Past Simple ali Past Continuous? When, while in during razloženi v slovenščini
Past Simple or Past Continuous? When and While
Na tej strani
Cilj
Po tej lekciji boste znali povedati kratko zgodbo o preteklosti: ozadje v času Past Continuous (preteklik v teku), dogodke v času Past Simple (preprosti preteklik). Povezali ju boste z when, while, during in for.
Glavna ideja
Zgodba ima dve plasti. Prva je ozadje: daljša dejanja, ki so že potekala – I was walking home, it was getting dark. Druga so dogodki: kratka, zaključena dejanja, ki zgodbo poženejo naprej – my phone rang, I stopped.
Predstavljajte si dolgo črto in kratko zarezo, ki jo prečka. Dolga črta je Past Continuous: dejanje v teku. Kratka zareza je Past Simple: dogodek, ki se zgodi sredi črte in jo pogosto prekine. I was walking home (dolga črta) when it started to rain (kratka zareza).
Kadar ozadja ni in se dejanja preprosto vrstijo eno za drugim, uporabite samo Past Simple, kot korake na seznamu: I got up, had a shower and left.
Pri vsakem preteklem dejanju se torej vprašajte: je to prizorišče za zgodbo ali korak v zgodbi?
Slovenščina in angleščina
Slovenščina pri pripovedovanju pogosto pomaga glagolski vid: „Ko sem hodil domov, je začelo deževati.“ Nedovršni „hodil“ je ozadje, dovršni „začelo“ je dogodek. Tu je podobno kot v angleščini, vendar ne enako: nedovršni glagol je v angleščini lahko tudi Past Simple (We walked for two hours), glagoli stanja pa ostanejo v času Past Simple, tudi kadar so ozadje.
Slovenski „ko“ je when, „medtem ko“ je while, „med“ pa je during. Pazite na zgradbo: za during stoji samostalnik („med izpitom“ → during the exam), za while pa osebek in glagol („medtem ko sem pisal izpit“ → while I was doing the exam). Za trajanje slovenščina predloga ne potrebuje („teden dni smo bili v Rimu“), angleščina pa navadno uporabi for.
| Slovenščina | Angleščina | V čem je razlika? |
|---|---|---|
| Ko sem hodil domov, je začelo deževati. | I was walking home when it started to rain. | ozadje → Past Continuous, dogodek → Past Simple |
| Medtem ko sem nakupoval, sem izgubil denarnico. | I lost my wallet while I was shopping. | „medtem ko“ + osebek in glagol → while |
| Med izpitom mi je zazvonil telefon. | My phone rang during the exam. | „med“ + samostalnik → during |
| Teden dni smo ostali v Rimu. | We stayed in Rome for a week. | trajanje: v angleščini for |
| Ko sem prišel domov, je sestra kuhala večerjo. | When I got home, my sister was cooking dinner. | začela je prej, jaz sem prišel sredi kuhanja |
| Ko sem prišel domov, je sestra skuhala večerjo. | When I got home, my sister cooked dinner. | najprej sem prišel jaz, nato je kuhala ona |
| Ko sem ga spoznal, nisem vedel, kako mu je ime. | When I met him, I didn't know his name. | glagol stanja → Past Simple |
Na kratko: ozadje je Past Continuous (pogosto z while), dogodek in zaporedje dogodkov sta Past Simple (pogosto z when); „med“ + samostalnik je during, „medtem ko“ + glagol je while.
Oblika
Prekinjeno dejanje
| Ozadje (Past Continuous) | Dogodek (Past Simple) |
|---|---|
| I was walking home | when it started to rain. |
| While I was walking home, | it started to rain. |
| She was having a shower | when the doorbell rang. |
Del z when ali while je lahko na začetku ali na koncu. Če je na začetku, za njim navadno stoji vejica.
