SlowingoGramatika
C1 16 / 20

Advanced Relative Clauses sa Ingles: To Whom, Whereby, In Which Case at Whatever

Advanced Relative Clauses

Sa pahinang ito
  1. Layunin
  2. Ang Pangunahing Ideya
  3. Filipino at Ingles
  4. Anyo
  5. Gamit
  6. Karaniwang Mali
  7. Mga Bitag para sa mga Pilipino
  8. Huwag Ipagkamali
  9. Baybay at Bigkas
  10. Gintong Tuntunin
  11. Mga Pagsasanay

Layunin

Pagkatapos ng araling ito, kaya mo nang gamitin ang mga pormal na relative structure — to whom, the extent to which, whereby, in which case, by which time, at which point — at ang mga nominal relative tulad ng what, whatever at whoever, at pagsamahin ang relative clause sa infinitive at sa mga quantifier.

Ang Pangunahing Ideya

Ang relative clause ay parang kawit: isinasabit nito ang dagdag na impormasyon sa isang pangngalan. Sa pang-araw-araw na Ingles, nakabitin ang preposition sa dulo ng kawit: the person I spoke to. Sa pormal na Ingles, lumilipat sa unahan ang preposition at kumakapit sa relative pronoun: the person to whom I spoke. Pareho ang kahulugan; rehistro lang ang nagbabago.

May mga pormal na relative na kumakawit sa buong ideya, hindi lang sa isang pangngalan: The train may be cancelled, in which case we'll drive. Dito, tumuturo ang which sa buong sitwasyon — ang posibleng pagkansela ng tren.

May iba namang relative na dala na sa loob ang pangngalan nila. Ang what ay the thing that; ang whoever ay any person who. Sa mga nominal relative na ito, gumagana bilang pangngalan ang buong clause: What she said surprised me.

Filipino at Ingles

Sa Filipino, iisang pang-angkop lang ang nag-uugnay ng pangngalan at relative clause: na / -ng. Wala tayong preposition sa loob ng clause, dahil ang pokus ng pandiwa ang nagsasabi ng ugnayan: ang bahay na tinitirhan namin (locative focus) = the house in which we live / the house we live in. Sa Ingles, kailangang lumabas ang preposition — sa dulo o sa unahan. Sa mga nominal relative naman, magkahawig tayo: ang ang + pandiwa ay gumagana rin bilang pangngalan (Ang ikinagulat ko… = What surprised me…), at ang kung sino man at kahit ano ang katapat ng whoever at whatever.

FilipinoInglesPansinin
ang taong pinadalhan ng sulat na itothe person to whom this letter is addressedpokus ng pandiwa → preposition sa Ingles
ang bahay na tinitirhan naminthe flat in which we live / the flat we live inhindi puwedeng mawala ang in
Ang pinakaikinagulat ko ay kung gaano siya kakalmado.What surprised me most was how calm she stayed.pareho: buong clause bilang pangngalan
Kung sino man ang gumawa ng app na ito, dapat siyang bigyan ng parangal.Whoever designed this app deserves an award.iisang salita sa Ingles
Puwede kang umorder kahit ano.You can order whatever you like.
Baka ma-delay ang flight, at kung mangyari iyon, …The flight might be delayed, in which case …tumuturo sa buong sitwasyon
May tatlo siyang kapatid, at lahat sila ay nasa ibang bansa.She has three brothers, all of whom live abroad.of whom, hindi of them

Anyo

Preposition + whom / which

Impormal (preposition sa dulo)Pormal (preposition sa unahan)
the person (who) I spoke tothe person to whom I spoke
the company (that) she works forthe company for which she works
the colleagues (who) he relies onthe colleagues on whom he relies
the way (that) the system worksthe way in which the system works

Pagkatapos ng preposition, gamitin ang whom (tao) o which (bagay), o whose + pangngalan (the writer to whose work I referred). Hindi kailanman puwede ang that dito, at iniiwasan ang who pagkatapos ng preposition sa maingat na Ingles.

