SlowingoGramatika
C1 8 / 20

Hedging sa Ingles: Seem, Appear, Tend To, Apparently, Allegedly at It Could Be Argued

Hedging and Distancing: It Seems That…

Sa pahinang ito
  1. Layunin
  2. Ang Pangunahing Ideya
  3. Filipino at Ingles
  4. Anyo
  5. Gamit
  6. Karaniwang Mali
  7. Mga Bitag para sa mga Pilipino
  8. Huwag Ipagkamali
  9. Baybay at Bigkas
  10. Gintong Tuntunin
  11. Mga Pagsasanay

Layunin

Pagkatapos ng araling ito, kaya mo nang gumawa ng maingat, magalang at akademikong pahayag gamit ang seem / appear, tend to, ang mga modal na may, might, could, would, mga pang-abay tulad ng apparently, arguably, presumably at allegedly, at mga balangkas tulad ng It could be argued that… — at maipakita na galing sa iba ang impormasyon.

Ang Pangunahing Ideya

Ang pahayag na sinabi nang may ganap na katiyakan ay parang baso sa matigas na sahig: Social media causes depression. Kapag may isang pag-aaral na hindi sang-ayon, nababasag ang pahayag, at mukhang pabaya ang sumulat.

Ang hedging ay naglalagay ng maliliit na unan sa paligid ng pahayag: Social media may contribute to depression in some teenagers. Tiyak na ngayon ang pahayag. Sinasabi nito nang eksakto kung gaano kasigurado ang sumulat — hindi labis, hindi kulang.

Kaugnay nito ang distancing. Ipinapakita nito na galing sa iba ang impormasyon, hindi sa sariling kaalaman ng nagsasalita: Apparently, the CEO is leaving. He is said to have taken the money.

Hindi kahinaan o kalabuan ang hedging. Sa akademikong pagsusulat, pamamahayag, negosyo at diplomasya, tanda ito ng katapatan at mabuting pagpapasya. Sa usapan, nagiging magalang ka sa halip na prangka. Pero kapag sobrang dami ng unan, natatabunan ang mensahe: karaniwang sapat na ang isa o dalawa sa bawat pahayag.

Filipino at Ingles

Mayaman ang Filipino sa maliliit na salitang pang-hedge at pang-distancing: daw / raw (narinig ko lang), yata, parang, mukhang, tila, siguro, baka, at sa balita, umano. Ang Sarado na raw ang restaurant ay eksaktong Apparently, the restaurant has closed down. Pero sa Ingles, buong salita o istruktura ang kailangan, at kailangang ipakita ng anyo ng to-infinitive ang panahon: mukhang gumagana → seems to be working; mukhang may kumuha → seems to have taken. Mag-ingat din sa siguro: puwede itong presumably (palagay batay sa lohika) o maybe / perhaps (posible lang).

FilipinoInglesPansinin
Mukhang masaya siya sa bagong trabaho niya.She seems happy in her new job.seem + pang-uri
Mukhang gumagana na ulit ang printer.The printer appears to be working again.nagaganap → to be + -ing
Mukhang may kumuha ng payong ko.Someone seems to have taken my umbrella.naganap → to have + past participle
Parang may hindi pagkakaunawaan.There seems to be a misunderstanding.parang may → there seems to be
Sarado na raw ang restaurant.Apparently, the restaurant has closed down.raw / daw → apparently
Umano'y nagnakaw ang suspek.The suspect allegedly stole the money.hindi pa napatutunayan
Sinasabing pinag-iisipan ng ministro ang pagbibitiw.The minister is said to be considering resignation.reporting passive
Baka problema sa software ang dahilan.The delay could be due to a software problem.posibilidad → modal

Anyo

Seem / appear + to-infinitive

AnyoKahuluganHalimbawa
seem / appear + to + base formkalagayan o gawi ngayonShe seems to know everyone.
seem / appear + to be + -ingnagaganap ngayonThe system appears to be working.
seem / appear + to have + past participlenaunang kilosThey seem to have left.
seem (+ to be) + pang-urikalagayan ngayonHe seems (to be) happy.
It seems / appears (that) + clausepangkalahatang impresyonIt seems that the train is late.
There seems / appears to be + pangngalanpag-iralThere appears to be a problem.

