Slowingoव्याकरण
B2 8 / 30

Non-Defining Relative Clauses: अल्पविरामसहितको थप जानकारी — सजिलो नेपालीमा

Non-Defining Relative Clauses

यस पृष्ठमा
  1. लक्ष्य
  2. मुख्य विचार
  3. नेपाली र अङ्ग्रेजी
  4. संरचना
  5. प्रयोग
  6. सामान्य गल्तीहरू
  7. नेपाली भाषीहरूका लागि पासोहरू
  8. नझुक्किनुहोस्
  9. हिज्जे र उच्चारण
  10. सुनौलो नियम
  11. अभ्यास

लक्ष्य

यो पाठपछि तपाईं अल्पविराम (comma) प्रयोग गरेर कुनै व्यक्ति, वस्तु, ठाउँ वा समयबारे थप जानकारी जोड्न सक्नुहुनेछ: My sister, who lives in Oslo, is a pilot। अल्पविरामले अर्थ कसरी बदल्छ भन्ने बुझ्न, पूरा उपवाक्यबारे टिप्पणी गर्न which प्रयोग गर्न, र some of whom / most of which प्रयोग गर्न पनि सक्नुहुनेछ।

मुख्य विचार

सम्बन्धवाचक उपवाक्य (relative clause) ले दुई एकदमै फरक काम गर्न सक्छ।

Defining उपवाक्य (A2-29, B1-20) ले कुन भन्ने बताउँछ। यो नभए सुन्ने व्यक्तिलाई तपाईं कसको वा केको कुरा गर्दै हुनुहुन्छ भन्ने थाहा हुँदैन: The woman who called you is my boss. कुन महिला? तपाईंलाई फोन गर्ने।

Non-defining उपवाक्यले पहिल्यै स्पष्ट भइसकेको कुराबारे थप जानकारी दिन्छ। मञ्चमा एक जना कलाकार कल्पना गर्नुहोस्, जो एकछिन दर्शकतिर फर्केर छोटो टिप्पणी गर्छ, अनि फेरि दृश्यमा फर्कन्छ। नाटकलाई त्यो टिप्पणी चाहिँदैन, तर यसले केही थप्छ: My boss, who is from Ireland, called today. मेरो हाकिम एक जना मात्र हुनुहुन्छ; उपवाक्यले उहाँबारे थप कुरा मात्र भन्छ। यसलाई हटाउनुहोस्, वाक्यको अर्थ अझै पूरा हुन्छ।

अल्पविरामले यो टिप्पणीलाई छुट्याउँछ। बोलीमा यी छोटो विराम बन्छन्, र आवाज अलिकति तल झर्छ। उपवाक्य छुट्टै टिप्पणी भएकाले यसका नियम अझ कडा छन्: that आउँदैन, र relative शब्द कहिल्यै छोड्न मिल्दैन।

नेपाली र अङ्ग्रेजी

नेपालीमा थप जानकारी प्रायः नामभन्दा अगाडि कृदन्तले दिइन्छ: “टोरन्टोमा बस्ने मेरो दाइ आर्किटेक्ट हुनुहुन्छ”। तर यो वाक्यले दाइ एक जना मात्र हुनुहुन्छ कि धेरैमध्ये एक, भन्ने छुट्याउँदैन। अङ्ग्रेजीमा यो फरक अल्पविरामले देखाउँछ। लेख्य नेपालीमा अङ्ग्रेजीजस्तै ढाँचा पनि आउँछ: “मेरो दाइ, जो टोरन्टोमा बस्नुहुन्छ, आर्किटेक्ट हुनुहुन्छ”; यो non-defining उपवाक्यसँग राम्ररी मिल्छ। पूरा कुराबारे टिप्पणी नेपालीमा जसले गर्दा वा जुन कुरा ले गरिन्छ: “ऊ फेरि फेल भयो, जुन कुराले सबैलाई अचम्मित बनायो”; अङ्ग्रेजीमा यो काम एउटै which ले गर्छ। “जसमध्ये धेरैजसो” ठ्याक्कै most of whom / most of which हो, र “जसको” whose हो।

