SlowingoGramatika
B1 2 / 39

For, since i How long: I've lived ili I've been living? Present Perfect Simple ili Continuous

For, Since, How Long — Simple or Continuous?

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete reći koliko dugo nešto traje s for, since i How long…? i izabrati između vremena Present Perfect Simple (I've read) i Present Perfect Continuous (I've been reading).

Osnovna ideja

Već znate da situacija koja je počela u prošlosti i još traje treba perfektno vrijeme, s for (trajanje) ili since (početak) A2-18: I've lived here for five years, a ne I live here for five years. Sada dolazi drugi izbor: simple ili continuous?

Zamislite dvije fotografije soboslikarice. Na prvoj je zid gotov i sjaji se: I've painted the wall. To je simple – pokazuje rezultat, nešto dovršeno ili zbroj koji možete izbrojiti. Na drugoj soboslikarica drži mokar kist, a odjeća joj je puna boje: I've been painting the wall. To je continuous – pokazuje aktivnost i koliko dugo traje. Možda je gotova, možda nije; nije to važno.

Neki glagoli (know, have za posjedovanje, be, like, believe) opisuju stanja, a ne aktivnosti. Za njih nema slike s mokrim kistom, pa ostaju u obliku simple.

Hrvatski i engleski

Za trajanje do sada hrvatski upotrebljava prezent („Znamo se godinama“, „U Zagrebu živim od 2020.“) – o tome smo govorili u A2-18. U ovoj lekciji važnije je nešto drugo: hrvatski nema dva perfektna oblika, pa engleski izbor I've read / I've been reading morate donijeti po smislu. Glagolski vid ponekad pomaže („pročitala sam“ obično znači da je gotovo, „čitam već tjednima“ da traje), ali to nije pravilo za engleski: pitajte se ima li rezultata ili broja – ili je u središtu sama aktivnost.

Još tri hrvatske riječi lako zavaraju. „Otkad radim ovdje…“ ima prezent, ali iza engleskog since dolazi Past Simple: since I started here. „Tijekom pet godina“ nije during five years, nego for five years. A „Prošle su dvije godine otkad…“ na engleskom je It's been two years since…

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Ovaj mjesec pročitala sam četiri knjige.I've read four books this month.broj → simple
Već tjednima čitam ovu knjigu.I've been reading this book for weeks.aktivnost i trajanje → continuous
Znamo se godinama.We've known each other for ages.glagol stanja → samo simple
Otkad je promijenila posao, puno je sretnija.She's been much happier since she changed jobs.since + Past Simple
Radio je ondje tijekom pet godina.He worked there for five years.trajanje → for, ne during
Prošle su dvije godine otkad sam je vidio.It's been two years since I saw her.stalni obrazac It's been … since
Koliko dugo živiš u Rimu?How long have you lived in Rome?još živi ondje → Present Perfect
Koliko si dugo živio u Rimu?How long did you live in Rome?više ne živi ondje → Past Simple

Ukratko: rezultat, broj ili glagol stanja → I've read / I've known; aktivnost i njezino trajanje → I've been reading. „Otkad“ + prezent → since + Past Simple, „tijekom“ → for, „prošlo je … otkad“ → It's been … since.

Oblik

For i since (ponavljanje iz A2-18)

Iza njega dolaziPrimjeri
forrazdoblje (trajanje)for two hours, for a week, for ages, for a long time
sincetrenutak (početak)since nine o'clock, since Monday, since 2015, since last summer
sincerečenica, obično u vremenu Past Simplesince I was a child, since we moved here

How long…?

VrijemePitanje
Present Perfect SimpleHow long have you known Ana?
Present Perfect ContinuousHow long have you been waiting?
s beHow long has she been a teacher?

Simple ili continuous?

Present Perfect Simple (have + particip prošli)Present Perfect Continuous (have been + -ing)
rezultat: I've painted the room. (gotovo je)aktivnost: I've been painting the room. (možda nije gotovo)
koliko / koliko puta: She's written three chapters.koliko dugo: She's been writing all morning.
stanja: I've known him for years.– (ne s glagolima stanja)
zvuči trajno: He's lived here all his life.zvuči privremeno: He's been living with his parents for a few months.

It's (been) … since …

ObrazacPrimjer
It's been + razdoblje + since + Past SimpleIt's been three years since I last saw her.
It's + razdoblje + since + Past SimpleIt's three years since I last saw her.

Kraći obrazac It's three years since… posebno je čest u britanskom engleskom.