Mas pormal ang appear kaysa sa seem. Negatibo: She doesn't seem to understand (karaniwan) o She seems not to understand (mas pormal).

Iba pang kasangkapan sa hedging

KasangkapanMga halimbawa
modalmay, might, could; would para palambutin ang konklusyon (This would suggest…)
hiligtend to + base form; There is a tendency for…
pang-abayapparently, arguably, presumably, supposedly, allegedly, seemingly
pariralang naglilimitato some / a certain extent, largely, in some cases, some, many
impersonal na balangkasIt could be argued that…; There is some evidence that…; It is possible that…
reporting passive (B2-12)It is believed that…; He is said to…

Para sa antas ng posibilidad (be likely to, be bound to, the chances are), tingnan ang B2-26.

Gamit

1Seem at Appear + To-infinitive

Gamitin ang seem / appear para magbigay ng impresyon, hindi ng katotohanan. Piliin ang anyo ng to-infinitive ayon sa panahon: to do (ngayon / pangkalahatan), to be doing (nagaganap), to have done (nauna). Kapag may pang-uri, puwedeng alisin ang to be. Sa UK English, karaniwan din ang seem + noun phrase nang walang to be: He seems a nice person.

The new manager seems to be very popular with the team.
Mukhang gustong-gusto ng team ang bagong manager.
She seems happy in her new job.
Mukhang masaya siya sa bagong trabaho niya.
seem + pang-uri: puwedeng walang to be; babae → she
The printer appears to be working again.
Mukhang gumagana na ulit ang printer.
nagaganap ngayon
Someone seems to have taken my umbrella.
Mukhang may kumuha ng payong ko.
naunang kilos: to have + past participle
The results appear to confirm our original theory.
Tila pinatutunayan ng mga resulta ang orihinal naming teorya.
The files seem to have been deleted by mistake.
Mukhang nabura nang hindi sinasadya ang mga file.
passive: tingnan ang B2-12
She doesn't seem to mind the noise.
Mukhang hindi naman siya naaabala sa ingay.

2It Seems / Appears That…; There Seems To Be

Gamitin ang It seems / appears (that) + clause para sa pangkalahatang impresyon, madalas para magbalita nang mahinahon. Ang There seems / appears to be ay naglalagay ng hedge sa pahayag tungkol sa pag-iral — ang parang may… natin. Sa impormal na pagsasalita, karaniwan din ang It seems like + clause.

It seems that we've been charged twice for the same order.
Mukhang dalawang beses kaming siningil para sa iisang order.
It appears that the fire started in the kitchen.
Lumilitaw na sa kusina nagsimula ang sunog.
mas pormal ang appear
There seems to be a misunderstanding about the deadline.
Parang may hindi pagkakaunawaan tungkol sa deadline.
isahan ang a misunderstanding → seems
It seems like everyone is working from home today.
Parang lahat ay naka-work from home ngayon.
impormal

3Mga Modal para sa Hedging

Inilalahad ng may, might at could ang pahayag bilang posible, hindi tiyak — ang maaari at baka natin. Pinalalambot ng would ang sarili mong konklusyon o opinyon: This would suggest…, I would argue…. Para sa mga pangunahing modal ng posibilidad, tingnan ang A2-22.

These findings may help explain why some patients recover faster.
Maaaring makatulong ang mga resultang ito na ipaliwanag kung bakit mas mabilis gumaling ang ilang pasyente.
The delay could be due to a software problem.
Baka problema sa software ang sanhi ng delay.
baka → could / might
This would suggest that the policy has had little effect.
Mukhang ipinahihiwatig nito na maliit lang ang naging epekto ng patakaran.
pinalalambot ng would ang konklusyon
I would argue that the plan needs more time.
Sa palagay ko, kailangan pa ng mas mahabang panahon ang plano.
pinalambot na opinyon
There might be a simpler explanation.
Baka may mas simpleng paliwanag.

4Mga Pang-abay ng Hedging at Distancing

May tiyak na kahulugan ang bawat pang-abay. Apparently = narinig ko / mukhang ganoon (ang daw natin). Arguably = may matibay na katwiran para dito (madalas bago ang superlative). Presumably = palagay ko, batay sa lohika. Supposedly = iyon ang sabi nila, pero nagdududa ako. Allegedly = may nagpaparatang, pero hindi pa napatutunayan (balita, batas) — ang umano sa balita. Seemingly = ganito ang itsura mula sa labas.