Mga relative na kumakawit sa paraan, oras o buong sitwasyon

RelativeKahuluganTinutukoy
wherebyby which / through whichsistema, paraan o kasunduan
in which caseat kung mangyari iyonang buong naunang clause
by which timeat bago ang oras na iyonoras o pangyayari
at which pointat sa sandaling iyonsandali o pangyayari

Nominal relative (nasa loob ang pangngalan)

RelativeKahuluganHalimbawa
whatang bagay/mga bagay naWhat I need is sleep.
whateverkahit anongTake whatever you want.
whoeversinumang / ang taongWhoever finishes first wins.
whicheverkahit alin (mula sa limitadong pagpipilian)Choose whichever room you like.
wherever / wheneverkahit saan / kahit kailanSit wherever you like.

Infinitive at quantifier relative (balik-aral)

PatternHalimbawa
pangngalan + to-infinitivethe person to contact
pangngalan + preposition + which/whom + to-infinitive (pormal)a place in which to live
quantifier + of + whom / whichall of which, neither of whom

Gamit

1Preposition + whom / which

Sa pormal na pagsusulat, ilagay ang preposition bago ang whom o which. Halos laging ganito ang ilang ekspresyon: the extent to which, the speed at which, the way in which, the basis on which. Hindi ito puwede sa phrasal verb: nananatili sa pandiwa ang particle nito (the problem I came across). Parehong tama ang dalawang ayos; ang rehistro ang magpapasya (C2-02).

The person to whom this letter is addressed no longer works here.
Hindi na rito nagtatrabaho ang taong pinadalhan ng sulat na ito.
pokus ng pandiwa sa Filipino, to whom sa Ingles
This is the research on which the whole theory is based.
Ito ang pananaliksik na pinagbatayan ng buong teorya.
She thanked the colleagues with whom she had worked for twenty years.
Nagpasalamat siya sa mga katrabahong nakasama niya nang dalawampung taon.
The study measures the extent to which sleep affects memory.
Sinusukat ng pag-aaral kung hanggang saan naaapektuhan ng tulog ang memorya.
nakapirming pattern
The speed at which technology changes can be overwhelming.
Nakalulula ang bilis ng pagbabago ng teknolohiya.

2Whereby

Ang whereby ay by which o through which. Ipinapakilala nito ang paraan o kaayusan ng isang sistema, iskema, kasunduan o proseso. Pormal ito at karaniwan sa pagsusulat sa negosyo at akademya.

The company has introduced a scheme whereby staff can buy shares at a discount.
Naglunsad ang kompanya ng iskema kung saan makabibili ang mga empleyado ng shares nang may discount.
paraan o kaayusan
The two sides reached an agreement whereby each would pay half the costs.
Nagkasundo ang dalawang panig na kalahati ng gastos ang babayaran ng bawat isa.
Photosynthesis is the process whereby plants turn light into energy.
Ang photosynthesis ang prosesong ginagamit ng mga halaman para gawing enerhiya ang liwanag.

3In Which Case, By Which Time, At Which Point

Tumuturo pabalik ang mga pariralang ito sa buong sitwasyon at idinadagdag kung ano ang kasunod nito. Dumarating sila pagkatapos ng kuwit. In which case = kung mangyari iyon; by which time = at bago ang sandaling iyon (madalas kasama ang past perfect); at which point = at sa mismong sandaling iyon.

The flight might be delayed, in which case we'll miss the connection.
Baka ma-delay ang flight, at kung mangyari iyon, mami-miss namin ang connecting flight.
You may find an error on the form, in which case please contact us immediately.
Kung may makita kang mali sa form, makipag-ugnayan agad sa amin.
We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed.
Hatinggabi na kami nakarating doon, at sarado na ang restawran noon.
past perfect: nauna ang pagsasara
The talks went on until 3 a.m., by which time everyone was exhausted.
Tumagal ang usapan hanggang alas-tres ng madaling-araw, at pagod na pagod na ang lahat noon.
He started shouting, at which point security asked him to leave.
Nagsimula siyang sumigaw, at doon na siya pinaalis ng security.
sa sandaling iyon

4Nominal Relative: what at ang mga -ever na salita

Dala ng nominal relative ang sarili nitong pangngalan, kaya puwedeng simuno o layon ang buong clause. What = the thing(s) that (B2-20). Idinadagdag ng mga -ever na anyo ang "kahit alin — hindi mahalaga kung alin". Para sa limitadong pagpipilian ang whichever. Sa simula ng pangungusap, puwede ring no matter what / who / where ang whatever, whoever at wherever (B2-23).

