SlowingoGramatika
C1 16 / 20

Advanced relative clauses: to whom, whereby, in which case, whatever – napredne odnosne rečenice

Advanced Relative Clauses

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete upotrebljavati formalne odnosne strukture – to whom, the extent to which, whereby, in which case, by which time, at which point – i odnosne rečenice u službi imenice kao what, whatever i whoever te spajati odnosne rečenice s infinitivom i s riječima koje izriču količinu.

Osnovna ideja

Odnosna rečenica je kuka: na imenicu vješa dodatnu informaciju. U svakodnevnom engleskom prijedlog visi na kraju kuke: the person I spoke to. U formalnom engleskom prijedlog se seli naprijed i drži se odnosne zamjenice: the person to whom I spoke. Značenje je isto; mijenja se samo stil.

Neke se formalne odnosne riječi kače na cijelu misao, a ne samo na jednu imenicu: The train may be cancelled, in which case we'll drive. Ovdje which upućuje na cijelu situaciju – na to da vlak bude otkazan.

Druge odnosne riječi nose imenicu u sebi. What znači the thing that; whoever znači any person who. S takvim odnosnim rečenicama u službi imenice cijela surečenica radi kao imenica: What she said surprised me.

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski uvijek stavlja prijedlog ispred odnosne zamjenice: „osoba kojoj sam pisao“, „kolege s kojima je radila“. Formalni engleski red riječi (the colleagues with whom she had worked) zato vam neće biti težak. Teže je drugo: u svakodnevnom engleskom prijedlog ide na kraj, a zamjenica često otpada (the colleagues she had worked with).

Glavni je problem hrvatska riječ „što“. Ona radi tri posla: „Sve što je rekao“ (everything that he said ili samo everything he said), „Ono što me iznenadilo“ (What surprised me) i „Zakasnio je, što me naljutilo“ (He was late, which made me angry). Engleski za ta tri posla ima tri rješenja, a what je točan samo u drugom. Isto tako hrvatsko „od kojih“ vrijedi i za ljude i za stvari, a engleski razlikuje of whom (ljudi) i of which (stvari).

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Osoba kojoj je pismo upućeno više ne radi ovdje.The person to whom this letter is addressed no longer works here.ovdje je isto: prijedlog naprijed (formalno)
Sve što je rekao bilo je točno.Everything (that) he said was true.iza everything nikad what
Ono što me najviše iznenadilo…What surprised me most…„ono što“ = what
Ispričala je vic, što je sve nasmijalo.She told a joke, which made everyone laugh.„, što“ o cijeloj misli = which
Let bi mogao kasniti, u kojem slučaju……, in which case we'll miss the connection.ovdje je isto
Ima tri brata, od kojih svi žive u inozemstvu.…three brothers, all of whom live abroad.ljudi: of whom; stvari: of which
Nema s kim podijeliti svoje brige.She had nobody with whom to share her worries. / …nobody to share them with.ispred infinitiva nikad who
Tko god je osmislio ovu aplikaciju, zaslužuje nagradu.Whoever designed this app deserves an award.„tko god“ = whoever (jedna riječ)

Ukratko: prijedlog ispred whom / which poznat vam je iz hrvatskog; pazite na „što“: „sve što“ = everything (that), „ono što“ = what, „, što“ = which; „od kojih“ = of whom (ljudi) ili of which (stvari).

Oblik

Prijedlog + whom / which

Neformalno (prijedlog na kraju)Formalno (prijedlog naprijed)
the person (who) I spoke tothe person to whom I spoke
the company (that) she works forthe company for which she works
the colleagues (who) he relies onthe colleagues on whom he relies
the way (that) the system worksthe way in which the system works

Iza prijedloga dolazi whom (ljudi) ili which (stvari), ili whose + imenica (the writer to whose work I referred). That tu nikad nije moguć, a who iza prijedloga u pažljivom engleskom izbjegavamo.

Odnosne riječi koje se kače na način, vrijeme ili cijelu situaciju

Odnosna riječZnačenjeNa što se odnosi
wherebykojim, putem kojegasustav, metodu ili dogovor
in which casea ako se to dogodi („u kojem slučaju“)cijelu prethodnu surečenicu
by which timea do tadavrijeme ili događaj
at which pointi u tom trenutkutrenutak ili događaj

Odnosne rečenice u službi imenice (imenica je u njima)

Odnosna riječZnačenjePrimjer
whatono štoWhat I need is sleep.
whateverbilo što, sve štoTake whatever you want.
whoevertko god, onaj tkoWhoever finishes first wins.
whicheverkoji god (od ograničenog broja)Choose whichever room you like.
wherever / whenevergdje god / kad godSit wherever you like.