Apparently, the restaurant has closed down.
Sarado na raw ang restaurant.
raw → apparently
It's arguably the best album of the decade.
Masasabing ito ang pinakamahusay na album ng dekada.
may matibay na katwiran
Presumably, you'll need a visa to work there.
Siguro kakailanganin mo ng visa para makapagtrabaho roon.
siguro dito = palagay batay sa lohika
This cream supposedly removes wrinkles in a week.
Kaya raw tanggalin ng cream na ito ang mga kulubot sa loob ng isang linggo.
sabi nila, pero nagdududa ang nagsasalita
The suspect allegedly stole over £2 million.
Umano'y nagnakaw ang suspek ng mahigit £2 milyon.
paratang, hindi pa napatutunayan
He walked away from the crash seemingly unhurt.
Umalis siya sa pinangyarihan ng banggaan na tila hindi nasaktan.

5Tend To, Pariralang Naglilimita at Impersonal na Balangkas

Inilalarawan ng tend to ang karaniwang totoo pero may eksepsiyon — ang madalas o kadalasan natin. Limitahan ang saklaw ng pahayag gamit ang to some / a certain extent, largely o in some cases. Inilalahad ng mga impersonal na balangkas tulad ng It could be argued that… at There is some evidence that… ang isang pananaw nang hindi ito ginagawang personal.

Students tend to leave their revision until the last minute.
Kadalasan, ipinagpapaliban ng mga estudyante ang pagre-review hanggang sa huling minuto.
kadalasan → tend to
To some extent, the success of the campaign was due to luck.
Sa ilang bahagi, suwerte ang dahilan ng tagumpay ng kampanya.
The crisis was largely caused by poor planning.
Pangunahing dulot ng hindi maayos na pagpaplano ang krisis.
It could be argued that the city needs fewer cars, not more roads.
Masasabing mas kaunting sasakyan ang kailangan ng lungsod, hindi mas maraming kalsada.
There is some evidence that regular exercise improves memory.
May ilang ebidensiya na napabubuti ng regular na ehersisyo ang memorya.

6Ang Reporting Passive bilang Kasangkapan sa Distancing

Ang reporting passive (B2-12) ay nag-uulat ng paniniwala o pahayag nang hindi sinasabi kung sino ang may hawak nito. Natural itong isabay sa mga hedge sa itaas at karaniwan sa balita at akademikong pagsusulat.

The minister is said to be considering resignation.
Sinasabing pinag-iisipan ng ministro ang pagbibitiw.
sinasabing → is said to
It is believed that the painting was stolen in the 1970s.
Pinaniniwalaang ninakaw ang painting noong dekada '70.
The company is thought to have lost millions last year.
Pinaniniwalaang milyon-milyon ang nalugi ng kompanya noong nakaraang taon.
naunang kilos: to have + past participle

Karaniwang Mali

❌He seems being tired.
✅He seems tired. o He seems to be tired.
seem + pang-uri o + to-infinitive, hindi kailanman + -ing lang.
❌She seems to leave already.
✅She seems to have left already.
Naunang kilos: to have + past participle.
❌It seems that he to be ill.
✅It seems that he is ill. o He seems to be ill.
Pagkatapos ng that, buong clause.
❌I'm seeming to have a problem with my login.
✅I seem to have a problem with my login.
State verb ang seem: hindi continuous.
❌There seem to be a problem.
✅There seems to be a problem.
Sumasang-ayon ang seem sa pangngalang kasunod: a problem → seems.
❌Older users are tend to prefer email.
✅Older users tend to prefer email.
Ordinaryong pandiwa ang tend; walang be.
❌It could argue that the policy failed.
✅It could be argued that the policy failed.
Impersonal na balangkas: passive na be argued.
⚠️It may perhaps possibly be true that some students might find this difficult.
✅Some students may find this difficult.
Sobrang hedging: tama ang gramatika, pero nawawala ang pahayag.

