SlowingoSlovnica
A2 25 / 38

Could you, Could I, Shall I: prošnje, ponudbe in dovoljenje v angleščini

Requests, Offers and Permission

Na tej strani
  1. Cilj
  2. Glavna ideja
  3. Slovenščina in angleščina
  4. Oblika
  5. Raba
  6. Pogoste napake
  7. Pasti za govorce slovenščine
  8. Ne zamenjujte
  9. Pravopis in izgovorjava
  10. Zlato pravilo
  11. Vaje

Cilj

Po tej lekciji boste znali koga prositi, naj nekaj naredi, vprašati, ali smete nekaj narediti, ponuditi pomoč in vljudno odgovoriti – in pri tem izbrati pravo stopnjo vljudnosti za položaj.

Glavna ideja

Ko koga za nekaj prosimo, ga prosimo za njegov čas ali trud. Angleščina prošnjo omehča z razdaljo: več razdalje ima prošnja, bolj vljudno zveni.

Predstavljajte si lestev vljudnosti. Na najnižji prečki je Can you help me? – neposredno in prijazno, kot nalašč za družino in prijatelje. Prečko višje: Could you help me? – could je videti kot pretekla oblika in to doda razdaljo, zato zveni mehkeje. Še višje: Would you mind helping me? – zdaj celo vprašate, ali je prošnja komu v breme. Na vrhu: I was wondering if you could help me – zelo previdno in zelo vljudno.

Poznamo tudi tri različna opravila. Prošnja prosi vas, da nekaj naredite: Could you…? Dovoljenje sprašuje, ali smem nekaj narediti jaz: Could I…? Ponudba pove, da sem jaz pripravljen nekaj narediti za vas: Shall I…? Najprej izberite opravilo, nato prečko na lestvi.

Slovenščina in angleščina

Slovenščina vljudnost gradi podobno: s pogojnikom. „Mi lahko pomagaš?“ je Can you help me?, „Bi mi lahko pomagali?“ pa Could you help me?. Pri vprašanju „Bi vas motilo…?“ je logika celo enaka kot pri Would you mind…?: če vas ne moti, odgovorite „Ne, sploh ne“ – No, not at all. Tu je enako.

Razlike so drugje. Za „Bi vam bilo težko…“ in „Bi vas motilo…“ stoji nedoločnik ali odvisnik s „če“, za mind pa vedno -ing oblika ali if + Present Simple (preprosti sedanjik). Ponudbo v slovenščini pogosto damo z „naj“ ali z „Hočeš, da…?“: „Naj nesem tvojo torbo?“, „Hočeš, da te zapeljem domov?“ V angleščini je to Shall I…? ali Do you want me to…? – brez odvisnika z that. Slovenski „lahko“ pomeni can, could in may, v vprašanjih pa angleški May stoji samo z I ali we: za dovoljenje, ne za prošnjo.

In še ena navada: v trgovini ali restavraciji rečemo „Dajte mi kavo, prosim“ in to je povsem vljudno. Angleški velelnik pa lahko zveni kot ukaz, tudi s please. Vljudnejše je Could I have…? ali Can I have…?

SlovenščinaAngleščinaV čem je razlika?
Mi lahko podaš sol?Can you pass the salt?prijateljska prošnja: enako
Bi mi lahko poslali datoteko?Could you send me the file?pogojnik → could / would: enako
Bi vam bilo težko malo počakati?Would you mind waiting?za mind stoji -ing oblika
Vas moti, če odprem okno?Do you mind if I open the window?if + Present Simple: enako kot „če odprem“
Smem vstopiti?May I come in?„smem“ → May I (formalno)
Naj nesem tvojo torbo?Shall I carry your bag?ponudba z „naj“ → Shall I
Hočeš, da ti pomagam?Do you want me to help you?„hočeš, da“ → want + oseba + to
Dajte mi jedilni list, prosim.Could I have the menu, please?slovenski velelnik s „prosim“ je vljuden, angleški pa lahko zveni grobo
„Bi vas motilo?“ „Ne, sploh ne.“"Would you mind?" "No, not at all."no = v redu: enako

Na kratko: pogojnik „bi“ za vljudnost poznate – v angleščini sta to could in would; za mind stoji -ing oblika, „Hočeš, da…?“ pa je Do you want me to…?

