SlowingoGramatika
B2 2 / 30

Mixed conditionals: miješane pogodbene rečenice na engleskom objašnjene na hrvatskom

Mixed Conditionals

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete povezati zamišljenu prošlost sa sadašnjošću (If I had taken that job, I would be rich now) i zamišljenu sadašnjost s prošlošću (If I weren't so shy, I would have spoken to her). Za svaku polovicu bilo koje pogodbene rečenice izabrat ćete pravi oblik tako da se pitate: kada je uvjet, a kada posljedica?

Osnovna ideja

Stvarni život ne drži prošlost i sadašnjost u odvojenim kutijama. Odluka koju ste donijeli prije deset godina određuje gdje danas živite. Osobina karaktera koja uvijek vrijedi objašnjava što ste učinili jučer.

Miješane pogodbene rečenice dopuštaju da svaka polovica rečenice zadrži svoje vrijeme. Zamislite rečenicu kao dva sata: jedan iznad uvjeta, drugi iznad posljedice. Svaki sat namještate posebno.

  • Uvjet u prošlosti, posljedica sada: If I had studied medicine (prošlost), I would be a doctor (sada).
  • Uvjet koji uvijek vrijedi ili vrijedi sada, posljedica u prošlosti: If I weren't so shy (uvijek), I would have spoken to her (sinoć na zabavi).

U ovoj lekciji nema novih oblika. Dijelove pogodbenih rečenica tipa 2 već znate (B1-06), kao i dijelove rečenica tipa 3 (B1-07). Samo uzmete po jednu polovicu iz svake – kad god dva sata pokazuju različito vrijeme.

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski u nestvarnim pogodbenim rečenicama ima „da“ + prezent ili perfekt u uvjetu („Da sam bogat…“, „Da sam znao…“) i kondicional u posljedici („bio bih“, „razgovarao bih“). Taj isti kondicional služi i za sadašnjost i za prošlost: „Da sam studirao medicinu, sada bih bio liječnik“ i „Da nisam tako sramežljiv, razgovarao bih s njom na zabavi“. (Kondicional prošli, „bio bih razgovarao“, postoji, ali se u govoru rijetko upotrebljava.)

Zato hrvatska posljedica ne pokazuje kada se nešto dogodilo, a engleska mora: sadašnja posljedica je would + osnovni oblik glagola, prošla je would have + particip prošli. Pazite i na zamku u obliku: „bio“ u „bih bio“ podsjeća na been, ali „sada bih bio liječnik“ je I would be a doctor now.

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Da sam studirao medicinu, sada bih bio liječnik.If I had studied medicine, I would be a doctor now.sadašnja posljedica → would be, ne would have been
Da nisam tako sramežljiv, razgovarao bih s njom na zabavi.If I weren't so shy, I would have spoken to her at the party.isti kondicional, prošla posljedica → would have spoken
Da zna voziti, došla bi po nas na kolodvor.If she could drive, she would have picked us up from the station.stalni uvjet → could (past simple oblik)
Da sam prošle godine dobio na lotu, sada ne bih radio ovdje.If I had won the lottery last year, I wouldn't be working here now.sada → would be + -ing
Da sam prošle godine dobio na lotu, kupio bih kuću.If I had won the lottery last year, I would have bought a house.oboje prošlo → would have bought (tip 3)
Da sam viši, igrao bih košarku.If I were taller, I would play basketball.ovdje je isto: oboje sada → tip 2

Ukratko: hrvatski kondicional ne pokazuje vrijeme posljedice; u engleskom za svaku polovicu pitajte „kada?“ – sada je would do, prošlost je would have done.

Oblik

Tip A: prošli uvjet → sadašnja posljedica

Rečenica s if (nestvarna prošlost)Glavna rečenica (nestvarna sadašnjost)
if + Past Perfectwould / could / might + osnovni oblik glagola
If I had taken that job,I would be living in Tokyo now.
If she hadn't missed the flight,she would be here.