नेपालीअर्थअङ्ग्रेजी
टोरन्टोमा बस्ने मेरो दाइ आर्किटेक्ट हुनुहुन्छ।एक कि धेरै दाइ? नेपालीले छुट्याउँदैनMy brother who lives in Toronto… / My brother, who lives in Toronto, …
मेरी हजुरआमा, जो ९२ वर्षकी हुनुहुन्छ, अझै हरेक बिहान पौडी खेल्नुहुन्छ।थप जानकारीMy grandmother, who is 92, still swims every morning.
ऊ फेरि फेल भयो, जुन कुराले सबैलाई अचम्मित बनायो।पूरा कुराबारे टिप्पणीHe failed again, which surprised everyone.
करिब पचास जनाले आवेदन दिए, जसमध्ये धेरैजसोसँग अनुभव थिएन।सङ्ख्या + मध्येAbout fifty people applied, most of whom had no experience.
Maya, जसकी बहिनीसँग म स्कुलमा सँगै पढेँ, …स्वामित्वMaya, whose sister I went to school with, …

संरचना

Non-defining उपवाक्यका relative शब्द

शब्दकेलाई जनाउँछउदाहरण
whoमानिस (कर्ता वा कर्म)My uncle, who is a chef, cooked dinner.
whomमानिस (कर्म; औपचारिक)The director, whom I met last year, has retired.
whichवस्तु, जनावर, पूरा उपवाक्यThe museum, which opened in 2019, is free.
whoseस्वामित्व (मानिस र वस्तु)Our neighbour, whose dog barks all night, is moving.
whereठाउँWe stayed in Porto, where my parents met.
whenसमयI'll call you on Friday, when I'm less busy.

नियम

नियम✅❌
उपवाक्यको दुवैतिर अल्पविराम (वाक्यको अन्त्यमा भए एउटा मात्र)My car, which is ten years old, still runs well.My car which is ten years old still runs well.
that प्रयोग हुँदैनParis, which I love, is expensive.Paris, that I love, is expensive.
Relative शब्द छोड्न मिल्दैनThe film, which I saw yesterday, was great.The film, I saw yesterday, was great.

सङ्ख्या / परिमाणवाचक शब्द + of whom / of which

परिमाणवाचक शब्दमानिसवस्तु
some / many / most / all / none / both / neither / one / two…+ of whom+ of which
उदाहरणI have three brothers, all of whom live abroad.She wrote five novels, two of which became films.

टिप्पणी उपवाक्य

मुख्य उपवाक्य, which … (पूरा उपवाक्यबारे)
The train was cancelled,which meant we had to take a taxi.

प्रयोग

1Defining र non-defining: अल्पविरामले अर्थ बदल्छ

अल्पविराम नभए उपवाक्यले कुन भन्ने छुट्याउँछ। अल्पविराम भए उपवाक्यले पहिल्यै चिनिएको कुराबारे जानकारी थप्छ। अर्थ फरक हुन सक्छ।

My brother who lives in Toronto is an architect.
टोरन्टोमा बस्ने मेरो दाइ आर्किटेक्ट हुनुहुन्छ।
मेरा एकभन्दा बढी दाइ छन्; यो कुन दाइ भन्ने बताउँछ
My brother, who lives in Toronto, is an architect.
मेरो दाइ, जो टोरन्टोमा बस्नुहुन्छ, आर्किटेक्ट हुनुहुन्छ।
मेरो दाइ एक जना मात्र हुनुहुन्छ; नेपालीको “-ने” ले यो फरक देखाउँदैन
The students who passed the exam got a certificate.
परीक्षा पास गर्ने विद्यार्थीहरूले प्रमाणपत्र पाए।
केही मात्र पास भए
The students, who passed the exam, got a certificate.
विद्यार्थीहरूले, जो सबै परीक्षामा पास भए, प्रमाणपत्र पाए।
सबै पास भए
Mount Everest, which is on the border of Nepal and China, attracts thousands of climbers.
सगरमाथा, जुन नेपाल र चीनको सिमानामा छ, हजारौँ आरोहीलाई आकर्षित गर्छ।
एउटै मात्र भएको कुरा: उपवाक्य सधैँ non-defining

