Slowingo语法
B1 17 / 39

英语情态动词表推测:must be、can't be、might be 的区别

Must Be, Can't Be, Might Be: Present Deduction

本页内容
  1. 学习目标
  2. 核心概念
  3. 中英对比
  4. 结构
  5. 用法
  6. 常见错误
  7. 中文母语者的常见陷阱
  8. 易混淆点
  9. 拼写与发音
  10. 黄金法则
  11. 练习

学习目标

学完这一课,你能根据线索对现在的情况做出合理的推测 —— She must be at work,That can't be right,He might be asleep —— 还能表达出你有多大把握。

核心概念

很多时候,你并不确定一件事,但你手里有线索。就像侦探一样,你看着证据,得出一个结论。英语用情态动词(modal verbs)来表示这个结论有多肯定。

想象侦探的笔记本上有三种结论。must =“只有这一种解释说得通”:The lights are off and the car has gone — they must be out. can't =“这不可能”:She has just eaten a huge lunch — she can't be hungry. might / may / could =“这是一种可能的解释”:He might be in a meeting.

这里的 must 不是说规定 A2-20,而是说逻辑。表示推测时,must 的反义词一般是 can't,而不是 mustn't。

中英对比

在这一点上,中文和英语很像。中文的“一定”也有两份工作:“你一定饿了”是推测,“你一定要系安全带”是要求 —— 英语的 must 正好也是这样。区别在于否定:中文说“一定不……”或“不可能……”,英语表示“肯定不是”时,最常用的是 can't。

中文英语把握
你一定累了。You must be tired.几乎肯定是
她可能在图书馆。/ 她说不定在图书馆。She might be in the library.有可能
他们可能还没到家。They may not be home yet.可能不是
那不可能是 Tom,他在巴黎呢。That can't be Tom — he's in Paris.几乎肯定不是
他一定在跟别人打电话。He must be talking to someone.推测正在发生的事

注意最后一行:中文用“在”表示动作正在进行,英语要用 must be + -ing。还有,中文的“可能”里虽然有个“能”,但英语表示“可能是”时,不用 can,用 might / may / could。

结构

情态动词 + 动词原形(很多时候是 be)

有多肯定?情态动词例子
几乎肯定是真的mustShe must be exhausted.
有可能might / may / couldHe might be at the gym.
可能不是might not / may notThey may not be home yet.
几乎肯定不是can't / couldn'tThat can't be Tom — he's in Paris.

情态动词 + be + -ing —— 推测此刻正在进行的事

句型例子
must be + -ingShe must be working late.
might / may / could be + -ingThey might be having dinner.
can't be + -ingYou can't be leaving already!

情态动词 + 其他动词 —— 多数是状态动词(know, have, live, mean, like, want)

例子意思
You must know Ana — she works in your office.我肯定你认识她。
He can't live here — his name isn't on the door.我肯定他不住这儿。
They may have a spare key.他们也许有备用钥匙。

疑问句 —— 用 could 或 might,或者 Do you think…?。疑问句里也可以用 can:Who can that be?

问法例子
Could… ?Could that be our taxi?
Who might… ?Who might that be at the door?
Who can… ?Who can that be at this time of night?
Do you think… ?Do you think she's ill?

用法

1must —— 几乎肯定是真的

证据只指向一个合理的结论时,用 must。

You've been travelling all day. You must be tired.
你赶了一整天路,一定累了吧。
The restaurant is always full. The food must be good.
这家餐厅总是坐满人,菜一定很好吃。
Her phone goes straight to voicemail. It must be switched off.
她的电话直接转到语音信箱,一定是关机了。
He's wearing a football shirt. He must be a fan.
他穿着足球球衣,肯定是球迷。

2can't / couldn't —— 几乎肯定不是

证据告诉你某件事不可能时,用 can't。couldn't 也可以,听起来稍微委婉一点。

That can't be the right address — this building is empty.
地址不可能是这儿,这栋楼是空的。
She can't be eighteen. She looks about twelve!
她不可能十八岁,看起来也就十二岁!
That noise couldn't be the cat — she's outside.
那声音不可能是猫弄的,它在外面呢。
英语用 she 指自家的猫,中文用“它”
You can't be serious!
你不是认真的吧!
固定说法:表示惊讶,“我不信你是这个意思”

3might / may / could —— 有可能

有可能,但证据不够、拿不准的时候,用这三个词。表示推测时它们意思差不多,may 稍微正式一点。表示“可能不是”,用 might not 或 may not,不用 couldn't A2-22。

I don't know where Lucy is. She might be in the library.
我不知道 Lucy 在哪儿,她可能在图书馆。
Don't call now — they may be asleep.
现在别打电话,他们可能已经睡了。
That noise could be the washing machine.
那声音可能是洗衣机发出来的。
He might not know about the meeting.
他可能还不知道开会的事。
也许不知道,不是“不可能知道”
The shop may not be open on a Sunday.
那家店周日可能不开门。