Infinitiv i riječi za količinu (ponavljanje)

ObrazacPrimjer
imenica + to-infinitivthe person to contact
imenica + prijedlog + which / whom + to-infinitiv (formalno)a place in which to live
riječ za količinu + of + whom / whichall of which, neither of whom

Uporaba

1Prijedlog + whom / which

U formalnom pisanju prijedlog stavite ispred whom ili which. Neki izrazi gotovo uvijek imaju taj oblik: the extent to which, the speed at which, the way in which, the basis on which. Fraznim glagolima to ne možemo učiniti: njihova čestica ostaje uz glagol (the problem I came across). Oba su reda riječi točna; birajte prema stilu (C2-02).

The person to whom this letter is addressed no longer works here.
Osoba kojoj je ovo pismo upućeno više ne radi ovdje.
This is the research on which the whole theory is based.
Ovo je istraživanje na kojem se temelji cijela teorija.
She thanked the colleagues with whom she had worked for twenty years.
Zahvalila je kolegama s kojima je radila dvadeset godina.
prijedlog naprijed, kao u hrvatskom
The study measures the extent to which sleep affects memory.
Istraživanje mjeri u kojoj mjeri san utječe na pamćenje.
stalni izraz: the extent to which
The speed at which technology changes can be overwhelming.
Brzina kojom se tehnologija mijenja zna biti zastrašujuća.

2Whereby

Whereby znači by which ili through which – „kojim“, „putem kojega“. Uvodi način rada sustava, programa, dogovora ili postupka. Formalan je i čest u poslovnom i akademskom pisanju.

The company has introduced a scheme whereby staff can buy shares at a discount.
Tvrtka je uvela program kojim zaposlenici mogu kupiti dionice po povlaštenoj cijeni.
The two sides reached an agreement whereby each would pay half the costs.
Dvije su strane postigle dogovor prema kojem će svaka platiti polovicu troškova.
Photosynthesis is the process whereby plants turn light into energy.
Fotosinteza je proces kojim biljke svjetlost pretvaraju u energiju.
način ili postupak

3In which case, by which time, at which point

Ovi izrazi upućuju na cijelu situaciju i dodaju ono što iz nje slijedi. Dolaze iza zareza. In which case = ako se to dogodi; by which time = a do tog trenutka (često s Past Perfect (pluskvamperfekt)); at which point = i baš u tom trenutku.

The flight might be delayed, in which case we'll miss the connection.
Let bi mogao kasniti, u kojem ćemo slučaju propustiti presjedanje.
ovdje je isto: „u kojem slučaju“
You may find an error on the form, in which case please contact us immediately.
Ako na obrascu pronađete pogrešku, odmah nam se javite.
We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed.
Stigli smo tek u ponoć, a do tada je restoran već bio zatvoren.
by which time + Past Perfect
The talks went on until 3 a.m., by which time everyone was exhausted.
Pregovori su trajali do tri ujutro, kad su već svi bili iscrpljeni.
He started shouting, at which point security asked him to leave.
Počeo je vikati, na što ga je zaštitar zamolio da ode.
baš u tom trenutku

4Odnosne rečenice u službi imenice: what i riječi na -ever

Takva odnosna rečenica sadrži vlastitu imenicu, pa cijela surečenica može biti subjekt ili objekt. What = the thing(s) that, naše „ono što“ (B2-20). Oblici na -ever dodaju „bilo koji, svejedno koji“ – kao naše „god“: „što god“, „tko god“. Whichever služi za ograničen izbor. Na početku rečenice whatever, whoever i wherever mogu značiti i no matter what / who / where (B2-23).

What surprised me most was how calm she stayed.
Ono što me najviše iznenadilo bilo je koliko je ostala mirna.
what = „ono što“
I'll do what I can to help.
Učinit ću sve što mogu da pomognem.
You can order whatever you like; it's my treat.
Naruči što god želiš; ja častim.
Whoever designed this app deserves an award.
Tko god je osmislio ovu aplikaciju, zaslužuje nagradu.
Take whichever seat you prefer.
Sjednite na koje god mjesto želite.
od slobodnih mjesta
Our dog follows me wherever I go.
Pas me prati kamo god krenem.
Whatever happens, don't panic.
Što god se dogodilo, nemojte paničariti.
= no matter what happens

5Odnosne rečenice s infinitivom (ponavljanje)

Odnosna rečenica može se skratiti na to-infinitiv, osobito iza imenica koje izriču svrhu te iza first, last, only i superlativa (B2-09). U formalnom stilu ispred infinitiva može stajati prijedlog + which / whom. Who i that nikad ne dolaze ispred infinitiva – ni kad hrvatski kaže „nemam s kim“ ili „nemam kome“.

