Slowingo语法
B1 2 / 39

英语 for 和 since 的区别:现在完成时还是现在完成进行时?

For, Since, How Long — Simple or Continuous?

本页内容
  1. 学习目标
  2. 核心概念
  3. 中英对比
  4. 结构
  5. 用法
  6. 常见错误
  7. 中文母语者的常见陷阱
  8. 易混淆点
  9. 拼写与发音
  10. 黄金法则
  11. 练习

学习目标

学完这一课,你能用 for、since 和 How long…? 说一个情况持续了多久,还能在 present perfect simple(现在完成时:I've read)和 present perfect continuous(现在完成进行时:I've been reading)之间做出选择。

核心概念

你已经知道,一个情况从过去开始、到现在还是这样,就要用完成时,加上 for(一段时间)或者 since(一个起点)A2-18:I've lived here for five years,而不是 I live here for five years。现在,你还要再选一次:用一般形式还是进行形式?

想象一个刷墙工人的两张照片。第一张:墙已经刷好了,闪闪发亮:I've painted the wall. 这是一般形式(simple)—— 它展示的是一个结果,一件完成了的事,或者一个能数得出来的总数。第二张:她手里拿着一把湿漉漉的刷子,衣服上沾满了油漆:I've been painting the wall. 这是进行形式(continuous)—— 它展示的是正在进行的活动,以及它持续了多久。可能刷完了,也可能还没刷完;这不是重点。

有些动词(know、表示拥有的 have、be、like、believe)描述的是状态,不是活动。它们没有“湿刷子”那样的画面,所以只用一般形式。

中英对比

中文说一件事持续了多久,靠的是词:“……了五年了”“从……起”“自从……以来”“已经”。动词本身不变:“我住在这儿”和“我在这儿住了五年了”,“住”都是同一个字。英语却要换动词形式:到现在为止的持续时间,要用 have + 过去分词或 have been + -ing,不能用一般现在时。另外,中文的“五年”和“2020 年”后面都可以加“以来”(五年以来、2020 年以来),英语却要分:一段时间用 for,一个起点用 since。

中文英语说明
我在这儿住了五年了。I've lived here for five years.一段时间 → for
我从 2020 年起就住在马德里。I've lived in Madrid since 2020.起点 → since
自从换了工作,她开心多了。She's been much happier since she changed jobs.since 后面的从句用一般过去时
你们结婚多久了?How long have you been married?married 是状态,用 be
我今天已经喝了四杯咖啡了。I've drunk four coffees today.数得出来的总数 → 一般形式
你的书我一直在看。I've been reading your book.活动,还没看完 → 进行形式

表格里的“了”都不是过去时的标志:句末的“了”说的是“到现在为止”。英语用完成时表达同样的意思。

结构

for 和 since(复习 A2-18)

后面跟例子
for一段时间(长度)for two hours, for a week, for ages, for a long time
since一个时间点(起点)since nine o'clock, since Monday, since 2015, since last summer
since一个从句,通常用一般过去时since I was a child, since we moved here

How long…?

时态问句
现在完成时How long have you known Ana?
现在完成进行时How long have you been waiting?
和 be 连用How long has she been a teacher?

一般形式还是进行形式?

现在完成时(have + 过去分词)现在完成进行时(have been + -ing)
结果:I've painted the room.(已经刷完了)活动:I've been painting the room.(可能还没刷完)
多少、几个:She's written three chapters.多久:She's been writing all morning.
状态:I've known him for years.——(状态动词不用)
感觉是长久的:He's lived here all his life.感觉是暂时的:He's been living with his parents for a few months.

It's (been) … since …

句型例子
It's been + 一段时间 + since + 一般过去时It's been three years since I last saw her.
It's + 一段时间 + since + 一般过去时It's three years since I last saw her.

短一点的 It's three years since… 在英式英语里特别常见。

用法

1for、since 和 How long:快速复习

For 说长度;since 说起点(某一天、某个日期、某个时间或某件事)。问时间长度,用 How long + 现在完成时。

I've had this phone for two years.
这部手机我用了两年了。
现在还在用;表示拥有的 have
He's been in a meeting since nine o'clock.
他从九点起就一直在开会。
She's been much happier since she changed jobs.
自从换了工作,她开心多了。
since + 从句(一般过去时)
"How long have you been learning English?" "For about three years."
“你学英语多久了?”“三年左右吧。”
"How long have you known each other?" "Since university."
“你们俩认识多久了?”“大学就认识了。”

2一般形式:结果和总数

动作已经完成,或者你在数东西 —— 多少、几个、几次 —— 用一般形式。

I've read four books this month.
这个月我已经读了四本书了。
一个数字
She's drunk three coffees since lunch.
从午饭到现在,她已经喝了三杯咖啡了。
We've walked twelve kilometres today.
我们今天已经走了十二公里了。
I've painted the kitchen. Do you like the colour?
我把厨房刷好了,你喜欢这个颜色吗?
一个完成的结果

3一般形式:状态动词

描述状态的动词 —— know, have(拥有), be, like, love, believe, understand, own —— 一般只用一般形式,就算说到持续了多久也一样。

