SlowingoGramatika
B1 16 / 39

Question tags na engleskom: isn't it, don't you – engleski „zar ne?“

Question Tags: …, Isn't It?

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete na kraj rečenice dodati question tag kao isn't it?, didn't you? i can she? da provjerite informaciju ili pozovete sugovornika da se složi – i izgovoriti ga s pravom intonacijom.

Osnovna ideja

Question tag je sićušno pitanje na kraju izjavne rečenice: It's cold, isn't it? Ono izjavu pretvara u poziv: „Jesam li u pravu? Slažete li se?“

Sjećate se jeke iz A2-32? U So do I i Neither can she pomoćni glagol iz prve rečenice vratio se kao jeka. Question tag je ista ta jeka, ali na kraju vaše vlastite rečenice. Ponavlja pomoćni glagol ili be – is, have, can, will, did – sa zamjenicom i obično ga okrene: potvrdna rečenica dobiva niječni tag, a niječna rečenica potvrdni.

You can swim, can't you? You can't swim, can you?

Pravo je značenje u glasu. S tonom koji pada govornik je prilično siguran i samo želi slaganje: Lovely day, isn't it? S tonom koji raste to je pravo pitanje – govornik nije siguran: You've paid, haven't you?

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski za sve rečenice ima isti, nepromjenjiv dodatak: „zar ne?“, „je li?“, „ne?“ – „Hladno je, zar ne?“, „Platio si, zar ne?“, „Ne voli ribu, je li?“. Engleski takvu univerzalnu riječ nema. Tag se svaki put gradi iznova: pomoćni glagol iz rečenice (ili do / does / did), okrenut u suprotni oblik, i zamjenica za subjekt.

Druga je razlika u nijekanju. U hrvatskom riječi kao „nitko“ i „nikad“ uvijek idu uz niječni glagol („Nitko nije zvao“). U engleskom je glagol potvrdan (Nobody called), a ipak je cijela rečenica niječna – pa tag mora biti potvrdan.

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Hladno je, zar ne?It's cold, isn't it?„zar ne“ → pomoćni glagol + zamjenica
Živiš blizu, zar ne?You live near here, don't you?nema pomoćnog glagola → do
Otišli su ranije, je li?They went home early, didn't they?Past Simple → did
Ne zna voziti, zar ne?She can't drive, can she?niječna rečenica → potvrdni tag
Nitko nije zvao, zar ne?Nobody called, did they?u engleskom glagol je potvrdan, ali nobody niječe → potvrdni tag
Naručimo pizzu, može?Let's order a pizza, shall we?prijedlog → shall we
Lijep dan, zar ne? (ton pada)It's a beautiful day, isn't it? ↘ovdje je isto: ton koji pada traži slaganje

Ukratko: hrvatsko „zar ne?“ uvijek je isto, a engleski tag svaki put ponavlja pomoćni glagol, okreće ga i dodaje zamjenicu.

Oblik

Potvrdna rečenica → niječni tag; niječna rečenica → potvrdni tag

RečenicaTag
It is expensive,isn't it?
It isn't expensive,is it?
You have finished,haven't you?
She can't drive,can she?
They will be there,won't they?
We should leave,shouldn't we?

Present Simple (jednostavno sadašnje vrijeme) i Past Simple (jednostavno prošlo vrijeme) → do / does / did – kad u rečenici nema pomoćnog glagola ni be, upotrijebite onaj iz niječnog oblika ili pitanja.

RečenicaTag
You live near here,don't you?
He works at the airport,doesn't he?
They went home early,didn't they?
She doesn't like fish,does she?

Posebni slučajevi

RečenicaTagNapomena
I'm late,aren't I?ne amn't I; am I not? vrlo je formalno
I'm not late,am I?pravilno
Let's go,shall we?prijedlog
Open the window,will you / would you / can you / could you?molba
Don't forget,will you?niječni imperativ
There's a problem,isn't there?there ostaje u tagu
Nobody called,did they?nobody = niječno → potvrdni tag; zamjenica they
Everyone's here,aren't they?everyone / someone → they
Nothing happened,did it?nothing / everything → it
This is yours,isn't it?this / that → it
You never call me,do you?never / hardly / rarely = niječno → potvrdni tag

Uporaba

1Poziv na slaganje – ton pada

Kad ste prilično sigurni i samo želite da se sugovornik složi ili da započnete razgovor, ton na tagu pada. Vrlo je često u komentarima o vremenu, hrani i događajima.