Oblika

Prošnje – koga prosimo, naj nekaj naredi

VzorecPrimerVljudnost
Can you + osnovna oblika?Can you pass the salt?nevtralno, prijateljsko
Could you + osnovna oblika?Could you send me the file?vljudno
Would you + osnovna oblika?Would you close the window, please?vljudno
Would you mind + -ing oblika?Would you mind waiting a moment?zelo vljudno
I was wondering if you could + osnovna oblikaI was wondering if you could help me.zelo vljudno, previdno

Dovoljenje – vprašamo, ali smemo nekaj narediti

VzorecPrimerVljudnost
Can I + osnovna oblika?Can I use your pen?nevtralno, prijateljsko
Could I + osnovna oblika?Could I leave early today?vljudno
May I + osnovna oblika?May I come in?formalno
Do you mind if I + Present Simple?Do you mind if I open the window?zelo vljudno

Ponudbe – povemo, da smo pripravljeni pomagati

VzorecPrimer
Shall I + osnovna oblika?Shall I carry your bag?
Can I + osnovna oblika?Can I help you?
I'll + osnovna oblika.I'll get the door.
Would you like me to + osnovna oblika?Would you like me to call a taxi?
Do you want me to + osnovna oblika? (neformalno)Do you want me to help?

Odgovori

VprašanjeDaNe
Can / Could / Would you…? Can / Could / May I…?Sure. / Of course. / Yes, go ahead. / No problem.I'm sorry, but… / I'm afraid…
Would you mind…? / Do you mind if I…?No, not at all. / No, go ahead. (no = v redu je)I'm sorry, but… / Actually, it's a bit difficult right now.
Shall I…? / Would you like me to…?Yes, please. / That would be great, thanks.No, thanks. I'm fine. / That's OK, thanks.

Raba

1Prošnje

Can you…? uporabite z ljudmi, ki jih dobro poznate. Could you…? ali Would you…? zvenita bolj vljudno – s sodelavci, neznanci ali v trgovini. Please prošnjo še dodatno omehča.

Can you turn the music down a bit?
Lahko malo utišaš glasbo?
prijateljsko
Could you tell me the way to the station, please?
Bi mi, prosim, povedali, kako pridem do postaje?
vljudno: „bi“ → could
Could you check this email for me?
Bi mi lahko pregledal to e-pošto?
Would you give this to your sister, please?
Bi to, prosim, dal sestri?

2Zelo vljudne prošnje – Would you mind + -ing?

Would you mind + -ing oblika je zelo vljudno. V resnici sprašuje „Vam je to v breme?“ – zato odgovor No pomeni „V redu, bom naredil.“ Tudi v slovenščini na „Bi vas motilo…?“ prijazno odgovorimo z „ne“.

Would you mind speaking more slowly?
Bi lahko, prosim, govorili počasneje?
za mind: -ing oblika
Would you mind not using your phone in here?
Bi vas lahko prosil, da tukaj ne uporabljate telefona?
zanikano: not + -ing
Would you mind moving your bag?
Bi lahko, prosim, umaknili torbo?
prošnja
No, not at all.
Ne, sploh ne.
odgovor: ne = v redu je

3Prošnja za dovoljenje

S Can I / Could I / May I + osnovno obliko vprašate, ali smete nekaj narediti. May I je formalen; pogost je v trgovinah, uradih in z ljudmi, ki jih ne poznate. Do you mind if I…? + Present Simple je zelo vljuden. Naučite se ga kot stalni okvir.

Can I borrow your charger?
Si lahko sposodim tvoj polnilnik?
Could I ask you a question?
Bi vas lahko nekaj vprašal?
May I see your passport, please?
Smem videti vaš potni list?
„smem“ → May I
Do you mind if I sit here?
Vas moti, če se usedem sem?
if + Present Simple
"Do you mind if I open the window?" "No, go ahead."
„Vas moti, če odprem okno?“ „Ne, kar odprite.“

4Ponujanje pomoči

S Shall I…? ali Would you like me to…? vprašate, ali drugi želi vašo pomoč. Tudi Can I…? je zelo pogosta ponudba (Can I help you?, Can I get you a drink?): ima obliko prošnje za dovoljenje, vendar ponujate, da boste nekaj naredili za drugega. Z I'll… ponudite pomoč neposredno, ko se odločite v trenutku (glejte A2-04). Would you like me to…? in Do you want me to…? se naučite kot stalna okvira; want / would like + oseba + to je v A2-25. Shall I…? je pogostejši v britanski angleščini; v ameriški sta običajnejša Should I…? ali Do you want me to…?

