SlowingoGramatika
B2 8 / 30

Non-defining relative clauses: odnosne rečenice sa zarezima na engleskom

Non-Defining Relative Clauses

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete zarezima dodati informaciju o osobi, stvari, mjestu ili vremenu – My sister, who lives in Oslo, is a pilot – razumjeti kako zarezi mijenjaju značenje, upotrijebiti which za komentar cijele rečenice i upotrijebiti some of whom / most of which.

Osnovna ideja

Odnosna rečenica (relative clause) može imati dva sasvim različita zadatka.

Rečenica koja određuje (defining; A2-29, B1-20) kaže o kojem je točno riječ. Bez nje slušatelj ne zna na koga ili na što mislite: The woman who called you is my boss. – Koja žena? Ona koja vas je nazvala.

Rečenica koja ne određuje (non-defining) dodaje dodatnu informaciju o nečemu što je već jasno. Zamislite glumca na pozornici koji se na trenutak okrene publici, kaže kratku opasku i vrati se u scenu. Predstavi ta opaska ne treba, ali nešto dodaje: My boss, who is from Ireland, called today. Imam samo jednu šeficu; rečenica samo kaže nešto više o njoj. Uklonite je i rečenica i dalje ima smisla.

Zarezi označavaju tu opasku. U govoru postaju kratke stanke, a glas se malo spusti. Budući da je rečenica zaseban komentar, pravila su stroža: nema that, a odnosna riječ nikad se ne izostavlja.

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski za ljude i za stvari ima istu riječ: koji, koja, koje. Engleski razlikuje who (ljudi) i which (stvari, životinje). Zato se lako pojavi which za osobu.

Kad komentiramo cijelu prethodnu rečenicu, kažemo „što“: „Opet je pao vozački, što je sve iznenadilo.“ A „što“ je u školi what. U engleskom je ovdje jedina mogućnost which.

Uz brojeve i riječi kao „većina“, „neki“, „oba“ kažemo „od kojih“: „pedeset prijava, od kojih većina…“. „Od“ nije from: engleski kaže most of whom / most of which. A hrvatsku rečenicu možemo nastaviti i samo zarezom: „Ima dva sina, oba su liječnici.“ U engleskom zarez ne može spojiti dvije samostalne rečenice – treba both of whom ili and.

Čiji odgovara riječi whose, gdje riječi where, a kad riječi when – ovdje je isto. I zapamtite: u engleskom zarezi nose značenje. Bez njih rečenica govori o kojem je točno riječ. Hrvatski pravopis umetnutu odnosnu rečenicu također stavlja među zareze – ovdje je isto – ali u govoru razliku često pokazujemo i riječima („onaj“, „svi“).

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Moja baka, koja ima 92 godine, još svako jutro pliva.My grandmother, who is 92, still swims every morning.osoba → who
Muzej, koji je otvoren 2019., besplatan je.The museum, which opened in 2019, is free.stvar → which
Opet je pao vozački, što je sve iznenadilo.He failed his driving test again, which surprised everyone.„što“ za cijelu rečenicu → which, nikad what
Prijavilo se pedesetak ljudi, od kojih većina nije imala iskustva.About fifty people applied, most of whom had no experience.„od kojih“ → of whom, a ne from
Kupila sam tri biljke, od kojih nijedna nije preživjela zimu.I bought three plants, none of which survived the winter.stvari → of which
Maya, čiju sam sestru znala iz škole, upravo se zaručila.Maya, whose sister I went to school with, has just got engaged.ovdje je isto: „čiji“ → whose
Ručali smo u Brightonu, gdje moj bratić ima kafić.We had lunch in Brighton, where my cousin runs a café.ovdje je isto: „gdje“ → where

Ukratko: „koji“ za osobu = who, za stvar = which; „što“ o cijeloj rečenici = which; „od kojih“ = of whom / of which; nikad that iza zareza.

