For, since, how long: Present Perfect ali Present Perfect Continuous?
For, Since, How Long — Simple or Continuous?
Na tej strani
Cilj
Po tej lekciji boste s for, since in How long…? znali povedati, kako dolgo nekaj traja, ter izbrati med Present Perfect (sedanji perfekt: I've read) in Present Perfect Continuous (sedanji perfekt v teku: I've been reading).
Glavna ideja
Že veste, da položaj, ki se je začel v preteklosti in velja še zdaj, potrebuje perfekt s for (dolžina) ali since (začetek) A2-18: I've lived here for five years, ne I live here for five years. Zdaj pa je tu še druga izbira: brez -ing ali z -ing?
Predstavljajte si dve fotografiji slikopleskarke. Na prvi je stena končana in se sveti: I've painted the wall. To je Present Perfect – pokaže rezultat, nekaj dokončanega, ali število, ki ga lahko preštejete. Na drugi slikopleskarka drži moker čopič, na obleki ima barvo: I've been painting the wall. To je Present Perfect Continuous – pokaže dejavnost in koliko časa že traja. Je končana ali ne? To ni pomembno.
Nekateri glagoli (know, have v pomenu „imeti v lasti“, be, like, believe) opisujejo stanja, ne dejavnosti. Zanje ni slike z mokrim čopičem, zato ostanejo brez -ing.
Slovenščina in angleščina
Za položaj, ki traja do zdaj, slovenščina uporabi sedanjik: „Tukaj živim od leta 2020“, „Poznava se že leta“, „Kako dolgo sta že poročena?“. Angleščina tu nikoli ne uporabi sedanjika, ampak perfekt: I've lived here since 2020, We've known each other for ages, How long have you been married? Pozor: Present Perfect ni slovenski preteklik – in tudi ni slovenski sedanjik.
„Od“ je since, kadar mu sledi začetek („od ponedeljka“, „od leta 2015“). „Že dve leti“ pa je for two years. Tretja beseda je „pred“, ki pomeni tako ago kot before: „pred dvema letoma“ je two years ago, z Past Simple.
| Slovenščina | Angleščina | V čem je razlika? |
|---|---|---|
| Ta telefon imam že dve leti. | I've had this phone for two years. | sedanjik + „že“ → perfekt + for |
| Na sestanku je od devetih. | He's been in a meeting since nine o'clock. | „od“ + začetek → since |
| Kako dolgo sta že poročena? | How long have you been married? | sedanjik → How long + perfekt |
| Poznava se že celo večnost. | We've known each other for ages. | glagol stanja → perfekt brez -ing |
| Ta mesec sem prebral štiri knjige. | I've read four books this month. | število → perfekt brez -ing |
| Tole knjigo berem že tedne. | I've been reading this book for weeks. | dejavnost in trajanje → have been + -ing |
| Službo sem začel pred šestimi meseci. | I started this job six months ago. | „pred“ → ago + Past Simple |
Na kratko: kar v slovenščini traja „že“ ali „od“ v sedanjiku, je v angleščini perfekt – z rezultatom, številom ali glagolom stanja brez -ing, z dejavnostjo in trajanjem pa z been + -ing.
Oblika
For in since (ponovitev A2-18)
| Sledi | Primeri | |
|---|---|---|
| for | obdobje (dolžina) | for two hours, for a week, for ages, for a long time |
| since | točka v času (začetek) | since nine o'clock, since Monday, since 2015, since last summer |
| since | odvisnik, navadno v času Past Simple | since I was a child, since we moved here |
How long…?
| Čas | Vprašanje |
|---|---|
| Present Perfect | How long have you known Ana? |
| Present Perfect Continuous | How long have you been waiting? |
| z be | How long has she been a teacher? |
Brez -ing ali z -ing?
| Present Perfect (have + pretekli deležnik) | Present Perfect Continuous (have been + -ing) |
|---|---|
| rezultat: I've painted the room. (končano) | dejavnost: I've been painting the room. (mogoče ni končano) |
| koliko: She's written three chapters. | kako dolgo: She's been writing all morning. |
| stanja: I've known him for years. | – (ne z glagoli stanja) |
| zveni trajno: He's lived here all his life. | zveni začasno: He's been living with his parents for a few months. |
It's (been) … since …
| Vzorec | Primer |
|---|---|
| It's been + obdobje + since + Past Simple | It's been three years since I last saw her. |
| It's + obdobje + since + Past Simple | It's three years since I last saw her. |
Krajši vzorec It's three years since… je posebno pogost v britanski angleščini.
