Slowingo语法
A2 36 / 38

英语主语疑问句和宾语疑问句:who called you 和 who did you call 的区别

Who Called You? Who Did You Call? Subject and Object Questions

本页内容
  1. 学习目标
  2. 核心概念
  3. 中英对比
  4. 结构
  5. 用法
  6. 常见错误
  7. 中文母语者的常见陷阱
  8. 易混淆点
  9. 拼写与发音
  10. 黄金法则
  11. 练习

学习目标

学完这一课,你能用 who、what、which 和 how many 问两种问题:问主语的问题(Who called you?)和问宾语的问题(Who did you call?)。你还能把介词放在疑问句的末尾(Who did you go with?),并且会问、会回答否定疑问句(Don't you like it?)。

核心概念

看这个句子:Anna called Ben. 里面有两个人。你可以问其中任何一个。

把疑问词想象成一块拼图。如果你不知道是谁打的电话 —— 也就是主语(subject)—— who 这块拼图就直接放进主语的位置:Who called Ben? 其他的都不动。语序和普通陈述句一样,所以没有 do、does 或 did。

如果你不知道是谁接到了电话 —— 也就是宾语(object)—— who 这块拼图就要跳到句子最前面,后面还要接一个普通的疑问句,主语前面要有助动词:Who did Anna call?

所以,提问之前先想清楚:我问的是做动作的人,还是接受动作的人?

中英对比

中文的疑问词不挪位置:问主语,就把“谁”放在主语的位置上;问宾语,就把“谁”放在宾语的位置上,其他的都不变。好消息是:英语的主语疑问句和中文完全一样 —— 疑问词放在主语的位置,语序不变,也不加 did。难点在宾语疑问句:英语要把疑问词搬到句首,再在主语前面加上 do / does / did。

中文英语问的是
谁给你打电话了?Who called you?主语:和中文一样,语序不变
你给谁打电话了?Who did you call?宾语:疑问词到句首,加 did
什么事让你开心?What makes you happy?主语
她说什么了?What did she say?宾语
你跟谁去的?Who did you go with?中文“跟”在前,英语 with 在句末
你不喜欢吗?Don't you like it?否定疑问句

还有一个大区别在回答否定疑问句的时候:中文的“对 / 是”表示“你说得对”,英语的 Yes / No 却只看事实本身。见下面的“用法 6”。

结构

同一个句子,两个问题:Anna called Ben.

问的是……问题回答
主语Who called Ben?Anna (did).
宾语Who did Anna call?Ben.

主语疑问句 —— 疑问词 + 动词(不用 do / does / did)

时态例子
一般现在时Who lives here?(用 he/she/it 的形式:加 -s)
一般过去时What happened?
现在进行时Who is making that noise?
情态动词Who can help me?

宾语疑问句 —— 疑问词 + 助动词 + 主语 + 动词

时态例子
一般现在时Who do you live with?
一般过去时What did you buy?
现在进行时What are you doing?
情态动词Who can we ask?

Which / How many + 名词作主语

主语疑问句宾语疑问句
Which bus goes to the airport?Which bus did you take?
How many people came to the party?How many people did you invite?

否定疑问句 —— 否定的助动词(缩写形式)+ 主语

形式例子
一般疑问句Don't you like it? / Isn't it beautiful? / Haven't you finished?
特殊疑问句Why didn't you call? / Why aren't you ready?
主语疑问句Who didn't come?

怎么回答否定疑问句 —— 看事实,不看问题的形式

问题事实是肯定的事实是否定的
Don't you like coffee?Yes, I do.(我喜欢。)No, I don't.(我不喜欢。)
Isn't she coming?Yes, she is.(她会来。)No, she isn't.(她不来。)

用法

1用 who 的主语疑问句

问做动作的人,用 Who + 动词。一般现在时里,动词用 he/she/it 的形式(加 -s),即使你觉得答案可能不止一个人。

Who wants a cup of tea?
谁要喝茶?
和中文一样,“谁”在主语的位置
Who broke the window?
谁把窗户打破了?
Who lives in that big house on the corner?
拐角那栋大房子里住的是谁?
Who told you about the party?
谁跟你说的聚会的事?
Who's coming to dinner tonight?
今晚谁来吃饭?
who's = who is

2用 what 的主语疑问句

问做了某事或发生了的东西、事情,用 What + 动词。

What happened to your phone?
你的手机怎么了?
不说 What did happen
What makes you happy?
什么事会让你开心?
What caused the delay?
是什么原因造成了延误?
What's making that strange noise?
是什么东西在发出那种怪声?