If you have questions, the person to contact is Ms Patel.
Ako imate pitanja, obratite se gospođi Patel.
the person to contact
They're looking for a quiet place in which to live.
Traže mirno mjesto za život.
formalno = a quiet place to live in
She felt she had nobody with whom to share her worries.
Osjećala je da nema s kim podijeliti svoje brige.
formalno = nobody to share them with
He was the last person to leave the building.
Posljednji je izašao iz zgrade.

6Riječ za količinu + of whom / of which (ponavljanje)

Riječ za količinu (all, some, most, many, neither, none, both, half) ili broj + of whom (ljudi) ili of which (stvari) upotrijebite kad govorite o dijelu skupine. Hrvatsko „od kojih“ vrijedi za oboje, a engleski razlikuje. Te su rečenice neodređujuće, pa dolaze iza zareza (B2-08).

She has three brothers, all of whom live abroad.
Ima tri brata i svi žive u inozemstvu.
ljudi: of whom
We received over 200 applications, most of which were excellent.
Primili smo više od 200 prijava, od kojih je većina bila izvrsna.
stvari: of which
I asked two mechanics, neither of whom could find the problem.
Pitao sam dvojicu mehaničara, a nijedan nije mogao pronaći kvar.
The museum owns thousands of paintings, many of which have never been shown.
Muzej posjeduje tisuće slika, od kojih mnoge nikad nisu bile izložene.

Česte pogreške

⚠️The man to who I spoke was very helpful.
✅The man to whom I spoke was very helpful. ili The man (who) I spoke to was very helpful.
who iza prijedloga ponekad se čuje u govoru, ali miješa stilove: formalni obrazac traži whom.
❌The flat in that we live is rented.
✅The flat in which we live is rented. ili The flat (that) we live in is rented.
that ne može stajati iza prijedloga.
❌This is the problem about which I came across.
✅This is the problem (that) I came across.
Frazni glagol zadržava svoju česticu.
❌I have two sisters, both of them are doctors.
✅I have two sisters, both of whom are doctors. ili …sisters, and both of them are doctors.
Za spajanje surečenica upotrijebite of whom.
❌Everything what he said was true.
✅Everything (that) he said was true.
Iza everything / all / something dolazi that ili ništa, a ne what.
❌The bus may be late, which case we'll walk.
✅The bus may be late, in which case we'll walk.
Stalni izraz glasi in which case.
❌She needs a friend who to talk to.
✅She needs a friend to talk to. ili …a friend with whom to talk.
Nikad who ispred infinitiva.
❌Whatever you will decide, I'll support you.
✅Whatever you decide, I'll support you.
Iza whatever / whenever / wherever za budućnost dolazi sadašnje vrijeme.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Sve što…“, „nešto što…“ → everything what. Hrvatsko „što“ prirodno se prevodi kao what, pa nastaje everything what, all what, anything what. Iza everything, all, something, anything, nothing engleski upotrebljava that ili ništa.

❌Is there anything what I can bring to the barbecue at your weekend house on Saturday?
✅Is there anything I can bring to the barbecue at your weekend house on Saturday? ili Is there anything that I can bring to the barbecue at your weekend house on Saturday?
iza anything: that ili ništa

2. „…, što je…“ → what za cijelu misao. Hrvatsko „što“ iza zareza može se odnositi na cijelu prethodnu rečenicu („Kiša je prestala, što nas je razveselilo“). Engleski za to upotrebljava which, a nikad what.

❌The organisers moved the open-air concert in Pula into the sports hall at the last minute, what annoyed most of the people who had come from Italy.
✅The organisers moved the open-air concert in Pula into the sports hall at the last minute, which annoyed most of the people who had come from Italy.
which = „, što“ za cijelu misao

3. „Od kojih…“ za ljude → of which. U hrvatskom „od kojih“ jednako govorimo za ljude i za stvari („dvadeset sudionika, od kojih je pola…“). Engleski za ljude traži of whom.

❌This year the sailing school in Biograd trained forty new skippers, half of which were women.
✅This year the sailing school in Biograd trained forty new skippers, half of whom were women.
ljudi: of whom

4. „Nemam koga zvati“ → who + infinitiv. U hrvatskom zamjenica lijepo stoji ispred infinitiva („Nema s kim razgovarati“, „Nemam koga zvati“). U engleskoj odnosnoj rečenici who ne može stajati ispred infinitiva: iza imenice dolazi samo infinitiv (s prijedlogom na kraju ako treba) ili, formalno, prijedlog + whom.

