SlowingoGramatika
A2 2 / 38

Past Simple ili Past Continuous? When, while, during i for

Past Simple or Past Continuous? When and While

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete ispričati kratku priču o prošlosti: s Past Continuous (prošlo vrijeme u tijeku) za pozadinu i s Past Simple (jednostavno prošlo vrijeme) za događaje. Povezivat ćete ih riječima when, while, during i for.

Osnovna ideja

Priča ima dva sloja. Jedan je sloj pozadina: dulje radnje koje su već bile u tijeku – I was walking home, it was getting dark. Drugi su sloj događaji: kratke, gotove radnje koje pokreću priču – my phone rang, I stopped.

Zamislite dugu crtu i kratku oznaku koja je presijeca. Duga crta je Past Continuous: radnja u tijeku. Kratka oznaka je Past Simple: događaj koji se dogodi usred crte i često je prekine. I was walking home (duga crta) when it started to rain (kratka oznaka).

Kad pozadine nema i radnje se samo nižu jedna za drugom, upotrebljavamo samo Past Simple, kao korake na popisu: I got up, had a shower and left.

Zato za svaku prošlu radnju pitajte: je li to scena iza priče ili korak u priči?

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski obje vrste radnje izriče perfektom, a razliku često pokazuje glagolskim vidom: „Hodao sam kući (nesvršeni vid) kad je počela kiša (svršeni vid).“ To vam ovdje često pomaže, ali nije pravilo: nesvršeni vid može biti i navika ili cijela radnja, a svršeni i niz događaja. U engleskom odlučuje vrijeme: pozadina u tijeku → was / were + -ing, događaj → Past Simple.

Veznici su vrlo slični hrvatskima: „kad“ = when, „dok“ = while. Ali „tijekom“ i „za vrijeme“ imaju dva engleska parnjaka: ispred imenice during (during the night), a za trajanje for (for three years). Na hrvatskom trajanje često kažemo i bez prijedloga („Ostali smo tjedan dana“), a engleski tu obično treba for.

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Hodao sam kući kad je počela kiša.I was walking home when it started to rain.pozadina → Past Continuous; događaj → Past Simple
Dok sam kupovao, izgubio sam novčanik.I lost my wallet while I was shopping.ovdje je isto: „dok“ = while + subjekt + glagol
Kad je film završio, otišli smo na pizzu.When the film finished, we went for a pizza.niz događaja → oba glagola u Past Simple
Tijekom ispita zazvonio mi je mobitel.My phone rang during the exam.„tijekom / za vrijeme“ + imenica → during
U Rimu smo ostali tjedan dana.We stayed in Rome for a week.trajanje: na hrvatskom često bez prijedloga → for
Čekao sam četrdeset minuta.I waited for forty minutes.koliko je trajalo → for, nikad during
Kad sam ga upoznao, nisam znao kako se zove.When I met him, I didn't know his name.glagol stanja → Past Simple, iako je „znati“ nesvršeni
Kad sam došao kući, sestra je kuhala / skuhala je večeru.When I got home, my sister was cooking / cooked dinner.vrijeme mijenja redoslijed događaja

Ukratko: scena iza priče → Past Continuous, korak u priči → Past Simple. During + imenica, while + rečenica, for + trajanje.

Oblik

Prekinuta radnja

Pozadina (Past Continuous)Događaj (Past Simple)
I was walking homewhen it started to rain.
While I was walking home,it started to rain.
She was having a showerwhen the doorbell rang.

Dio rečenice s when ili while može stajati na početku ili na kraju. Kad je na početku, iza njega obično stavljamo zarez.

When ili while?

RiječObično iza nje dolaziPrimjer
whenkratka radnja (Past Simple)…when the phone rang.
whiledulja radnja (Past Continuous)While I was cooking, …

Niz događaja

ObrazacPrimjer
Past Simple, Past Simple, Past SimpleI opened the door, turned on the light and saw the mess.
when + Past Simple, Past SimpleWhen the film ended, we went home. (prvo jedno, zatim drugo)

During, while, for

Riječ+Primjer
duringimenicaduring the meeting, during the night
whilerečenica (subjekt + glagol)while we were having the meeting
forrazdobljefor two hours, for three days

Uporaba

1Pozadinska radnja koju prekida događaj

Dulja radnja bila je u tijeku, a usred nje dogodila se kratka radnja. Kratka radnja često prekine ili promijeni dulju.