Tip B: sadašnji ili stalni uvjet → prošla posljedica

Rečenica s if (nestvarna sadašnjost / uvijek vrijedi)Glavna rečenica (nestvarna prošlost)
if + Past Simple (were)would / could / might + have + particip prošli
If I weren't so shy,I would have spoken to her.
If he could read a map,he could have found the hotel.

Rečenica s if može doći i druga, bez zareza: I would be a doctor now if I had studied medicine.

Sve pogodbene rečenice: pregled

TipUvjetPosljedicaPrimjer
tip 0Present SimplePresent SimpleIf you heat ice, it melts.
tip 1Present Simplewill + osnovni oblikIf it rains, we'll stay in.
tip 2Past Simplewould + osnovni oblikIf I had time, I'd learn to sail.
tip 3Past Perfectwould have + particip prošliIf I'd known, I'd have helped.
miješani APast Perfectwould + osnovni oblikIf I'd saved, I'd be rich now.
miješani BPast Simplewould have + particip prošliIf I were rich, I'd have bought it.

Tipovi 0 i 1 su stvarni uvjeti (A2-27); ostali su nestvarni (zamišljeni, suprotni činjenicama).

Uporaba

1Prošli uvjet → sadašnja posljedica

Drugačija prošlost značila bi drugačije sada. Posljedica često sadrži now, today, still ili neku sadašnju situaciju.

If I had studied medicine, I would be a doctor now.
Da sam studirao medicinu, sada bih bio liječnik.
„sada bih bio“ → would be
If we hadn't sold our flat in 2015, we would be much richer today.
Da 2015. nismo prodali stan, danas bismo bili mnogo bogatiji.
flat (UK) = apartment (US)
If you'd gone to bed earlier, you wouldn't feel so tired.
Da si ranije otišla spavati, sada ne bi bila tako umorna.
sadašnja posljedica → wouldn't feel
If they hadn't met at that conference, they wouldn't be married.
Da se nisu upoznali na onoj konferenciji, ne bi bili u braku.
i danas su u braku
I could speak Italian fluently if I had kept up my lessons.
Sada bih tečno govorio talijanski da sam nastavio sa satovima.
rečenica s if na drugom mjestu: bez zareza

2Sadašnji ili stalni uvjet → prošla posljedica

Situacija koja općenito vrijedi – karakter, sposobnost, stalna činjenica – objašnjava prošlu posljedicu. Rečenica s if govori o tome što vrijedi uvijek ili sada, a ne o jednom trenutku u prošlosti.

If I weren't so shy, I would have spoken to her at the party.
Da nisam tako sramežljiv, razgovarao bih s njom na zabavi.
isti hrvatski kondicional; prošlost → would have spoken
If he were more organised, he wouldn't have missed the deadline.
Da je organiziraniji, ne bi propustio rok.
stalna osobina; US: organized
If I didn't trust you, I wouldn't have lent you the money.
Da ti ne vjerujem, ne bih ti posudio novac.
vjerujem ti i sada
If she could drive, she would have picked us up from the station.
Da zna voziti, došla bi po nas na kolodvor.
sposobnost → could
If I weren't allergic to cats, I would have adopted that kitten.
Da nisam alergična na mačke, udomila bih onog mačića.
stalna činjenica, prošla odluka

3Izbor prave polovice – pitajte „kada?“

Za svaku polovicu pitajte: Kada je uvjet? Kada je posljedica? Onda izaberite odgovarajući oblik. Posljedica prošlog uvjeta može biti čak i u budućnosti.