We've known each other for ages.
我们认识好多年了。
know 是状态,不用进行时
He's had that car since he was twenty.
那辆车他二十岁就有了,一直开到现在。
have = 拥有
I've always liked spicy food.
我一直都喜欢吃辣的。
She's been a nurse for ten years.
她当护士已经十年了。
be 是状态

4进行形式:活动和它持续的时间

重点是活动本身、它持续了多久,或者它留下的痕迹时,用进行形式。活动可能结束了,也可能没结束。

I've been reading this book for weeks. It's so long!
这本书我看了好几个星期了,太长了!
She's been driving since six this morning, so she needs a break.
她从早上六点一直开车开到现在,得休息一下了。
They've been arguing about money for months.
他们为钱的事吵了好几个月了。
I've been painting the kitchen. That's why I'm covered in paint.
我一直在刷厨房,所以身上全是油漆。
活动

5live、work、study、teach:两种都可以

描述一个长期情况的动词,和 for、since 连用时两种形式都对,意思常常几乎没有区别。进行形式听起来可能更像暂时的情况。

I've lived in Madrid since 2020.
我从 2020 年起就住在马德里。
I've been living in Madrid since 2020.
我从 2020 年起就住在马德里。
这里意思一样
He's taught at this school for twenty years.
他在这所学校教了二十年书了。
感觉是长久的
He's been teaching here for a few weeks, while the usual teacher is away.
原来的老师不在,他在这儿代课已经几个星期了。
感觉是暂时的

6It's (been) + 一段时间 + since…

用这个句型说从过去某件事到现在过了多久。since 后面的从句一般用一般过去时。如果 since 从句里的情况也一直持续到现在,也可以用现在完成时;但在 It's been… since 这个句型里,用一般过去时最保险。

It's been ages since we had a holiday.
我们好久没有度假了。
holiday 是英式说法,美式说 vacation
It's two months since I last went to the gym.
我上一次去健身房已经是两个月前了。
How long has it been since you saw a doctor?
你多久没看医生了?
I haven't seen Paolo for two years.
我两年没见到 Paolo 了。
意思和 It's been two years since I saw Paolo 一样
I've been happy since I've known you.
自从认识你,我一直很幸福。
两个情况都持续到现在

常见错误

❌I live here since 2020.
✅I've lived here since 2020. 或 I've been living here since 2020.
一直持续到现在的情况,要用现在完成时。
❌I've worked here since three years.
✅I've worked here for three years.
一段时间 → for;起点 → since。
❌We've been friends for 2015.
✅We've been friends since 2015.
年份是一个起点 → since。
❌I've been knowing her since school.
✅I've known her since school.
know 是状态动词 → 只用一般形式。
⚠️I've been drinking four coffees today.
✅I've drunk four coffees today.
已经完成的东西的数量 → 一般形式。只有当你想说的是“今天一直在喝咖啡”这个活动、而不是总数时,才可以用进行形式。
❌How long are you married?
✅How long have you been married?
到现在为止的时间:How long + 现在完成时。
❌How long do you know him?
✅How long have you known him?
到现在为止的时间:How long + 现在完成时。
❌It's been a year since I see him.
✅It's been a year since I saw him.
since 从句一般用一般过去时。
❌I've lived here during five years.
✅I've lived here for five years.
during 回答的是“什么时候”,不是“多久” —— 见 A2-02。

中文母语者的常见陷阱

1. “我爸妈开这家店二十年了”用一般现在时。 中文动词不变,靠“了”和时间词表示“到现在为止”,所以很多同学说 My parents run this shop for twenty years。英语里,持续到现在的情况一定要用完成时。

❌My parents run this shop for twenty years.
✅My parents have run this shop for twenty years.
❌She plays the violin since she was six.
✅She has been playing the violin since she was six.

2. “两个小时以来”“三年来”说成 since two hours。 中文的“以来”“来”前面既可以是一段时间(三年来),也可以是一个起点(2020 年以来)。英语要分开:一段时间用 for,起点用 since。

❌We've been waiting since two hours.
✅We've been waiting for two hours.

3. “我们结婚五年了”说成 have married。 中文的“结婚”是一个动作,所以很多同学说 We have married for five years。可是“结婚五年了”说的是一种状态:已婚。英语要用 be married。

❌We have married for five years.
✅We've been married for five years.
❌How long have you married?
✅How long have you been married?

4. “我今天上午已经发了二十封邮件了”用进行形式。 中文的“已经……了”容易让人想到“一直在”。可是有了具体的数字,说的就是总数和结果,要用一般形式。

⚠️I've been sending twenty emails this morning.
✅I've sent twenty emails this morning.
说总数时,用进行形式不自然。

5. “自从她搬去加拿大”里用一般现在时。 中文“自从”后面的动词不变,英语 since 后面说过去的某件事,要用一般过去时。

❌I haven't spoken to her since she moves to Canada.
✅I haven't spoken to her since she moved to Canada.

