英语主语疑问句和宾语疑问句:who called you 和 who did you call 的区别
Who Called You? Who Did You Call? Subject and Object Questions
学习目标
学完这一课,你能用 who、what、which 和 how many 问两种问题:问主语的问题(Who called you?)和问宾语的问题(Who did you call?)。你还能把介词放在疑问句的末尾(Who did you go with?),并且会问、会回答否定疑问句(Don't you like it?)。
核心概念
看这个句子:Anna called Ben. 里面有两个人。你可以问其中任何一个。
把疑问词想象成一块拼图。如果你不知道是谁打的电话 —— 也就是主语(subject)—— who 这块拼图就直接放进主语的位置:Who called Ben? 其他的都不动。语序和普通陈述句一样,所以没有 do、does 或 did。
如果你不知道是谁接到了电话 —— 也就是宾语(object)—— who 这块拼图就要跳到句子最前面,后面还要接一个普通的疑问句,主语前面要有助动词:Who did Anna call?
所以,提问之前先想清楚:我问的是做动作的人,还是接受动作的人?
中英对比
中文的疑问词不挪位置:问主语,就把“谁”放在主语的位置上;问宾语,就把“谁”放在宾语的位置上,其他的都不变。好消息是:英语的主语疑问句和中文完全一样 —— 疑问词放在主语的位置,语序不变,也不加 did。难点在宾语疑问句:英语要把疑问词搬到句首,再在主语前面加上 do / does / did。
| 中文 | 英语 | 问的是 |
|---|---|---|
| 谁给你打电话了? | Who called you? | 主语:和中文一样,语序不变 |
| 你给谁打电话了? | Who did you call? | 宾语:疑问词到句首,加 did |
| 什么事让你开心? | What makes you happy? | 主语 |
| 她说什么了? | What did she say? | 宾语 |
| 你跟谁去的? | Who did you go with? | 中文“跟”在前,英语 with 在句末 |
| 你不喜欢吗? | Don't you like it? | 否定疑问句 |
还有一个大区别在回答否定疑问句的时候:中文的“对 / 是”表示“你说得对”,英语的 Yes / No 却只看事实本身。见下面的“用法 6”。
结构
同一个句子,两个问题:Anna called Ben.
| 问的是…… | 问题 | 回答 |
|---|---|---|
| 主语 | Who called Ben? | Anna (did). |
| 宾语 | Who did Anna call? | Ben. |
主语疑问句 —— 疑问词 + 动词(不用 do / does / did)
| 时态 | 例子 |
|---|---|
| 一般现在时 | Who lives here?(用 he/she/it 的形式:加 -s) |
| 一般过去时 | What happened? |
| 现在进行时 | Who is making that noise? |
| 情态动词 | Who can help me? |
宾语疑问句 —— 疑问词 + 助动词 + 主语 + 动词
| 时态 | 例子 |
|---|---|
| 一般现在时 | Who do you live with? |
| 一般过去时 | What did you buy? |
| 现在进行时 | What are you doing? |
| 情态动词 | Who can we ask? |
Which / How many + 名词作主语
| 主语疑问句 | 宾语疑问句 |
|---|---|
| Which bus goes to the airport? | Which bus did you take? |
| How many people came to the party? | How many people did you invite? |
否定疑问句 —— 否定的助动词(缩写形式)+ 主语
| 形式 | 例子 |
|---|---|
| 一般疑问句 | Don't you like it? / Isn't it beautiful? / Haven't you finished? |
| 特殊疑问句 | Why didn't you call? / Why aren't you ready? |
| 主语疑问句 | Who didn't come? |
怎么回答否定疑问句 —— 看事实,不看问题的形式
| 问题 | 事实是肯定的 | 事实是否定的 |
|---|---|---|
| Don't you like coffee? | Yes, I do.(我喜欢。) | No, I don't.(我不喜欢。) |
| Isn't she coming? | Yes, she is.(她会来。) | No, she isn't.(她不来。) |
用法
1用 who 的主语疑问句
问做动作的人,用 Who + 动词。一般现在时里,动词用 he/she/it 的形式(加 -s),即使你觉得答案可能不止一个人。
2用 what 的主语疑问句
问做了某事或发生了的东西、事情,用 What + 动词。
3宾语疑问句
问接受动作的人或东西,用疑问词 + 助动词 + 主语 + 动词。
4which 和 how many 作主语
Which + 名词和 How many + 名词也可以作主语。这时也不用 do / does / did。
5介词放在句末的疑问句
疑问词是介词(with、to、about、for、from)的宾语时,日常英语一般把介词放在问句的末尾。
6否定疑问句
否定疑问句可以表示惊讶(Don't you like it?),可以请对方同意你的看法(Isn't it beautiful?),也可以问原因,常常带点不满(Why didn't you call?)。回答时看事实:Yes = 事实是肯定的,No = 事实是否定的。这和中文的“对”“是”不一样。
常见错误
中文母语者的常见陷阱
1. 否定疑问句按中文的“对 / 是”回答。 中文里,“你不会游泳吗?”可以回答“对,我不会”,“对”的意思是“你说得对”。照着说,就成了 Yes, I can't。英语的 Yes / No 只看事实:不会就是 No,会就是 Yes。
2. 宾语疑问句不加 did,也不倒装。 中文问宾语,语序不变:“你跟她说了什么?”很多同学把 what 搬到了句首,却忘了加 did,或者忘了把助动词放到主语前面。
3. 主语疑问句反而多加 did。 学了“疑问句要加 do / did”以后,很多同学到处都加。可是问主语的时候,英语和中文一样,语序不变,不用 did。
4. “你为什么不……”按中文语序说。 中文是“为什么 + 你 + 不”,英语的否定助动词要放在主语前面。
易混淆点
Who called you? 和 Who did you call? —— 问问自己:疑问词是做动作的人,还是接受动作的人?