If I had won the lottery last year, I wouldn't be working here now.
Da sam prošle godine dobio na lotu, sada ne bih radio ovdje.
prošli uvjet, sadašnja posljedica
If I had won the lottery last year, I would have bought a house.
Da sam prošle godine dobio na lotu, kupio bih kuću.
oboje prošlo: tip 3
If I were taller, I would have become a basketball player.
Da sam viši, postao bih košarkaš.
stalni uvjet, prošla posljedica
If I were taller, I would play basketball.
Da sam viši, igrao bih košarku.
oboje sada: tip 2
If I hadn't broken my leg, I would be running the marathon on Sunday.
Da nisam slomio nogu, u nedjelju bih trčao maraton.
prošli uvjet, buduća posljedica

4Modalni glagoli i oblici u tijeku

Could i might čine posljedicu mogućom, a ne sigurnom. Oblici u tijeku rade u obje polovice: would be + -ing za sadašnju aktivnost, had been + -ing za aktivnost u prošlosti i were + -ing za sadašnji ili budući dogovor.

If she had accepted the offer, she might be living in Singapore now.
Da je prihvatila ponudu, možda bi sada živjela u Singapuru.
might = možda
If I hadn't been looking at my phone, I wouldn't be in hospital now.
Da nisam gledao u mobitel, sada ne bih bio u bolnici.
UK; US: in the hospital
If I weren't working tomorrow, I would have stayed at the party longer.
Da sutra ne radim, ostao bih dulje na zabavi.
uvjet: dogovor za sutra
If we had left on time, we could be at the beach by now.
Da smo krenuli na vrijeme, već bismo mogli biti na plaži.
could = mogli bismo

5Žaljenje, kritika i objašnjenje

Miješane pogodbene rečenice vrlo su česte kad žalimo zbog prošle odluke koja još utječe na nas ili kad kritiziramo ili objašnjavamo prošlu posljedicu nečijim karakterom.

If I'd listened to my teacher, I wouldn't be in this mess now.
Da sam slušao učiteljicu, sada ne bih bio u ovakvoj nevolji.
žaljenje
If you weren't so stubborn, you would have apologised days ago.
Da nisi tako tvrdoglav, već bi se prije nekoliko dana ispričao.
kritika; US: apologized
If he didn't love her, he wouldn't have moved across the world for her.
Da je ne voli, ne bi se zbog nje preselio na drugi kraj svijeta.
objašnjenje
If we had booked earlier, we would be on a beach right now.
Da smo ranije rezervirali, sada bismo bili na plaži.
prošla odluka, sadašnja posljedica

Česte pogreške

❌If I didn't miss the bus this morning, I would be at work now.
✅If I hadn't missed the bus this morning, I would be at work now.
Nestvarni uvjet o trenutku u prošlosti traži Past Perfect.
❌If I would have taken the job, I would be rich now.
✅If I had taken the job, I would be rich now.
U rečenici s if nema would.
❌If I had studied medicine, I would have been a doctor now.
✅If I had studied medicine, I would be a doctor now.
now = sadašnja posljedica → would + osnovni oblik glagola
❌If she had been born in Canada, she will have a Canadian passport.
✅If she had been born in Canada, she would have a Canadian passport.
Nestvarna posljedica → would, ne will.
❌If he weren't so lazy, he would pass the exam last week.
✅If he weren't so lazy, he would have passed the exam last week.
Prošla posljedica → would have + particip prošli
❌If I had known about the party last night, I would go.
✅If I had known about the party last night, I would have gone.
Zabava je bila sinoć, pa je i posljedica prošla: tip 3.
⚠️If I was more patient, I would have waited for you.
✅If I were more patient, I would have waited for you.
Was je čest u neformalnom govoru; were je standard u pisanju. Pogledajte B1-06.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Sada bih bio…“ → would have been now. U hrvatskom „bih bio“ ima riječ „bio“, koja podsjeća na been. Ali „Da sam se odselio, sada bih bio…“ govori o sadašnjosti. Za sadašnju posljedicu treba would be, bez have.

❌Marko would have been a captain on a big tanker now if he had accepted that offer from the shipping company in Rijeka.
✅Marko would be a captain on a big tanker now if he had accepted that offer from the shipping company in Rijeka.
sada → would be

2. Isti kondicional za sadašnjost i prošlost → would + osnovni oblik za prošlu posljedicu. „Da vjeruje liječnicima, otišla bi na pregled“ – hrvatski ne pokazuje je li to bilo ili tek bude. Kad je posljedica u prošlosti (prošli mjesec, jučer, na rođendanu), engleski traži would have + particip prošli.