Raba
1For, since in How long: hitra ponovitev
For pove dolžino; since pove začetek (dan, datum, uro ali dogodek). Po dolžini vprašate s How long + Present Perfect. Slovenščina ima tu sedanjik.
2Present Perfect za rezultate in števila
Present Perfect brez -ing uporabite, ko je dejanje končano ali ko nekaj štejete: koliko, koliko kosov, kolikokrat. Slovenščina ima tu preteklik, pogosto z dovršnim glagolom.
3Present Perfect z glagoli stanja
Glagoli, ki opisujejo stanja – know, have (imeti v lasti), be, like, love, believe, understand, own –, navadno ostanejo brez -ing, tudi ko povemo, kako dolgo.
4Present Perfect Continuous za dejavnost in njeno trajanje
Obliko z -ing uporabite, ko je v ospredju dejavnost, koliko časa že poteka, ali sledi, ki jih je pustila. Dejavnost je lahko končana ali ne.
5Live, work, study, teach: mogoči sta obe obliki
Pri glagolih, ki opisujejo daljši položaj, sta s for in since pravilni obe obliki, pogosto skoraj brez razlike. Oblika z -ing lahko položaj prikaže kot bolj začasen.
6It's (been) + čas + since…
S tem vzorcem povemo, koliko časa je minilo od preteklega dogodka. Odvisnik s since je navadno v času Past Simple. Odvisnik s since ima lahko Present Perfect, ko tudi ta položaj traja do zdaj; v vzorcu It's been… since pa je Past Simple varna izbira.
Pogoste napake
Pasti za govorce slovenščine
1. „Tu delam od leta 2018“ → I work here since 2018. Slovenščina za položaj, ki traja do zdaj, uporabi sedanjik. Angleščina potrebuje Present Perfect (ali obliko z -ing).
2. „Kako dolgo že…?“ → How long are you / do you…? Slovensko vprašanje ima sedanjik. Angleški How long za čas do zdaj zahteva perfekt.
3. „Ta traktor ima od leta 1985“ → has been having. Ko učenci sedanjik popravijo v perfekt, radi dodajo še -ing. Glagoli stanja (know, have v pomenu „imeti v lasti“, be, like) ostanejo brez -ing.
4. „Pred dvanajstimi leti“ → before twelve years. Slovenski „pred“ pomeni ago in before. Za čas, ki je minil do zdaj, uporabite ago – in Past Simple.
Ne zamenjujte
for, since in ago – for = dolžina; since = začetek; ago = kako daleč nazaj je bil končan pretekli dogodek, s Past Simple A2-19. Slovenski „pred“ je ago, ne before.
How long have you…? in How long did you…? – Present Perfect sprašuje o nečem, kar še velja; Past Simple o končanem obdobju. V slovenščini sedanjik in preteklik.
I've been here for a week in I'm here for a week – Prvo meri čas do zdaj; drugo pove celotno dolžino sedanjega ali prihodnjega bivanja. Slovenščina loči z „že“: „V Londonu sem že teden dni“ in „V Londonu sem en teden“.
I've read your book in I've been reading your book – Brez -ing: prebral sem jo. Z -ing: sem sredi branja ali sem nekaj časa bral.
Pravopis in izgovorjava
- for je v govoru navadno šibek: /fə/ (UK), /fɚ/ (US). Samoglasnik je polglasnik, kot v „pes“.
- since ohrani poln samoglasnik: /sɪns/. Končni /s/ je oster, /ɪ/ pa kratek in sproščen – ne dolgi i.