What happened? 和 What did you do? —— 第一句里 what 是主语(something happened),第二句里 what 是宾语(you did something)。
Who's 和 whose —— Who's = who is 或 who has。Whose 问的是“谁的”。见 A2-13。
直接疑问句和间接疑问句 —— 放在一个更长、更客气的问句里(Could you tell me who…?)时,语序又会变。见 B1-14。
拼写与发音
- 说快的时候,Who did you 常常连在一起,弱读成 /ˈhuː dɪdʒə/:did 的 d 和 you 连在一起,变成 /dʒ/ 的音。
- What did you → /ˈwɒdɪdʒə/(英式),/ˈwʌdɪdʒə/(美式)。what 的 t 几乎听不到。
- 句末的介词要重读,读强读形式:Who are you waiting for /fɔː/(英式),/fɔːr/(美式)?
- 特殊疑问句的句末一般用降调:Who called you? ↘。而 Don't you like it? 这样的一般疑问句通常用升调。
- 日常口语里,否定疑问句用缩写形式:Don't you…? Isn't it…? 完整的 Do you not like it? 也有,但更正式或者语气更强。don't 结尾的 t 很轻,但不要变成 do。
黄金法则
疑问词是主语(做动作的人)时,语序不变 —— 不用 do / does / did:Who called? 疑问词是宾语时,用助动词 + 主语:Who did you call? 回答否定疑问句,事实是肯定的说 Yes,事实是否定的说 No —— 不要照着中文的“对”来回答。
练习
A. 结构
按要求用英语提问。
-
就斜体部分提问,问主语:Maria took my umbrella.
-
就斜体部分提问,问宾语:Maria took my umbrella.
-
就斜体部分提问,问主语:Five students failed the test. (How many…?)
-
连词成句,组成疑问句:you / who / to / talking / are
-
把介词放到句末:With whom did you travel?
-
组成否定疑问句(一般现在时):you / like / horror films
B. 意义
选择正确的一项。
-
选择正确的一项:Who … this song?
-
选择正确的一项:What … for lunch?
-
选择正确的一项:Who … next door?
-
"Didn't you see the email?" 你没有看到那封邮件。怎么回答?…
-
"Isn't Tom coming?" Tom 会来。怎么回答?…
C. 找错
改正错误。如果句子正确,写 correct。
-
What did happen last night?
-
Who you invited to the party?
-
Why you didn't tell me?
-
Which team won the match?
D. 语境练习
用一个词补全对话;有括号的地方,用括号里的动词的正确形式。
Kim: 16 happened to your arm?
Sam: I fell off my bike on Saturday.
Kim: Oh no! Who 17 (take) you to the hospital?
Sam: My brother. And we met our old teacher there!
Kim: Really? What 18 she say?
Sam: She asked about you.
Kim: That's nice. But why 19 you call me on Saturday? I was at home all day.
Sam: Sorry! My phone was broken too. Who 20 I talk to about a new one?
E. 轮到你了
用英语回答。
-
关于一部你知道的电影,写一个主语疑问句和一个宾语疑问句。
-
你的朋友从来不看电视。写一个否定疑问句,表示你很惊讶。
F. 综合复习
复习前面学过的内容。
-
A2-29 英语定语从句入门:who、which、that 和 where 的用法 The man lives next door is a pilot.
-
A2-32 英语“我也是”怎么说:so do I、neither do I、me too 的用法 "I didn't go to the party." "Neither I."
-
A1-16 英语特殊疑问词 what、where、when、who、why、how 的用法和疑问句语序 often do you go to the gym?
参考答案
A. 结构
- Who took your umbrella? / Who took my umbrella?
- What did Maria take? / What did she take?
- How many students failed the test?
- Who are you talking to?
- Who did you travel with?
- Don't you like horror films? / Do you not like horror films?
B. 意义
- wrote
- did you eat
- lives
- No, I didn't.
- Yes, he is.
C. 找错
- What happened last night?
- Who did you invite to the party?
- Why didn't you tell me?
- ✓ Which team won the match?
D. 语境练习
- What
- took
- did
- didn't / couldn't
- should / can / could / do / shall
E. 轮到你了
- Who played the main character? Who did the main character fall in love with?
- Don't you like TV?
F. 综合复习
- who / that
- did
- How