4推测正在进行的动作:情态动词 + be + -ing

推测此刻正在发生的事,用 情态动词 + be + -ing。状态动词还是用原形:说 He must know,不说 He must be knowing。

The line's busy. He must be talking to someone.
电话占线,他一定在跟别人通话。
中文用“在”,英语用 be + -ing
Listen! Someone might be trying to get in.
你听!可能有人想进来。
She can't be working at this time — the office closes at six.
这个点她不可能还在上班,办公室六点就关门了。
You must be joking!
你开玩笑的吧!
固定说法:“你不会是认真的吧”

5根据证据推理

推测通常会带上理由。可以先说证据,再说结论(常用 so);也可以先说结论,再用 because 补充理由。想问别人的推测,用 could、might 或 Do you think…?。

There are no lights on, so they must be away.
灯都没开,所以他们一定出门了。
Everyone's wearing coats. It must be cold outside.
大家都穿着大衣,外面一定很冷。
It can't be very far, because the sign says 2 km.
不可能很远,因为路牌上写着 2 公里。
Could that be our taxi?
那会不会是我们叫的出租车?
"Who might that be at the door?" "It might be the plumber."
“门口会是谁呢?”“可能是修水管的师傅。”

6must not 表推测 —— 可以,但少见

must not(= 我肯定不是)也能表示推测,主要在美式英语里,通常用完整形式。在英式英语里,mustn't 让人首先想到的是“禁止” A2-20。无论哪种英语,can't 都是最稳妥的选择。

He can't be home — his car isn't here.
他不可能在家,车都不在。
各种英语里的最佳选择
He must not be home — his car isn't here.
他肯定不在家,车都不在。
(美)可以这样说
They must not have any money left.
他们肯定一分钱都不剩了。
(美)= 我肯定他们没钱了

常见错误

❌He must to be tired.
✅He must be tired.
情态动词 + 动词原形,不加 to。
❌They must are on holiday.
✅They must be on holiday.
情态动词后面用 be,不用 am / is / are。
❌It mights be true.
✅It might be true.
情态动词永远不加 -s。
❌She must be work now.
✅She must be working now.
推测正在进行的事:be + -ing。
❌You must be knowing my sister.
✅You must know my sister.
know 是状态动词,不用 -ing A1-23。
❌"Where's Tom?" "He can be in the kitchen."
✅He could be in the kitchen. 或 He might be in the kitchen.
陈述句里的 can 表示一般的可能性(It can be cold here in winter),不用来推测眼前某一件事;疑问句里可以:Who can that be?
⚠️She mustn't be at home — her car's gone.
✅She can't be at home — her car's gone.
可以这样说(主要在美式英语里,用 must not),但 can't 是稳妥、常见的选择。
⚠️He couldn't be at home.(想说“他可能不在家”时)
✅He might not be at home.
couldn't 是“不可能”;might not 是“可能不”。

中文母语者的常见陷阱

1. “可能”里有个“能”,就用 can。 中文“可能是快递员”里有个“能”字,很多同学就说 It can be…。英语陈述句里的 can 说的是一般情况下的可能性(It can be cold here in winter. 这里冬天有时会很冷),推测眼前某一件事时,要用 might / may / could。

❌"Who's at the door?" "It can be the courier."
✅It might be the courier.

2. maybe 和 may be 混用。 “可能”可以翻成 maybe,也可以翻成 may be,但两者语法完全不同:maybe 是副词(= 也许),后面还需要动词;may be 是情态动词 + be。很多同学写成 He maybe at the gym,句子里就没有动词了。

❌He maybe at the gym.
✅He may be at the gym.
或者:Maybe he is at the gym.
⚠️He maybe is tired.
✅He may be tired.
很不自然;或者说 Maybe he is tired.,maybe 一般放在句首。

3. “一定不……”译成 mustn't。 中文说“她一定不在家”,很多同学就把“一定”和“不”拼起来,变成 mustn't。这在英式英语里容易被听成“不准在家”。表示“肯定不是”,最自然的说法是 can't。

⚠️She mustn't be at home — her car's gone.
✅She can't be at home — her car's gone.
不算错(美式英语里有 must not 的说法),但 can't 更稳妥。

4. 用“在”的意思,却忘了 -ing。 中文“他们一定在等我们”,“在”就表示正在进行,动词“等”不变。照搬过来,就成了 They must be wait。英语要用 be + -ing。

❌They must be wait for us.
✅They must be waiting for us.