❌My grandmother is so stubborn – if she trusted doctors, she would go for that check-up in Zadar last month.
✅My grandmother is so stubborn – if she trusted doctors, she would have gone for that check-up in Zadar last month.
last month = prošlost → would have gone

3. „Kad bih / ako bih“ → would u uvjetu. Hrvatski kondicional ponekad stoji i u uvjetu („Kad bih bio pametniji…“), pa would sklizne u rečenicu s if. U engleskoj rečenici s if nikad nema would: uvjet je Past Simple ili Past Perfect.

❌Our Spanish would be much better today if Ema and I would have taken those summer jobs at the travel agency in Dubrovnik.
✅Our Spanish would be much better today if Ema and I had taken those summer jobs at the travel agency in Dubrovnik.
u uvjetu: had taken

4. Perfekt → Past Simple za uvjet o jednom prošlom trenutku. Hrvatski perfekt („da nisam zaboravio“) obično prevodimo s Past Simple. Ali kad je nestvarni uvjet vezan za jedan trenutak u prošlosti (jutros, sinoć, nakon srednje škole), engleski traži Past Perfect.

❌Do you think Ana and I would still be close if I didn't go to university in Osijek after secondary school?
✅Do you think Ana and I would still be close if I hadn't gone to university in Osijek after secondary school?
odlazak na fakultet = jedan prošli događaj → hadn't gone

Ne miješajte

Tip 3 i miješani (prošlost → sadašnjost) – uvjet je isti; mijenja se samo vrijeme posljedice. Hrvatski u oba slučaja ima isti kondicional.

If I'd caught the flight, I would have arrived yesterday.
Da nisam zakasnio na let, stigao bih jučer.
prošla posljedica: tip 3
If I'd caught the flight, I would be in Rome now.
Da nisam zakasnio na let, sada bih bio u Rimu.
sadašnja posljedica: miješani

Tip 2 i miješani (sadašnjost → prošlost) – uvjet je isti; posljedica se pomiče u prošlost.

If I weren't afraid of heights, I would go climbing with you.
Da se ne bojim visine, išao bih s tobom na penjanje.
sadašnja / buduća posljedica: tip 2
If I weren't afraid of heights, I would have gone climbing with you last weekend.
Da se ne bojim visine, prošli bih vikend išao s tobom na penjanje.
prošla posljedica: miješani

Miješana pogodbena rečenica i wish – oboje može izraziti žaljenje, ali wish nema rečenicu s posljedicom. Pogledajte B2-04.

Za formalne obrasce poput Had I known… i If it weren't for… pogledajte C1-03; za uvjete bez if (Without your help…) C1-04.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • 'd ima dva značenja: u rečenici s if If I'd = If I had (iza njega particip prošli); u posljedici I'd be = I would be (iza njega osnovni oblik glagola).
  • would have je u govoru slab: /ˈwʊdəv/; wouldn't have /ˈwʊdntəv/. Od have ostaje samo neutralni glas /ə/ i v. Neutralnog glasa /ə/ u hrvatskom nema: kratak je, usta su malo otvorena, jezik miruje. Pišite would have, nikad would of.
  • U would se l ne izgovara, a /w/ izgovarate zaobljenim usnama, kao kratko u – nije hrvatsko v.
  • Naglasite riječi za vrijeme da miješanje bude jasno: If I'd taken the job, I'd be in Tokyo now.
  • Stavite zarez kad rečenica s if dolazi prva; bez zareza kad posljedica dolazi prva.