Mga Bitag para sa mga Pilipino

1. Mukhang + pandiwa → seem + -ing. Sa Mukhang hindi gumagana ang elevator, sumusunod agad ang pandiwa sa mukhang, kaya doesn't seem working ang lumalabas. Sa Ingles, kailangan ng to-infinitive: doesn't seem to work o, para sa nagaganap ngayon, doesn't seem to be working.

❌The elevator in our building doesn't seem working, so let's take the stairs.
✅The elevator in our building doesn't seem to be working, so let's take the stairs. o The elevator in our building doesn't seem to work, so let's take the stairs.
seem + to-infinitive, hindi -ing lang.

2. Mukhang … na → seem to + base form + already. Sa Mukhang naubos na ang tiket, ang naganap na aspekto at ang na ang nagpapakitang tapos na. Kapag isinalin ito sa seem to + base form + already, nawawala ang nakaraan. Sa Ingles, ang anyo ng to-infinitive ang nagdadala nito: to have + past participle.

❌The concert tickets seem to sell out already.
✅The concert tickets seem to have sold out already.
Tapos na ang kilos → to have + past participle.

3. Supposedly = dapat sana. Sa Taglish, madalas gamitin ang supposedly para sa dapat sana o sa orihinal na plano (Supposedly, pupunta ako sa reunion…). Sa Ingles, ang supposedly ay "iyon ang sabi nila, pero nagdududa ako". Para sa planong hindi natuloy, was / were supposed to.

⚠️Supposedly, I'm going to our class reunion, but I have a night shift that day.
✅I was supposed to go to our class reunion, but I have a night shift that day.
Ang supposedly ay pagdududa sa sabi ng iba; para sa naudlot na plano, was supposed to.

Huwag Ipagkamali

Apparently at obviously / clearly — Nagdadagdag ng distansiya ang apparently: "narinig ko" o "mukhang". Kabaligtaran naman ang obviously at clearly: inilalahad ng mga ito ang isang bagay bilang tiyak.

Apparently, the meeting is cancelled.
Kanselado raw ang meeting.
narinig ko lang ito
Obviously, the meeting is cancelled — the boss is ill.
Siyempre kanselado ang meeting
may sakit ang boss. — inilalahad bilang tiyak

Supposedly at presumably — Supposedly = "iyon ang sabi nila, pero nagdududa ako". Presumably = "palagay ko, batay sa lohika". Parehong siguro o raw ang naiisip natin, kaya mag-ingat.

This is supposedly the oldest pub in London.
Ito raw ang pinakamatandang pub sa London.
sabi nila; hindi ako sigurado
You'll presumably want a window seat.
Siguro gusto mo ng upuan sa tabi ng bintana.
palagay ko

Arguably at allegedly — Ipinapakilala ng arguably ang opinyong kaya mong ipagtanggol. Nag-uulat naman ang allegedly ng paratang na hindi pa napatutunayan. Papuri ang She is arguably the best singer of her generation; paratang laban sa kanya ang She allegedly cheated.

Tend to at used to — Ang tend to ay pangkalahatang hilig ngayon; ang used to ay gawi noon na tumigil na (tingnan ang A2-28) — ang dati natin.

I tend to work better in the morning.
Kadalasan, mas maayos akong magtrabaho sa umaga.
ngayon, karaniwan
I used to work at night, but not any more.
Dati, sa gabi ako nagtatrabaho, pero hindi na ngayon.
dati → used to

Baybay at Bigkas

  • Diin: apPArently, ARguably, preSUMably /prɪˈzjuːməbli/ (UK), /prɪˈzuːməbli/ (US), supPOSedly /səˈpəʊzɪdli/ (UK), /səˈpoʊzɪdli/ (US), alLEGedly /əˈledʒɪdli/. (Ang malalaking titik dito ay para lang ipakita ang diin.) Nasa unang pantig ang diin ng arguably — iwasan ang "ar-GYU-a-bli".
  • Sa supposedly at allegedly, buong pantig ang -ed-: "suh-POH-zid-lee", "uh-LEJ-id-lee".
  • Ang s sa presumably at supposedly ay /z/ — may ugong, parang bubuyog — hindi matigas na s. Sa allegedly, ang g ay /dʒ/, tulad ng j sa jeep.
  • Mahina at maikli ang mga unang patinig na walang diin (/ə/): apparently /əˈpærəntli/, allegedly. Hindi kailangang bigkasin nang buo ang bawat patinig.
  • Baybay: arguably (walang e: argue → arguably); apparently (dalawang p, isang r).
  • Sa pagsasalita, madalas may maikling hinto pagkatapos ng pang-abay ng hedging sa simula: Apparently, | she's quit.

