Cleft sentences: It was… that, What I need is… – isticanje dijela rečenice na engleskom
Cleft Sentences: What I Need Is…
Na ovoj stranici
Cilj
Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete rečenicu podijeliti na dva dijela – It was… that / who…, What I need is…, All I want is…, The reason… is that… – kako biste istaknuli najvažniju informaciju i izgovorili je s pravim naglaskom.
Osnovna ideja
Cleft znači rascijepljen. Rascijepljena rečenica uzima jednu jednostavnu rečenicu i reže je na dva dijela, tako da jedan dio stoji sam pod reflektorom.
Krenimo od: Anna broke the window. Ako netko misli da je to učinio Tom, reflektor možete usmjeriti na Annu: It was Anna who broke the window. Činjenice su iste; mijenja se fokus. Slušatelj sada zna da je Anna nova, važna informacija, a da je netko razbio prozor već poznato.
Engleski ima dva glavna alata. It-cleft (It was… that / who…) usmjerava reflektor na jedan dio i kaže „baš ovaj, a ne neki drugi“. Wh-cleft (What I need is…) najprije pokazuje poznatu ideju, a novu informaciju donosi na kraju – ondje gdje engleski prirodno stavlja najjači naglasak. Oba vam omogućuju da sami birate što će slušatelj primijetiti.
Hrvatski i engleski
Hrvatski fokus najčešće pokazuje redom riječi i naglaskom: novu informaciju stavimo na kraj („Prozor je razbila Ana.“) ili dodamo česticu „upravo“, „baš“, „tek“. Engleski red riječi mnogo je stroži (subjekt – glagol – objekt), pa za isti učinak treba posebna konstrukcija: It was Anna who…
Wh-cleft ima dobar hrvatski parnjak: „Ono što mi treba jest odmor.“ Ovdje je isto – samo što se „ono što“ ne prevodi kao that what, a „sve što“ ne kao all what. Pazite i na glagol: u „To su bili moji roditelji“ hrvatski glagol ide u množinu, a engleski It was uvijek ostaje u jednini.
| Hrvatski | Engleski | U čemu je razlika? |
|---|---|---|
| Prozor je razbila Ana, a ne Tom. | It was Anna who broke the window, not Tom. | hrvatski: red riječi; engleski: it-cleft |
| Ogrebotinu sam primijetio tek kad sam stigao kući. | It wasn't until I got home that I noticed the scratch. | „tek kad“ → It wasn't until… that |
| Ono što mi treba jest odmor. | What I need is a holiday. | ovdje je isto; ne That what |
| Sve što želim jest mir. | All I want is peace. | „sve što“ → all, ne all what |
| To su bili moji roditelji koji su zvali. | It was my parents who called. | hrvatski glagol u množini; It was uvijek jednina |
| Kasnim zato što mi je otkazan vlak. | The reason I'm late is that my train was cancelled. | u pažljivom pisanju is that, ne is because |
Ukratko: što hrvatski postiže redom riječi i riječima „upravo“, „baš“, „tek“, engleski postiže rascijepljenom rečenicom; „ono što“ = what, „sve što“ = all, a It was ne ide u množinu.
Oblik
It-cleft: It + be + fokus + that / who + ostatak rečenice
| Obična rečenica | Fokus | It-cleft |
|---|---|---|
| Anna broke the window. | subjekt | It was Anna who / that broke the window. |
| I lost my keys. | objekt | It was my keys that I lost. |
| We met in Lisbon. | mjesto | It was in Lisbon that we met. |
| He left because of the noise. | razlog | It was because of the noise that he left. |
- Za osobe upotrijebite who ili that, a za sve ostalo obično that – i za vrijeme i za mjesto.
- It is / It was ostaje u jednini, čak i ispred fokusa u množini: It was the twins who…
- Glagol iza who / that slaže se s fokusom: It's my parents who are worried.