易混淆点

for、since 和 ago —— for = 时间长度;since = 起点;ago = 一件已经结束的事离现在多远,和一般过去时连用 A2-19。

I've worked here for six months.
我在这儿工作了六个月了。
长度
I've worked here since January.
我从一月份起就在这儿工作。
起点
I started this job six months ago.
我六个月前开始做这份工作。
一般过去时 + ago

How long have you…? 和 How long did you…? —— 现在完成时问的是现在还是这样的事;一般过去时问的是已经结束的一段时间。

How long have you lived in Rome?
你在罗马住多久了?
你现在还住在那里
How long did you live in Rome?
你在罗马住过多久?
你现在不住在那里了

I've been here for a week 和 I'm here for a week —— 第一句算的是到现在为止的时间;第二句说的是这次停留一共多长,包括现在和将来。

I've been in London for a week.
我来伦敦一个星期了。
七天前到的
I'm in London for a week.
我这次在伦敦待一个星期。
整个行程一个星期

I've read your book 和 I've been reading your book —— 一般形式:我看完了。进行形式:我正看到一半,或者我花了不少时间在看。

I've read your book. It's brilliant!
你的书我看完了,写得太好了!
看完了
I've been reading your book. I'm on chapter five.
你的书我一直在看,看到第五章了。
还没看完

拼写与发音

  • 口语里 for 一般弱读:/fə/(英式),/fɚ/(美式)—— for two years 里的 for 又轻又短。
  • since 保持完整的元音:/sɪns/。/ɪ/ 是短而松的音,结尾的 n 是前鼻音,后面紧跟着 s,不要读成 sings 那样的后鼻音。
  • How long have you…? 要连在一起说:/haʊ ˈlɒŋ əv jə/(英式),/haʊ ˈlɔːŋ əv jə/(美式)。long 结尾是后鼻音 /ŋ/,不要在后面加 g 的爆破音。
  • It's been 常常当成一个整体来说:/ɪts bɪn/ —— It's been ages!
  • she's known = she has known;she's been 可以是 she has been(绝不是 she is been)。

黄金法则

现在还是这样?用现在完成时,加上 for(一段时间)或 since(一个起点)。结果、数字或状态动词 → 一般形式。活动和它持续的时间 → 进行形式(live, work, study 用两种往往都可以)。中文的“……了”“……以来”,英语都不能用一般现在时。

练习

A. 结构

填空,或者按要求改写句子。

  1. I've had this bike 2021.
  2. She's been sleeping ten hours.
  3. We've been friends we were five.
  4. 用一般过去时填空:It's been two years since I (see) my cousins.
  5. 用进行形式和 for 改写:I started learning the piano three years ago.
  6. 写出问句,答案是 "For five years."(用 you、have、your car)

B. 意义

根据意思选择正确的一项。

  1. 选择正确的一项:I … Tom for years.
  2. 选择正确的一项:I … four cups of coffee today.
  3. 选择正确的一项:Sorry about my hands. I … the car.
  4. 哪一句表示书已经看完了?
  5. 哪一句听起来更像是暂时的情况?

C. 找错

改正错误。如果句子正确,写 correct。

  1. I live in this town since 2019.
  2. How long are you waiting?
  3. He's worked here since six months.
  4. We've been travelling for three weeks, and we've visited five countries.

D. 语境练习

用括号里的动词的正确形式补全邮件;没有括号的空,填一个合适的词。

来自里斯本的邮件
Hi Sam! I 16 (live) in Lisbon 17 March, and I love it. I 18 (learn) Portuguese for three months, but it's hard! So far I 19 (make) a few friends at my language school. It 20 (be) ages since we last spoke — how are you?

E. 轮到你了

用英语回答。

  1. 写两句话:你认识一个朋友多久了?你拥有的一样东西用了多久了?
  2. 写一句话说说你最近一直在做的一件事,再写一句话说说它的结果。

F. 综合复习

复习前面学过的内容。

  1. B1-01 英语现在完成进行时的用法:have been doing
    Your eyes are red. you (cry)?
  2. A2-19 英语现在完成时和一般过去时的区别
    I (move) to London two years ago.
  3. A2-17 英语现在完成时和 just、already、yet 的用法
    Have you finished your homework ?
参考答案

A. 结构

  1. since
  2. for
  3. since
  4. saw / last saw
  5. I have been learning the piano for three years. / I've been learning the piano for three years.
  6. How long have you had your car?

B. 意义

  1. have known
  2. have drunk
  3. have been repairing
  4. I've read your book.
  5. He's been living with friends since the fire.

C. 找错

  1. I have lived in this town since 2019. / I've lived in this town since 2019. / I have been living in this town since 2019. / I've been living in this town since 2019.
  2. How long have you been waiting?
  3. He's worked here for six months. / He's been working here for six months.
  4. ✓ We've been travelling for three weeks, and we've visited five countries.

D. 语境练习

  1. have lived / have been living
  2. since
  3. have been learning
  4. have made
  5. has been / is

E. 轮到你了

  1. I've known my best friend since primary school. I've had this watch for ten years.
  2. I've been running every morning this month. I've lost three kilos.

F. 综合复习

  1. Have … been crying
  2. moved
  3. yet / already
Android应用随时随地学习 Google Play