Oblik

Odnosne riječi u rečenicama koje ne određuju

RiječOdnosi se naPrimjer
wholjude (subjekt ili objekt)My uncle, who is a chef, cooked dinner.
whomljude (objekt; formalno)The director, whom I met last year, has retired.
whichstvari, životinje, cijele rečeniceThe museum, which opened in 2019, is free.
whoseposvojnost (ljudi i stvari)Our neighbour, whose dog barks all night, is moving.
wheremjestaWe stayed in Porto, where my parents met.
whenvrijemeI'll call you on Friday, when I'm less busy.

Pravila

Pravilo✅❌
Zarezi oko rečenice (ili jedan zarez ako je na kraju)My car, which is ten years old, still runs well.My car which is ten years old still runs well.
Nema thatParis, which I love, is expensive.Paris, that I love, is expensive.
Odnosna riječ ne smije se izostavitiThe film, which I saw yesterday, was great.The film, I saw yesterday, was great.

Riječ za količinu + of whom / of which

Riječ za količinuLjudiStvari
some / many / most / all / none / both / neither / one / two…+ of whom+ of which
PrimjerI have three brothers, all of whom live abroad.She wrote five novels, two of which became films.

Rečenica s komentarom

Glavna rečenica, which … (o cijeloj rečenici)
The train was cancelled,which meant we had to take a taxi.

Uporaba

1Određuje ili ne određuje – zarezi mijenjaju značenje

Bez zareza rečenica kaže o kojem je točno riječ. Sa zarezima dodaje informaciju o nečemu što je već poznato. Značenje može biti različito. Na hrvatskom tu razliku često moramo pokazati drugim riječima („onaj“, „svi“).

My brother who lives in Toronto is an architect.
Onaj moj brat koji živi u Torontu arhitekt je.
imam više braće
My brother, who lives in Toronto, is an architect.
Moj brat, koji živi u Torontu, arhitekt je.
imam jednog brata
The students who passed the exam got a certificate.
Studenti koji su položili ispit dobili su potvrdu.
položili su samo neki
The students, who passed the exam, got a certificate.
Studenti, koji su svi položili ispit, dobili su potvrdu.
položili su svi
Mount Everest, which is on the border of Nepal and China, attracts thousands of climbers.
Mount Everest, koji se nalazi na granici Nepala i Kine, privlači tisuće penjača.
jedinstvena stvar: rečenica uvijek ne određuje

2Dodatna informacija – who, which, whom

Za ljude upotrijebite who, a za stvari which – iako je na hrvatskom oboje „koji“. U formalnom pisanju whom se upotrebljava kad je osoba objekt; u razgovoru većina ljudi kaže who. Rečenica može stajati u sredini ili na kraju.

Our new manager, who started on Monday, seems very friendly.
Naša nova voditeljica, koja je počela u ponedjeljak, čini se vrlo ljubazna.
osoba → who
I've just finished the novel you lent me, which took me six months.
Upravo sam dovršio roman koji si mi posudio, za koji mi je trebalo šest mjeseci.
stvar → which
Dr Patel, whom many patients ask for by name, works only on Tuesdays.
Dr. Patel, kojeg mnogi pacijenti traže poimence, radi samo utorkom.
formalno: whom kao objekt
We're flying with SkyLink, which I've never used before.
Letimo sa SkyLinkom, s kojim još nikad nisam letio.
My grandmother, who is 92, still swims every morning.
Moja baka, koja ima 92 godine, još svako jutro pliva.

3Which za cijelu rečenicu

Which može komentirati cijelu misao prethodne rečenice, a ne samo jednu imenicu – kao naše „što“. Takva rečenica dolazi iza rečenice koju komentira, nakon zareza. What ovdje nije moguć.