2थप जानकारी: who, which, whom

मानिसका लागि who र वस्तुका लागि which प्रयोग गर्नुहोस्। औपचारिक लेखाइमा व्यक्ति कर्म हुँदा whom प्रयोग हुन्छ; कुराकानीमा धेरैजसो मानिस who नै भन्छन्। उपवाक्य वाक्यको बीचमा वा अन्त्यमा आउन सक्छ।

Our new manager, who started on Monday, seems very friendly.
हाम्रा नयाँ म्यानेजर, जसले सोमबारदेखि काम सुरु गर्नुभयो, निकै मिलनसार देखिनुहुन्छ।
I've just finished the novel you lent me, which took me six months.
तिमीले सापटी दिएको उपन्यास भर्खरै सकेँ, जुन पढ्न मलाई छ महिना लाग्यो।
पहिलो उपवाक्य defining (you lent me), दोस्रो non-defining
Dr Patel, whom many patients ask for by name, works only on Tuesdays.
डा. Patel, जसलाई धेरै बिरामी नाम लिएरै खोज्छन्, मङ्गलबार मात्र काम गर्नुहुन्छ।
औपचारिक: whom
We're flying with SkyLink, which I've never used before.
हामी SkyLink बाट उड्दै छौँ, जुन एयरलाइन्स मैले पहिले कहिल्यै प्रयोग गरेको छैन।
My grandmother, who is 92, still swims every morning.
मेरी हजुरआमा, जो ९२ वर्षकी हुनुहुन्छ, अझै हरेक बिहान पौडी खेल्नुहुन्छ।

3पूरा उपवाक्यलाई जनाउने which

Which ले एउटा नाम मात्र होइन, अघिल्लो पूरा उपवाक्यको विचारबारे टिप्पणी गर्न सक्छ। यस्तो उपवाक्य आफूले टिप्पणी गर्ने उपवाक्यपछि, अल्पविरामसँगै आउँछ। यहाँ what आउन सक्दैन।

He failed his driving test again, which surprised everyone.
ऊ फेरि ड्राइभिङ टेस्टमा फेल भयो, जुन कुराले सबैलाई अचम्मित बनायो।
which = ऊ फेरि फेल भयो भन्ने कुरा
The flight was delayed by six hours, which meant we missed our connection.
उडान छ घण्टा ढिलो भयो, जसले गर्दा हाम्रो अर्को उडान छुट्यो।
“जसले गर्दा” → which meant
She offered to drive me home, which was really kind of her.
उनले मलाई गाडीमा घरसम्म पुर्याइदिन्छु भनिन्, जुन उनको साँच्चै ठूलो उदारता थियो।
Prices have gone up again, which is why we're eating out less.
फेरि भाउ बढ्यो, त्यसैले हामी आजकल बाहिर कम खान्छौँ।
which is why = त्यसैले

4परिमाणवाचक शब्द + of whom / of which

सङ्ख्या वा परिमाणवाचक शब्दपछि मानिसका लागि of whom र वस्तुका लागि of which प्रयोग गर्नुहोस्। यसले दुई विचारलाई एउटै सहज वाक्यमा जोड्छ, र लेखाइमा धेरै प्रयोग हुन्छ।

About fifty people applied, most of whom had no experience.
करिब पचास जनाले आवेदन दिए, जसमध्ये धेरैजसोसँग अनुभव थिएन।
“जसमध्ये धेरैजसो” → most of whom
I bought three plants, none of which survived the winter.
मैले तीनवटा बिरुवा किनेँ, जसमध्ये एउटा पनि जाडो पार गर्न सकेन।
none of which: अङ्ग्रेजीमा नकारात्मक शब्द एउटा मात्र
She has two sons, both of whom are doctors.
उनका दुई छोरा छन्, दुवै डाक्टर हुन्।
The report makes several suggestions, some of which are quite expensive.
प्रतिवेदनले केही सुझाव दिएको छ, जसमध्ये केही निकै खर्चिला छन्।
We visited four cities, the last of which was Kraków.
हामी चारवटा सहर घुम्यौँ, जसमध्ये अन्तिम Kraków थियो।