When ali while?
| Beseda | Navadno sledi | Primer |
|---|---|---|
| when | kratko dejanje (Past Simple) | …when the phone rang. |
| while | daljše dejanje (Past Continuous) | While I was cooking, … |
Zaporedje dogodkov
| Vzorec | Primer |
|---|---|
| Past Simple, Past Simple, Past Simple | I opened the door, turned on the light and saw the mess. |
| when + Past Simple, Past Simple | When the film ended, we went home. (najprej eno, nato drugo) |
During, while, for
| Beseda | + | Primer |
|---|---|---|
| during | samostalnik | during the meeting, during the night |
| while | odvisnik (osebek + glagol) | while we were having the meeting |
| for | časovno obdobje | for two hours, for three days |
Raba
1Dejanje v ozadju, ki ga prekine dogodek
Daljše dejanje je potekalo, sredi njega pa se je zgodilo kratko dejanje. Kratko dejanje daljše pogosto prekine ali spremeni.
2When + kratko dejanje, while + daljše dejanje
When navadno uvede kratko dejanje (Past Simple), while pa daljše dejanje (Past Continuous). When je mogoč tudi z daljšim dejanjem, vendar while pomen pove jasneje.
3Zaporedje dogodkov – samo Past Simple
Kadar si dejanja sledijo eno za drugim, so vsa v času Past Simple. When + Past Simple pogosto pomeni „najprej to, nato ono“.
Primerjajte: čas spremeni vrstni red zgodbe. V slovenščini to pogosto pokaže vid: „kuhala“ ali „skuhala“.
4During + samostalnik, while + odvisnik, for + obdobje
During in while oba pomenita „v času, ko“, vendar during stoji pred samostalnikom, while pa pred osebkom in glagolom. For pove, kako dolgo je nekaj trajalo.
5Glagoli stanja ostanejo v času Past Simple
Glagoli, ki izražajo stanje in ne dejanja (know, want, like, need, believe, understand, belong, seem), navadno ostanejo v času Past Simple, tudi v ozadju. Glejte A1-23.
Pogoste napake
Pasti za govorce slovenščine
1. „Oče je popravljal žleb, ko je zdrsnil“ → My dad fixed… Slovenski preteklik ima za ozadje in za dogodek isto obliko na -l; razliko nosi le vid, ki ga v naglici zlahka spregledamo. Kadar je dejanje potekalo in ga je prekinil dogodek, angleščina zahteva was / were + -ing.
2. „Med“ in „medtem ko“ → during / while. Ker sta si slovenski besedi podobni, ju v angleščini zlahka zamenjamo. „Med vzponom“ (samostalnik) je during the climb, „medtem ko smo se vzpenjali“ (osebek + glagol) pa while we were climbing.
3. „Takrat sem potreboval avto“ → I was needing. Nedovršni glagol stanja („potreboval“, „verjel“, „razumel“) ni dejanje v teku. Tudi kadar je ozadje zgodbe, ostane v angleščini v času Past Simple.
Ne zamenjujte
When in while – oba povezujeta dva dela povedi, vendar navadno uvajata različni dejanji.
During in for – during pove, kdaj se je nekaj zgodilo (v katerem obdobju); for pove, kako dolgo je trajalo. Druge časovne besede, kot sta by in until, so v B1-31.
Ena veznica, dve kombinaciji časov – vrstni red dogodkov pokaže čas, ne veznica. Več o kombiniranju preteklih časov je v B1-04.
Pravopis in izgovorjava
- Če je del z when / while na začetku, za njim stoji vejica: While I was out, the parcel arrived. Če je na koncu, vejice navadno ni: The parcel arrived while I was out. Slovenščina vejico pred „ko“ in „medtem ko“ piše vedno – angleščina ne.
- while /waɪl/: h je pri večini govorcev nem. Začetni /w/ izgovorite z zaokroženimi ustnicami, ne kot slovenski v. Končni /l/ je temen: zadnji del jezika se dvigne.
- V hitrem govoru sta was in were šibka (/wəz/, /wə/), zato je poudarek na glavnih glagolih in samostalnikih: I was walking home when it started to rain.
