SlowingoSlovnica
B1 16 / 39

Question Tags: vprašalni dodatki v angleščini (…, isn't it?) namesto slovenskega „kajne“

Question Tags: …, Isn't It?

Na tej strani
  1. Cilj
  2. Glavna ideja
  3. Slovenščina in angleščina
  4. Oblika
  5. Raba
  6. Pogoste napake
  7. Pasti za govorce slovenščine
  8. Ne zamenjujte
  9. Pravopis in izgovorjava
  10. Zlato pravilo
  11. Vaje

Cilj

Po tej lekciji boste znali na konec povedi dodati vprašalni dodatek (question tag), kot so isn't it?, didn't you? in can she?, da preverite podatek ali sogovornika povabite, naj se strinja – in ga izgovoriti s pravo intonacijo.

Glavna ideja

Vprašalni dodatek je drobno vprašanje na koncu izjave: It's cold, isn't it? Izjavo spremeni v povabilo: „Imam prav? Se strinjate?“

Se spomnite odmeva iz A2-32? V So do I in Neither can she se je pomožni glagol iz prve povedi vrnil kot odmev. Vprašalni dodatek je isti odmev, le da pride na konec vaše lastne povedi. Ponovi pomožni glagol ali be – is, have, can, will, did – z osebnim zaimkom in ga navadno obrne: trdilna poved dobi zanikan dodatek, zanikana poved pa trdilnega.

You can swim, can't you? You can't swim, can you?

Pravi pomen pa je v glasu. Če glas na koncu pade, je govorec precej prepričan in želi le pritrditev: Lovely day, isn't it? Če se glas dvigne, je to pravo vprašanje – govorec ni prepričan: You've paid, haven't you?

Slovenščina in angleščina

Slovenščina ima za to eno samo nespremenljivo besedico: „kajne?“, „ne?“ ali „ali ne?“. Pristavimo jo lahko kateri koli povedi: „Lep dan je, kajne?“, „Ti živiš tu blizu, kajne?“, „Niste lačni, kajne?“. Angleški dodatek pa se vsakič sestavi na novo: ponovi pomožni glagol iz povedi, njegov čas in osebek (kot zaimek) ter obrne trdilnost. Zato je isn't it? za vse povedi tipična slovenska napaka – to je naš „kajne“, prenesen v angleščino.

Druga razlika: v slovenščini je zanikanje vedno vidno na glagolu („Nihče ni prišel“, „Nikoli ne posluša“). V angleščini je skrito v besedi nobody ali never, glagol pa je videti trdilen: Nobody came. Ker je poved zanikana, je dodatek trdilen. Pri angleškem dodatku pa veliko pove tudi glas: padajoči išče pritrditev, dvigajoči sprašuje.

SlovenščinaAngleščinaV čem je razlika?
Mrzlo je, kajne?It's cold, isn't it?dodatek ponovi is in obrne trdilnost
Živiš tu blizu, kajne?You live near here, don't you?ni pomožnega glagola → do / does / did
Včeraj so te poklicali, ne?They called you yesterday, didn't they?čas povedi: did
Ne znaš plavati, kajne?You can't swim, can you?zanikana poved → trdilen dodatek
Tu blizu je banka, ne?There's a bank near here, isn't there?there ostane v dodatku
Nihče ni klical, kajne?Nobody called, did they?v slovenščini „ni“ na glagolu; v angleščini nobody → trdilen dodatek
Gremo na pico, ali ne?Let's go for a pizza, shall we?Let's → shall we

Na kratko: slovenski „kajne“ je vedno enak, angleški dodatek pa ponovi pomožni glagol, čas in osebek in obrne trdilnost; padajoči glas išče pritrditev, dvigajoči sprašuje.

Oblika

Trdilna poved → zanikan dodatek; zanikana poved → trdilen dodatek

PovedDodatek
It is expensive,isn't it?
It isn't expensive,is it?
You have finished,haven't you?
She can't drive,can she?
They will be there,won't they?
We should leave,shouldn't we?

Present Simple (preprosti sedanjik) in Past Simple (preprosti preteklik) → do / does / did – kadar v povedi ni pomožnega glagola in ni be, uporabite tistega, ki bi stal v zanikani povedi ali vprašanju.

PovedDodatek
You live near here,don't you?
He works at the airport,doesn't he?
They went home early,didn't they?
She doesn't like fish,does she?

