SlowingoGramatika
A2 2 / 38

Past Simple ili Past Continuous? When i while – kako ispričati priču na engleskom

Past Simple or Past Continuous? When and While

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Srpski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Upotreba
  6. Česte greške
  7. Zamke za govornike srpskog
  8. Ne mešajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vežbe

Cilj

Posle ove lekcije moći ćete da ispričate kratku priču o prošlosti: za pozadinu ćete koristiti Past Continuous (trajno prošlo vreme), a za događaje Past Simple (prosto prošlo vreme). Delove priče ćete povezivati rečima when, while, during i for.

Osnovna ideja

Priča ima dva sloja. Jedan sloj je pozadina: duže radnje koje su već bile u toku – I was walking home, it was getting dark. Drugi sloj su događaji: kratke, završene radnje koje guraju priču napred – my phone rang, I stopped.

Zamislite dugu liniju i kratku crtu koja je preseca. Duga linija je Past Continuous: radnja u toku. Kratka crta je Past Simple: događaj koji se desi usred linije i često je prekine. I was walking home (duga linija) when it started to rain (kratka crta).

Kada pozadine nema i radnje se samo nižu jedna za drugom, koristite samo Past Simple, kao korake na spisku: I got up, had a shower and left.

Zato se za svaku prošlu radnju zapitajte: da li je ovo scena iza priče ili jedan korak u priči?

Srpski i engleski

Srpski za oba sloja koristi perfekat, a razliku često nosi glagolski vid: „išla sam kući“ (nesvršeni, pozadina) i „počela je kiša“ (svršeni, događaj). U pričama vas vid zato često dobro vodi. Ali vid nije englesko vreme: i nesvršeni glagol može da bude niz događaja ili navika, a glagoli stanja („znala sam“) ostaju u vremenu Past Simple. Reči dok i tokom rade isto kao while i during. Razlika je kod trajanja: na srpskom kažemo „tri godine“ ili „tokom tri godine“, a na engleskom for three years.

SrpskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Išla sam kući kad je počela kiša.I was walking home when it started to rain.nesvršeni glagol → pozadina, svršeni → događaj
Kad sam stigao, sestra je kuvala večeru.When I got home, my sister was cooking dinner.već je kuvala → was cooking
Kad sam stigao, sestra je spremila večeru.When I got home, my sister cooked dinner.počela je posle mog dolaska → cooked
Ustao sam, skuvao kafu i proverio mejl.I got up, made coffee and checked my emails.ovde je isto: niz događaja, svaki glagol u prošlom vremenu
Dok sam kupovala, izgubila sam novčanik.I lost my wallet while I was shopping.ovde je isto: „dok“ + rečenica = while
Tokom ispita mi je zazvonio telefon.My phone rang during the exam.ovde je isto: „tokom“ + imenica = during
U Rimu smo bili nedelju dana.We stayed in Rome for a week.trajanje: na srpskom bez predloga, na engleskom for
Počela je kiša.It started to rain.na srpskom je subjekat „kiša“; na engleskom it + rain
Kad sam ga upoznala, nisam znala kako se zove.When I met him, I didn't know his name.nesvršeni vid, ali glagol stanja → Past Simple

Ukratko: duga radnja u pozadini → was / were + -ing, kratak događaj ili niz događaja → Past Simple. „Dok“ = while, „tokom“ = during, a „koliko dugo“ = for.

Oblik

Prekinuta radnja

Pozadina (Past Continuous)Događaj (Past Simple)
I was walking homewhen it started to rain.
While I was walking home,it started to rain.
She was having a showerwhen the doorbell rang.

Deo rečenice sa when ili while može da stoji na početku ili na kraju. Kada stoji na početku, posle njega obično stavljamo zarez.

When ili while?

RečPosle nje obično dolaziPrimer
whenkratka radnja (Past Simple)…when the phone rang.
whileduža radnja (Past Continuous)While I was cooking, …

Niz događaja

ŠemaPrimer
Past Simple, Past Simple, Past SimpleI opened the door, turned on the light and saw the mess.
when + Past Simple, Past SimpleWhen the film ended, we went home. (prvo jedno, pa drugo)

During, while, for

Reč+Primer
duringimenicaduring the meeting, during the night
whilerečenica (subjekat + glagol)while we were having the meeting
forperiodfor two hours, for three days

Upotreba

1Radnja u pozadini koju prekine događaj

Duža radnja je bila u toku, a kratka radnja se desila usred nje. Kratka radnja često zaustavi ili promeni dužu.