易混淆点

表推测的 must 和表义务的 must —— 同一个词,两份工作:推测 = 逻辑;义务 = 规定 A2-20。中文的“一定”也一样:“一定饿了”和“一定要系”。

You must be hungry.
你一定饿了。
推测:我肯定你饿了
You must wear a seatbelt.
你必须系安全带。
义务:这是规定

can't(不可能)和 mustn't(不允许)

That can't be true.
那不可能是真的。
不可能
You mustn't tell anyone.
你不准告诉任何人。
不允许

might not 和 can't —— might not 门还开着;can't 把门关上了。

She might not be at work.
她可能没在上班。
也许不在
She can't be at work.
她不可能在上班。
我肯定她不在

对现在的推测和对过去的推测 —— 推测过去的事,用 must have / can't have / might have + 过去分词,B2-06 会讲。

She must be at home now.
她现在一定在家。
She must have been at home last night.
她昨晚一定在家。
对过去的推测,见 B2-06

拼写与发音

  • 表推测的 must 通常弱读:/məst/,在辅音前常常读成 /məs/ —— She must be… 里的 must 又轻又短,/t/ 几乎听不见。
  • can't 要读重、读清楚:/kɑːnt/(英)、/kænt/(美)。词尾的 /t/ 常常听不清,所以英式英语靠长元音 /ɑː/、美式英语靠重音让人听出是否定。can 在句中常弱读成 /kən/,can't 从不弱读。
  • 想表示怀疑时,might 常常重读:It MIGHT be true… but I doubt it.
  • You must be joking! 和 You can't be serious! 是固定的反应,要重读 joking 和 serious。

黄金法则

证据 → 结论。must = 我肯定是;might / may / could = 有可能;can't = 我肯定不是。“可能不是”用 might not / may not;“肯定不是”,最常用的是 can't。

练习

A. 结构

用括号里的动词和合适的情态动词补全句子。

  1. She's been running for an hour. She (be) tired. (I'm sure.)
  2. That (be) Jack — he's on holiday in Thailand. (I'm sure it isn't.)
  3. I'm not sure where my keys are. They (be) in the car.
  4. He isn't answering. He (sleep). (I'm sure.)
  5. 改成“可能不是”:She may be at home.
  6. 用 could 改成疑问句:That is our taxi.
  7. They (live) here — the name on the door is different. (I'm sure they don't.)

B. 意义

根据意思选择正确的一项。

  1. 选择正确的一项:You … be hungry — you've just had a big lunch.
  2. 选择正确的一项:Everyone's carrying umbrellas. It … be raining.
  3. 这句话是什么意思?"She might not be at work."
  4. 电话响了。妈妈常在这个时间打来,老板也是。选择正确的一项:… Mum.
  5. 在 "You must be tired" 里,must 说的是 …。

C. 找错

改正错误。如果句子正确,写 correct。

  1. They must to be at the cinema.
  2. He might be study at the moment.
  3. "Where's Ella?" "She can be in the garden."
  4. You must be knowing my sister.
  5. That can't be right — the shop closed an hour ago.

D. 语境练习

读对话,根据说话人的把握程度补全句子。

新邻居
Ben: Whose car is that outside?
Ana: It 18 be Mark's. His car is blue, and that one's red.
Ben: Then it 19 be the new neighbours' car. I'm not sure.
Ana: Look — there are boxes everywhere. They 20 be moving in today. That's obvious!
Ben: Then they 21 (feel) exhausted. I'm sure of it. Shall we take them some coffee?
Ana: Good idea. But they 22 (have) lunch right now — I don't know. Let's wait an hour.

E. 轮到你了

用英语写出你自己的推测。

  1. 看看你周围。写两个推测,一个用 must,一个用 can't,并说出你的证据。
  2. 一个朋友不接电话。用 might、may 和 could 写出三种可能的解释。

F. 综合复习

复习前面学过的内容。

  1. A2-20 英语 must 和 have to 的区别:mustn't 和 don't have to 怎么用
    You ___ wear a seatbelt — it's the law. …
  2. A2-22 英语 may、might、could 表示“可能”:maybe 和 may be 的区别
    … it will rain later.
  3. B1-14 英语间接疑问句:Could you tell me where… 怎么客气地提问
    Do you know where ___? …
参考答案

A. 结构

  1. must be
  2. can't be / couldn't be
  3. might be / may be / could be
  4. must be sleeping
  5. She may not be at home. / She might not be at home.
  6. Could that be our taxi?
  7. can't live / couldn't live

B. 意义

  1. can't
  2. must
  3. Perhaps she isn't.
  4. It might be
  5. logic

C. 找错

  1. They must be at the cinema.
  2. He might be studying at the moment.
  3. She could be in the garden. / She might be in the garden. / She may be in the garden.
  4. You must know my sister.
  5. ✓ That can't be right — the shop closed an hour ago.

D. 语境练习

  1. can't / couldn't
  2. might / may / could
  3. must
  4. must be feeling / must feel
  5. might be having / may be having / could be having

E. 轮到你了

  1. My neighbour's car isn't there, so she must be at work. It can't be very late — it's still light outside.
  2. She might be driving. She may be in a meeting. Her phone could be switched off.

F. 综合复习

  1. must
  2. Maybe
  3. the station is
Android应用随时随地学习 Google Play