Wh-cleft: What + surečenica + be + fokus
| Obična rečenica | Wh-cleft |
|---|---|
| I need a long holiday. | What I need is a long holiday. |
| The lights went out. | What happened was (that) the lights went out. |
| She left. | What she did was (to) leave. |
Obrnuti wh-cleft: fokus + be + surečenica s what
| Wh-cleft | Obrnuto |
|---|---|
| What I need is a holiday. | A holiday is what I need. |
| What I mean is this. | That's what I mean. |
Drugi počeci – All (= jedino), the thing (that), the reason (why), the place (where), the person (who), the only thing, the last thing: All I want is some peace. The reason I called is that I need advice.
Uporaba
1It-cleft za ispravljanje i suprotstavljanje
It-cleft upotrijebite kad želite reći „baš ovaj, a ne neki drugi“ – često da nekoga ispravite ili da suprotstavite dvije mogućnosti. Fokus je nova informacija; dio s that / who već je poznat.
2It-cleft za vrijeme, mjesto, razlog i način
It-cleft može istaknuti i kada, gdje, zašto ili kako. Iza svih upotrijebite that. It was not until… that… vrlo je čest obrazac za isticanje kasnog trenutka – naše „tek kad“.
3Wh-cleft s imenicama i surečenicama
Wh-cleft počinje poznatom ili jednostavnom idejom (What I need…, What surprised me…), a novu informaciju čuva za kraj. Vrlo je čest u govoru kad postupno dolazite do glavne misli. Kad je fokus u množini, upotrebljavaju se i is i are: What we need is / are more volunteers.
4What happened was… / What she did was (to)…
It-cleft ne može istaknuti glagol. Da istaknete cijeli događaj ili radnju, upotrijebite What happened was (that) + surečenica ili What + subjekt + do + be + (to) + osnovni oblik. Iza do… was / is češći je osnovni oblik bez to. Ako je prvi glagol u obliku u tijeku, upotrijebite -ing. Hrvatski ovdje ima „da“ + glagol („Ono što je učinila jest da je nazvala šefa“), a engleski samo osnovni oblik.
5Obrnuti wh-cleft
Fokus stavite na početak, a surečenicu s what iza be. To je često kad je fokus kratak ili već spomenut te u sažecima s That's what….
6All, the thing, the reason, the place, the person, the only thing
Ovi počeci rade kao what, ali su precizniji. All znači „jedino“ i često sugerira „ništa više“. The reason (why)… is that… objašnjava uzrok. Uz mjesta, vremena i osobe the place, the time i the person zvuče prirodnije od where, when i who.
Česte pogreške
Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
1. „Ono što…“ → That what… Hrvatsko „ono što“ ima dvije riječi, pa se lako prevede kao that what. U engleskom what već znači „ono što“ – nikakav that ispred njega ne treba.
2. „Sve što…“ → all what. „Sve što“ doslovno je all what, ali engleski iza all ne upotrebljava what: all + surečenica ili all that + surečenica.
3. „To su bile…“ → It were… Kad je fokus u množini, hrvatski glagol ide u množinu: „To su bile srpanjske oluje, a ne turisti…“. Englesko It is / It was u rascijepljenoj rečenici uvijek ostaje u jednini.
4. „Bilo je to u Puli gdje…“ → It was in Pula where… Hrvatski uz mjesto prirodno upotrebljava „gdje“, pa ga govornici prenose u it-cleft. U neformalnom govoru čuje se i where, ali standardni je izbor that.
5. „Razlog je taj što… / zato što…“ → The reason… is because… Hrvatski kaže „razlog je to što“ ili čak „razlog je zato što“, pa se lako napiše is because. U govoru je to vrlo često, ali u eseju za maturu ili IELTS bolje je is that.
Ne miješajte
It-cleft i It is + pridjev + that – U rascijepljenoj rečenici možete maknuti It was… that i dobiti normalnu rečenicu. Uz It is + pridjev + that (pogledajte B2-20) to ne možete.
Wh-cleft i obična surečenica s what – U wh-cleftu be povezuje surečenicu s what i fokus. Obična surečenica s what samo je subjekt ili objekt, s bilo kojim glagolom (pogledajte B2-20).