What surprised me most was how calm she stayed.
Ang pinakaikinagulat ko ay kung gaano siya kakalmado.
what = the thing that; ang + pandiwa
I'll do what I can to help.
Gagawin ko ang makakaya ko para tumulong.
You can order whatever you like; it's my treat.
Puwede kang umorder ng kahit ano; libre ko.
Whoever designed this app deserves an award.
Kung sino man ang gumawa ng app na ito, dapat siyang bigyan ng parangal.
Take whichever seat you prefer.
Pumili ka ng kahit aling upuang gusto mo.
mula sa mga upuang naroon
Our dog follows me wherever I go.
Sinusundan ako ng aso namin kahit saan ako magpunta.
Whatever happens, don't panic.
Anuman ang mangyari, huwag kang mag-panic.
= no matter what happens

5Infinitive Relative (balik-aral)

Puwedeng lumiit ang relative clause tungo sa to-infinitive, lalo na pagkatapos ng mga pangngalan ng layunin at pagkatapos ng first, last, only at mga superlative (B2-09). Sa pormal na istilo, puwedeng mauna sa infinitive ang preposition + which / whom. Hindi kailanman ginagamit ang who at that bago ang infinitive.

If you have questions, the person to contact is Ms Patel.
Kung may tanong ka, si Ms Patel ang dapat mong kontakin.
They're looking for a quiet place in which to live.
Naghahanap sila ng tahimik na lugar na matitirhan.
pormal = a quiet place to live in
She felt she had nobody with whom to share her worries.
Pakiramdam niya, wala siyang mapagsabihan ng mga alalahanin niya.
pormal = nobody to share them with
He was the last person to leave the building.
Siya ang huling taong umalis sa gusali.

6Quantifier + of whom / of which (balik-aral)

Gumamit ng quantifier (all, some, most, many, neither, none, both, half) o numero + of whom (tao) o of which (bagay) para pag-usapan ang bahagi ng isang grupo. Non-defining ang mga clause na ito, kaya sumusunod sila sa kuwit (B2-08).

She has three brothers, all of whom live abroad.
May tatlo siyang kapatid na lalaki, at lahat sila ay nasa ibang bansa.
of whom: tao
We received over 200 applications, most of which were excellent.
Mahigit 200 aplikasyon ang natanggap namin, at karamihan sa mga iyon ay napakahusay.
of which: bagay
I asked two mechanics, neither of whom could find the problem.
Nagtanong ako sa dalawang mekaniko, at walang isa man sa kanila ang nakahanap ng problema.
The museum owns thousands of paintings, many of which have never been shown.
Libu-libong painting ang pag-aari ng museo, at marami sa mga iyon ang hindi pa kailanman naipakita.