It's a beautiful day, isn't it?
Prekrasan je dan, zar ne?
ton pada ↘
That was a great match, wasn't it?
Bila je to sjajna utakmica, zar ne?
ton pada ↘
The food here is amazing, isn't it?
Hrana je ovdje odlična, zar ne?
ton pada ↘
Your kids have grown so much, haven't they?
Djeca su vam baš narasla, zar ne?
ton pada ↘

2Provjera informacije – ton raste

Kad mislite da je nešto točno, ali niste sigurni, ton raste. Tag tada djeluje gotovo kao pitanje da / ne.

You've sent the invoice, haven't you?
Poslao si račun, je li?
ton raste ↗
The meeting isn't today, is it?
Sastanak nije danas, zar ne?
ton raste ↗
She works from home on Fridays, doesn't she?
Petkom radi od kuće, zar ne?
ton raste ↗
We don't need tickets, do we?
Ne trebaju nam karte, je li tako?
ton raste ↗

3Usklađivanje pomoćnog glagola i vremena

Ponovite pomoćni glagol (ili be) iz rečenice. Ako ga nema, upotrijebite do / does / did u istom vremenu kao glavni glagol. Hrvatsko „zar ne“ tu ništa ne pomaže – tag morate složiti sami.

You're coming to the party, aren't you?
Dolaziš na zabavu, zar ne?
He's been to Kenya, hasn't he?
Bio je u Keniji, zar ne?
he's = he has
Your sister lives in Lisbon, doesn't she?
Sestra ti živi u Lisabonu, zar ne?
lives → doesn't
They called you yesterday, didn't they?
Jučer su te zvali, zar ne?
called → didn't
You'd tell me if something was wrong, wouldn't you?
Rekao bi mi da nešto nije u redu, zar ne?

4Posebni subjekti

I am dobiva aren't I; there is / are zadržava there; everyone, somebody, nobody dobivaju they; everything, nothing, this, that dobivaju it.

I'm on the list, aren't I?
Na popisu sam, zar ne?
There aren't any eggs left, are there?
Nije ostalo jaja, zar ne?
Everybody enjoyed the show, didn't they?
Svima se svidjela predstava, zar ne?
everybody → they
Nothing was broken, was it?
Ništa nije razbijeno, zar ne?
nothing → it

5Niječne riječi bez not

Never, hardly, rarely, no one, nobody, nothing čine rečenicu niječnom, pa je tag potvrdan. U hrvatskom te riječi traže i niječni glagol („nikad ne sluša“), a u engleskom glagol ostaje potvrdan.

He never listens, does he?
Nikad ne sluša, zar ne?
never → potvrdni tag
You hardly ate anything, did you?
Skoro ništa nisi pojeo, zar ne?
No one noticed, did they?
Nitko nije primijetio, zar ne?

6Prijedlozi i molbe – Let's i imperativ

Iza Let's tag je shall we?. Iza imperativa will you?, would you? ili could you? od naredbe čine prijateljsku molbu. Iza niječnog imperativa upotrijebite will you?

Let's order a pizza, shall we?
Naručimo pizzu, može?
Pass me the salt, will you?
Dodaj mi sol, molim te.
Close the door behind you, could you?
Zatvori vrata za sobom, hoćeš?
Don't tell anyone, will you?
Nemoj nikome reći, dobro?