Gintong Tuntunin

Sabihin nang eksakto kung gaano ka kasigurado — hindi labis, hindi kulang. Lagyan ng unan ang pahayag gamit ang seem / appear, tend to, may / might / could / would, isang tiyak na pang-abay o isang pariralang naglilimita, at gumamit ng distancing (apparently, is said to) kapag hindi sa iyo galing ang impormasyon. Kung saan daw, mukhang o baka ang gamit natin, buong salita o istruktura ang kailangan sa Ingles. Karaniwang sapat ang isa o dalawang hedge sa bawat pahayag.

Mga Pagsasanay

A. Anyo

Isulat muli ang bawat pangungusap gamit ang salita o balangkas na ibinigay. Panatilihin ang kahulugan.

  1. Isulat muli gamit ang "seem": It seems that he knows everyone in the building.
  2. Isulat muli gamit ang "appear": It appears that they have lost the original documents.
  3. Isulat muli gamit ang "appear": It appears that the engineers are fixing the problem right now.
  4. Isulat muli simula sa "There seems": I think there's a mistake in the final bill.
  5. Palambutin ang konklusyon gamit ang "would": These results suggest that the drug is effective.
  6. Isulat muli simula sa "It could be argued": Some people say the city needs fewer cars, not more roads.
  7. Isulat muli gamit ang "allegedly": People claim that the director hid the losses from shareholders, but nobody has proved it.

B. Kahulugan

Piliin ang pangungusap na tugma sa konteksto. Ipinapaliwanag ng tala kung bakit.

  1. Isang ulat sa balita tungkol sa kaso sa korte na hindi pa tapos. Alin ang angkop?
  2. Hindi ka naniniwala sa isang advertisement. Aling pangungusap ang nagpapakita ng pagdududa mo?
  3. Isang akademikong essay. Aling pahayag ang may tamang dami ng hedging?
  4. Isang email sa katrabahong mukhang mali ang mga numero. Alin ang mas diplomatiko?
  5. Tinanong ka ng isang katrabaho tungkol sa gawi mo sa trabaho ngayon. Aling pangungusap ang sumasagot sa tanong?
  6. Lilipat sa Japan para magtrabaho ang kaibigan mo, at iniisip ninyo kung ano ang kakailanganin niya. Aling pangungusap ang sarili mong palagay batay sa lohika?

C. Hanapin ang Mali

Itama ang mali at isulat ang buong naitamang pangungusap. Kung tama na ang pangungusap, isulat ang correct.

  1. Since the update last week, the app seems crashing every time I try to upload a photo from my phone.
  2. According to early reports, the captain seems to leave the ship before all the passengers had been rescued.
  3. There seem to be a serious misunderstanding between the two departments about who is responsible for the budget.
  4. Students who live at home are tend to spend less on food than those who live in university accommodation.
  5. The files appear to have been deleted by mistake during the overnight backup, so we may need to restore them.

D. Sa Konteksto

Basahin ang draft at ang komento ng tutor. Isulat muli ang bawat may numerong pangungusap ayon sa panuto para magkaroon ng hedging ang pahayag.

Essay draft — tutor's comment: "Too certain. Hedge each numbered claim."
Since 2020, universities in many countries have moved part of their teaching online. (19) Online learning has grown rapidly since then. (20) Students prefer short videos to long lectures, and many lecturers now record ten-minute clips instead of hour-long talks. (21) Short clips improve attention. (22) However, short videos make deep thinking harder, because students rarely have to follow a long argument. (23) One small study at a business school proves this. (24) The biggest change is not the technology but the way students plan their time. Further research with larger groups is needed before universities change their courses again.
  1. Pangungusap (19): gamitin ang "appear" + ang tamang anyo ng to-infinitive.
  2. Pangungusap (20): gamitin ang "tend".
  3. Pangungusap (21): magsimula sa "There is some evidence that".
  4. Pangungusap (22): magsimula sa "However, it could be argued that".
  5. Pangungusap (23): palitan ang "proves" ng "would" + mas malambot na pandiwa.
  6. Pangungusap (24): magsimula sa pang-abay ng hedging na nangangahulugang "may matibay na katwiran para dito".