Karaniwang Mali

⚠️The man to who I spoke was very helpful.
✅The man to whom I spoke was very helpful. o The man (who) I spoke to was very helpful.
Minsan naririnig ang who pagkatapos ng preposition sa pagsasalita, pero naghahalo ito ng istilo: whom ang kailangan ng pormal na pattern.
❌The flat in that we live is rented.
✅The flat in which we live is rented. o The flat (that) we live in is rented.
Hindi puwedeng sumunod ang that sa preposition.
❌This is the problem about which I came across.
✅This is the problem (that) I came across.
Nananatili sa phrasal verb ang particle nito.
❌I have two sisters, both of them are doctors.
✅I have two sisters, both of whom are doctors. o …sisters, and both of them are doctors.
Para pagdugtungin ang mga clause, gamitin ang of whom.
❌Everything what he said was true.
✅Everything (that) he said was true.
Pagkatapos ng everything/all/something, that o walang salita, hindi what.
❌The bus may be late, which case we'll walk.
✅The bus may be late, in which case we'll walk.
Ang nakapirming parirala ay in which case.
❌She needs a friend who to talk to.
✅She needs a friend to talk to. o …a friend with whom to talk.
Hindi kailanman who bago ang infinitive.
❌Whatever you will decide, I'll support you.
✅Whatever you decide, I'll support you.
Present tense para sa kahulugang panghinaharap pagkatapos ng whatever/whenever/wherever.

Mga Bitag para sa mga Pilipino

1. Nawawalang preposition. Sa Filipino, ang pokus ng pandiwa ang nagdadala ng ugnayan: ang kompanyang pinagtatrabahuhan ko, ang paksang pinag-usapan namin. Walang hiwalay na preposition, kaya madalas itong mawala sa Ingles. Pero kailangan ito — sa dulo (impormal) o sa unahan, kasama ang which / whom (pormal).

❌This is the company I have worked since 2019.
✅This is the company I have worked for since 2019. o This is the company for which I have worked since 2019.
work for: hindi puwedeng mawala ang for
❌The topic we talked yesterday will be in the exam.
✅The topic we talked about yesterday will be in the exam. o The topic about which we talked yesterday will be in the exam.
talk about

2. Of which para sa tao. Iisa ang na natin para sa tao at bagay, kaya minsan which ang lumalabas kahit tao ang tinutukoy. Sa quantifier relative, of whom ang para sa tao, of which ang para sa bagay.

❌I invited my old barkada from college, some of which I hadn't seen in ten years.
✅I invited my old barkada from college, some of whom I hadn't seen in ten years.
tao → of whom

3. Kung sino ang → Who sa halip na Whoever. Sa Kung sino ang unang makauwi, siya ang magsasaing, madaling isalin ang kung sino ang bilang who lang. Pero sa simula ng pangungusap na walang pangngalan bago nito, whoever ang kailangan — o the person who.

❌Who gets home first should start cooking the rice.
✅Whoever gets home first should start cooking the rice. o The person who gets home first should start cooking the rice.
walang pangngalan bago ang who

Huwag Ipagkamali

what at which (buong clause) — Dala ng what ang pangngalan nito (= the thing that). Ang which pagkatapos ng kuwit ay nagkokomento sa buong naunang clause (B2-08).

What she said made everyone laugh.
Pinatawa ng sinabi niya ang lahat.
what = the thing that
She told a joke, which made everyone laugh.
Nagbiro siya, at natawa ang lahat dahil doon.
which = and this

whereby at where — Tungkol sa lugar (pisikal o abstrakto) ang where; tungkol sa paraan o kaayusan ang whereby. Parehong kung saan ang madalas nating salin, kaya mag-ingat.

This is the office where I first worked.
Ito ang opisinang una kong pinagtrabahuhan.
lugar
We have a system whereby new staff are paired with a mentor.
May sistema kami kung saan may kapares na mentor ang bawat bagong empleyado.
paraan

whoever at who — Kailangan ng who ng pangngalan bago ito (the person who…). Kasama na sa whoever ang pangngalan.

The person who wins gets a free trip.
Ang taong mananalo ay makakakuha ng libreng biyahe.
Whoever wins gets a free trip.
Kung sino man ang manalo, may libreng biyahe siya.