Posebni primeri

PovedDodatekOpomba
I'm late,aren't I?ne amn't I; am I not? je zelo formalno
I'm not late,am I?pravilno
Let's go,shall we?predlog
Open the window,will you / would you / can you / could you?prošnja
Don't forget,will you?zanikan velelnik
There's a problem,isn't there?there ostane v dodatku
Nobody called,did they?nobody = zanikanje → trdilen dodatek; zaimek they
Everyone's here,aren't they?everyone / someone → they
Nothing happened,did it?nothing / everything → it
This is yours,isn't it?this / that → it
You never call me,do you?never / hardly / rarely = zanikanje → trdilen dodatek

Raba

1Vabilo k strinjanju – padajoča intonacija

Ko ste precej prepričani in želite le, da se sogovornik strinja ali da začnete pogovor, naj glas na dodatku pade. Zelo pogosto pri pogovoru o vremenu, hrani in dogodkih – kot naš „kajne“ s padajočim glasom.

It's a beautiful day, isn't it?
Čudovit dan je, kajne?
padajoče ↘
That was a great match, wasn't it?
To je bila odlična tekma, ne?
padajoče ↘; was → wasn't
The food here is amazing, isn't it?
Hrana je tu izvrstna, kajne?
padajoče ↘
Your kids have grown so much, haven't they?
Kako so vaši otroci zrasli, kajne?
padajoče ↘; have → haven't they

2Preverjanje podatka – dvigajoča intonacija

Ko mislite, da nekaj drži, a niste prepričani, naj se glas dvigne. Dodatek tedaj deluje skoraj kot vprašanje da / ne.

You've sent the invoice, haven't you?
Račun ste že poslali, kajne?
dvigajoče ↗
The meeting isn't today, is it?
Sestanek vendar ni danes, kajne?
dvigajoče ↗; zanikana poved → is it
She works from home on Fridays, doesn't she?
Ob petkih dela od doma, ne?
dvigajoče ↗; works → doesn't
We don't need tickets, do we?
Vstopnic ne potrebujemo, kajne?
dvigajoče ↗

3Isti pomožni glagol in isti čas

Ponovite pomožni glagol (ali be) iz povedi. Če ga ni, uporabite do / does / did v istem času kot glavni glagol. Slovenski „kajne“ se ne spreminja – angleški dodatek pa vedno.

You're coming to the party, aren't you?
Prideš na zabavo, kajne?
are → aren't
He's been to Kenya, hasn't he?
Bil je že v Keniji, ne?
he's = he has → hasn't
Your sister lives in Lisbon, doesn't she?
Tvoja sestra živi v Lizboni, kajne?
lives → doesn't she
They called you yesterday, didn't they?
Včeraj so te poklicali, ne?
called → didn't
You'd tell me if something was wrong, wouldn't you?
Povedal bi mi, če bi bilo kaj narobe, kajne?
'd = would → wouldn't

4Posebni osebki

I am ima aren't I; there is / are ohrani there; everyone, somebody, nobody imajo they; everything, nothing, this, that pa it.

I'm on the list, aren't I?
Na seznamu sem, kajne?
I am → aren't I
There aren't any eggs left, are there?
Jajc ni več, kajne?
there ostane
Everybody enjoyed the show, didn't they?
Predstava je bila všeč vsem, kajne?
everybody → they
Nothing was broken, was it?
Nič se ni razbilo, kajne?
nothing → it; trdilen dodatek

5Zanikanje brez not

Never, hardly, rarely, no one, nobody, nothing naredijo poved zanikano, zato je dodatek trdilen. V slovenščini zanikanje vidimo na glagolu, v angleščini pa je skrito v teh besedah.

He never listens, does he?
Nikoli ne posluša, kajne?
„ne posluša“, angleško pa listens; dodatek does he
You hardly ate anything, did you?
Skoraj nič nisi pojedel, kajne?
hardly = zanikanje → did you
No one noticed, did they?
Nihče ni opazil, kajne?
„ni opazil“, angleško pa noticed; dodatek did they

6Predlogi in prošnje – Let's in velelnik

Za Let's je dodatek shall we?. Za velelnikom will you?, would you? ali could you? ukaz spremeni v prijazno prošnjo. Za zanikanim velelnikom uporabite will you?

