SlowingoGramatika
B1 22 / 39

Relative Clauses sa Ingles: Whose, Where, When at Pag-alis ng Who/That

Relative Clauses: Whose, Where, When and Leaving Out the Pronoun

Sa pahinang ito
  1. Layunin
  2. Ang Pangunahing Ideya
  3. Filipino at Ingles
  4. Anyo
  5. Gamit
  6. Karaniwang Mali
  7. Mga Bitag para sa mga Pilipino
  8. Huwag Ipagkamali
  9. Baybay at Bigkas
  10. Gintong Tuntunin
  11. Mga Pagsasanay

Layunin

Pagkatapos ng araling ito, kaya mo nang bumuo ng defining relative clause gamit ang whose, where, when at why, alisin ang relative pronoun kapag layon (object) ito, at ilagay ang preposition sa dulo ng sugnay.

Ang Pangunahing Ideya

Ang defining relative clause ay maliit na pangungusap na inilalagay pagkatapos ng isang pangngalan para sabihin kung alin mismo ang tinutukoy mo: the woman who lives next door, the café where we met. Kung wala ito, magtatanong ang kausap: "Aling babae? Aling café?"

Isipin ang dalawang pangungusap na pinagdurugtong ng isang zipper. This is the café. We met there. Sumasara ang zipper, nalalaglag ang inuulit na salitang there, at pumapalit ang relative word na where: This is the café where we met. Iisang bagay ang pinapalitan ng bawat relative word: who / which / that ang tao o bagay A2-29, whose ang paari (his, her, its, their), where ang lugar (there, in it), when ang oras (then, on that day), why ang dahilan.

Dahil nasa puwestong iyon na ang relative word, wala nang ibang puwedeng pumuno ulit dito — mali ang the book that I bought it. At kapag layon ang relative word, madalas itong tuluyang inaalis ng Ingles: the book I bought.

Filipino at Ingles

Sa Filipino, iisang pang-angkop ang gamit natin para sa halos lahat: na / -ng — para sa tao (ang babaeng sumagot), sa bagay (ang librong binabasa ko) at sa oras (ang araw na naligaw tayo). Para sa lugar, madalas nating gamitin ang kung saan. Sa Ingles, pumipili tayo ayon sa trabaho: who (tao), which / that (bagay), whose (paari), where (lugar), when (oras). Hindi rin puwedeng alisin ang na / -ng sa Filipino, pero sa Ingles, madalas inaalis ang pronoun kapag layon ito. At walang preposition sa dulo sa Filipino — kaya madaling makalimutan ang about o to sa the guy I was telling you about.

FilipinoIngles
Ito ang café kung saan tayo nagkita.This is the café where we met.
Napakamatulungin ng babaeng sumagot sa telepono.The woman who answered the phone was very helpful.
Napakaganda ng librong binabasa ko ngayon.The book I'm reading at the moment is brilliant.
May kaibigan akong nagtatrabaho ang ate sa bagong ospital.I've got a friend whose sister works at the new hospital.
Naaalala mo ba ang araw na naligaw tayo sa Venice?Do you remember the day when we got lost in Venice?
Siya ang lalaking ikinukuwento ko sa iyo.That's the guy I was telling you about.

Pansinin ang ikatlong hanay: may -ng sa Filipino, pero walang that sa Ingles — at tama iyon. At sa ikaapat na hanay, walang hiwalay na salita sa Filipino para sa paari; sa Ingles, whose + pangngalan.

Anyo

Mga relative word

SalitaPinapalitanHalimbawa
who / thattao (simuno o layon)the man who called
which / thatbagay (simuno o layon)the bus that goes to the airport
whosehis / her / its / their + pangngalanthe girl whose bike was stolen
wherethere / in it / at it… (lugar)the hotel where we stayed
whenthen / on that day… (oras)the year when we met
whyfor that reasonthe reason why I left
whomtao bilang layon (pormal)the candidate whom we interviewed

Pagbuo ng sugnay

Dalawang pangungusapIsang pangungusap
That's the man. His dog bit me.That's the man whose dog bit me.
This is the café. We met there.This is the café where we met.
I remember the day. We moved on that day.I remember the day (when) we moved.
She's the person. I spoke to her.She's the person (who / that) I spoke to.

Simuno o layon? Puwede bang alisin ang pronoun?

Trabaho ng pronounHalimbawaPuwedeng alisin?
simunothe man who called youHindi
layonthe man (who) you calledOo

Pagsubok: kung may bagong simuno agad pagkatapos ng relative word (who you called), layon ang pronoun at puwede itong alisin.