I was walking home when it started to rain.
Išla sam kući kad je počela kiša.
na engleskom it started to rain
We were having dinner when the lights went out.
Večerali smo kad je nestalo struje.
She was crossing the road when she saw her old teacher.
Prelazila je ulicu kad je ugledala svoju staru nastavnicu.
While he was playing football, he hurt his knee.
Dok je igrao fudbal, povredio je koleno.
The phone rang while I was in the shower.
Telefon je zazvonio dok sam bila pod tušem.
was in = prošlo vreme glagola be; -ing nije potreban
What were you doing when the accident happened?
Šta ste radili kad se desila nesreća?

2When + kratka radnja, while + duža radnja

When obično uvodi kratku radnju (Past Simple). While uvodi dužu radnju (Past Continuous). When je moguće i uz dužu radnju, ali while čini značenje jasnijim.

When I arrived, they were still eating.
Kad sam stigao, oni su još jeli.
I arrived while they were eating.
Stigao sam dok su jeli.
I lost my wallet while I was shopping.
Izgubila sam novčanik dok sam kupovala.
Somebody knocked on the door while we were watching the match.
Neko je pokucao na vrata dok smo gledali utakmicu.
When the teacher came in, the students were talking loudly.
Kad je nastavnik ušao, učenici su glasno pričali.

3Niz događaja – samo Past Simple

Kada se radnje dešavaju jedna za drugom, sve su u vremenu Past Simple. When + Past Simple često znači „prvo ovo, pa ono“.

I got up, made coffee and checked my emails.
Ustala sam, skuvala kafu i proverila mejl.
When the film finished, we went for a pizza.
Kad se film završio, otišli smo na picu.
prvo se završio film, a onda smo otišli
She opened the box, looked inside and smiled.
Otvorila je kutiju, pogledala unutra i nasmešila se.
We landed, picked up the car and drove to the hotel.
Sleteli smo, preuzeli auto i odvezli se do hotela.

Uporedite: vreme menja redosled događaja u priči.

When I got home, my sister was cooking dinner.
Kad sam stigao kući, sestra je kuvala večeru.
počela je pre nego što sam stigao
When I got home, my sister cooked dinner.
Kad sam stigao kući, sestra je spremila večeru.
prvo sam stigao ja, a onda je ona počela

4During + imenica, while + rečenica, for + period

During i while znače „za vreme“, ali during stoji ispred imenice, a while ispred subjekta i glagola. For kaže koliko je nešto trajalo.

My phone rang during the exam.
Tokom ispita mi je zazvonio telefon.
tokom + imenica → during
My phone rang while I was doing the exam.
Telefon mi je zazvonio dok sam radio ispit.
dok + rečenica → while
Several people fell asleep during the presentation.
Nekoliko ljudi je zaspalo tokom prezentacije.
We stayed in Rome for a week.
U Rimu smo ostali nedelju dana.
na srpskom bez predloga; na engleskom for
I waited for forty minutes, and then I went home.
Čekala sam četrdeset minuta, a onda sam otišla kući.

5Glagoli stanja ostaju u vremenu Past Simple

Glagoli koji označavaju stanje, a ne radnju (know, want, like, need, believe, understand, belong, seem), obično ostaju u vremenu Past Simple, čak i u pozadini priče. Pogledajte A1-23.