5Non-defining उपवाक्यमा whose, where र when

Whose ले स्वामित्व, where ले ठाउँबारे र when ले समयबारे थप जानकारी दिन्छ।

Maya, whose sister I went to school with, has just got engaged.
Maya, जसकी बहिनीसँग म स्कुलमा सँगै पढेँ, भर्खरै इन्गेज भइन्।
“जसकी” → whose
The company, whose profits doubled last year, is hiring 200 people.
त्यो कम्पनी, जसको नाफा गत वर्ष दोब्बर भयो, २०० जना कर्मचारी भर्ना गर्दै छ।
वस्तुका लागि पनि whose
We had lunch in Brighton, where my cousin runs a café.
हामीले Brighton मा खाना खायौँ, जहाँ मेरो काकाको छोरा एउटा क्याफे चलाउँछ।
Come in August, when the weather is at its best.
अगस्टमा आउनुहोस्, जुन बेला मौसम सबैभन्दा राम्रो हुन्छ।
In 2010, when I first moved to the city, rents were much lower.
२०१० मा, जुन बेला म पहिलो पटक सहर सरेँ, घरभाडा निकै कम थियो।

सामान्य गल्तीहरू

❌My father, that is a teacher, loves football.
✅My father, who is a teacher, loves football.
non-defining उपवाक्यमा that आउँदैन।
❌The book, I borrowed from you, is brilliant.
✅The book, which I borrowed from you, is brilliant.
relative शब्द छोड्न मिल्दैन।
❌He was late again, what annoyed his boss.
✅He was late again, which annoyed his boss.
पूरा उपवाक्यबारे टिप्पणी = which।
❌I have two cousins, both of them live in Dubai.
✅I have two cousins, both of whom live in Dubai.
अल्पविरामले जोडिएका दुई उपवाक्यमा of whom चाहिन्छ (वा: …cousins, and both of them live in Dubai)।
❌The hotel, which we stayed in it, was lovely.
✅The hotel, which we stayed in, was lovely.
which ले it को ठाउँ लिन्छ: it नदोहोर्याउनुहोस्।
❌I spoke to Mr Lee, who his son is in my class.
✅I spoke to Mr Lee, whose son is in my class.
स्वामित्व = whose।
❌My mother who is 60 has just retired.
✅My mother, who is 60, has just retired.
चिह्नको गल्ती: अल्पविराम नभए तपाईंका एकभन्दा बढी आमा हुनुहुन्छ जस्तो देखिन्छ।

नेपाली भाषीहरूका लागि पासोहरू

1. “-ने” कृदन्त → अल्पविराम छुट्नु। नेपालीको “फेवा तालका लागि प्रसिद्ध पोखरा” वा “कतारमा काम गर्ने मेरो बुबा” मा defining र non-defining को फरक देखिँदैन, त्यसैले अङ्ग्रेजीमा अल्पविराम नै छुट्छ। सहर, देश, आफ्नो बुबा वा आमा जस्ता एउटै मात्र भएका कुराबारेको थप जानकारी सधैँ अल्पविरामभित्र राख्नुहोस्।

❌Pokhara which is famous for Phewa Lake gets thousands of tourists every year.
✅Pokhara, which is famous for Phewa Lake, gets thousands of tourists every year.
पोखरा एउटै छ: non-defining
❌My father who works in Qatar sends us money every month.
✅My father, who works in Qatar, sends us money every month.
अल्पविराम नभए तपाईंका एकभन्दा बढी बुबा भएजस्तो देखिन्छ

2. “-हरूमध्ये धेरैजसो …” → , most of them…। नेपालीमा “हाम्रो कक्षामा चालीस जना विद्यार्थी छन्, धेरैजसो चितवनका छन्” भन्न सकिन्छ, किनभने नेपाली वाक्य अल्पविरामले सजिलै जोडिन्छन्। अङ्ग्रेजीमा अल्पविरामले मात्र दुई पूरा उपवाक्य जोड्न मिल्दैन: of whom / of which प्रयोग गर्नुहोस्, वा and थप्नुहोस्।

❌Our class has forty students, most of them come from Chitwan.
✅Our class has forty students, most of whom come from Chitwan. वा Our class has forty students, and most of them come from Chitwan.
❌Suman sent me ten photos of the trek, three of them were blurry.
✅Suman sent me ten photos of the trek, three of which were blurry.