Gamit

1Whose — Pag-aari

Pinapalitan ng whose ang his, her, its, their, at laging may pangngalan pagkatapos nito. Gumagana ito para sa tao, at pati sa mga bagay, kompanya at lugar.

I've got a friend whose sister works at the new hospital.
May kaibigan akong nagtatrabaho ang ate sa bagong ospital.
whose sister = ang ate niya
We need a babysitter whose English is really good.
Kailangan namin ng babysitter na magaling talaga sa Ingles.
whose English, hindi who her English
Students whose essays are late will lose marks.
Mababawasan ng puntos ang mga estudyanteng late magpasa ng essay.
marks (UK), points (US)
It's a company whose products are sold all over the world.
Kompanya ito na ang mga produkto ay ibinebenta sa buong mundo.
whose para sa bagay

2Where — Mga Lugar

Nakilala mo na ang where sa A2-29; ito ang mahalagang pagsubok. Gamitin ang where kapag buo na ang sugnay kahit walang lugar: we stayed ✓, I can work quietly ✓. Kung kailangan ng pandiwa ang lugar bilang layon (visit, see, like), gamitin ang that / which o wala. Ang where ay "in / at / on which".

This is the restaurant where we had our first date.
Ito ang restawran kung saan tayo nag-first date.
buo ang "we had our first date" → where
Do you know a shop where I can buy a good umbrella?
May alam ka bang tindahan na mabibilhan ko ng magandang payong?
The village where my grandparents lived has changed a lot.
Malaki na ang ipinagbago ng baryo kung saan nakatira ang lolo't lola ko noon.
I need a room where I can work quietly.
Kailangan ko ng kuwartong tahimik kong mapagtatrabahuhan.

3When — Mga Oras

Gamitin ang when pagkatapos ng pangngalang tungkol sa oras (day, year, time, moment). Puwede ring that, o alisin ang salita.

Do you remember the day when we got lost in Venice?
Naaalala mo ba ang araw na naligaw tayo sa Venice?
na → when
Summer is the time when hotels are most expensive.
Summer ang panahong pinakamahal ang mga hotel.
That was the moment I realised my mistake.
Iyon ang sandaling napagtanto ko ang pagkakamali ko.
inalis ang when

4Why — Mga Dahilan

Pagkatapos ng the reason, gamitin ang why, that, o wala.

The reason why I called was to say sorry.
Ang dahilan kung bakit ako tumawag ay para mag-sorry.
the reason why = ang dahilan kung bakit
That's the reason I didn't apply.
Iyan ang dahilan kung bakit hindi ako nag-apply.
inalis ang why
Nobody knows the reason that the meeting was cancelled.
Walang nakaaalam kung bakit kinansela ang meeting.

5Pag-alis ng Object Pronoun

Kapag layon ng sugnay ang who, which o that, puwede mo itong alisin. Napakakaraniwan nito sa pagsasalita. Kapag simuno ito, kailangang manatili.

The book I'm reading at the moment is brilliant.
Napakaganda ng librong binabasa ko ngayon.
may -ng sa Filipino, pero puwedeng walang that sa Ingles
Is this the phone you wanted?
Ito ba ang cellphone na gusto mo?
Everyone I met at the conference was really friendly.
Napakabait ng lahat ng nakilala ko sa conference.
The film we saw last night was too long.
Masyadong mahaba ang pelikulang pinanood namin kagabi.
The woman who answered the phone was very helpful.
Napakamatulungin ng babaeng sumagot sa telepono.
simuno: kailangan ang who

6Preposition sa Dulo

Sa pang-araw-araw na Ingles, napupunta sa dulo ng relative clause ang preposition na kasama ng pandiwa (talk to, live in, work for), at karaniwang inaalis ang pronoun.

That's the guy I was telling you about.
Siya ang lalaking ikinukuwento ko sa iyo.
huwag kalimutan ang about sa dulo
The flat we're living in is quite small.
Medyo maliit ang flat na tinitirhan namin.
flat (UK), apartment (US); live in → in sa dulo
This is the company I used to work for.
Ito ang kompanyang pinagtrabahuhan ko dati.
work for → for sa dulo
Is that the song you were listening to?
Iyan ba ang kantang pinakikinggan mo kanina?
listen to → to sa dulo

7Who at Whom (Maikli)

Ang whom ay pormal na anyo ng who bilang layon. Ginagamit ito lalo na sa pormal na pagsulat. Agad pagkatapos ng preposition, whom ang gamit sa standard na Ingles, hindi who (to whom). Sa pang-araw-araw na pagsasalita, gamitin ang who, that o walang pronoun. Higit pa sa C1-15.