3宾语疑问句

问接受动作的人或东西,用疑问词 + 助动词 + 主语 + 动词。

Who did you meet at the conference?
你在会上见到谁了?
中文“谁”在后面,英语 who 在句首,还要加 did
What did she say?
她说什么了?
Who are you texting?
你在给谁发消息?
What do you usually have for breakfast?
你早饭一般吃什么?

4which 和 how many 作主语

Which + 名词和 How many + 名词也可以作主语。这时也不用 do / does / did。

Which team won the final?
决赛哪个队赢了?
Which road goes to the beach?
哪条路通往海滩?
How many students passed the exam?
有多少个学生考试及格了?
How many people work in your office?
你们办公室有多少人上班?
Which shoes did you buy in the end?
你最后买了哪双鞋?
宾语疑问句:did + 主语

5介词放在句末的疑问句

疑问词是介词(with、to、about、for、from)的宾语时,日常英语一般把介词放在问句的末尾。

Who did you go to the cinema with?
你跟谁去看的电影?
中文“跟谁”在动词前,英语 with 在句末
What are you looking for?
你在找什么?
Who is this present for?
这个礼物是给谁的?
What are you two talking about?
你们俩在聊什么?

6否定疑问句

否定疑问句可以表示惊讶(Don't you like it?),可以请对方同意你的看法(Isn't it beautiful?),也可以问原因,常常带点不满(Why didn't you call?)。回答时看事实:Yes = 事实是肯定的,No = 事实是否定的。这和中文的“对”“是”不一样。

Don't you like it? You haven't eaten anything!
你不喜欢吗?你一口都没吃!
表示惊讶
Isn't it a beautiful day?
今天天气多好啊,是不是?
请对方同意
Why didn't you call me? I was worried.
你怎么不给我打电话?我都担心死了。
Didn't you get my message?
你没收到我的消息吗?
No, I didn't. My phone was off.
对,没收到。我手机关机了。
回应上一句;中文说“对”,英语按事实说 No
"Aren't you hungry?" "Yes, I am! Let's eat."
“你不饿吗?”“饿啊!走,吃饭去。”
事实是饿,所以说 Yes

常见错误

❌Who did call you?
✅Who called you?
主语疑问句:不用 did。(如果重读 did 来强调,第一句也可能出现,但那不是普通的问句。)
❌Who you saw yesterday?
✅Who did you see yesterday?
宾语疑问句:did + 主语 + 动词原形。
❌Who did you saw?
✅Who did you see?
did 后面用动词原形。
❌Who live here?
✅Who lives here?
一般现在时的主语疑问句:动词加 -s。
❌Who you are waiting for?
✅Who are you waiting for?
宾语疑问句:助动词放在主语前面。
❌Why you didn't call me?
✅Why didn't you call me?
否定的助动词放在主语前面。
❌"Don't you like coffee?" "Yes, I don't."
✅"No, I don't."
看事实回答:事实是否定的 → No。
⚠️With who did you go?
✅Who did you go with?
听起来不自然。日常英语把介词放在句末;非常正式的说法是 With whom did you go?

中文母语者的常见陷阱

1. 否定疑问句按中文的“对 / 是”回答。 中文里,“你不会游泳吗?”可以回答“对,我不会”,“对”的意思是“你说得对”。照着说,就成了 Yes, I can't。英语的 Yes / No 只看事实:不会就是 No,会就是 Yes。

❌"Can't you swim?" "Yes, I can't."
✅"Can't you swim?" "No, I can't."
❌"Aren't you tired?" "No, I am."
✅"Aren't you tired?" "Yes, I am."

2. 宾语疑问句不加 did,也不倒装。 中文问宾语,语序不变:“你跟她说了什么?”很多同学把 what 搬到了句首,却忘了加 did,或者忘了把助动词放到主语前面。

❌What you said to her?
✅What did you say to her?
❌What you are doing?
✅What are you doing?

3. 主语疑问句反而多加 did。 学了“疑问句要加 do / did”以后,很多同学到处都加。可是问主语的时候,英语和中文一样,语序不变,不用 did。

❌Who did eat my sandwich?
✅Who ate my sandwich?

4. “你为什么不……”按中文语序说。 中文是“为什么 + 你 + 不”,英语的否定助动词要放在主语前面。

❌Why you don't come with us?
✅Why don't you come with us?

易混淆点

Who called you? 和 Who did you call? —— 问问自己:疑问词是做动作的人,还是接受动作的人?

Who called you?
谁给你打电话了?
有人给你打了电话,是谁?
Who did you call?
你给谁打电话了?
你给某人打了电话,是谁?