He failed his driving test again, which surprised everyone.
Opet je pao vozački, što je sve iznenadilo.
„što“ → which
The flight was delayed by six hours, which meant we missed our connection.
Let je kasnio šest sati, zbog čega smo propustili presjedanje.
She offered to drive me home, which was really kind of her.
Ponudila se da me odveze kući, što je bilo jako lijepo od nje.
which = to što se ponudila
Prices have gone up again, which is why we're eating out less.
Cijene su opet porasle, zbog čega rjeđe jedemo vani.
which is why = zbog čega

4Riječ za količinu + of whom / of which

Iza broja ili riječi za količinu upotrijebite of whom za ljude i of which za stvari. Hrvatski tu ima „od kojih“, ali of nije from. Tako dvije misli spajate u jednu glatku rečenicu; često je u pisanom jeziku.

About fifty people applied, most of whom had no experience.
Prijavilo se pedesetak ljudi, od kojih većina nije imala iskustva.
„od kojih“ → of whom
I bought three plants, none of which survived the winter.
Kupila sam tri biljke, od kojih nijedna nije preživjela zimu.
stvari → of which
She has two sons, both of whom are doctors.
Ima dva sina, oba su liječnici.
hrvatski može samo sa zarezom, engleski treba of whom
The report makes several suggestions, some of which are quite expensive.
Izvješće donosi nekoliko prijedloga, od kojih su neki prilično skupi.
We visited four cities, the last of which was Kraków.
Posjetili smo četiri grada, a posljednji je bio Krakov.

5Whose, where i when u rečenicama koje ne određuju

Whose izriče posvojnost („čiji“), where dodaje informaciju o mjestu („gdje“), when o vremenu („kad“).

Maya, whose sister I went to school with, has just got engaged.
Maya, s čijom sam sestrom išla u školu, upravo se zaručila.
„čiji“ → whose
The company, whose profits doubled last year, is hiring 200 people.
Tvrtka, čija se dobit prošle godine udvostručila, zapošljava 200 ljudi.
whose i za stvari
We had lunch in Brighton, where my cousin runs a café.
Ručali smo u Brightonu, gdje moj bratić ima kafić.
Come in August, when the weather is at its best.
Dođite u kolovozu, kad je vrijeme najljepše.
In 2010, when I first moved to the city, rents were much lower.
Godine 2010., kad sam se tek doselio u grad, najamnine su bile puno niže.

Česte pogreške

❌My father, that is a teacher, loves football.
✅My father, who is a teacher, loves football.
Nema that u rečenicama koje ne određuju.
❌The book, I borrowed from you, is brilliant.
✅The book, which I borrowed from you, is brilliant.
Odnosna riječ ne smije se izostaviti.
❌He was late again, what annoyed his boss.
✅He was late again, which annoyed his boss.
Komentar cijele rečenice = which.
❌I have two cousins, both of them live in Dubai.
✅I have two cousins, both of whom live in Dubai.
Dvije rečenice spojene zarezom trebaju of whom (ili: …cousins, and both of them live in Dubai).
❌The hotel, which we stayed in it, was lovely.
✅The hotel, which we stayed in, was lovely.
which zamjenjuje it: ne ponavljajte ga.
❌I spoke to Mr Lee, who his son is in my class.
✅I spoke to Mr Lee, whose son is in my class.
Posvojnost = whose.
❌My mother who is 60 has just retired.
✅My mother, who is 60, has just retired.
Pogreška u interpunkciji: bez zareza zvuči kao da imate više majki.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Moj šogor, koji je kuhar…“ → which za osobu. Hrvatsko „koji“ vrijedi i za ljude i za stvari, pa se which lako upotrijebi i za osobu. U engleskom osobe dobivaju who (ili formalno whom), a which je samo za stvari i životinje.

❌My brother-in-law, which works as a chef on a cruise ship, only comes home to Rijeka twice a year.
✅My brother-in-law, who works as a chef on a cruise ship, only comes home to Rijeka twice a year.
osoba → who

2. „…, što nas je iznenadilo“ → what. Hrvatski komentar cijele rečenice uvodi s „što“, a „što“ smo naučili kao what. U engleskom takav komentar uvijek počinje s which.