Baybay at Bigkas

  • Whom /huːm/ — parang who + "m"; mahaba ang /uː/ at bilugan ang labi. Hindi binibigkas ang w.
  • Iisang salita ang whereby, may diin sa ikalawang pantig: /weəˈbaɪ/ (UK), /werˈbaɪ/ (US) — whereby.
  • Iisang salita ang bawat isa sa whatever, whoever, whichever, wherever, whenever; nasa -ev- ang diin: whatever, whoever. Mahina at maikli ang huling pantig.
  • Ang what ever bilang dalawang salita ay mariing tanong (What ever happened to him?), hindi nominal relative — tingnan ang C1-06.
  • May maikling hinto, na ipinapakita ng kuwit, bago ang in which case, by which time at at which point.
  • Sa most of which, neither of whom, nasa quantifier ang diin: most of which. Mahina ang of (/əv/), at /v/ ang dulo nito — hindi /f/ at hindi "op".

Gintong Tuntunin

Sa pormal na Ingles, puwede mong ilipat sa unahan ang preposition; pagkatapos nito, whom o which — hindi kailanman that. Pero huwag itong alisin: kahit pokus ng pandiwa ang gumagawa nito sa Filipino, kailangan ng Ingles ang preposition. Gamitin ang what at ang mga -ever na salita kapag ang relative clause mismo ang pangngalan. Gamitin ang in which case, by which time at at which point para ikawit ang bagong clause sa buong sitwasyon.

Mga Pagsasanay

A. Anyo

Isulat muli ang bawat pangungusap gamit ang istrukturang ibinigay. Panatilihin ang kahulugan.

  1. Isulat muli nang pormal, na nauuna ang preposition sa relative pronoun: The woman I sent the email to is my manager.
  2. Isulat muli bilang isang pangungusap gamit ang "whereby": The company has a new scheme. Under this scheme, staff can buy shares at a discount.
  3. Isulat muli bilang isang pangungusap gamit ang "in which case": The flight might be delayed. If that happens, we'll miss our connection.
  4. Isulat muli bilang isang pangungusap gamit ang "by which time": We didn't get there until midnight. The restaurant had already closed then.
  5. Isulat muli bilang isang pangungusap gamit ang "of whom": I asked two mechanics. Neither of them could find the problem.
  6. Isulat muli simula sa "Whoever": The person who designed this app deserves an award.
  7. Isulat muli nang pormal, gamit ang preposition + "whom" + to-infinitive: She felt she had nobody to share her worries with.

B. Kahulugan

Basahin ang konteksto, saka piliin ang mas angkop na pangungusap.

  1. Isang pormal na letter of reference. Aling pangungusap ang mas bagay sa rehistro?
  2. Isang text message sa kaibigan. Alin ang mas natural?
  3. Inilalarawan ng isang pormal na policy document ang isang mentoring scheme. Aling pananalita ang mas tumpak?
  4. Inilalarawan ng isang news report ang nangyari sa isang pulong. Aling pangungusap ang bagay?
  5. Ipinapakita ng isang host sa bisita ang tatlong bakanteng kuwarto. Aling pangungusap ang pinakabagay?

C. Hanapin ang Mali

Itama ang mali. Kung tama na ang pangungusap, isulat ang correct.

  1. We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, most of them had several years of experience in the industry.
  2. Everything what the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers.
  3. The house in that my grandparents lived for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family.
  4. Whatever you will decide about the job offer, your family and friends will support you all the way.
  5. The study measures the extent to which regular exercise improves sleep in adults over the age of sixty.

D. Sa Konteksto

Basahin ang email at isulat muli ang mga may numerong bahagi sa mas pormal at magkakaugnay na istilo.

Interview invitation
Dear Ms Kovac,
(18) Thank you for your application. We received it on 3 May. (19) The panel has five members. All of them were impressed by your experience, and we would like to invite you to an interview. (20) We use a system. In this system, each candidate gives a ten-minute presentation. (21) Interviews end on 20 May. At that moment the panel will make its decision. (22) Please let us know if you cannot attend. If that happens, we will offer you another date. (23) You may bring any materials that you find useful. (24) The person you should send questions to is Mr Adebayo.
Yours sincerely,
Hana Iqbal
  1. Pagsamahin ang (18) sa isang pangungusap na may non-defining relative clause.
  2. Pagsamahin ang unang dalawang pangungusap ng (19) gamit ang "all of whom".
  3. Pagsamahin ang (20) sa isang pangungusap gamit ang "whereby".
  4. Pagsamahin ang (21) gamit ang "at which point".
  5. Pagsamahin ang (22) gamit ang "in which case".
  6. Isulat muli ang (23) gamit ang nominal relative na nagtatapos sa -ever.
  7. Isulat muli ang (24) nang pormal, gamit ang "to whom".