Uporaba

1For, since i How long – kratko ponavljanje

For daje trajanje; since daje početak (dan, datum, sat ili događaj). O trajanju pitate s How long + Present Perfect. Na hrvatskom je tu obično prezent.

I've had this phone for two years.
Ovaj mobitel imam već dvije godine.
have = posjedovati → simple
He's been in a meeting since nine o'clock.
Od devet je na sastanku.
She's been much happier since she changed jobs.
Otkad je promijenila posao, puno je sretnija.
since + rečenica u vremenu Past Simple
"How long have you been learning English?" "For about three years."
„Koliko dugo već učiš engleski?“ „Oko tri godine.“
"How long have you known each other?" "Since university."
„Koliko se dugo poznajete?“ „Od faksa.“

2Simple za rezultate i zbrojeve

Simple upotrijebite kad je radnja dovršena ili kad nešto brojite: koliko, koliko puta.

I've read four books this month.
Ovaj mjesec pročitala sam četiri knjige.
broj → simple
She's drunk three coffees since lunch.
Od ručka je popila tri kave.
We've walked twelve kilometres today.
Danas smo prehodali dvanaest kilometara.
I've painted the kitchen. Do you like the colour?
Obojio sam kuhinju. Sviđa li ti se boja?
gotov rezultat

3Simple s glagolima stanja

Glagoli koji opisuju stanja – know, have (posjedovati), be, like, love, believe, understand, own – obično ostaju u obliku simple, čak i kad kažete koliko dugo.

We've known each other for ages.
Znamo se godinama.
know → nikad been knowing
He's had that car since he was twenty.
Taj auto ima otkad mu je bilo dvadeset godina.
have = posjedovati
I've always liked spicy food.
Uvijek sam volio ljutu hranu.
She's been a nurse for ten years.
Već deset godina radi kao medicinska sestra.
be = stanje

4Continuous za aktivnost i njezino trajanje

Continuous upotrijebite kad je u središtu aktivnost, koliko dugo traje ili tragovi koje je ostavila. Aktivnost može biti gotova ili ne.

I've been reading this book for weeks. It's so long!
Već tjednima čitam ovu knjigu. Tako je duga!
trajanje aktivnosti
She's been driving since six this morning, so she needs a break.
Vozi od šest ujutro, pa joj treba odmor.
They've been arguing about money for months.
Već se mjesecima svađaju oko novca.
I've been painting the kitchen. That's why I'm covered in paint.
Bojio sam kuhinju. Zato sam sav u boji.
aktivnost

5Live, work, study, teach – moguća su oba

Uz glagole koji opisuju dugu situaciju oba su oblika ispravna uz for i since, često gotovo bez razlike. Continuous može učiniti da situacija zvuči privremenije.

I've lived in Madrid since 2020.
U Madridu živim od 2020.
I've been living in Madrid since 2020.
U Madridu živim od 2020.
ovdje isto značenje
He's taught at this school for twenty years.
U ovoj školi predaje već dvadeset godina.
zvuči trajno
He's been teaching here for a few weeks, while the usual teacher is away.
Ovdje predaje tek nekoliko tjedana, dok redovne nastavnice nema.
zvuči privremeno

6It's (been) + vrijeme + since…

Ovim obrascem kažete koliko je vremena prošlo od nekog događaja u prošlosti – hrvatsko „prošlo je … otkad“. Rečenica sa since obično je u vremenu Past Simple. Rečenica sa since može imati Present Perfect kad i ta situacija traje do sada; u obrascu It's been… since Past Simple je siguran izbor.

It's been ages since we had a holiday.
Sto godina nismo bili na odmoru.
holiday (UK); vacation (US)
It's two months since I last went to the gym.
Prošla su dva mjeseca otkad sam zadnji put bio u teretani.
„prošlo je … otkad“ → It's … since
How long has it been since you saw a doctor?
Koliko je prošlo otkad si bio kod liječnika?
I haven't seen Paolo for two years.
Paola nisam vidio već dvije godine.
ista ideja: It's been two years since I saw Paolo.
I've been happy since I've known you.
Sretan sam otkad te poznajem.
obje situacije traju do sada