Zlatno pravilo

Namjestite dva sata posebno: prošli uvjet → had done; sadašnji ili stalni uvjet → did / were; sadašnja posljedica → would do; prošla posljedica → would have done. Hrvatski kondicional („bih bio“) ne kaže kada – pitajte se sami.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite rečenice glagolom iz zagrade u točnom obliku ili spojite rečenice.

  1. If I (not spend) all my money last weekend, I could come out with you tonight.
  2. If he were more careful, he (not break) the vase yesterday.
  3. If we had left earlier, we (be) there by now.
  4. If I (be) better at maths, I would have studied engineering.
  5. If she (not move) to Berlin, she wouldn't speak German so well.
  6. If they (not be) so rich, they wouldn't have bought a yacht.
  7. Spojite rečenice u miješanu pogodbenu rečenicu: I didn't buy the tickets. I'm not at the concert now.

B. Značenje

Odaberite oblik koji odgovara značenju ili odgovorite na pitanje.

  1. Odaberite točan odgovor: If she had taken the medicine, she … better now.
  2. Odaberite točan odgovor: If I knew more about history, I … the museum tour last week.
  3. Odaberite manje sigurnu posljedicu: If I'd trained harder, I … be in the team now.
  4. Je li uvjet prošli ili stalni (past / permanent)? "If he weren't so impatient, he would have waited."
  5. Tip 2, tip 3 ili miješani (second / third / mixed)? "If I'd caught the flight, I would be in Rome now."

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. If I had married him, I would have been unhappy now.
  2. If he weren't so impatient, he would wait for us yesterday.
  3. If I would have known, I would be there now.
  4. If I hadn't lost my keys, I wouldn't be waiting outside now.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite razgovor glagolima iz zagrade u točnom obliku.

Two friends talking
Jo: You look tired.
Kim: I am. If I 17 (not / stay) up so late, I 18 (not / feel) like this now.
Jo: Why did you stay up?
Kim: My brother called. If he 19 (not / be) so talkative, I 20 (go) to bed at ten!
Jo: And if you 21 (be) a morning person, you 22 (enjoy) this early class.

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o svom životu.

  1. Sjetite se jedne odluke iz prošlosti koja vam je promijenila život. Napišite miješanu pogodbenu rečenicu o tome kako bi vam život danas bio drugačiji.
  2. Napišite nešto o osobini svog karaktera koja objašnjava nešto što ste prošli tjedan učinili (ili niste učinili).

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. B1-07 Third Conditional: If I had known… – pogodbene rečenice tipa 3 na hrvatskom
    If you (tell) me, I would have helped you.
  2. B1-06 Second Conditional: If I had…, I would… – pogodbene rečenice tipa 2 na hrvatskom
    If I (be) you, I'd take the job.
  3. B1-09 Should have, could have, might have: žaljenje i kritika na engleskom
    You (should tell) me about the problem earlier.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. hadn't spent
  2. wouldn't have broken
  3. would be / could be / might be
  4. were / was
  5. hadn't moved
  6. weren't / wasn't
  7. If I had bought the tickets, I would be at the concert now. / If I'd bought the tickets, I'd be at the concert now. / I would be at the concert now if I had bought the tickets.

B. Značenje

  1. would feel
  2. would have enjoyed
  3. might
  4. permanent
  5. mixed

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. If I had married him, I would be unhappy now.
  2. If he weren't so impatient, he would have waited for us yesterday. / If he wasn't so impatient, he would have waited for us yesterday.
  3. If I had known, I would be there now. / If I'd known, I'd be there now.
  4. ✓ If I hadn't lost my keys, I wouldn't be waiting outside now.

D. U kontekstu

  1. hadn't stayed
  2. wouldn't feel
  3. weren't / wasn't / hadn't been
  4. would have gone / could have gone / might have gone
  5. were / was
  6. would enjoy / might enjoy / could enjoy

E. Vaš red

  1. If I hadn't moved to Dublin, I wouldn't speak English this well.
  2. If I weren't so lazy, I would have gone to the gym on Saturday.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. had told
  2. were / was
  3. should have told
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play