SlowingoGramatika
B1 22 / 39

Relative clauses na engleskom: whose, where, when i izostavljanje odnosne zamenice

Relative Clauses: Whose, Where, When and Leaving Out the Pronoun

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Srpski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Upotreba
  6. Česte greške
  7. Zamke za govornike srpskog
  8. Ne mešajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vežbe

Cilj

Posle ove lekcije moći ćete da gradite odnosne rečenice koje određuju imenicu (defining relative clauses) sa whose, where, when i why, da izostavite odnosnu zamenicu kada je ona objekat i da predlog stavite na kraj odnosne rečenice.

Osnovna ideja

Odnosna rečenica koja određuje imenicu je mala rečenica posle imenice koja kaže tačno na koga ili šta mislite: the woman who lives next door, the café where we met. Bez nje bi sagovornik pitao: „Koja žena? Koji kafić?“

Zamislite dve rečenice spojene rajsferšlusom. This is the café. We met there. Rajsferšlus se zatvara, ponovljena reč there ispada, a njeno mesto zauzima odnosna reč where: This is the café where we met. Svaka odnosna reč zamenjuje jednu stvar: who / which / that osobu ili stvar A2-29, whose prisvojni oblik (his, her, its, their), where mesto (there, in it), when vreme (then, on that day), why razlog.

Pošto je odnosna reč već zauzela to mesto, ništa drugo ne može ponovo da ga popuni – the book that I bought it je pogrešno. A kada je odnosna reč objekat, engleski je često potpuno izostavi: the book I bought.

Srpski i engleski

Srpski ima skoro savršene parnjake: čiji = whose, gde = where, kada = when, zašto / zbog kojeg = why. „Devojka čija je torba ukradena“ = the girl whose bag was stolen – ovde je isto. Ali u svakodnevnom govoru srpski umesto „čiji“ često kaže „kojoj sestra radi…“, „koji mu pas laje…“, i to vodi do who her sister. Druga razlika je predlog: na srpskom predlog uvek stoji ispred odnosne reči („stan u kome živimo“, „firma za koju sam radio“), a na engleskom u svakodnevnom govoru ide na kraj: the flat we live in. Treća: srpsko „koji“ se nikad ne izostavlja, a englesko who / which / that se kao objekat često izostavlja.

SrpskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Devojka čija je torba ukradena.the girl whose bag was stolenovde je isto: „čiji“ = whose
Imam drugaricu kojoj sestra radi u bolnici.I've got a friend whose sister works at the hospital.razgovorno „kojoj sestra“ → whose sister
Firma čiji se proizvodi prodaju svuda.a company whose products are sold everywherewhose i za stvari i firme
Restoran gde smo imali prvi sastanak.the restaurant where we had our first dateovde je isto: „gde“ = where
Dan kada smo se izgubili u Veneciji.the day (when) we got lost in Venicewhen može i da se izostavi
Razlog zbog kojeg sam zvao.the reason (why) I called„zbog kojeg“ → why ili ništa
Knjiga koju sad čitam je odlična.The book I'm reading now is brilliant.srpski „koju“ ostaje; engleski objekat se izostavlja
Stan u kome živimo je mali.The flat we're living in is small.predlog ispred → engleski predlog na kraju
Firma za koju sam radio.the company I used to work for„za koju“ → … for
Žena koja se javila na telefon.the woman who answered the phonesubjekat: who mora da ostane

Ukratko: „čiji“ = whose, „gde“ = where; predlog na engleskom ide na kraj, a odnosna zamenica kao objekat može da se izostavi.

Oblik

Odnosne reči

RečZamenjujePrimer
who / thatosobu (subjekat ili objekat)the man who called
which / thatstvar (subjekat ili objekat)the bus that goes to the airport
whosehis / her / its / their + imenicathe girl whose bike was stolen
wherethere / in it / at it… (mesto)the hotel where we stayed
whenthen / on that day… (vreme)the year when we met
whyfor that reasonthe reason why I left
whomosobu kao objekat (formalno)the candidate whom we interviewed

Kako se gradi odnosna rečenica

Dve rečeniceJedna rečenica
That's the man. His dog bit me.That's the man whose dog bit me.
This is the café. We met there.This is the café where we met.
I remember the day. We moved on that day.I remember the day (when) we moved.
She's the person. I spoke to her.She's the person (who / that) I spoke to.