Shall I open the window? It's hot in here.
Naj odprem okno? Vroče je.
„naj“ → Shall I
Would you like me to drive you home?
Bi želeli, da vas zapeljem domov?
„da vas zapeljem“ → me to drive
Can I get you a drink?
Vam lahko prinesem kaj za pijačo?
ponudba
Your hands are full. I'll get the door.
Roke imaš polne. Bom jaz odprl vrata.
odločitev v trenutku: I'll
Do you want me to help you with your homework?
Hočeš, da ti pomagam pri domači nalogi?
neformalno; „hočeš, da“ → want me to

5Posebno vljudni okvirji – I was wondering if… / I'd like to ask…

Za veliko uslugo ali s pomembno osebo uporabite stalni vljudni okvir. V I was wondering if you could… oblika Past Continuous (preteklik v teku) ne pomeni preteklega časa; doda razdaljo, zato zveni previdno in vljudno.

I was wondering if you could help me with my CV.
Zanima me, ali bi mi lahko pomagali pri življenjepisu.
CV (UK); résumé (US)
I was wondering if I could leave a bit early on Friday.
Ali bi v petek lahko odšel malo prej?
pretekla oblika samo za vljudnost
I'd like to ask you a favour.
Rad bi vas prosil za uslugo.
I'd like to ask a question about my bill.
Imel bi vprašanje glede računa.

6Vljudno reči da in ne

Za „da“ uporabite kratke prijazne izraze. Za „ne“ ne recite samo No – uporabite I'm sorry, but… ali I'm afraid… in navedite razlog.

"Could you help me with this box?" "Sure, no problem."
„Mi lahko pomagaš s to škatlo?“ „Seveda, ni problema.“
"Can I use your phone?" "I'm sorry, but the battery's dead."
„Lahko uporabim tvoj telefon?“ „Žal mi je, baterija je prazna.“
Could you work late tonight?
Bi lahko nocoj delali dlje?
prošnja
I'm afraid I can't. I have to pick up my son.
Žal ne morem. Iti moram po sina.
vljuden ne, z razlogom
"Shall I make some tea?" "Yes, please. That would be lovely."
„Naj skuham čaj?“ „Ja, prosim. To bi bilo lepo.“
"Would you like me to wait for you?" "No, thanks. I'll be fine."
„Želiš, da te počakam?“ „Ne, hvala. Bom že.“

Pogoste napake

❌Would you mind to open the door?
✅Would you mind opening the door?
Za mind stoji -ing oblika.
❌Could you to help me?
✅Could you help me?
Za can / could / would ni to.
❌Do you mind if I will sit here?
✅Do you mind if I sit here?
Za if I stoji Present Simple.
❌Do you want that I help you?
✅Do you want me to help you?
want + oseba + nedoločnik s to.
❌May you help me?
✅Could you help me?
May je za dovoljenje (May I…?), ne za prošnje.
⚠️"Would you mind waiting?" "Yes, of course."
✅"No, not at all."
Ljudje res rečejo „Yes, of course“ in mislijo, da je v redu, strogo pa yes pomeni „moti me“. No, not at all je jasno.
⚠️Give me the menu.
✅Could I have the menu, please?
Slovnično je pravilno, vendar velelnik kot prošnja lahko zveni nevljudno.

Pasti za govorce slovenščine

1. „Hočeš, da ti pomagam?“ → Do you want that I help you? Slovenščina za „hočeš“ ali „želiš“ postavi odvisnik z „da“. Angleščina takega odvisnika za want in would like ne pozna: want + oseba + to.

❌Do you want that I print the hiking map of the Kamnik Alps for you, or have you got one on your phone?
✅Do you want me to print the hiking map of the Kamnik Alps for you, or have you got one on your phone?
„hočeš, da“ → want me to
❌Would you like that I look after your rabbits during your family's week at the seaside in Izola?
✅Would you like me to look after your rabbits during your family's week at the seaside in Izola?
would like + oseba + to

2. „Bi vas motilo, če bi…“ → Would you mind if I would… Slovenski pogojnik ima „bi“ v obeh delih povedi. V angleščini za if ne stoji would: Do you mind if I + Present Simple ali Would you mind if I + Past Simple (preprosti preteklik).