I was walking home when it started to rain.
Hodao sam kući kad je počela kiša.
hodanje je pozadina, kiša je događaj
We were having dinner when the lights went out.
Večerali smo kad je nestalo struje.
She was crossing the road when she saw her old teacher.
Prelazila je cestu kad je ugledala svoju bivšu učiteljicu.
While he was playing football, he hurt his knee.
Dok je igrao nogomet, ozlijedio je koljeno.
dok = while
The phone rang while I was in the shower.
Telefon je zazvonio dok sam bio pod tušem.
was in je prošli oblik glagola be: -ing nije potreban
What were you doing when the accident happened?
Što si radio kad se dogodila nesreća?
were ispred subjekta

2When + kratka radnja, while + dulja radnja

When obično uvodi kratku radnju (Past Simple). While uvodi dulju radnju (Past Continuous). When je moguć i uz dulju radnju, ali je s while značenje jasnije.

When I arrived, they were still eating.
Kad sam stigao, oni su još jeli.
kad sam stigao, jelo je bilo u tijeku
I arrived while they were eating.
Stigao sam dok su jeli.
I lost my wallet while I was shopping.
Izgubio sam novčanik dok sam kupovao.
Somebody knocked on the door while we were watching the match.
Netko je pokucao na vrata dok smo gledali utakmicu.
knock on the door: „pokucati na vrata“
When the teacher came in, the students were talking loudly.
Kad je nastavnica ušla, učenici su glasno razgovarali.

3Niz događaja – samo Past Simple

Kad se radnje događaju jedna za drugom, sve su u Past Simple. When + Past Simple često znači „prvo ovo, zatim ono“.

I got up, made coffee and checked my emails.
Ustao sam, skuhao kavu i pregledao e-mailove.
tri koraka jedan za drugim
When the film finished, we went for a pizza.
Kad je film završio, otišli smo na pizzu.
prvo je završio film, zatim smo otišli
She opened the box, looked inside and smiled.
Otvorila je kutiju, pogledala unutra i nasmiješila se.
We landed, picked up the car and drove to the hotel.
Sletjeli smo, preuzeli auto i odvezli se do hotela.

Usporedite: vrijeme mijenja redoslijed priče.

When I got home, my sister was cooking dinner.
Kad sam došao kući, sestra je kuhala večeru.
počela je kuhati prije nego što sam stigao
When I got home, my sister cooked dinner.
Kad sam došao kući, sestra je skuhala večeru.
prvo sam stigao ja, zatim je ona počela kuhati

4During + imenica, while + rečenica, for + razdoblje

During i while znače „za vrijeme“, ali during stoji ispred imenice, a while ispred subjekta i glagola. For kaže koliko je nešto trajalo.

My phone rang during the exam.
Tijekom ispita zazvonio mi je mobitel.
during + imenica
My phone rang while I was doing the exam.
Mobitel mi je zazvonio dok sam pisao ispit.
while + subjekt + glagol
Several people fell asleep during the presentation.
Za vrijeme prezentacije nekoliko je ljudi zaspalo.
We stayed in Rome for a week.
U Rimu smo ostali tjedan dana.
na hrvatskom bez prijedloga; u engleskom for
I waited for forty minutes, and then I went home.
Čekao sam četrdeset minuta, a onda sam otišao kući.
trajanje → for

5Glagoli stanja ostaju u Past Simple

Glagoli koji izriču stanje, a ne radnju (know, want, like, need, believe, understand, belong, seem), obično ostaju u Past Simple, čak i u pozadini priče. Pogledajte A1-23.