Česte pogreške

❌You like coffee, isn't it?
✅You like coffee, don't you?
Tag ponavlja pomoćni glagol i subjekt; nije nepromjenjivi „isn't it“.
❌She went out, wasn't she?
✅She went out, didn't she?
Past Simple → did.
❌She can drive, doesn't she?
✅She can drive, can't she?
Ponovite pomoćni glagol koji već postoji: can.
❌I'm right, amn't I?
✅I'm right, aren't I?
I am → aren't I.
❌Your brother is a doctor, isn't your brother?
✅Your brother is a doctor, isn't he?
U tagu stoji zamjenica.
❌Nobody came, didn't they?
✅Nobody came, did they?
nobody je niječno → potvrdni tag.
❌Let's go, don't we?
✅Let's go, shall we?
Let's → shall we.
❌There's a bank near here, isn't it?
✅There's a bank near here, isn't there?
there is → isn't there.
❌You never call, don't you?
✅You never call, do you?
never je niječno → potvrdni tag.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „…, zar ne?“ → isn't it? uz svaku rečenicu. Hrvatsko „zar ne?“ stoji iza bilo koje rečenice, pa ga učenici prevedu jednom zauvijek kao isn't it?. Engleski tag mora ponoviti pomoćni glagol i subjekt rečenice.

❌Your parents spend every July and August in their little stone house near Zadar, isn't it?
✅Your parents spend every July and August in their little stone house near Zadar, don't they?
spend → don't; parents → they

2. „…, ne?“ / „…, je li?“ → , no? / , yes? U hrvatskom razgovoru kratko „ne?“ ili „je li?“ na kraju sasvim je obično. U engleskom no? i yes? na kraju rečenice zvuče strano ili vrlo neformalno; prirodno je pravi question tag.

⚠️You've already checked the opening hours of the museum on their website, no?
✅You've already checked the opening hours of the museum on their website, haven't you?
Gramatički je ispravno, ali „no?“ na kraju zvuči strano; izvorni govornik reći će „haven't you?“.

3. „Skoro nikad ne…“ → hardly ever …, don't they? U hrvatskom uz „nikad“, „jedva“ i „nitko“ stoji niječni glagol, pa je nijekanje dobro vidljivo. U engleskom je glagol potvrdan (leave, called), pa učenici misle da je rečenica potvrdna i daju niječni tag. Hardly, never, nobody već niječu rečenicu – tag je potvrdan.

❌Ivana's grandparents hardly ever leave their village on Krk in winter, don't they?
✅Ivana's grandparents hardly ever leave their village on Krk in winter, do they?
hardly ever = niječno → do they

4. „Marko se ponudio da nas odveze, zar ne?“ → has …, didn't he? Hrvatski perfekt pokriva i Past Simple i Present Perfect (sadašnji perfekt), pa učenik u tagu automatski upotrijebi did, kao za svaku prošlu radnju. Tag ponavlja pomoćni glagol koji stvarno stoji u rečenici: has → hasn't.

❌Your cousin Marko has offered to drive us to the airport on Sunday morning, didn't he?
✅Your cousin Marko has offered to drive us to the airport on Sunday morning, hasn't he?
has offered → hasn't he

Ne miješajte

Ton pada ili raste – iste riječi, različito značenje.

You're from Leeds, aren't you?
Ti si iz Leedsa, zar ne?
ton pada ↘: siguran sam, samo potvrđujem
You've locked the door, haven't you?
Zaključao si vrata, je li?
ton raste ↗: mislim da jesi, ali nisam siguran

Question tag ili kratka reakcija – tag dolazi na kraj vaše vlastite rečenice. Reakcije kao So do I ili Are you? odgovaraju na tuđu rečenicu A2-32.

You love jazz, don't you?
Voliš jazz, zar ne?
tag
"I love jazz." "So do I."
„Volim jazz.“ „I ja.“
reakcija

Odgovor na tag – odgovarajte o činjenicama, ne o tagu: yes = potvrdna činjenica, no = niječna činjenica (kao kod niječnih pitanja A2-33).