The person to whom this letter is addressed has moved.
Lumipat na ang taong pinadadalhan ng sulat na ito.
pormal
The person this letter is addressed to has moved.
Lumipat na ang taong pinadadalhan ng sulat na ito.
pang-araw-araw; pareho sa Filipino
The manager whom I contacted never replied.
Hindi kailanman sumagot ang manager na kinontak ko.
pormal; pang-araw-araw: the manager I contacted

Karaniwang Mali

❌The book that I bought it is boring.
✅The book (that) I bought is boring.
Pinalitan na ng that ang "it"
❌The man who he lives next door is a pilot.
✅The man who lives next door is a pilot.
Simuno ang who: walang pangalawang simuno
❌The city where I visited last year was beautiful.
✅The city (that) I visited last year was beautiful.
Kailangan ng visit ng layon: gamitin ang that / which o wala
❌That's the girl who her bag was stolen.
✅That's the girl whose bag was stolen.
Pag-aari = whose
❌The man spoke to me was rude.
✅The man who spoke to me was rude.
Hindi puwedeng alisin ang pronoun na simuno
❌The hotel where we stayed in was lovely.
✅The hotel where we stayed was lovely. o The hotel we stayed in was lovely.
Kasama na sa where ang "in"
❌The person with that I work is kind.
✅The person I work with is kind. o The person with whom I work is kind.
Hindi puwede ang that pagkatapos ng preposition

Mga Bitag para sa mga Pilipino

1. Kung saan → where para sa lahat ng lugar. Dahil kung saan ang gamit natin sa halos lahat ng lugar, madalas where ang lumalabas kahit kailangan ng pandiwa ng layon (love, recommend, choose). Itanong: buo ba ang sugnay kung wala ang lugar?

❌Baguio is the city where I love the most.
✅Baguio is the city (that) I love the most.
love what? → layon: that o wala.
❌Tagaytay is a place where I always recommend to tourists.
✅Tagaytay is a place (that) I always recommend to tourists.
recommend what? → layon: that o wala.

2. Iisang na / -ng → which para sa tao. Dahil iisang pang-angkop ang gamit natin sa tao at sa bagay, minsan which ang lumalabas para sa tao. Para sa tao: who (o that).

❌My teacher which taught me English in high school is now a principal.
✅My teacher who taught me English in high school is now a principal.
Tao → who / that, hindi which.

3. Na + niya / nila → that his / that their. Sa Filipino, ipinapakita natin ang paari sa loob ng sugnay (pamilyang malapit sa dagat ang bahay nila). Kapag isinalin, nagiging that their house o who his. Sa Ingles, iisang salita lang ang gamit: whose.

❌We stayed with a family that their house is near the beach.
✅We stayed with a family whose house is near the beach.
Pag-aari → whose + pangngalan.

4. Nawawalang preposition sa dulo. Walang preposition sa dulo ng sugnay sa Filipino (ang kompanyang pinagtrabahuhan ko), kaya madalas itong makalimutan sa Ingles.

❌This is the project I told you yesterday.
✅This is the project I told you about yesterday.
tell someone about something → about sa dulo.

Huwag Ipagkamali

whose at who's — whose = pag-aari A2-13; who's = who is o who has. Magkatunog ang dalawa.

That's the student whose phone rang in the exam.
Iyan ang estudyanteng nag-ring ang cellphone sa exam.
pag-aari: ang cellphone niya
That's the student who's always late.
Iyan ang estudyanteng laging late.
who's = who is

where at which / that para sa mga lugar — Gamitin ang where kapag buo ang sugnay kahit walang lugar. Gamitin ang which / that (o wala) kapag simuno o layon ng sugnay ang lugar.

That's the museum where we saw the dinosaur bones.
Iyan ang museo kung saan namin nakita ang mga buto ng dinosaur.
buo ang "we saw the bones"
That's the museum that we visited.
Iyan ang museong binisita namin.
visited what? → ang museo = layon; kung saan sa Filipino, pero hindi where sa Ingles

Defining at non-defining — Ang mga sugnay na nagsasabi kung alin ang tinutukoy (walang kuwit) ang saklaw ng araling ito. Nasa B2-08 ang mga sugnay na nagdaragdag lang ng impormasyon, may kuwit.

Baybay at Bigkas

  • Parehong /huːz/ ang bigkas ng whose at who's — "hooz". Mahaba ang /uː/, at may ugong ang /z/ sa dulo: huwag itong gawing /s/.
  • Karaniwang mahina ang that sa relative clause: /ðət/ — "thut" (the car that I bought). Ang /ð/ ay may ugong: ilagay nang bahagya ang dila sa pagitan ng mga ngipin. Huwag itong gawing /d/ ("dat").
  • Walang kuwit sa paligid ng defining relative clause: The man who called you is here.
  • Sa pagsasalita, iisang yunit ang pangngalan at ang relative clause nito, walang hinto: the woman I work with.