When I met him, I didn't know his name.
Kad sam ga upoznala, nisam znala kako se zove.
ne „wasn't knowing“
She wanted a new job, so she was looking at online ads.
Želela je nov posao, pa je pregledala oglase na internetu.
want ostaje wanted
We were walking through the old town, and I loved every street.
Šetali smo starim gradom i svaka ulica mi se dopala.
love je glagol stanja → loved

Česte greške

❌During I was at work, she called.
✅While I was at work, she called.
during + imenica; while + rečenica.
❌While the lesson, my phone rang.
✅During the lesson, my phone rang.
Posle while ne može da stoji samo imenica; koristite during.
❌I lived in Paris during three years.
✅I lived in Paris for three years.
Za trajanje koristite for.
❌When I met her, I was knowing she was special.
✅When I met her, I knew she was special.
Glagoli stanja ostaju u vremenu Past Simple.
❌I was walk home when it started to rain.
✅I was walking home when it started to rain.
was / were + -ing oblik.
⚠️I walked home when it started to rain. (meaning: I was already on my way)
✅I was walking home when it started to rain.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali znači da je prvo počela kiša, a onda sam krenuo kući.
⚠️I was waking up, I was having a shower and I was leaving.
✅I woke up, had a shower and left.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali niz događaja obično ide u vremenu Past Simple; trajni oblik ih pretvara u pozadinu.

Zamke za govornike srpskog

1. „Šest godina“ / „tokom šest godina“ → during six years. Na srpskom trajanje kažemo bez predloga („Radio je na brodu šest godina“) ili sa „tokom“. Pošto „tokom“ inače znači during, lako se pojavi during six years. Na engleskom za trajanje uvek stoji for; during kaže kada, u kom periodu.

❌My uncle worked on a cruise ship during six years.
✅My uncle worked on a cruise ship for six years.
koliko dugo → for

2. Pozadina u vremenu Past Simple. Srpski perfekat pokriva i pozadinu i događaj („gledao sam utakmicu“, „pozvao me je“), pa mnogi u engleskoj priči sve stavljaju u Past Simple. Ali radnja koja je već bila u toku kada se nešto desilo traži Past Continuous.

⚠️When Marko called me, I watched the match, so I didn't answer.
✅When Marko called me, I was watching the match, so I didn't answer.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali Past Simple znači da sam utakmicu počeo da gledam tek posle poziva.

3. „Smrklo se“, „Zahladnelo je“ → bez it. Srpski nema reč kao it u rečenicama o vremenu napolju: „Smrklo se“, „Zahladnelo je“, „Grmelo je“. U engleskoj rečenici mora da postoji subjekat, pa za vreme napolju stoji it.

❌We were having a picnic by the lake when suddenly started to rain.
✅We were having a picnic by the lake when suddenly it started to rain. ili We were having a picnic by the lake when it suddenly started to rain.
nedostaje subjekat it

4. Nesvršeni vid → was / were + -ing za svaki glagol. Kada pričamo kako je nešto izgledalo, na srpskom nižemo nesvršene glagole: „Uzimao je torbu, zaključavao stan, trčao na autobus…“ Ako na engleskom sve to stavite u trajni oblik, priča zvuči kao da stoji u mestu. Za korake koji slede jedan za drugim koristite Past Simple.

⚠️Luka was grabbing his bag, was locking the flat and was running to the bus stop.
✅Luka grabbed his bag, locked the flat and ran to the bus stop.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali niz koraka prirodno ide u vremenu Past Simple.

Ne mešajte

When i while – obe reči mogu da povežu dve rečenice, ali obično uvode različite radnje.

When the alarm went off, I was dreaming.
Kad je zazvonio budilnik, sanjala sam.
when + kratka radnja
While I was dreaming, the alarm went off.
Dok sam sanjala, zazvonio je budilnik.
while + duža radnja

During i for – during kaže kada se nešto desilo (u kom periodu); for kaže koliko dugo je trajalo. Više reči za vreme, kao by i until, ima u B1-31.

I woke up twice during the night.
Tokom noći sam se probudio dva puta.
kada → during
I slept for eight hours.
Spavao sam osam sati.
koliko dugo → for; na srpskom bez predloga

Ista vezna reč, dve kombinacije vremena – redosled događaja ne pokazuje vezna reč, nego vreme. Više o kombinovanju prošlih vremena u B1-04.