- started /ˈstɑːtɪd/ ima dva zloga: dodatni zlog -ed izgovorimo samo za /t/ in /d/. rained pa ostane en zlog s končnim zvenečim /d/, ne [t].
- Pravopis časa Past Simple (stop → stopped, try → tried) je v A1-27; nepravilne oblike (ring → rang, fall → fell) so v A1-28.
Zlato pravilo
Daljše dejanje v ozadju → Past Continuous (pogosto z while). Kratek dogodek sredi njega → Past Simple (pogosto z when). Dogodki eden za drugim → Past Simple za vse. „Med“ + samostalnik je during, „medtem ko“ + glagol je while.
Vaje
A. Oblika
Dopolnite povedi z glagolom iz oklepaja v pravilni obliki (Past Simple ali Past Continuous). V nalogah 4 in 5 povežite povedi z dano besedo.
-
I (read) when the lights (go) out.
-
While we (drive) to the coast, the car (break) down.
-
She (cut) her finger while she (make) a salad.
-
Povežite z when: He was taking a photo. He dropped his phone.
-
Povežite z while: I was jogging. It started to snow.
B. Pomen
Izberite pravilni odgovor.
-
Izberite pravilni odgovor: … the bus arrived, everybody got on.
-
Izberite pravilni odgovor: … I was waiting for the bus, I met an old friend.
-
Izberite pravilni odgovor: I fell asleep … the film.
-
Izberite pravilni odgovor: We lived in Canada … two years.
-
Izberite pravilni odgovor: When I got home, my sister … dinner. She started an hour before I arrived.
C. Poiščite napako
V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.
-
During I was sleeping, someone called.
-
When I saw him, I was knowing he was angry.
-
I was opening the door and I was going in.
-
I met my wife while I was working in Rome.
D. V kontekstu
Dopolnite zgodbo z glagolom iz oklepaja v pravilni obliki. Kjer oklepaja ni, dopolnite manjkajočo besedo.
Last Friday I 15 (sit) on the sofa and my cat 16 (sleep) next to me. Suddenly, someone 17 (knock) on the door. I 18 (open) it, but nobody was there. Then, 19 I was closing the door, I 20 (see) a small box on the ground. I woke up twice 21 the night because I was thinking about it!
E. Na vrsti ste vi
Pišite v angleščini.
-
Opišite trenutek, ko se je zgodilo nekaj presenetljivega. Uporabite eno daljše dejanje v ozadju in en kratek dogodek.
-
Napišite tri stvari, ki ste jih danes zjutraj naredili eno za drugo.
F. Mešano ponavljanje
Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.
-
A2-01 Past Continuous: kaj ste ravno počeli v preteklosti (I was working) Popravite napako: What you were doing at 9 pm?
-
A1-28 Past Simple: nepravilni glagoli, did in didn't v angleščini Napišite preteklik: fall
-
A1-29 Vezniki and, but, or, so, because v angleščini – in also, too, as well Izberite pravilni odgovor: It was raining, … we stayed at home.
Rešitve
A. Oblika
- was reading … went
- were driving … broke
- cut … was making
- He was taking a photo when he dropped his phone. / He dropped his phone when he was taking a photo.
- While I was jogging, it started to snow. / It started to snow while I was jogging.
B. Pomen
- When
- While / When
- during
- for
- was cooking
C. Poiščite napako
- While I was sleeping, someone called. / When I was sleeping, someone called.
- When I saw him, I knew he was angry.
- I opened the door and went in. / I opened the door and I went in.
- ✓ I met my wife while I was working in Rome.
D. V kontekstu
- was sitting
- was sleeping
- knocked
- opened
- while / when
- saw
- during / in
E. Na vrsti ste vi
- I was waiting for the train when I saw my old school friend.
- I got up, had breakfast and took the bus to work.
F. Mešano ponavljanje
- What were you doing at 9 pm?
- fell
- so