❌The last ferry from Hvar left twenty minutes early, what nobody at the harbour could explain to us.
✅The last ferry from Hvar left twenty minutes early, which nobody at the harbour could explain to us.
komentar cijele rečenice → which
❌Our landlord agreed to fix the broken heating before Christmas, what was a nice surprise for everyone in the building.
✅Our landlord agreed to fix the broken heating before Christmas, which was a nice surprise for everyone in the building.
„što“ → which

3. „…, od kojih su mnogi…“ → from whom / from which. Hrvatsko „od kojih“ doslovno se prevodi s from. Iza riječi za količinu engleski upotrebljava of: many of whom, some of which.

❌The summer school in Zadar had over forty participants, many from whom had never been to Croatia before.
✅The summer school in Zadar had over forty participants, many of whom had never been to Croatia before.
„od kojih“ → of whom
❌We tried six different olive oils on the farm in Istria, two from which were made from the farmer's own trees.
✅We tried six different olive oils on the farm in Istria, two of which were made from the farmer's own trees.
stvari → of which

4. „Preporučio je četiri restorana, tri su bila zatvorena…“ → zarez između dviju rečenica. Na hrvatskom je posve prirodno dvije rečenice spojiti samo zarezom: „Preporučio nam je četiri restorana, tri su bila zatvorena.“ U engleskom zarez ne može spojiti dvije samostalne rečenice. Upotrijebite three of which / all of whom ili veznik but / and.

❌The guide at the hotel in Šibenik recommended four seafood restaurants in the old town, three of them were closed for the winter.
✅The guide at the hotel in Šibenik recommended four seafood restaurants in the old town, three of which were closed for the winter. ili The guide at the hotel in Šibenik recommended four seafood restaurants in the old town, but three of them were closed for the winter.
three of which ili but three of them

Ne miješajte

rečenica koja određuje i rečenica koja ne određuje – pogledajte A2-29 i B1-20.

The phone that I bought last week has stopped working.
Mobitel koji sam kupio prošli tjedan prestao je raditi.
kaže koji mobitel; that je u redu
My phone, which I bought last week, has stopped working.
Moj mobitel, koji sam kupio prošli tjedan, prestao je raditi.
dodatna informacija; which, ne that

which (jedna imenica) i which (cijela rečenica)

She sent me a long email, which I haven't read yet.
Poslala mi je dug e-mail, koji još nisam pročitao.
which = e-mail („koji“)
She sent me a long email, which was unusual.
Poslala mi je dug e-mail, što je bilo neobično.
which = to što mi ga je poslala („što“)

which i what – which se odnosi na nešto što je bilo prije; what znači „ono što“ i ispred sebe nema ništa. Pogledajte B2-20.

He said nothing, which was strange.
Nije rekao ništa, što je bilo čudno.
„što“ iza zareza → which
What he said was strange.
Ono što je rekao bilo je čudno.
„ono što“ → what

Formalne strukture s prijedlogom ispred whom ili which (the colleague to whom I spoke) obrađuju se u C1-15. Više pravila o zarezima naći ćete u B2-27.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • U govoru rečenica koja ne određuje ima kratku stanku ispred i iza sebe i izgovara se malo niže i brže, kao opaska: My brother | who lives in Toronto | is an architect.
  • Rečenica koja određuje nema stanki: My brother who lives in Toronto is an architect izgovara se kao jedna cjelina.
  • Kad je rečenica u sredini, trebate dva zareza – jedan ispred i jedan iza nje.
  • whose (posvojnost) i who's (= who is / who has) zvuče isto: /huːz/. Who's that? / The man whose car… Početno h samo je lagan dah, a ne hrvatsko h s trenjem; /uː/ je dug, s jako zaobljenim usnama.
  • whom /huːm/ formalan je i u govoru rijedak.
  • /w/ u which, where, when nije hrvatsko v: zaoblite usne kao za u i odmah prijeđite na samoglasnik, a zubi ne dodiruju donju usnu.