Cleft i premještanje na početak (fronting) – Oboje mijenja fokus, ali cleft dodaje it… that ili what… is, a fronting samo premješta riječ na početak. Pogledajte C1-06.
It was me who… i It was I who… – U svakodnevnom engleskom me je normalan iza It is / was. It was I who… vrlo je formalno.
Pravopis i izgovor
- It-cleft: glavni naglasak pada na fokus; dio s that / who izgovara se niže i brže jer je poznat: It was ANna who broke the window. (Velika slova ovdje samo pokazuju naglasak.) Hrvatski fokus često pokazuje redom riječi, a engleski ga ovdje mora pokazati glasom.
- Wh-cleft: na kraju surečenice s what glas se blago podiže ili zastane, a zatim snažno padne na fokusu: What I need… is a HOliday.
- U It was oblik was je slab: /wəz/, s nejasnim samoglasnikom, a ne puno „o“. U govoru je normalno It's: It's Tom who….
- Između dva dijela rascijepljene rečenice nema zareza: What I need is a break (ne What I need, is a break).
- The reason… is that… preporučuje se u formalnom pisanju; The reason… is because… često je u govoru, ali ga pažljivo pisanje često kritizira.
Zlatno pravilo
Da istaknete jednu informaciju, rascijepite rečenicu: It + be + fokus + that / who… („baš ovaj, a ne drugi“) ili What + surečenica + be + fokus (poznato prvo, novo na kraju). Glavni naglasak stavite na fokus. „Ono što“ = what, „sve što“ = all, a It was ostaje u jednini.
Vježbe
A. Oblik
Preoblikujte svaku rečenicu u rascijepljenu rečenicu. Upotrijebite zadane riječi, a značenje neka ostane isto.
-
Preoblikujte u it-cleft koji ističe "the finance team": The finance team spotted the error, not the auditors.
-
Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "It wasn't until": I only noticed the scratch on the car when I got home.
-
Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "What surprised me": I was surprised by how friendly everyone was.
-
Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "What happened was": The server crashed in the middle of the update.
-
Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "What she did": She called the manager directly.
-
Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "All": I only asked whether the price included breakfast!
-
Preoblikujte za formalni mail uz "The reason… is that…": I am writing because the invoice contains two errors.
-
Preoblikujte u obrnuti wh-cleft: Teamwork made this project a success.
B. Značenje
Pročitajte situaciju i odaberite bolju rečenicu.
-
Ben misli da je Kate pokvarila aparat za kavu. Vi znate da je to bio Tom. Koji ga odgovor ispravlja?it-cleft: baš ta osoba, a ne druga
-
Govornik želi postupno doći do ključne ideje i izreći je na kraju. Koja rečenica to čini?wh-cleft: poznato prvo, nova informacija na kraju
-
Netko pita: "What did the council do about the budget cuts?" Koji odgovor odgovara pitanju?pitanje je o radnji: What… did was + osnovni oblik
-
Formalna pisana isprika zbog propuštenog sastanka. Što je bolje?pažljivo pisanje traži the reason… is that
-
Koja je rečenica cleft (možete maknuti "It was… that" i ostaje cijela rečenica)?it + be + pridjev + that nije cleft
C. Pronađite pogrešku
U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna gramatička pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.
-
It were the two youngest players who scored the goals in yesterday's final against the league champions.
-
It's the neighbours upstairs who is responsible for the noise, not the people in the flat next door.
-
The thing what annoys me most about open-plan offices is the constant noise from phone calls.
-
All what we need to finish the project on time is two more developers and a little luck.
-
What I don't understand is why nobody told us about the changes before the contract was signed.
D. U kontekstu
Pročitajte bilješke sa sastanka. Preoblikujte označene rečenice u rascijepljene rečenice uz zadane riječi.
The board asked who was responsible for the six-week delay. (19) The supplier's late delivery caused the delay, not our team. Looking ahead, (20) we need a second supplier for the key components. The problems started last spring, when (21) the factory flooded and production stopped for three weeks. (22) We only realised how fragile our supply chain was after the flood. The board also asked why the budget had increased. (23) It increased because shipping costs doubled. Finally, (24) the client values reliability above everything else, so we must not let this happen again.