When I met him, I didn't know his name.
Kad sam ga upoznao, nisam znao kako se zove.
ne „wasn't knowing“
She wanted a new job, so she was looking at online ads.
Htjela je novi posao, pa je pregledavala oglase na internetu.
want je glagol stanja, look je radnja u tijeku
We were walking through the old town, and I loved every street.
Šetali smo starim gradom i svaka mi se ulica svidjela.
love: glagol stanja

Česte pogreške

❌During I was at work, she called.
✅While I was at work, she called.
during + imenica; while + rečenica.
❌While the lesson, my phone rang.
✅During the lesson, my phone rang.
Sama imenica iza while nije ispravna; upotrijebite during.
❌I lived in Paris during three years.
✅I lived in Paris for three years.
Za trajanje upotrijebite for.
❌When I met her, I was knowing she was special.
✅When I met her, I knew she was special.
Glagoli stanja ostaju u Past Simple.
❌I was walk home when it started to rain.
✅I was walking home when it started to rain.
was / were + -ing oblik.
⚠️I walked home when it started to rain. (meaning: I was already on my way)
✅I was walking home when it started to rain.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali znači da je prvo počela kiša, a ja sam zatim krenuo kući.
⚠️I was waking up, I was having a shower and I was leaving.
✅I woke up, had a shower and left.
Niz događaja obično je u Past Simple; s -ing oblikom zvuči kao pozadina.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Tijekom pet sati“ → during + trajanje. Na hrvatskom „tijekom“ može stajati i uz razdoblje koje mjerimo („tijekom pet sati“, „tijekom tri godine“). Englesko during kaže samo kada se nešto dogodilo, unutar kojeg razdoblja. Za koliko dugo upotrijebite for.

❌On Sunday my little brother played video games during five hours, and then he complained about a headache.
✅On Sunday my little brother played video games for five hours, and then he complained about a headache.
trajanje → for

2. „Vozio se niz puteljak kad je pao“ → Past Simple za pozadinu. Hrvatski perfekt („vozio se“) ne pokazuje vremenom je li radnja bila u tijeku, pa ga lako prevedemo s Past Simple. Ali u engleskom dva glagola u Past Simple uz when znače niz: prvo jedno, zatim drugo.

⚠️Grandpa fell off his bike when he rode down the steep gravel path to the vineyard behind the house.
✅Grandpa fell off his bike when he was riding down the steep gravel path to the vineyard behind the house.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali znači da je djed prvo pao, a tek se onda vozio niz puteljak; za pozadinu → was riding.

3. „Čekali smo trajekt“ → wait bez for. Na hrvatskom „čekati“ ima izravni objekt: čekamo nekoga ili nešto. U engleskom uz wait dolazi for.

❌We were waiting the last ferry to Brač for almost two hours, and in the end the kids fell asleep on our bags.
✅We were waiting for the last ferry to Brač for almost two hours, and in the end the kids fell asleep on our bags.
wait for + ono što čekamo

4. „Na festivalu“ → on a festival. Hrvatsko „na“ stoji uz mnoga događanja: na koncertu, na utakmici, na vjenčanju. Engleski za takav događaj obično kaže at.

❌Ivana was dancing on a jazz festival in Grožnjan when she lost her new sunglasses somewhere in the grass.
✅Ivana was dancing at a jazz festival in Grožnjan when she lost her new sunglasses somewhere in the grass.
događaj → at a festival

Ne miješajte

When i while – oba veznika povezuju dva dijela rečenice, ali obično uvode različite radnje.

When the alarm went off, I was dreaming.
Kad je zazvonila budilica, sanjao sam.
when + kratka radnja
While I was dreaming, the alarm went off.
Dok sam sanjao, zazvonila je budilica.
while + dulja radnja

During i for – during kaže kada se nešto dogodilo (unutar kojeg razdoblja), a for koliko je dugo trajalo. Još riječi za vrijeme, kao by i until, naći ćete u B1-31.

I woke up twice during the night.
Tijekom noći probudio sam se dvaput.
kada: u noći
I slept for eight hours.
Spavao sam osam sati.
koliko dugo → for

Jedan veznik, dvije kombinacije vremena – redoslijed događaja pokazuje vrijeme, a ne veznik. Više o kombiniranju prošlih vremena u B1-04.