Zlatno pravilo

Dodatna informacija? Stavite je između zareza i upotrijebite who / whom / which / whose / where / when – ne that – i nikad ne izostavite odnosnu riječ. I zapamtite: „koji“ za osobu je who, „što“ o cijeloj rečenici je which, a „od kojih“ je of whom / of which.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite rečenice odnosnom riječju koja nedostaje.

  1. My best friend, lives next door, is a nurse.
  2. The castle, was built in 1250, is now a hotel.
  3. Our teacher, husband is a famous chef, invited us to dinner.
  4. We went to Lisbon, we ate the best seafood of our lives.
  5. The company has 300 employees, most of work from home.
  6. I've read his three books, none of I enjoyed.
  7. Spojite rečenice tako da jedna postane dodatna informacija: Rome has nearly three million people. It is the capital of Italy.

B. Značenje

Odgovorite na pitanje ili odaberite točan odgovor.

  1. Tko se razbolio? "The guests, who ate the fish, got sick."
  2. Tko se razbolio? "The guests who ate the fish got sick."
  3. Na što se odnosi which u rečenici "He forgot my birthday, which hurt me"?
  4. Odaberite točan odgovor: I missed the bus, … meant I was late.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. My car, that is very old, broke down again.
  2. She has two daughters, both of them are lawyers.
  3. The restaurant, we went to last night, was excellent.
  4. Our flat, which has two bedrooms, is near the station.

D. U kontekstu

U svako mjesto u tekstu upišite odnosnu riječ (who, whom, which, whose, where, when) ili riječ za količinu.

A family email
Hi Ana! We're having a great time in Edinburgh, 16 it hasn't stopped raining since Monday! We're staying with Uncle Tom, 17 house is right in the old town. His two sons, 18 of 19 study music, play the piano every evening. Yesterday we visited the castle, 20 was built on top of an old volcano. Then Tom's car broke down, 21 meant we had to walk home in the rain!

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o svojoj obitelji i nedavnim događajima.

  1. Napišite rečenicu o nekom članu obitelji ili prijatelju i dodajte informaciju s who ili whose.
  2. Napišite rečenicu o nečemu što se nedavno dogodilo, a zatim to komentirajte s which.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. A2-29 Who, which, that i where: odnosne rečenice na engleskom
    A dentist is someone ___ looks after your teeth. …
  2. B1-20 Odnosne rečenice na engleskom: whose, where, when i izostavljanje zamjenice
    That's the woman son plays in my team.
  3. B2-07 Need, needn't have i be supposed to: obveza i potreba na engleskom
    We (needn't bring) our umbrellas — it was sunny all day.
  4. B2-06 Must have, can't have, might have: nagađanje o prošlosti na engleskom
    She (can't see) the message — her phone was off.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. who
  2. which
  3. whose
  4. where
  5. whom
  6. which
  7. Rome, which is the capital of Italy, has nearly three million people. / Rome, which has nearly three million people, is the capital of Italy.

B. Značenje

  1. all the guests
  2. only some of the guests
  3. the fact that he forgot
  4. which

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. My car, which is very old, broke down again.
  2. She has two daughters, both of whom are lawyers. / She has two daughters, and both of them are lawyers.
  3. The restaurant, which we went to last night, was excellent. / The restaurant we went to last night was excellent.
  4. ✓ Our flat, which has two bedrooms, is near the station.

D. U kontekstu

  1. where
  2. whose
  3. both
  4. whom
  5. which
  6. which

E. Vaš red

  1. My cousin Lara, who works in a hospital, is coming to visit next week.
  2. My phone fell in the sink, which meant I had to buy a new one.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. who
  2. whose
  3. needn't have brought / didn't need to bring
  4. can't have seen / couldn't have seen
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play