor koji se nije ostvario. Had to govori o stvarnoj obvezi i obično znači da je ispunjena. Za ono što se očekivalo, a nije se dogodilo, engleski ima was / were supposed to.

⚠️I had to pick up Ema from her piano lesson at five, but the tram broke down and she waited for me for half an hour.
✅I was supposed to pick up Ema from her piano lesson at five, but the tram broke down and she waited for me for half an hour.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali had to znači obvezu; za dogovor koji se nije ostvario prirodnije je was supposed to.

4. „Od gostiju se traži…“ → it is required from. Hrvatska rečenica s „od“ i „traži se“ nema osobu kao subjekt. Doslovni prijevod s from nije engleski. U engleskom osoba postaje subjekt: X are required to + osnovni oblik.

❌At the reception desk it is required from all guests to show an identity card or a passport before they get their room key.
✅At the reception desk all guests are required to show an identity card or a passport before they get their room key.
osoba je subjekt + are required to

Ne miješajte

mustn't i don't need to / needn't – mustn't znači nemoj to raditi („ne smiješ“). Don't need to znači nije potrebno („ne trebaš“; možete ako želite). Pogledajte A2-20.

You mustn't touch the wires.
Ne smiješ dirati žice.
zabranjeno
You don't need to wear a tie.
Ne trebaš nositi kravatu.
po želji

needn't have done i didn't need to do – učinili ste to ili (obično) niste.

I needn't have hurried.
Nisam se trebao žuriti.
žurio sam se uzalud
I didn't need to hurry.
Nije bilo potrebe da se žurim.
pa se nisam žurio

be supposed to i should – should je savjet samoga govornika. Be supposed to prenosi što drugi očekuju ili što kažu pravila.

You should try the new café.
Trebao bi probati onaj novi kafić.
moj savjet
You're supposed to pay at the counter.
Ovdje se plaća na šanku.
tako je ovdje uređeno

needn't have i shouldn't have – needn't have = bilo je nepotrebno; shouldn't have = bilo je pogrešno. Na hrvatskom je oboje „nisi trebao“. Pogledajte B1-09.

You needn't have paid for me.
Nisi trebao platiti za mene.
lijepo od tebe, ali nije bilo potrebno
You shouldn't have paid for me.
Zbilja nisi trebao platiti za mene.
uljudan prosvjed: učinio si nešto što nisi trebao

Need + -ing s pasivnim značenjem (The car needs washing) obrađuje se u B2-13. Formalno be to (You are to report at nine) obrađuje se u C1-16.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • supposed to izgovara se /səˈpəʊstə/ (UK), /səˈpoʊstə/ (US). -d se ispred to ne čuje, ali se mora napisati. Prvi slog ima neutralni glas /ə/ – kratak i opušten, a ne puno hrvatsko u.
  • needn't /ˈniːdnt/: d i n spajaju se bez samoglasnika između njih, a zrak izlazi kroz nos. Završno t često je vrlo slabo, pa slušajte niječno značenje. needn't have /ˈniːdntəv/.
  • have to = /ˈhæftə/ i has to = /ˈhæstə/: glas f i glas s, a ne v i z.
  • obliged /əˈblaɪdʒd/ ima dva sloga. /dʒ/ je isto kao hrvatsko dž – tu ste u prednosti. Naglasak je na drugom slogu.

Zlatno pravilo

Pitajte koliko je jako i tko odlučuje: should (savjet) → need to (potrebno) → have to / must (obveza) → be required to / be obliged to (formalna pravila). Be supposed to = ono što se očekuje, a često se ne radi. Za prošlost: needn't have done = učinili ste, ali nije bilo potrebno; didn't need to do = nije bilo potrebno (i obično niste). I zapamtite: „trebao sam“ po dogovoru je was supposed to.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite ili preoblikujte rečenice prema uputi.

  1. Dopunite s needn't + have: We took sandwiches, but there was free food. We (bring) sandwiches.
  2. Dopunite s be supposed to (prošlost): The train arrive at six, but it was an hour late.
  3. Dopunite: Drivers are required (carry) their licence.
  4. Preoblikujte rečenicu (upotrijebite needn't): It isn't necessary for you to wait for me.
  5. Preoblikujte rečenicu (upotrijebite be obliged to): The law says landlords must return the deposit.
  6. Napišite niječnu rečenicu: You need to print the tickets.

B. Značenje

Odaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. Odaberite točan odgovor: You … pay — the museum is free on Sundays.
  2. Odaberite točan odgovor: It was a holiday, so I to work. I stayed in bed.
  3. Odaberite točan odgovor: I — the exam was easy, but I was nervous all week.
  4. Odaberite točan odgovor: You're not … to eat in the library — it's against the rules.
  5. Odaberite savjet, a ne pravilo: … see a dentist once a year.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. You needn't to call me back.
  2. I'm suppose to start work at eight.
  3. She needs not worry about the exam.
  4. We didn't need to queue because we had booked online.

D. U kontekstu

Upotrijebite needn't have, didn't need to ili be supposed to u točnom obliku.

The wedding
Lena: How was the wedding?
Max: Lovely, but I made a few mistakes. First, I took a taxi from the station — and then I saw the hotel was right next to it. I 16 (take) a taxi at all!
Lena: Oh no. What about the dress code?
Max: The invitation said guests 17 (supposed / wear) something blue. I forgot.
Lena: Did you need to bring a gift?
Max: No, we 18 (not / need / bring) anything — they asked for donations to a charity instead, so I just gave money.
Lena: And the speech?
Max: I 19 (supposed / give) a short speech, but I was too nervous, so my brother did it.
Lena: Well, at least you were there!

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o obvezama u svom životu.

  1. Napišite nešto što ste učinili, a pokazalo se nepotrebnim, s needn't have.
  2. Napišite jedno pravilo u svojoj školi ili na poslu koje ljudi često krše, s be supposed to.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. A2-20 Must, have to, mustn't i don't have to: obveza i zabrana na engleskom
    You ___ … smoke here — it's a hospital.
  2. B1-09 Should have, could have, might have: žaljenje i kritika na engleskom
    I'm so tired. I (not stay) up so late last night.
  3. B2-06 Must have, can't have, might have: nagađanje o prošlosti na engleskom
    The ground is wet. It (must rain) in the night.
  4. B2-05 Would rather, had better i prefer: radije bih i bolje da na engleskom
    It's late. We'd better (go) home.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. needn't have brought
  2. was supposed to
  3. to carry
  4. You needn't wait for me.
  5. Landlords are obliged to return the deposit. / Landlords are legally obliged to return the deposit.
  6. You don't need to print the tickets. / You needn't print the tickets.

B. Značenje

  1. don't need to
  2. didn't need to go
  3. needn't have worried / didn't need to worry
  4. supposed
  5. You should

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. You needn't call me back. / You don't need to call me back.
  2. I'm supposed to start work at eight.
  3. She needn't worry about the exam. / She doesn't need to worry about the exam.
  4. ✓ We didn't need to queue because we had booked online.

D. U kontekstu

  1. needn't have taken / didn't need to take
  2. were supposed to wear
  3. didn't need to bring
  4. was supposed to give

E. Vaš red

  1. I needn't have taken an umbrella yesterday — it didn't rain at all.
  2. We're supposed to turn off our computers every evening, but most people forget.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. mustn't
  2. shouldn't have stayed
  3. must have rained
  4. go
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play