❌On a Sunday afternoon the only mechanic in town who to call is Josip's uncle.
✅On a Sunday afternoon the only mechanic in town to call is Josip's uncle. ili On a Sunday afternoon the only mechanic in town you can call is Josip's uncle.
u odnosnoj rečenici nikad who ispred infinitiva

5. Prijedlog naprijed u neformalnom govoru. Budući da u hrvatskom prijedlog uvijek stoji ispred „kojeg / kojem“, mnogi i u opuštenom razgovoru kažu the friend with whom I…. Nije pogrešno, ali u poruci ili razgovoru zvuči ukočeno, kao službeni dopis.

⚠️Wait, are those the guys from your basketball team with whom you went camping on Krk last summer?
✅Wait, are those the guys from your basketball team you went camping with on Krk last summer?
Gramatički je ispravno, ali u neformalnom razgovoru prijedlog ide na kraj.

Ne miješajte

what i which (cijela surečenica) – What sadrži imenicu (= „ono što“). Which iza zareza komentira cijelu prethodnu surečenicu (= „, što“) (B2-08).

What she said made everyone laugh.
Ono što je rekla sve je nasmijalo.
what = „ono što“
She told a joke, which made everyone laugh.
Ispričala je vic, što je sve nasmijalo.
which = „, što“

whereby i where – Where govori o mjestu (stvarnom ili prenesenom); whereby o načinu ili dogovoru.

This is the office where I first worked.
Ovo je ured u kojem sam prvi put radio.
mjesto
We have a system whereby new staff are paired with a mentor.
Imamo sustav prema kojem svaki novi zaposlenik dobiva mentora.
način

whoever i who – Who treba imenicu ispred sebe (the person who…). Whoever imenicu sadrži.

The person who wins gets a free trip.
Osoba koja pobijedi dobiva besplatno putovanje.
Whoever wins gets a free trip.
Tko god pobijedi, dobiva besplatno putovanje.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • Whom /huːm/ zvuči kao who s dodanim m. h je samo lagan dah, a ne hrvatsko h s trenjem, a w se ne izgovara.
  • Whereby je jedna riječ s naglaskom na drugom slogu: /weəˈbaɪ/ (UK), /werˈbaɪ/ (US). Na početku je /w/: zaokružite usne kao za u, a ne v.
  • Whatever, whoever, whichever, wherever, whenever pišu se kao jedna riječ (za razliku od hrvatskog „što god“, „tko god“); naglasak pada na -ev-: whatever.
  • What ever kao dvije riječi je naglašeno pitanje (What ever happened to him?), a ne odnosna riječ – pogledajte C1-06.
  • Ispred in which case, by which time i at which point dolazi kratka stanka, koju u pisanju pokazuje zarez – isto kao ispred hrvatskog „u kojem slučaju“.
  • U most of which, neither of whom naglasak pada na riječ za količinu: most of which. of je slab: /əv/.

Zlatno pravilo

U formalnom engleskom prijedlog možete pomaknuti naprijed; iza njega dolazi whom ili which – nikad that. What i riječi na -ever upotrijebite kad je sama odnosna rečenica imenica. In which case, by which time i at which point kače novu surečenicu na cijelu situaciju. I pazite na „što“: „sve što“ = everything (that), „, što“ = which.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Preoblikujte svaku rečenicu zadanom strukturom. Značenje neka ostane isto.

  1. Preoblikujte formalno, s prijedlogom ispred odnosne zamjenice: The woman I sent the email to is my manager.
  2. Spojite u jednu rečenicu s "whereby": The company has a new scheme. Under this scheme, staff can buy shares at a discount.
  3. Spojite u jednu rečenicu s "in which case": The flight might be delayed. If that happens, we'll miss our connection.
  4. Spojite u jednu rečenicu s "by which time": We didn't get there until midnight. The restaurant had already closed then.
  5. Spojite u jednu rečenicu s "of whom": I asked two mechanics. Neither of them could find the problem.
  6. Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "Whoever": The person who designed this app deserves an award.
  7. Preoblikujte formalno, s prijedlogom + "whom" + to-infinitivom: She felt she had nobody to share her worries with.

B. Značenje

Pročitajte situaciju i odaberite bolju rečenicu.

  1. Formalno pismo preporuke. Koja rečenica bolje pristaje stilu?
  2. Poruka prijatelju. Što je prirodnije?
  3. Službeni dokument opisuje program mentorstva. Koja je formulacija preciznija?
  4. Vijest opisuje što se dogodilo na sastanku. Koja rečenica pristaje?
  5. Domaćin gostu pokazuje tri slobodne sobe. Koja rečenica najbolje pristaje?