3. “जसले गर्दा” → due to which। नेपालीको “जसले गर्दा” लाई शब्दशः अनुवाद गर्दा due to which वा because of which बन्छ। यी गलत होइनन्, तर दैनिक अङ्ग्रेजीमा भारी र कृत्रिम सुनिन्छन्। स्वाभाविक रूप which meant (that)… वा which is why… हो।

⚠️There was a landslide on the highway, due to which our bus arrived in Kathmandu at midnight.
✅There was a landslide on the highway, which meant our bus arrived in Kathmandu at midnight.
व्याकरणका हिसाबले ठीक छ, तर due to which अति औपचारिक र भारी सुनिन्छ; which meant स्वाभाविक हुन्छ।

नझुक्किनुहोस्

defining र non-defining — A2-29 र B1-20 हेर्नुहोस्।

The phone that I bought last week has stopped working.
मैले गत हप्ता किनेको फोन चल्न छाड्यो।
कुन फोन भन्ने छुट्याउँछ; that ठीक छ
My phone, which I bought last week, has stopped working.
मेरो फोन, जुन मैले गत हप्ता किनेँ, चल्न छाड्यो।
थप जानकारी; that होइन, which

which (एउटा नाम) र which (पूरा उपवाक्य)

She sent me a long email, which I haven't read yet.
उनले मलाई लामो इमेल पठाइन्, जुन मैले अझै पढेको छैन।
which = इमेल
She sent me a long email, which was unusual.
उनले मलाई लामो इमेल पठाइन्, जुन असामान्य कुरा थियो।
which = उनले पठाएको कुरा

which र what — which ले आफूभन्दा अघिको कुरालाई जनाउँछ; what को अर्थ “जुन कुरा” हो, र यसको अघि केही हुँदैन। B2-20 हेर्नुहोस्।

He said nothing, which was strange.
उसले केही भनेन, जुन अनौठो थियो।
What he said was strange.
उसले भनेको कुरा अनौठो थियो।

whom वा which अघि preposition आउने औपचारिक संरचना (the colleague to whom I spoke) C1-15 मा सिकाइन्छ। अल्पविरामका अरू नियम B2-27 मा छन्।

हिज्जे र उच्चारण

  • बोलीमा non-defining उपवाक्यको अघि र पछि छोटो विराम हुन्छ, र यो अलि तल्लो स्वरमा र अलि छिटो भनिन्छ, छेउको टिप्पणीजस्तै: My brother | who lives in Toronto | is an architect.
  • Defining उपवाक्यमा विराम हुँदैन: My brother who lives in Toronto is an architect एउटै टुक्राका रूपमा भनिन्छ।
  • उपवाक्य वाक्यको बीचमा छ भने दुईवटा अल्पविराम चाहिन्छ: एउटा अघि, एउटा पछि।
  • whose (स्वामित्व) र who's (= who is / who has) उस्तै सुनिन्छन्: /huːz/, "hooz"। Who's that? / The man whose car… अन्त्यको /z/ मा आवाज आउँछ; यसलाई “ज” वा /s/ नबनाउनुहोस्।
  • whom /huːm/, "hoom", औपचारिक हो र बोलीमा कमै सुनिन्छ। who, whom, whose मा w उच्चारण हुँदैन: सुरुमा /h/ मात्र।

सुनौलो नियम

थप जानकारी? त्यसलाई अल्पविरामभित्र राख्नुहोस् र who / whom / which / whose / where / when प्रयोग गर्नुहोस्, that होइन; अनि relative शब्द कहिल्यै नछोड्नुहोस्। सहर, देश वा आफ्नो एउटै मात्र भएको कुराबारेको जानकारी सधैँ अल्पविरामभित्र जान्छ।

अभ्यास

A. संरचना

हरेक ठाउँमा सही शब्द लेख्नुहोस्।

  1. My best friend, lives next door, is a nurse.
  2. The castle, was built in 1250, is now a hotel.
  3. Our teacher, husband is a famous chef, invited us to dinner.
  4. We went to Lisbon, we ate the best seafood of our lives.
  5. The company has 300 employees, most of work from home.
  6. I've read his three books, none of I enjoyed.
  7. वाक्यहरूलाई थप जानकारीका रूपमा जोड्नुहोस्: Rome has nearly three million people. It is the capital of Italy.