Let's order a pizza, shall we?
Naročimo pico, ali ne?
Let's → shall we
Pass me the salt, will you?
Mi podaš sol, prosim?
prošnja
Close the door behind you, could you?
Zapri, prosim, vrata za sabo.
could you omili ukaz
Don't tell anyone, will you?
Saj ne boš nikomur povedal, kajne?
zanikan velelnik → will you

Pogoste napake

❌You like coffee, isn't it?
✅You like coffee, don't you?
Dodatek ponovi pomožni glagol in osebek; ni nespremenljivi „isn't it“.
❌She went out, wasn't she?
✅She went out, didn't she?
Past Simple → did.
❌She can drive, doesn't she?
✅She can drive, can't she?
Ponovite pomožni glagol, ki je v povedi: can.
❌I'm right, amn't I?
✅I'm right, aren't I?
I am → aren't I.
❌Your brother is a doctor, isn't your brother?
✅Your brother is a doctor, isn't he?
V dodatku je osebni zaimek.
❌Nobody came, didn't they?
✅Nobody came, did they?
nobody je zanikanje → trdilen dodatek.
❌Let's go, don't we?
✅Let's go, shall we?
Let's → shall we.
❌There's a bank near here, isn't it?
✅There's a bank near here, isn't there?
there is → isn't there.
❌You never call, don't you?
✅You never call, do you?
never je zanikanje → trdilen dodatek.

Pasti za govorce slovenščine

1. „…, kajne?“ → isn't it? za vse. Slovenski „kajne“ in „ne?“ se nikoli ne spreminjata, zato se tudi isn't it? hitro prilepi na vsako poved. Angleški dodatek pa mora ponoviti pomožni glagol in osebek iz povedi.

❌Your brother Ziga spends every summer working as a waiter in a hotel in Portoroz, isn't it?
✅Your brother Ziga spends every summer working as a waiter in a hotel in Portoroz, doesn't he?
spends → doesn't he
❌You and Spela will be back from your week at the seaside in Piran before the school year starts, isn't it?
✅You and Spela will be back from your week at the seaside in Piran before the school year starts, won't you?
will → won't you

2. Brez pomožnega glagola → napačen dodatek z be. V slovenščini pomožnega glagola do ni, zato v dodatek rad zaide be (weren't you, aren't they). Če v povedi ni pomožnega glagola in ni be, uporabite do / does / did v istem času.

❌You and Nejc came back from the hike on Velika planina quite late on Saturday evening, weren't you?
✅You and Nejc came back from the hike on Velika planina quite late on Saturday evening, didn't you?
came → didn't you
❌Your grandparents still keep a few cows and make their own cheese near Bovec, aren't they?
✅Your grandparents still keep a few cows and make their own cheese near Bovec, don't they?
keep, make → don't they

3. „Nihče ni …“ → nobody …, didn't they? V slovenščini je zanikanje vidno na glagolu („nihče ni pozabil“, „nikoli ne vozi“). V angleščini je glagol videti trdilen (remembered, drives), zanikanje pa je v nobody ali never. Poved je zanikana, zato je dodatek trdilen.

❌Nobody in our group remembered to pack a map of the Julian Alps, didn't they?
✅Nobody in our group remembered to pack a map of the Julian Alps, did they?
nobody → did they
❌Your grandfather never drives on the motorway to Maribor after dark, doesn't he?
✅Your grandfather never drives on the motorway to Maribor after dark, does he?
never → does he

Ne zamenjujte

Padajoča in dvigajoča intonacija – iste besede, različen pomen.

You're from Leeds, aren't you?
Iz Leedsa ste, kajne?
padajoče ↘: prepričan sem, le potrjujem
You've locked the door, haven't you?
Vrata si zaklenil, kajne?
dvigajoče ↗: mislim, da si, a nisem prepričan

Vprašalni dodatki in kratki odzivi – Dodatek pride na konec vaše lastne povedi. Odzivi, kot sta So do I ali Are you?, pa se odzovejo na poved drugega A2-32.

You love jazz, don't you?
Rad imaš jazz, kajne?
dodatek
"I love jazz." "So do I."
„Rad imam jazz.“ „Jaz tudi.“
odziv

Odgovor na dodatek – Odgovorite o dejstvih, ne o dodatku: yes = trdilno dejstvo, no = zanikano dejstvo (kot pri zanikanih vprašanjih A2-33). Najvarneje je, da v odgovoru ponovite glagol – tako kot v slovenščini „Nisem.“ ali „Sem.“

"You aren't busy, are you?" "No, I'm not."
„Saj nisi zaseden, kajne?“ „Nisem.“
nisem zaseden
"You aren't busy, are you?" "Yes, I am, actually."
„Saj nisi zaseden, kajne?“ „Pravzaprav sem.“
sem zaseden

Dodatki v isti smeri – So you're the new manager, are you? (trdilna poved + trdilen dodatek) izraža presenečenje ali zanimanje. To ni napaka; razložena je v C2-03.