Subjekat ili objekat? Može li zamenica da se izostavi?

Uloga zamenicePrimerIzostaviti?
subjekatthe man who called youNe
objekatthe man (who) you calledDa

Test: ako odmah posle odnosne reči dolazi novi subjekat (who you called), zamenica je objekat i može da se izostavi.

Upotreba

1Whose – pripadanje

Whose zamenjuje his, her, its, their i posle njega uvek dolazi imenica. Koristi se za ljude, ali i za stvari, firme i mesta. Na srpskom: „čiji / čija / čije“.

I've got a friend whose sister works at the new hospital.
Imam drugaricu čija sestra radi u novoj bolnici.
razgovorno i „kojoj sestra radi“, ali na engleskom samo whose
We need a babysitter whose English is really good.
Treba nam bebisiterka koja odlično zna engleski.
srpski „koja zna“; engleski whose English
Students whose essays are late will lose marks.
Učenicima čiji eseji kasne biće oduzeti poeni.
marks (UK), points (US)
It's a company whose products are sold all over the world.
To je firma čiji se proizvodi prodaju po celom svetu.
whose i za stvar

2Where – mesta

Where ste upoznali u A2-29; evo ključnog testa. Where koristite kada je rečenica potpuna i bez mesta: we stayed ✓, I can work quietly ✓. Ako glagolu treba mesto kao objekat (visit, see, like), koristite that / which ili ništa. Where znači „u / na kome“.

This is the restaurant where we had our first date.
Ovo je restoran gde smo imali prvi sastanak.
„gde“ = where
Do you know a shop where I can buy a good umbrella?
Znaš li neku prodavnicu gde mogu da kupim dobar kišobran?
The village where my grandparents lived has changed a lot.
Selo u kome su živeli moji baba i deda mnogo se promenilo.
„u kome“ → where
I need a room where I can work quietly.
Treba mi soba u kojoj mogu da radim na miru.

3When – vreme

When koristite posle imenice za vreme (day, year, time, moment). Možete da koristite i that ili da reč izostavite.

Do you remember the day when we got lost in Venice?
Sećaš li se dana kada smo se izgubili u Veneciji?
Summer is the time when hotels are most expensive.
Leto je doba kada su hoteli najskuplji.
That was the moment I realised my mistake.
To je bio trenutak kada sam shvatio grešku.
when izostavljeno

4Why – razlozi

Posle the reason koristite why, that ili ništa.

The reason why I called was to say sorry.
Zvao sam zato što sam hteo da se izvinim.
srpski „zato što“; engleski the reason why
That's the reason I didn't apply.
Zbog toga se nisam prijavio.
why izostavljeno
Nobody knows the reason that the meeting was cancelled.
Niko ne zna zašto je sastanak otkazan.
srpski „zašto“; engleski the reason that

5Izostavljanje zamenice kada je objekat

Kada je who, which ili that objekat odnosne rečenice, možete da ga izostavite. To je vrlo često u govoru. Kada je subjekat, mora da ostane. Na srpskom „koji / koju“ uvek ostaje.

The book I'm reading at the moment is brilliant.
Knjiga koju trenutno čitam je odlična.
srpski „koju“; engleski bez zamenice
Is this the phone you wanted?
Je l' ovo telefon koji si hteo?
Everyone I met at the conference was really friendly.
Svi koje sam upoznao na konferenciji bili su stvarno ljubazni.
The film we saw last night was too long.
Film koji smo gledali sinoć bio je predugačak.
The woman who answered the phone was very helpful.
Žena koja se javila na telefon bila je veoma ljubazna.
subjekat: who mora da ostane

6Predlog na kraju

U svakodnevnom engleskom predlog koji pripada glagolu (talk to, live in, work for) ide na kraj odnosne rečenice, a zamenica se obično izostavlja. Na srpskom predlog stoji ispred „koji“.

That's the guy I was telling you about.
To je onaj lik o kome sam ti pričao.
„o kome“ → … about
The flat we're living in is quite small.
Stan u kome živimo je prilično mali.
flat (UK), apartment (US); „u kome“ → … in
This is the company I used to work for.
Ovo je firma za koju sam nekad radio.
„za koju“ → … for
Is that the song you were listening to?
Je l' to pesma koju si slušao?
listen to: to na kraju

7Who i whom (ukratko)

Whom je formalni oblik za who kao objekat. Koristi se uglavnom u formalnom pisanju. Neposredno posle predloga standardni engleski koristi whom, a ne who (to whom). U svakodnevnom govoru koristite who, that ili ništa. Više u C1-15.