Česte pogreške

❌I live here since 2020.
✅I've lived here since 2020. ili I've been living here since 2020.
Situacija do sada traži Present Perfect.
❌I've worked here since three years.
✅I've worked here for three years.
Razdoblje → for; početak → since.
❌We've been friends for 2015.
✅We've been friends since 2015.
Godina je početak → since.
❌I've been knowing her since school.
✅I've known her since school.
know je glagol stanja → samo simple.
⚠️I've been drinking four coffees today.
✅I've drunk four coffees today.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali broj gotovih stvari → simple. Continuous je moguć samo ako mislite na aktivnost (kako ste proveli dan), a ne na zbroj.
❌How long are you married?
✅How long have you been married?
How long + Present Perfect za razdoblje do sada.
❌How long do you know him?
✅How long have you known him?
How long + Present Perfect za razdoblje do sada.
❌It's been a year since I see him.
✅It's been a year since I saw him.
Rečenica sa since obično je u vremenu Past Simple.
❌I've lived here during five years.
✅I've lived here for five years.
during odgovara na pitanje „kada?“, a ne „koliko dugo?“ – pogledajte A2-02.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Otkad radi od kuće“ → since + Present Simple. Iza hrvatskog „otkad“ često stoji prezent: „Otkad radi od kuće, puno je opuštenija.“ Iza engleskog since dolazi početak, a početak je u prošlosti: Past Simple (since she started) ili, ako i to stanje traje do sada, Present Perfect.

❌Ever since Mia works from home, she has been much more relaxed and cheerful.
✅Ever since Mia started working from home, she has been much more relaxed and cheerful.
since + početak u prošlosti: Past Simple
❌It's been much quieter in our street ever since they close it to lorries at night.
✅It's been much quieter in our street ever since they closed it to lorries at night.
since + Past Simple

2. „Tijekom pet godina“ → during five years. Hrvatsko „tijekom“ dobro opisuje trajanje („tijekom tri ljeta radila je na Hvaru“). Englesko during odgovara na pitanje „kada?“ i stoji uz imenicu (during the summer), a ne uz broj godina ili mjeseci. Za trajanje upotrijebite for.

❌Filip has been the captain of the local rowing team during four seasons, and nobody wants him to stop.
✅Filip has been the captain of the local rowing team for four seasons, and nobody wants him to stop.
trajanje → for

3. „Koliko si dugo radio…?“ → How long have you…? za završeno razdoblje. Hrvatski perfekt („Koliko je dugo tvoj ujak radio na brodovima?“) lako se prevede kao Present Perfect. Ali ako je to razdoblje završeno, engleski traži Past Simple: How long did you…? Present Perfect nije hrvatski perfekt, iako se tako zove i izgleda slično.

❌How long has your uncle worked as a cook on cruise ships before he opened his konoba in Makarska?
✅How long did your uncle work as a cook on cruise ships before he opened his konoba in Makarska?
završeno razdoblje → How long did … work?

4. „Prošle su tri godine otkad…“ → Three years passed since… Doslovni prijevod hrvatskog „prošle su“ daje glagol pass u vremenu Past Simple. Za vrijeme koje je proteklo do sada engleski ima stalni obrazac It's been / It's + razdoblje + since.

⚠️Three years passed since Ivana and I last slept in a tent near the Plitvice Lakes.
✅It's been three years since Ivana and I last slept in a tent near the Plitvice Lakes. ili Three years have passed since Ivana and I last slept in a tent near the Plitvice Lakes.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali passed (Past Simple) ne povezuje to vrijeme sa sadašnjošću; prirodno je It's been … since.

Ne miješajte

for, since i ago – for = trajanje; since = početak; ago = koliko je davno bio završeni događaj, uz Past Simple A2-19. Hrvatsko „od“ je since, „prije“ + razdoblje je ago.

I've worked here for six months.
Ovdje radim šest mjeseci.
trajanje
I've worked here since January.
Ovdje radim od siječnja.
početak
I started this job six months ago.
Na ovaj sam posao došao prije šest mjeseci.
„prije“ + razdoblje → ago

How long have you…? i How long did you…? – Present Perfect pita o nečemu što još traje; Past Simple pita o završenom razdoblju. Na hrvatskom razliku čujete na glagolu: „živiš“ ili „si živio“.

How long have you lived in Rome?
Koliko dugo živiš u Rimu?
još živite ondje
How long did you live in Rome?
Koliko si dugo živio u Rimu?
sada ne živite ondje

I've been here for a week i I'm here for a week – Prva rečenica mjeri vrijeme do sada; druga govori o ukupnom trajanju sadašnjeg ili budućeg boravka.