When we arrived, the party was starting.
Kad smo stigli, zabava je upravo počinjala.
u tijeku dok smo stizali
When we arrived, the party started.
Kad smo stigli, zabava je počela.
počela je nakon što smo stigli

Pravopis i izgovor

  • Kad je dio s when / while na početku, stavite zarez: While I was out, the parcel arrived. Kad je na kraju, zareza obično nema: The parcel arrived while I was out.
  • while /waɪl/: početak je /w/, a ne v – usne zaobljite kao za u, zubi ne dodiruju usnu. h se kod većine govornika ne izgovara.
  • l na kraju while je „tamno“ l: stražnji dio jezika podignite prema nepcu.
  • U brzom govoru was i were su slabi (/wəz/, /wə/), pa naglasak pada na glavne glagole i imenice: I was walking home when it started to rain.
  • started ima dva sloga jer završava na t: /ˈstɑːtɪd/. Ali walked, stopped i looked imaju jedan slog: -ed iza bezvučnog glasa izgovara se /t/.
  • Pravopis Past Simple (stop → stopped, try → tried) obrađen je u A1-27, a nepravilni oblici (ring → rang, fall → fell) u A1-28.

Zlatno pravilo

Dulja pozadinska radnja → Past Continuous (često s while). Kratak događaj usred nje → Past Simple (često s when). Događaji jedan za drugim → za sve Past Simple. During + imenica, for + trajanje.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite rečenice glagolom iz zagrade u točnom obliku.

  1. I (read) when the lights (go) out.
  2. While we (drive) to the coast, the car (break) down.
  3. She (cut) her finger while she (make) a salad.
  4. Povežite riječju when: He was taking a photo. He dropped his phone.
  5. Povežite riječju while: I was jogging. It started to snow.

B. Značenje

Odaberite odgovor koji odgovara značenju.

  1. Odaberite točan odgovor: … the bus arrived, everybody got on.
  2. Odaberite točan odgovor: … I was waiting for the bus, I met an old friend.
  3. Odaberite točan odgovor: I fell asleep … the film.
  4. Odaberite točan odgovor: We lived in Canada … two years.
  5. Odaberite točan odgovor: When I got home, my sister … dinner. She started an hour before I arrived.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. During I was sleeping, someone called.
  2. When I saw him, I was knowing he was angry.
  3. I was opening the door and I was going in.
  4. I met my wife while I was working in Rome.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite priču glagolom iz zagrade u točnom obliku ili riječju koja nedostaje.

A strange evening
Last Friday I 15 (sit) on the sofa and my cat 16 (sleep) next to me. Suddenly, someone 17 (knock) on the door. I 18 (open) it, but nobody was there. Then, 19 I was closing the door, I 20 (see) a small box on the ground. I woke up twice 21 the night because I was thinking about it!

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o jednom neobičnom događaju i o svom jutru.

  1. Opišite trenutak kad se dogodilo nešto iznenađujuće. Upotrijebite jednu dulju pozadinsku radnju i jedan kratak događaj.
  2. Napišite tri stvari koje ste jutros napravili, jednu za drugom.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. A2-01 Past Continuous: što ste radili u određenom trenutku u prošlosti
    Ispravite pogrešku: What you were doing at 9 pm?
  2. A1-28 Past Simple: nepravilni glagoli, did i didn't na hrvatskom
    Napišite prošli oblik: fall
  3. A1-29 And, but, or, so, because: veznici u engleskom objašnjeni na hrvatskom
    Odaberite točan odgovor: It was raining, … we stayed at home.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. was reading … went
  2. were driving … broke
  3. cut … was making
  4. He was taking a photo when he dropped his phone. / He dropped his phone when he was taking a photo.
  5. While I was jogging, it started to snow. / It started to snow while I was jogging.

B. Značenje

  1. When
  2. While / When
  3. during
  4. for
  5. was cooking

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. While I was sleeping, someone called. / When I was sleeping, someone called.
  2. When I saw him, I knew he was angry.
  3. I opened the door and went in. / I opened the door and I went in.
  4. ✓ I met my wife while I was working in Rome.

D. U kontekstu

  1. was sitting
  2. was sleeping
  3. knocked
  4. opened
  5. while / when
  6. saw
  7. during / in

E. Vaš red

  1. I was waiting for the train when I saw my old school friend.
  2. I got up, had breakfast and took the bus to work.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. What were you doing at 9 pm?
  2. fell
  3. so
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play