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, most of them had several years of experience in the industry.
  2. Everything what the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers.
  3. The house in that my grandparents lived for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family.
  4. Whatever you will decide about the job offer, your family and friends will support you all the way.
  5. The study measures the extent to which regular exercise improves sleep in adults over the age of sixty.

D. U kontekstu

Pročitajte mail i preoblikujte označene dijelove u formalnijem, povezanijem stilu.

Interview invitation
Dear Ms Kovac,
(18) Thank you for your application. We received it on 3 May. (19) The panel has five members. All of them were impressed by your experience, and we would like to invite you to an interview. (20) We use a system. In this system, each candidate gives a ten-minute presentation. (21) Interviews end on 20 May. At that moment the panel will make its decision. (22) Please let us know if you cannot attend. If that happens, we will offer you another date. (23) You may bring any materials that you find useful. (24) The person you should send questions to is Mr Adebayo.
Yours sincerely,
Hana Iqbal
  1. Spojite (18) u jednu rečenicu s neodređujućom odnosnom rečenicom.
  2. Spojite prve dvije rečenice u (19) s "all of whom".
  3. Spojite (20) u jednu rečenicu s "whereby".
  4. Spojite (21) s "at which point".
  5. Spojite (22) s "in which case".
  6. Preoblikujte (23) s odnosnom riječju na -ever.
  7. Preoblikujte (24) formalno, s "to whom".

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom formalne zahvale, planove i opise.

  1. Napišite formalnu zahvalu nastavniku ili mentoru u 2–3 rečenice. Jednom upotrijebite prijedlog + whom, a jednom the extent to which ili the way in which.
  2. U 2–3 rečenice opišite plan koji bi mogao poći po zlu. Jednom upotrijebite in which case, a jednom by which time ili at which point.
  3. U 2–3 rečenice opišite skupinu ljudi ili stvari koju poznajete. Upotrijebite jednu riječ za količinu + of whom / of which i jednu riječ na -ever (whoever, whatever ili whichever).

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. B2-08 Non-defining relative clauses: odnosne rečenice sa zarezima na engleskom
    Spojite s neodređujućom odnosnom rečenicom: My sister is a chef. She lives in Rome.
  2. B2-20 Noun clauses na hrvatskom: that, whether i what (imeničke rečenice)
    Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "What": The thing that surprised me was her calm reaction.
  3. C1-13 Discourse markers II: given that, hence, namely, albeit – riječi za uzrok, primjer, ustupak i zaključak
    Preoblikujte s "albeit": The project was a success, although it was an expensive one.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. The woman to whom I sent the email is my manager.
  2. The company has a new scheme whereby staff can buy shares at a discount.
  3. The flight might be delayed, in which case we'll miss our connection.
  4. We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed. / We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had already closed.
  5. I asked two mechanics, neither of whom could find the problem.
  6. Whoever designed this app deserves an award.
  7. She felt she had nobody with whom to share her worries.

B. Značenje

  1. She is someone on whom I have always been able to rely.
  2. Is that the guy you were telling me about?
  3. We have a system whereby new staff are paired with a mentor.
  4. The speaker began shouting, at which point security asked him to leave.
  5. You can take whichever room you prefer tonight.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, most of whom had several years of experience in the industry. / We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, and most of them had several years of experience in the industry.
  2. Everything the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers. / Everything that the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers.
  3. The house in which my grandparents lived for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family. / The house that my grandparents lived in for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family.
  4. Whatever you decide about the job offer, your family and friends will support you all the way.
  5. ✓ The study measures the extent to which regular exercise improves sleep in adults over the age of sixty.

D. U kontekstu

  1. Thank you for your application, which we received on 3 May.
  2. The panel has five members, all of whom were impressed by your experience, and we would like to invite you to an interview.
  3. We use a system whereby each candidate gives a ten-minute presentation.
  4. Interviews end on 20 May, at which point the panel will make its decision.
  5. Please let us know if you cannot attend, in which case we will offer you another date.
  6. You may bring whatever materials you find useful.
  7. The person to whom you should send questions is Mr Adebayo.

E. Vaš red

  1. I would like to thank Dr Novak, without whom I would never have finished this project. Her advice has changed the way in which I approach research.
  2. We're planning to leave at six, but the traffic may be heavy, in which case we'll take the train. Either way, we should arrive by eight, by which time the speeches will have started.
  3. Our team has six members, most of whom work from home. Whoever comes into the office first on Monday makes the coffee.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. My sister, who lives in Rome, is a chef.
  2. What surprised me was her calm reaction.
  3. The project was a success, albeit an expensive one.
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play