I've been in London for a week.
U Londonu sam već tjedan dana.
stigao sam prije sedam dana
I'm in London for a week.
U Londonu sam na tjedan dana.
cijeli boravak traje tjedan

I've read your book i I've been reading your book – Simple: pročitao sam je. Continuous: na pola sam ili sam joj posvetio vrijeme.

I've read your book. It's brilliant!
Pročitao sam tvoju knjigu. Odlična je!
gotovo
I've been reading your book. I'm on chapter five.
Čitam tvoju knjigu. Na petom sam poglavlju.
nije gotovo

Pravopis i izgovor

  • for je u govoru obično slab: /fə/ (UK), /fɚ/ (US). Samoglasnik je kratak, neutralni /ə/ – ne izgovarajte jasno o.
  • since zadržava puni samoglasnik: /sɪns/. /ɪ/ je kratak i opušten, ne hrvatsko dugo i.
  • How long have you…? izgovara se kao jedna cjelina: /haʊ ˈlɒŋ əv jə/ (UK), /haʊ ˈlɔːŋ əv jə/ (US). Na kraju long stoji /ŋ/ bez g.
  • It's been često je jedna cjelina: /ɪts bɪn/ – It's been ages!
  • she's known = she has known; she's been može biti she has been (nikad she is been).

Zlatno pravilo

Još traje? Upotrijebite Present Perfect s for (trajanje) ili since (početak). Rezultat, broj ili glagol stanja → simple. Aktivnost i koliko dugo traje → continuous (uz live, work, study često su dobra oba). „Tijekom pet godina“ je for five years, a „prošlo je … otkad“ je It's been … since.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite rečenice ili ih napišite na nov način.

  1. I've had this bike 2021.
  2. She's been sleeping ten hours.
  3. We've been friends we were five.
  4. Dopunite glagolom u vremenu Past Simple: It's been two years since I (see) my cousins.
  5. Napišite ponovno s vremenom Present Perfect Continuous i for: I started learning the piano three years ago.
  6. Napišite pitanje za odgovor "For five years." (you, have, your car)

B. Značenje

Odaberite odgovor koji odgovara značenju.

  1. Odaberite točan odgovor: I … Tom for years.
  2. Odaberite točan odgovor: I … four cups of coffee today.
  3. Odaberite točan odgovor: Sorry about my hands. I … the car.
  4. Koja rečenica kaže da je knjiga pročitana do kraja?
  5. Koja rečenica zvuči privremenije?

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. I live in this town since 2019.
  2. How long are you waiting?
  3. He's worked here since six months.
  4. We've been travelling for three weeks, and we've visited five countries.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite e-poruku riječima koje nedostaju ili glagolima iz zagrade u točnom obliku.

An email from Lisbon
Hi Sam! I 16 (live) in Lisbon 17 March, and I love it. I 18 (learn) Portuguese for three months, but it's hard! So far I 19 (make) a few friends at my language school. It 20 (be) ages since we last spoke — how are you?

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o sebi.

  1. Napišite dvije rečenice: koliko dugo poznajete nekog prijatelja i koliko dugo imate nešto svoje.
  2. Napišite jednu rečenicu o aktivnosti kojom se bavite u zadnje vrijeme i jednu o rezultatu.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. B1-01 Present Perfect Continuous: kako reći čekam već sat vremena na engleskom
    Your eyes are red. you (cry)?
  2. A2-19 Present Perfect ili Past Simple? Razlika objašnjena na hrvatskom
    I (move) to London two years ago.
  3. A2-17 Present Perfect s just, already i yet: značenje i mjesto u rečenici na hrvatskom
    Have you finished your homework ?
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. since
  2. for
  3. since
  4. saw / last saw
  5. I have been learning the piano for three years. / I've been learning the piano for three years.
  6. How long have you had your car?

B. Značenje

  1. have known
  2. have drunk
  3. have been repairing
  4. I've read your book.
  5. He's been living with friends since the fire.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. I have lived in this town since 2019. / I've lived in this town since 2019. / I have been living in this town since 2019. / I've been living in this town since 2019.
  2. How long have you been waiting?
  3. He's worked here for six months. / He's been working here for six months.
  4. ✓ We've been travelling for three weeks, and we've visited five countries.

D. U kontekstu

  1. have lived / have been living
  2. since
  3. have been learning
  4. have made
  5. has been / is

E. Vaš red

  1. I've known my best friend since primary school. I've had this watch for ten years.
  2. I've been running every morning this month. I've lost three kilos.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. Have … been crying
  2. moved
  3. yet / already
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play