E. Ikaw Naman

Isulat sa Ingles.

  1. Sumulat ng pormal na pasasalamat sa isang guro o mentor sa 2–3 pangungusap. Gamitin nang isang beses ang preposition + whom, at nang isang beses ang the extent to which o the way in which.
  2. Ilarawan sa 2–3 pangungusap ang isang planong baka pumalpak. Gamitin nang isang beses ang in which case, at nang isang beses ang by which time o at which point.
  3. Ilarawan sa 2–3 pangungusap ang isang grupo ng tao o bagay na kilala mo. Gumamit ng isang quantifier + of whom / of which, at isang -ever na salita (whoever, whatever o whichever).

F. Halo-halong Balik-aral

Balikan ang mga naunang aralin.

  1. B2-08 Non-Defining Relative Clauses sa Ingles: Dagdag na Impormasyon na may Kuwit
    Pagsamahin gamit ang non-defining relative clause: My sister is a chef. She lives in Rome.
  2. B2-20 Noun Clauses sa Ingles: That, Whether, If at What, Madaling Paliwanag
    Isulat muli simula sa "What": The thing that surprised me was her calm reaction.
  3. C1-13 Discourse Markers sa Ingles II: Given That, Hence, Namely, Admittedly at In Conclusion
    Isulat muli gamit ang "albeit": The project was a success, although it was an expensive one.
Mga sagot

A. Anyo

  1. The woman to whom I sent the email is my manager.
  2. The company has a new scheme whereby staff can buy shares at a discount.
  3. The flight might be delayed, in which case we'll miss our connection.
  4. We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed. / We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had already closed.
  5. I asked two mechanics, neither of whom could find the problem.
  6. Whoever designed this app deserves an award.
  7. She felt she had nobody with whom to share her worries.

B. Kahulugan

  1. She is someone on whom I have always been able to rely.
  2. Is that the guy you were telling me about?
  3. We have a system whereby new staff are paired with a mentor.
  4. The speaker began shouting, at which point security asked him to leave.
  5. You can take whichever room you prefer tonight.

C. Hanapin ang Mali

  1. We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, most of whom had several years of experience in the industry. / We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, and most of them had several years of experience in the industry.
  2. Everything the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers. / Everything that the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers.
  3. The house in which my grandparents lived for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family. / The house that my grandparents lived in for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family.
  4. Whatever you decide about the job offer, your family and friends will support you all the way.
  5. ✓ The study measures the extent to which regular exercise improves sleep in adults over the age of sixty.

D. Sa Konteksto

  1. Thank you for your application, which we received on 3 May.
  2. The panel has five members, all of whom were impressed by your experience, and we would like to invite you to an interview.
  3. We use a system whereby each candidate gives a ten-minute presentation.
  4. Interviews end on 20 May, at which point the panel will make its decision.
  5. Please let us know if you cannot attend, in which case we will offer you another date.
  6. You may bring whatever materials you find useful.
  7. The person to whom you should send questions is Mr Adebayo.

E. Ikaw Naman

  1. I would like to thank Dr Novak, without whom I would never have finished this project. Her advice has changed the way in which I approach research.
  2. We're planning to leave at six, but the traffic may be heavy, in which case we'll take the train. Either way, we should arrive by eight, by which time the speeches will have started.
  3. Our team has six members, most of whom work from home. Whoever comes into the office first on Monday makes the coffee.

F. Halo-halong Balik-aral

  1. My sister, who lives in Rome, is a chef.
  2. What surprised me was her calm reaction.
  3. The project was a success, albeit an expensive one.
App para sa AndroidMatuto Kahit Saan Google Play