"You aren't busy, are you?" "No, I'm not."
„Nisi zauzet, zar ne?“ „Nisam.“
nisam zauzet
"You aren't busy, are you?" "Yes, I am, actually."
„Nisi zauzet, zar ne?“ „Zapravo jesam.“
zauzet sam

Tag u istom smjeru – So you're the new manager, are you? (potvrdno + potvrdno) pokazuje iznenađenje ili zanimanje. To nije pogreška; obrađuje se u C2-03.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • Ispred taga stavite zarez, a iza njega upitnik: It's late, isn't it?
  • Tag se izgovara brzo i spojeno s rečenicom: isn't it /ˈɪznt ɪt/, didn't you /ˈdɪdntʃuː/ (t i y stapaju se u /tʃ/, kao hrvatsko „č“), won't you /ˈwəʊntʃuː/ (UK), /ˈwoʊntʃuː/ (US).
  • Ton pada ↘ = siguran sam, tražim slaganje. Ton raste ↗ = pravo pitanje, provjeravam. Kad samo tražite slaganje, svjesno spustite glas na tagu.
  • aren't I /ˈɑːnt aɪ/ (UK), /ˈɑːrnt aɪ/ (US): dugo otvoreno /ɑː/, britanski bez r.
  • Pomoćni glagol u tagu nosi naglasak: You're coming, AREN'T you?

Zlatno pravilo

Ponovite pomoćni glagol (ili be) i okrenite ga: potvrdna rečenica → niječni tag, niječna rečenica → potvrdni tag, obično sa zamjenicom. Nema pomoćnog glagola ni be? Upotrijebite do / does / did. Nema univerzalnog „zar ne?“. Ton pada = „složite se“; ton raste = „je li tako?“

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dodajte question tag.

  1. You're a nurse, ?
  2. He can't swim, ?
  3. They live in Rome, ?
  4. She didn't call, ?
  5. I'm late, ?
  6. Let's take a break, ?
  7. There's some milk in the fridge, ?
  8. You've never been here before, ?

B. Značenje

Odaberite točan odgovor.

  1. Želite provjeriti nešto u što niste sigurni. Odaberite ton na tagu: …
  2. Vi i prijatelj gledate prekrasan zalazak sunca. Kažete: "Beautiful, isn't it?" Odaberite ton: …
  3. "You didn't lock the door, did you?" ", I did." (Zaključali ste vrata.)
  4. Odaberite tag za prijateljsku molbu: Open the window, …?

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. Your parents went to Peru, wasn't it?
  2. Tom is a chef, isn't Tom?
  3. Nobody saw you, didn't they?
  4. Everyone's ready, aren't they?

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite razgovor riječima koje nedostaju.

At the office kitchen
Amy: It's freezing in here today, 17?
Dan: It is! The heating isn't working, 18?
Amy: No. You told the manager, 19?
Dan: Yes, this morning. Let's make some hot tea, 20?
Amy: Good idea. You don't take sugar, 21?
Dan: No, thanks. Pass me the milk, 22?

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom s question tagovima.

  1. Napišite dvije rečenice s tagom kojima započinjete razgovor sa susjedom.
  2. Napišite rečenicu s tagom kojom provjeravate činjenicu u koju niste sigurni.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. A2-32 So do I, neither do I, me too: kako reći i ja i ni ja na engleskom
    "I can't swim." "Neither I."
  2. A2-32 So do I, neither do I, me too: kako reći i ja i ni ja na engleskom
    "I'm moving to Rome." " you? That's exciting!"
  3. B1-14 Indirect questions: pristojna neizravna pitanja na engleskom (Could you tell me where…?)
    Do you know where (Tom / live)?
  4. A2-33 Who called you ili who did you call? Pitanja o subjektu i objektu na engleskom
    (you / not / like) coffee? I thought you loved it!
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. aren't you
  2. can he
  3. don't they
  4. did she
  5. aren't I
  6. shall we
  7. isn't there
  8. have you

B. Značenje

  1. rising
  2. falling
  3. Yes
  4. will you

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. Your parents went to Peru, didn't they?
  2. Tom is a chef, isn't he?
  3. Nobody saw you, did they?
  4. ✓ Everyone's ready, aren't they?

D. U kontekstu

  1. isn't it
  2. is it
  3. didn't you
  4. shall we
  5. do you
  6. will you / would you / can you / could you

E. Vaš red

  1. It's really quiet today, isn't it? You've just moved in, haven't you?
  2. The shop doesn't open on Sundays, does it?

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. can
  2. Are
  3. Tom lives
  4. Don't you like / Do you not like
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play