- How long have you…? teče skupaj: /haʊ ˈlɒŋ əv jə/ (UK), /haʊ ˈlɔːŋ əv jə/ (US). Na koncu long je /ŋ/ brez dodanega g, kot n v „banka“.
- It's been izgovorimo kot eno enoto: /ɪts bɪn/ – It's been ages!
- she's known = she has known; she's been je lahko she has been (nikoli she is been).
- I've izgovorite z zvenečim /v/: zgornji zobje se dotaknejo spodnje ustnice. Ne izgovarjajte ga kot slovenski [w] v „nov“ in ne kot /f/.
Zlato pravilo
Velja še zdaj? Uporabite Present Perfect s for (dolžina) ali since (začetek) – nikoli sedanjika, čeprav slovenščina reče „živim že“ ali „poznam od“. Rezultat, število ali glagol stanja → brez -ing. Dejavnost in koliko časa že traja → been + -ing (pri live, work, study sta pogosto pravilni obe obliki).
Vaje
A. Oblika
Dopolnite povedi ali jih preoblikujte po navodilu.
-
I've had this bike 2021.
-
She's been sleeping ten hours.
-
We've been friends we were five.
-
Dopolnite z obliko Past Simple: It's been two years since I (see) my cousins.
-
Preoblikujte z obliko na -ing in for: I started learning the piano three years ago.
-
Napišite vprašanje za odgovor "For five years." (you, have, your car)
B. Pomen
Izberite pravilni odgovor.
-
Izberite pravilni odgovor: I … Tom for years.
-
Izberite pravilni odgovor: I … four cups of coffee today.
-
Izberite pravilni odgovor: Sorry about my hands. I … the car.
-
Katera poved pove, da je knjiga prebrana?
-
Katera poved zveni bolj začasno?
C. Poiščite napako
V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.
-
I live in this town since 2019.
-
How long are you waiting?
-
He's worked here since six months.
-
We've been travelling for three weeks, and we've visited five countries.
D. V kontekstu
Dopolnite elektronsko sporočilo. Glagol v oklepaju postavite v pravilno obliko.
Hi Sam! I 16 (live) in Lisbon 17 March, and I love it. I 18 (learn) Portuguese for three months, but it's hard! So far I 19 (make) a few friends at my language school. It 20 (be) ages since we last spoke — how are you?
E. Na vrsti ste vi
Pišite v angleščini.
-
Napišite dve povedi: kako dolgo že poznate prijatelja in kako dolgo že imate nekaj, kar je vaše.
-
Napišite eno poved o dejavnosti, ki jo v zadnjem času počnete, in eno o rezultatu.
F. Mešano ponavljanje
Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.
-
B1-01 Present Perfect Continuous: I've been waiting razloženo v slovenščini Your eyes are red. you (cry)?
-
A2-19 Present Perfect ali Past Simple? Razlika razložena v slovenščini I (move) to London two years ago.
-
A2-17 Present Perfect z just, already in yet: pravkar, že in še ne Have you finished your homework ?already = surprise
Rešitve
A. Oblika
- since
- for
- since
- saw / last saw
- I have been learning the piano for three years. / I've been learning the piano for three years.
- How long have you had your car?
B. Pomen
- have known
- have drunk
- have been repairing
- I've read your book.
- He's been living with friends since the fire.
C. Poiščite napako
- I have lived in this town since 2019. / I've lived in this town since 2019. / I have been living in this town since 2019. / I've been living in this town since 2019.
- How long have you been waiting?
- He's worked here for six months. / He's been working here for six months.
- ✓ We've been travelling for three weeks, and we've visited five countries.
D. V kontekstu
- have lived / have been living
- since
- have been learning
- have made
- has been / is
E. Na vrsti ste vi
- I've known my best friend since primary school. I've had this watch for ten years.
- I've been running every morning this month. I've lost three kilos.
F. Mešano ponavljanje
- Have … been crying
- moved
- yet / already