E. Ikaw Naman

Isulat sa Ingles.

  1. Isulat muli ang prangkang pahayag na ito para sa isang akademikong essay, sa isa o dalawang pangungusap: "Video games make children violent." Gumamit ng kahit dalawang magkaibang kasangkapan sa hedging (halimbawa, modal, salitang naglilimita, impersonal na balangkas), pero hindi hihigit sa tatlo.
  2. Sumulat ng 2–3 pangungusap sa isang kaibigan para ibalita ang narinig mo pero hindi mo pa natitiyak tungkol sa isang lugar o event sa inyo. Gamitin ang apparently nang isang beses at ang is said to o is thought to nang isang beses.
  3. Sumulat ng 2–3 diplomatikong pangungusap sa isang katrabahong mukhang may maling numero sa report. Gamitin ang seem o appear kahit isang beses at isang modal ng posibilidad.

F. Halo-halong Balik-aral

Balikan ang mga naunang aralin.

  1. B2-12 It Is Said That at He Is Said To sa Ingles: Ang Reporting Passive at ang Daw ng Filipino
    Isulat muli simula sa "The painting": People believe that the painting was stolen in the 1970s.
  2. C1-07 Advanced Participle Clauses sa Ingles: Built in 1850, Having Been Told, With Prices Rising
    Isulat muli gamit ang clause ng resulta: The update failed, and this caused chaos for thousands of users.
  3. C1-03 Pormal na Conditional sa Ingles: Should You Need, Were I To, Had I Known at But For
    Isulat muli simula sa "Should": If you need any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Mga sagot

A. Anyo

  1. He seems to know everyone in the building.
  2. They appear to have lost the original documents.
  3. The engineers appear to be fixing the problem right now.
  4. There seems to be a mistake in the final bill.
  5. These results would suggest that the drug is effective.
  6. It could be argued that the city needs fewer cars, not more roads.
  7. The director allegedly hid the losses from shareholders. / Allegedly, the director hid the losses from shareholders.

B. Kahulugan

  1. The manager allegedly stole £2 million from the company.
  2. This cream supposedly makes you look ten years younger.
  3. Social media may contribute to depression in some teenagers.
  4. There seem to be a few problems with the figures in the report.
  5. I tend to work better in the morning.
  6. Presumably, you'll need a visa to work there.

C. Hanapin ang Mali

  1. Since the update last week, the app seems to crash every time I try to upload a photo from my phone. / Since the update last week, the app seems to be crashing every time I try to upload a photo from my phone.
  2. According to early reports, the captain seems to have left the ship before all the passengers had been rescued.
  3. There seems to be a serious misunderstanding between the two departments about who is responsible for the budget.
  4. Students who live at home tend to spend less on food than those who live in university accommodation.
  5. ✓ The files appear to have been deleted by mistake during the overnight backup, so we may need to restore them.

D. Sa Konteksto

  1. Online learning appears to have grown rapidly since then.
  2. Students tend to prefer short videos to long lectures, and many lecturers now record ten-minute clips instead of hour-long talks.
  3. There is some evidence that short clips improve attention.
  4. However, it could be argued that short videos make deep thinking harder, because students rarely have to follow a long argument.
  5. One small study at a business school would suggest this. / One small study at a business school would seem to support this.
  6. Arguably, the biggest change is not the technology but the way students plan their time.

E. Ikaw Naman

  1. There is some evidence that violent video games may contribute to aggressive behaviour in children.
  2. Apparently, the café on the corner is closing next month. The owner is said to be moving to the coast. Let's go there one last time before it shuts.
  3. There seem to be a few problems with the figures in Table 3. The totals don't appear to match the monthly data. Could an older version of the spreadsheet have been used?

F. Halo-halong Balik-aral

  1. The painting is believed to have been stolen in the 1970s.
  2. The update failed, causing chaos for thousands of users.
  3. Should you need any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.
App para sa AndroidMatuto Kahit Saan Google Play