B. अर्थ

अर्थ हेरेर प्रश्नको उत्तर दिनुहोस् वा सही उत्तर छान्नुहोस्।

  1. को बिरामी परे? "The guests, who ate the fish, got sick."
  2. को बिरामी परे? "The guests who ate the fish got sick."
  3. "He forgot my birthday, which hurt me" मा which ले केलाई जनाउँछ?
  4. सही उत्तर छान्नुहोस्: I missed the bus, … meant I was late.

C. गल्ती पत्ता लगाउनुहोस्

हरेक वाक्यमा एउटा गल्ती छ वा वाक्य सही छ। सच्याइएको वाक्य लेख्नुहोस् वा correct लेख्नुहोस्।

  1. My car, that is very old, broke down again.
  2. She has two daughters, both of them are lawyers.
  3. The restaurant, we went to last night, was excellent.
  4. Our flat, which has two bedrooms, is near the station.

D. पाठभित्र

हरेक ठाउँमा relative शब्द (who, whom, which, whose, where, when) वा परिमाणवाचक शब्द चाहिन्छ।

A family email
Hi Ana! We're having a great time in Edinburgh, 16 it hasn't stopped raining since Monday! We're staying with Uncle Tom, 17 house is right in the old town. His two sons, 18 of 19 study music, play the piano every evening. Yesterday we visited the castle, 20 was built on top of an old volcano. Then Tom's car broke down, 21 meant we had to walk home in the rain!

E. तपाईंको पालो

अङ्ग्रेजीमा लेख्नुहोस्।

  1. परिवारको कुनै सदस्य वा साथीबारे एउटा वाक्य लेख्नुहोस्, र who वा whose बाट थप जानकारी जोड्नुहोस्।
  2. हालसालै भएको कुनै घटनाबारे एउटा वाक्य लेख्नुहोस्, अनि which बाट त्यसबारे टिप्पणी गर्नुहोस्।

F. मिश्रित दोहोर्याइ

अघिल्ला पाठहरू दोहोर्याउनुहोस्।

  1. A2-29 Relative Clauses: Who, Which, That र Where — सजिलो नेपालीमा
    A dentist is someone ___ looks after your teeth. …
  2. B1-20 Relative Clauses (सम्बन्धवाचक उपवाक्य): Whose, Where, When र Pronoun छोड्ने तरिका — सजिलो नेपालीमा
    That's the woman son plays in my team.
  3. B2-07 Need, Needn't Have र Be Supposed To: बाध्यता र आवश्यकता गहिराइमा — सजिलो नेपालीमा
    We (needn't bring) our umbrellas — it was sunny all day.
  4. B2-06 Must Have, Can't Have, Might Have: विगतबारे अनुमान — सजिलो नेपालीमा
    She (can't see) the message — her phone was off.
उत्तरहरू

A. संरचना

  1. who
  2. which
  3. whose
  4. where
  5. whom
  6. which
  7. Rome, which is the capital of Italy, has nearly three million people. / Rome, which has nearly three million people, is the capital of Italy.

B. अर्थ

  1. all the guests
  2. only some of the guests
  3. the fact that he forgot
  4. which

C. गल्ती पत्ता लगाउनुहोस्

  1. My car, which is very old, broke down again.
  2. She has two daughters, both of whom are lawyers. / She has two daughters, and both of them are lawyers.
  3. The restaurant, which we went to last night, was excellent. / The restaurant we went to last night was excellent.
  4. ✓ Our flat, which has two bedrooms, is near the station.

D. पाठभित्र

  1. where
  2. whose
  3. both
  4. whom
  5. which
  6. which

E. तपाईंको पालो

  1. My cousin Lara, who works in a hospital, is coming to visit next week.
  2. My phone fell in the sink, which meant I had to buy a new one.

F. मिश्रित दोहोर्याइ

  1. who
  2. whose
  3. needn't have brought / didn't need to bring
  4. can't have seen / couldn't have seen
एन्ड्रोइड एपजाँदाजाँदै सिक्नुहोस् Google Play