The person to whom this letter is addressed has moved.
Osoba kojoj je ovo pismo upućeno odselila se.
formalno
The person this letter is addressed to has moved.
Osoba kojoj je ovo pismo upućeno odselila se.
svakodnevno: predlog na kraju
The manager whom I contacted never replied.
Menadžer kome sam se obratio nikad nije odgovorio.
formalno; svakodnevno: the manager I contacted

Česte greške

❌The book that I bought it is boring.
✅The book (that) I bought is boring.
that već zamenjuje „it“
❌The man who he lives next door is a pilot.
✅The man who lives next door is a pilot.
who je subjekat: nema drugog subjekta
❌The city where I visited last year was beautiful.
✅The city (that) I visited last year was beautiful.
visit traži objekat: that / which ili ništa
❌That's the girl who her bag was stolen.
✅That's the girl whose bag was stolen.
pripadanje = whose
❌The man spoke to me was rude.
✅The man who spoke to me was rude.
zamenica kao subjekat ne može da se izostavi
❌The hotel where we stayed in was lovely.
✅The hotel where we stayed was lovely. ili The hotel we stayed in was lovely.
where već sadrži „in“
❌The person with that I work is kind.
✅The person I work with is kind. ili The person with whom I work is kind.
that ne može da stoji posle predloga

Zamke za govornike srpskog

1. „Koji mu pas laje“ → who his. U svakodnevnom srpskom umesto „čiji“ često kažemo „koji“ + zamenica: „Ana ima komšiju kome pas laje celu noć.“ Doslovan prevod daje who his dog. Na engleskom pripadanje uvek pokazuje whose + imenica.

❌Ana has a neighbour who his dog barks all night.
✅Ana has a neighbour whose dog barks all night.
„kome pas“ → whose dog

2. „Razlog zbog kojeg“ → the reason because. Srpsko „razlog zbog kojeg“ i „zato što“ lako se spoje u the reason because. Posle the reason engleski koristi why, that ili ništa.

❌Nobody told us the reason because the concert was cancelled.
✅Nobody told us the reason why the concert was cancelled. ili Nobody told us the reason the concert was cancelled.
the reason why, ne because

3. „Sa kojim igraš“ → predlog na početku. Na srpskom predlog uvek stoji ispred odnosne reči: „Je l' to dečko sa kojim igraš tenis?“ Engleski i to može, ali tada mora whom, i zvuči formalno, kao u službenom pismu. U svakodnevnom govoru predlog ide na kraj, a zamenica se izostavlja.

⚠️Is that the boy with whom you play tennis?
✅Is that the boy you play tennis with?
Gramatički je ispravno, ali u razgovoru zvuči previše formalno.

Ne mešajte

whose i who's – whose = pripadanje A2-13; who's = who is ili who has. Izgovaraju se isto.

That's the student whose phone rang in the exam.
To je učenik kome je zazvonio telefon na ispitu.
whose: njegov telefon
That's the student who's always late.
To je učenik koji uvek kasni.
who's = who is

where i which / that za mesta – Where koristite kada je rečenica potpuna i bez mesta. Which / that (ili ništa) koristite kada je mesto subjekat ili objekat odnosne rečenice. Srpski tu pravi istu razliku: „gde smo videli“, ali „koji smo posetili“.

That's the museum where we saw the dinosaur bones.
To je muzej gde smo videli kosti dinosaurusa.
„we saw the bones“ je potpuno
That's the museum that we visited.
To je muzej koji smo posetili.
posetili šta? → muzej = objekat

Odnosne rečenice koje određuju i koje dodaju informaciju – Ova lekcija pokriva rečenice koje određuju na koga ili šta mislite (bez zareza). Rečenice koje samo dodaju informaciju, sa zarezima, obrađuju se u B2-08. I na srpskom se odnosna rečenica koja određuje imenicu po pravilu ne odvaja zarezom („Knjiga koju čitam je odlična“), iako se zarez ispred „koji“ često piše greškom. Na engleskom ovde zareza nema.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • whose i who's izgovaraju se isto: /huːz/. h je samo lagan izdah, mnogo slabiji od srpskog h, a /uː/ je dugo u, sa zaobljenim usnama.
  • that je u odnosnim rečenicama obično slabo: /ðət/ (the car that I bought). Za /ð/ stavite vrh jezika između zuba i pustite glas – nije ni d ni z; /ə/ je kratak, opušten glas.
  • Oko odnosne rečenice koja određuje imenicu nema zareza: The man who called you is here.
  • U govoru imenica i njena odnosna rečenica čine jednu celinu, bez pauze: the woman I work with.