Pravopis in izgovorjava

  • Pred dodatkom pišite vejico, za njim vprašaj: It's late, isn't it?
  • Dodatek izgovorite hitro in povezano s povedjo: isn't it /ˈɪznt ɪt/, didn't you /ˈdɪdntʃuː/, won't you /ˈwəʊntʃuː/ (UK), /ˈwoʊntʃuː/ (US). Na stiku t in y nastane /tʃ/ – to je slovenski č, ki ga že znate.
  • Padajoči glas ↘ = prepričan sem, prosim za pritrditev. Dvigajoči glas ↗ = pravo vprašanje, preverjam.
  • aren't I /ˈɑːnt aɪ/ (UK), /ˈɑːrnt aɪ/ (US): v britanski izgovorjavi se r ne sliši, samoglasnik pa je dolg in odprt. V ameriški izgovorjavi je r mehak, z jezikom, ki se ne dotakne neba – ne drdrajte ga kot slovenski r.
  • Pomožni glagol v dodatku nosi naglas: You're coming, AREN'T you?
  • n't je brez samoglasnika: v isn't /ˈɪznt/ in didn't /ˈdɪdnt/ jezik ostane za zgornjimi zobmi, zrak pa uide skozi nos. Ne vstavljajte e.

Zlato pravilo

Ponovite pomožni glagol (ali be) in ga obrnite: trdilna poved → zanikan dodatek, zanikana poved → trdilen dodatek, navadno z osebnim zaimkom. Ni pomožnega glagola in ni be? Uporabite do / does / did. Slovenski „kajne“ ni vedno isn't it. Padajoči glas = „strinjaj se z mano“; dvigajoči = „je res tako?“

Vaje

A. Oblika

Dopolnite povedi s pravilnim vprašalnim dodatkom.

  1. You're a nurse, ?
  2. He can't swim, ?
  3. They live in Rome, ?
  4. She didn't call, ?
  5. I'm late, ?
  6. Let's take a break, ?
  7. There's some milk in the fridge, ?
  8. You've never been here before, ?

B. Pomen

Izberite odgovor, ki ustreza položaju.

  1. Preveriti želite nekaj, v kar niste prepričani. Izberite intonacijo dodatka: …
  2. S prijateljem gledata čudovit sončni zahod. Rečete: "Beautiful, isn't it?" Izberite intonacijo: …
  3. "You didn't lock the door, did you?" ", I did." (I locked it.)
  4. Izberite dodatek za prijazno prošnjo: Open the window, …?

C. Poiščite napako

V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.

  1. Your parents went to Peru, wasn't it?
  2. Tom is a chef, isn't Tom?
  3. Nobody saw you, didn't they?
  4. Everyone's ready, aren't they?

D. V kontekstu

Dopolnite pogovor z manjkajočimi besedami.

At the office kitchen
Amy: It's freezing in here today, 17?
Dan: It is! The heating isn't working, 18?
Amy: No. You told the manager, 19?
Dan: Yes, this morning. Let's make some hot tea, 20?
Amy: Good idea. You don't take sugar, 21?
Dan: No, thanks. Pass me the milk, 22?

E. Na vrsti ste vi

Pišite v angleščini.

  1. Napišite dve povedi z vprašalnim dodatkom, s katerima začnete pogovor s sosedom.
  2. Napišite poved z dodatkom, s katero preverite dejstvo, v katero niste prepričani.
Rešitve

A. Oblika

  1. aren't you
  2. can he
  3. don't they
  4. did she
  5. aren't I
  6. shall we
  7. isn't there
  8. have you

B. Pomen

  1. rising
  2. falling
  3. Yes
  4. will you

C. Poiščite napako

  1. Your parents went to Peru, didn't they?
  2. Tom is a chef, isn't he?
  3. Nobody saw you, did they?
  4. ✓ Everyone's ready, aren't they?

D. V kontekstu

  1. isn't it
  2. is it
  3. didn't you
  4. shall we
  5. do you
  6. will you / would you / can you / could you

E. Na vrsti ste vi

  1. It's really quiet today, isn't it? You've just moved in, haven't you?
  2. The shop doesn't open on Sundays, does it?

F. Mešano ponavljanje

  1. can
  2. Are
  3. Tom lives
  4. Don't you like / Do you not like
Aplikacija za AndroidUčite se na poti Google Play