What happened? 和 What did you do? —— 第一句里 what 是主语(something happened),第二句里 what 是宾语(you did something)。

What happened at work today?
今天上班出什么事了?
what 是主语
What did you do at work today?
你今天上班都干了些什么?
what 是宾语

Who's 和 whose —— Who's = who is 或 who has。Whose 问的是“谁的”。见 A2-13。

Who's seen my keys?
谁看见我的钥匙了?
who has
Whose keys are these?
这是谁的钥匙?
问“谁的”

直接疑问句和间接疑问句 —— 放在一个更长、更客气的问句里(Could you tell me who…?)时,语序又会变。见 B1-14。

拼写与发音

  • 说快的时候,Who did you 常常连在一起,弱读成 /ˈhuː dɪdʒə/:did 的 d 和 you 连在一起,变成 /dʒ/ 的音。
  • What did you → /ˈwɒdɪdʒə/(英式),/ˈwʌdɪdʒə/(美式)。what 的 t 几乎听不到。
  • 句末的介词要重读,读强读形式:Who are you waiting for /fɔː/(英式),/fɔːr/(美式)?
  • 特殊疑问句的句末一般用降调:Who called you? ↘。而 Don't you like it? 这样的一般疑问句通常用升调。
  • 日常口语里,否定疑问句用缩写形式:Don't you…? Isn't it…? 完整的 Do you not like it? 也有,但更正式或者语气更强。don't 结尾的 t 很轻,但不要变成 do。

黄金法则

疑问词是主语(做动作的人)时,语序不变 —— 不用 do / does / did:Who called? 疑问词是宾语时,用助动词 + 主语:Who did you call? 回答否定疑问句,事实是肯定的说 Yes,事实是否定的说 No —— 不要照着中文的“对”来回答。

练习

A. 结构

按要求用英语提问。

  1. 就斜体部分提问,问主语:Maria took my umbrella.
  2. 就斜体部分提问,问宾语:Maria took my umbrella.
  3. 就斜体部分提问,问主语:Five students failed the test. (How many…?)
  4. 连词成句,组成疑问句:you / who / to / talking / are
  5. 把介词放到句末:With whom did you travel?
  6. 组成否定疑问句(一般现在时):you / like / horror films

B. 意义

选择正确的一项。

  1. 选择正确的一项:Who … this song?
  2. 选择正确的一项:What … for lunch?
  3. 选择正确的一项:Who … next door?
  4. "Didn't you see the email?" 你没有看到那封邮件。怎么回答?…
  5. "Isn't Tom coming?" Tom 会来。怎么回答?…

C. 找错

改正错误。如果句子正确,写 correct。

  1. What did happen last night?
  2. Who you invited to the party?
  3. Why you didn't tell me?
  4. Which team won the match?

D. 语境练习

用一个词补全对话;有括号的地方,用括号里的动词的正确形式。

周末过后
Kim: 16 happened to your arm?
Sam: I fell off my bike on Saturday.
Kim: Oh no! Who 17 (take) you to the hospital?
Sam: My brother. And we met our old teacher there!
Kim: Really? What 18 she say?
Sam: She asked about you.
Kim: That's nice. But why 19 you call me on Saturday? I was at home all day.
Sam: Sorry! My phone was broken too. Who 20 I talk to about a new one?

E. 轮到你了

用英语回答。

  1. 关于一部你知道的电影,写一个主语疑问句和一个宾语疑问句。
  2. 你的朋友从来不看电视。写一个否定疑问句,表示你很惊讶。

F. 综合复习

复习前面学过的内容。

  1. A2-29 英语定语从句入门:who、which、that 和 where 的用法
    The man lives next door is a pilot.
  2. A2-32 英语“我也是”怎么说:so do I、neither do I、me too 的用法
    "I didn't go to the party." "Neither I."
  3. A1-16 英语特殊疑问词 what、where、when、who、why、how 的用法和疑问句语序
    often do you go to the gym?
参考答案

A. 结构

  1. Who took your umbrella? / Who took my umbrella?
  2. What did Maria take? / What did she take?
  3. How many students failed the test?
  4. Who are you talking to?
  5. Who did you travel with?
  6. Don't you like horror films? / Do you not like horror films?

B. 意义

  1. wrote
  2. did you eat
  3. lives
  4. No, I didn't.
  5. Yes, he is.

C. 找错

  1. What happened last night?
  2. Who did you invite to the party?
  3. Why didn't you tell me?
  4. ✓ Which team won the match?

D. 语境练习

  1. What
  2. took
  3. did
  4. didn't / couldn't
  5. should / can / could / do / shall

E. 轮到你了

  1. Who played the main character? Who did the main character fall in love with?
  2. Don't you like TV?

F. 综合复习

  1. who / that
  2. did
  3. How
Android应用随时随地学习 Google Play