When we arrived, the party was starting.
Kad smo stigli, žurka je upravo počinjala.
bila je u toku dok smo stizali
When we arrived, the party started.
Kad smo stigli, žurka je počela.
počela je posle našeg dolaska

Pravopis i izgovor

  • Kada deo sa when / while stoji na početku, stavite zarez: While I was out, the parcel arrived. Kada stoji na kraju, obično nema zareza: The parcel arrived while I was out.
  • while /waɪl/: h većina govornika ne izgovara. /w/ nije srpsko v – zaokružite usne kao za u i ne dodirujte zube donjom usnom. Krajnje l je „tamno“: zadnji deo jezika se blago podiže.
  • U brzom govoru was i were su slabi (/wəz/, /wə/), pa naglasak pada na glavne glagole i imenice: I was walking home when it started to rain. Ne izgovarajte was punim samoglasnikom u svakoj rečenici.
  • Pisanje Past Simple (stop → stopped, try → tried) je u A1-27; nepravilni oblici (ring → rang, fall → fell) su u A1-28.

Zlatno pravilo

Duža radnja u pozadini → Past Continuous (često sa while). Kratak događaj koji se desi usred nje → Past Simple (često sa when). Događaji jedan za drugim → svi u vremenu Past Simple. Koliko dugo? → for, ne during.

Vežbe

A. Oblik

Stavite glagole iz zagrada u Past Simple ili Past Continuous.

  1. I (read) when the lights (go) out.
  2. While we (drive) to the coast, the car (break) down.
  3. She (cut) her finger while she (make) a salad.
  4. Povežite rečenice sa when: He was taking a photo. He dropped his phone.
  5. Povežite rečenice sa while: I was jogging. It started to snow.

B. Značenje

Izaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. Izaberite tačan odgovor: … the bus arrived, everybody got on.
  2. Izaberite tačan odgovor: … I was waiting for the bus, I met an old friend.
  3. Izaberite tačan odgovor: I fell asleep … the film.
  4. Izaberite tačan odgovor: We lived in Canada … two years.
  5. Izaberite tačan odgovor: When I got home, my sister … dinner. She started an hour before I arrived.

C. Pronađite grešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna greška ili je rečenica tačna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. During I was sleeping, someone called.
  2. When I saw him, I was knowing he was angry.
  3. I was opening the door and I was going in.
  4. I met my wife while I was working in Rome.

D. U kontekstu

Stavite glagole iz zagrada u odgovarajući oblik i dopunite reči koje nedostaju.

A strange evening
Last Friday I 15 (sit) on the sofa and my cat 16 (sleep) next to me. Suddenly, someone 17 (knock) on the door. I 18 (open) it, but nobody was there. Then, 19 I was closing the door, I 20 (see) a small box on the ground. I woke up twice 21 the night because I was thinking about it!

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o svojim doživljajima.

  1. Napišite nešto o trenutku kada se desilo nešto iznenađujuće. Upotrebite jednu dužu radnju u pozadini i jedan kratak događaj.
  2. Napišite tri stvari koje ste jutros uradili, jednu za drugom.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

Ponovite prethodne lekcije.

  1. A2-01 Past Continuous: trajno prošlo vreme na engleskom (I was working)
    Ispravite grešku: What you were doing at 9 pm?
  2. A1-28 Past Simple: nepravilni glagoli, did i didn't na engleskom
    Napišite prošli oblik: fall
  3. A1-29 And, but, or, so, because: veznici na engleskom
    Izaberite tačan odgovor: It was raining, … we stayed at home.
Решења

A. Oblik

  1. was reading … went
  2. were driving … broke
  3. cut … was making
  4. He was taking a photo when he dropped his phone. / He dropped his phone when he was taking a photo.
  5. While I was jogging, it started to snow. / It started to snow while I was jogging.

B. Značenje

  1. When
  2. While / When
  3. during
  4. for
  5. was cooking

C. Pronađite grešku

  1. While I was sleeping, someone called. / When I was sleeping, someone called.
  2. When I saw him, I knew he was angry.
  3. I opened the door and went in. / I opened the door and I went in.
  4. ✓ I met my wife while I was working in Rome.

D. U kontekstu

  1. was sitting
  2. was sleeping
  3. knocked
  4. opened
  5. while / when
  6. saw
  7. during / in

E. Vaš red

  1. I was waiting for the train when I saw my old school friend.
  2. I got up, had breakfast and took the bus to work.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

  1. What were you doing at 9 pm?
  2. fell
  3. so
Android апликацијаУчите у покрету Google Play