Gintong Tuntunin

Pinapalitan ng relative word ang isang bahagi ng sugnay — kaya huwag punuin nang dalawang beses ang puwestong iyon. Kung layon ang pronoun, puwede mo itong alisin: the film (that) we saw. Gamitin ang where kapag buo ang sugnay kahit wala ang lugar — hindi lahat ng kung saan ay where. Para sa paari, whose.

Mga Pagsasanay

A. Anyo

Kumpletuhin o pagdugtungin ang mga pangungusap.

  1. That's the actor films I love.
  2. Is this the beach you lost your ring?
  3. I'll never forget the day my son was born.
  4. Pagdugtungin gamit ang whose: I know a woman. Her husband is a chef.
  5. Pagdugtungin: The man was very friendly. I met him at the party.
  6. Pagdugtungin, at ilagay ang preposition sa dulo: This is the flat. We live in it.
  7. Isulat muli sa pang-araw-araw na Ingles: the people with whom I work

B. Kahulugan

Sagutin o piliin ang tamang sagot.

  1. Puwede bang alisin ang pronoun? "the bus that goes to the centre" …
  2. Puwede bang alisin ang pronoun? "the cake that you made" …
  3. Piliin ang tamang sagot: That's the museum … we visited last summer.
  4. Piliin ang tamang sagot: That's the museum … we saw the dinosaur bones.
  5. Piliin ang tamang sagot: Here's the colleague … organising the trip.

C. Hanapin ang Mali

Itama ang mali. Kung tama na ang pangungusap, isulat ang correct.

  1. The laptop that I bought it last week has stopped working.
  2. The town where I visited was crowded.
  3. That's the girl who her bag was stolen.
  4. The woman answered the phone was very helpful.
  5. The reason I'm late is the traffic.

D. Sa Konteksto

Ilagay ang tamang relative word.

My grandmother's village
My grandmother grew up in a small village 18 everybody knew everybody. She often talks about the year 19 the river flooded the main street. Her best friend was a girl 20 father owned the only shop. That shop, she says, was a little room 21 all the village news started! The friend 22 she shared all her secrets with still writes to her today.

E. Ikaw Naman

Isulat sa Ingles.

  1. Ilarawan ang isang lugar na mahalaga sa iyo gamit ang sugnay na may where.
  2. Sumulat ng dalawang pangungusap tungkol sa mga taong kilala mo: isa gamit ang whose at isa na walang relative pronoun.

F. Halo-halong Balik-aral

Balikan ang mga naunang aralin.

  1. B1-19 Gerund sa Ingles: -ing bilang Simuno at Pagkatapos ng Preposition
    I'm interested in (learn) Spanish.
  2. B1-12 Reported Speech sa Ingles: Paano Iulat ang Sinabi ng Iba (She Said That…)
    "I'm tired," she said. Iulat ito.
  3. A2-13 Mine, Yours, Whose: Possessive Pronouns sa Ingles
    ___ is this coat? Is it yours? …
Mga sagot

A. Anyo

  1. whose
  2. where
  3. when / that
  4. I know a woman whose husband is a chef.
  5. The man I met at the party was very friendly. / The man who I met at the party was very friendly. / The man that I met at the party was very friendly. / The man whom I met at the party was very friendly.
  6. This is the flat we live in. / This is the flat that we live in. / This is the flat which we live in.
  7. the people I work with / the people who I work with / the people that I work with

B. Kahulugan

  1. no
  2. yes
  3. that
  4. where
  5. who's

C. Hanapin ang Mali

  1. The laptop I bought last week has stopped working. / The laptop that I bought last week has stopped working. / The laptop which I bought last week has stopped working.
  2. The town I visited was crowded. / The town that I visited was crowded. / The town which I visited was crowded.
  3. That's the girl whose bag was stolen.
  4. The woman who answered the phone was very helpful. / The woman that answered the phone was very helpful.
  5. ✓ The reason I'm late is the traffic.

D. Sa Konteksto

  1. where
  2. when / that
  3. whose
  4. where
  5. who / that / whom

E. Ikaw Naman

  1. The park near my flat is the place where I go to think.
  2. I have a cousin whose dog can open doors. The colleague I sit next to is very funny.

F. Halo-halong Balik-aral

  1. learning
  2. She said she was tired. / She said that she was tired.
  3. Whose
App para sa AndroidMatuto Kahit Saan Google Play