Zlatno pravilo

Odnosna reč zamenjuje jedan deo rečenice – zato to mesto nikad ne popunjavajte dvaput. Ako je zamenica objekat, možete da je izostavite: the film (that) we saw. Where koristite samo kada je rečenica potpuna i bez mesta. I zapamtite: „čiji“ je whose, a predlog u razgovoru ide na kraj.

Vežbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite odnosnu reč ili spojite rečenice.

  1. That's the actor films I love.
  2. Is this the beach you lost your ring?
  3. I'll never forget the day my son was born.
  4. Spojite sa whose: I know a woman. Her husband is a chef.
  5. Spojite: The man was very friendly. I met him at the party.
  6. Spojite tako da predlog bude na kraju: This is the flat. We live in it.
  7. Napišite kako bi se reklo u svakodnevnom engleskom: the people with whom I work

B. Značenje

Izaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. Da li zamenica može da se izostavi? "the bus that goes to the centre" …
  2. Da li zamenica može da se izostavi? "the cake that you made" …
  3. Izaberite tačan odgovor: That's the museum … we visited last summer.
  4. Izaberite tačan odgovor: That's the museum … we saw the dinosaur bones.
  5. Izaberite tačan odgovor: Here's the colleague … organising the trip.

C. Pronađite grešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna greška ili je rečenica tačna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. The laptop that I bought it last week has stopped working.
  2. The town where I visited was crowded.
  3. That's the girl who her bag was stolen.
  4. The woman answered the phone was very helpful.
  5. The reason I'm late is the traffic.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite odnosne reči koje nedostaju u tekstu.

My grandmother's village
My grandmother grew up in a small village 18 everybody knew everybody. She often talks about the year 19 the river flooded the main street. Her best friend was a girl 20 father owned the only shop. That shop, she says, was a little room 21 all the village news started! The friend 22 she shared all her secrets with still writes to her today.

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o mestima i ljudima koje znate.

  1. Opišite mesto koje vam je važno, rečenicom sa where.
  2. Napišite dve rečenice o ljudima koje poznajete: jednu sa whose i jednu bez odnosne zamenice.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

Ponovite prethodne lekcije.

  1. B1-19 Gerund na engleskom: -ing oblik kao subjekat i posle predloga (look forward to seeing)
    I'm interested in (learn) Spanish.
  2. B1-12 Reported speech: indirektni govor na engleskom (said, told, slaganje vremena)
    "I'm tired," she said. Prenesite.
  3. A2-13 Mine, yours, whose: prisvojne zamenice na engleskom
    ___ is this coat? Is it yours? …
Решења

A. Oblik

  1. whose
  2. where
  3. when / that
  4. I know a woman whose husband is a chef.
  5. The man I met at the party was very friendly. / The man who I met at the party was very friendly. / The man that I met at the party was very friendly. / The man whom I met at the party was very friendly.
  6. This is the flat we live in. / This is the flat that we live in. / This is the flat which we live in.
  7. the people I work with / the people who I work with / the people that I work with

B. Značenje

  1. no
  2. yes
  3. that
  4. where
  5. who's

C. Pronađite grešku

  1. The laptop I bought last week has stopped working. / The laptop that I bought last week has stopped working. / The laptop which I bought last week has stopped working.
  2. The town I visited was crowded. / The town that I visited was crowded. / The town which I visited was crowded.
  3. That's the girl whose bag was stolen.
  4. The woman who answered the phone was very helpful. / The woman that answered the phone was very helpful.
  5. ✓ The reason I'm late is the traffic.

D. U kontekstu

  1. where
  2. when / that
  3. whose
  4. where
  5. who / that / whom

E. Vaš red

  1. The park near my flat is the place where I go to think.
  2. I have a cousin whose dog can open doors. The colleague I sit next to is very funny.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

  1. learning
  2. She said she was tired. / She said that she was tired.
  3. Whose
Android апликацијаУчите у покрету Google Play