-
Preoblikujte rečenicu (19) u it-cleft.
-
Preoblikujte rečenicu (20) tako da počinje s "what".
-
Preoblikujte rečenicu (21) tako da počinje s "what happened was".
-
Preoblikujte rečenicu (22) tako da počinje s "It was only".
-
Preoblikujte rečenicu (23) uz "The reason… is / was that…".
-
Preoblikujte rečenicu (24) u obrnuti wh-cleft.
E. Vaš red
Pišite na engleskom ispravke, uvode u izlaganje i pritužbe.
-
Kolega misli da ste vi predložili otkazivanje izleta tima. Napišite 2–3 rečenice kojima ga ispravljate. Upotrijebite jedan it-cleft i jedan wh-cleft.
-
Napišite početak kratkog izlaganja (2–3 rečenice) o nečemu što je promijenilo vaše mišljenje. Upotrijebite What surprised me most was… i The reason… is that….
-
Napišite pritužbu hotelu u dvije rečenice. Upotrijebite All I… i The last thing I needed….
F. Miješano ponavljanje
Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.
-
C1-02 Inversion: Only then, Not until, So… that, Here comes – „tek tada“ i „evo ga“ na engleskom Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "Not until": I didn't understand the problem until I read the letter.
-
C1-01 Inversion: Never have I…, No sooner had I… – inverzija iza niječnih izraza na engleskom Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "Little": We had no idea that the company was about to close.
-
B2-20 Noun clauses na hrvatskom: that, whether i what (imeničke rečenice) Formalni mail. Koja rečenica ima pravi veznik za otvoreno pitanje?decide + whether za pitanje da / ne
Rješenja
A. Oblik
- It was the finance team that spotted the error, not the auditors. / It was the finance team who spotted the error, not the auditors.
- It wasn't until I got home that I noticed the scratch on the car.
- What surprised me was how friendly everyone was.
- What happened was that the server crashed in the middle of the update. / What happened was the server crashed in the middle of the update.
- What she did was call the manager directly. / What she did was to call the manager directly.
- All I did was ask whether the price included breakfast! / All I asked was whether the price included breakfast!
- The reason I am writing is that the invoice contains two errors. / The reason why I am writing is that the invoice contains two errors.
- Teamwork is what made this project a success. / Teamwork was what made this project a success.
B. Značenje
- It was Tom who broke the coffee machine, not Kate.
- What we really need is a completely new approach.
- What the council did was close the library.
- The reason I missed the meeting is that my train was cancelled.
- It was in Lisbon that the two founders first met.
C. Pronađite pogrešku
- It was the two youngest players who scored the goals in yesterday's final against the league champions.
- It's the neighbours upstairs who are responsible for the noise, not the people in the flat next door.
- The thing that annoys me most about open-plan offices is the constant noise from phone calls. / What annoys me most about open-plan offices is the constant noise from phone calls.
- All we need to finish the project on time is two more developers and a little luck. / All that we need to finish the project on time is two more developers and a little luck.
- ✓ What I don't understand is why nobody told us about the changes before the contract was signed.
D. U kontekstu
- It was the supplier's late delivery that caused the delay, not our team.
- what we need is a second supplier for the key components.
- what happened was that the factory flooded and production stopped for three weeks.
- It was only after the flood that we realised how fragile our supply chain was.
- The reason it increased is that shipping costs doubled. / The reason the budget increased was that shipping costs had doubled.
- reliability is what the client values above everything else, so we must not let this happen again.
E. Vaš red
- It wasn't me who suggested cancelling the trip; it was Marta. What I actually said was that we should move it to June.
- What surprised me most about living abroad was how quickly I stopped missing home. The reason I'm telling you this is that many of you will soon move away for work.
- All I asked for was a quiet room away from the lift. The last thing I needed after a twelve-hour flight was a room next to a building site.
F. Miješano ponavljanje
- Not until I read the letter did I understand the problem.
- Little did we know that the company was about to close. / Little did we realise that the company was about to close.
- We have not yet decided whether the event will go ahead.