❌Would you mind if I would bring my little sister to Ziga's birthday picnic on Saturday?
✅Do you mind if I bring my little sister to Ziga's birthday picnic on Saturday? ali Would you mind if I brought my little sister to Ziga's birthday picnic on Saturday?
za if ni would

3. „Bi vam bilo težko počakati?“ → mind to wait. Za slovenske izraze „bi vam bilo težko“, „bi vas motilo“ stoji nedoločnik ali odvisnik. Za mind pa stoji vedno -ing oblika.

❌Excuse me, would you mind to move your car a little, because I can't get out of the garage?
✅Excuse me, would you mind moving your car a little, because I can't get out of the garage?
za mind: -ing oblika

4. „Dajte mi, prosim…“ → Give me…, please. V slovenski trgovini ali kavarni je velelnik s „prosim“ povsem vljuden. Angleški velelnik pa lahko zveni kot ukaz, tudi s please. Naravno je Could I have…? ali Can I have…?

⚠️Give me the cheapest return ticket to Maribor for tomorrow morning, please.
✅Could I have the cheapest return ticket to Maribor for tomorrow morning, please?
Slovnično je pravilno, vendar velelnik zveni neprijazno; vljudneje je Could I have…?

5. „Mi lahko pomagate?“ → May you help me? „Lahko“ pokrije can, could in may. May pa v prošnjah uporabljamo samo z I ali we (dovoljenje). Ko prosimo drugega, recimo Could you…? ali Can you…?

❌May you show me how this ticket machine at Ljubljana bus station works? I've never used it before.
✅Could you show me how this ticket machine at Ljubljana bus station works? I've never used it before.
za prošnjo: Could you…?, ne May you…?

Ne zamenjujte

Could you…? in Could I…? – Opravilo določi osebek. Dejanje izvedete vi (you) = prošnja. Dejanje izvedem jaz (I) = dovoljenje.

Could you open the door?
Bi lahko odprli vrata?
prošnja: odprete vi
Could I open the door?
Smem odpreti vrata?
dovoljenje: odprem jaz

Shall I…? in Will you…? – Shall I ponuja pomoč. Will you prosi drugega, naj nekaj naredi; lahko zveni kot ukaz, zato je Could you…? navadno varnejši. Glejte A2-04.

Shall I wash the dishes?
Naj pomijem posodo?
ponudba
Will you wash the dishes?
Boš pomil posodo?
prošnja: precej neposredno

Would you like…? in Do you like…? – Would you like je ponudba zdaj; Do you like sprašuje po splošnem okusu. Glejte A1-25.

Would you like some cake?
Bi kos torte?
ponudba
Do you like cake?
Imaš rad torte?
splošno vprašanje

Pravopis in izgovorjava

  • Could you in Would you se zlijeta: /ˈkʊdʒu/, /ˈwʊdʒu/. Glas /dʒ/ poznate – je slovenski dž kot v „džungla“.
  • Would se začne z /w/: ustnice zaokrožite in jih hitro razprite. Ne izgovarjajte ga kot slovenski v z zobmi na ustnici. l v could in would je nem.
  • Can I se poveže: /kənaɪ/. Samoglasnik v can je tu šibak, kot slovenski polglasnik.
  • Shall I je v hitrem govoru pogosto /ʃəlaɪ/. /ʃ/ je slovenski š.
  • Intonacija je pomembna. Glas, ki se na koncu dvigne ali najprej spusti in nato dvigne, zveni prijazno. Raven, padajoč ton lahko zveni kot ukaz, tudi s please.
  • Please navadno stoji na koncu (Could you help me, please?) ali za osebkom (Could you please help me?). Pred please na koncu stoji vejica.

Zlato pravilo

Najprej izberite opravilo: prošnja (Could you…?), dovoljenje (Could I…?) ali ponudba (Shall I…?). Nato izberite vljudnost: več razdalje (could, would, would you mind, I was wondering if) zveni bolj vljudno. Na Would you mind…? in Do you mind if I…? je prijazen odgovor No (not at all). „Hočeš, da ti pomagam?“ pa je Do you want me to help you?

Vaje

A. Oblika

Dopolnite povedi z glagolom iz oklepaja v pravilni obliki.

  1. Would you mind (turn) off the light?
  2. Do you mind if I (use) your phone?
  3. Would you like me (call) a taxi?
  4. Napišite vljudneje s Could you: Pass me the water.
  5. Prosite za dovoljenje z May I: (come in)
  6. Napišite zelo vljudno z I was wondering if: Can you help me?

B. Pomen

Izberite odgovor, ki ustreza položaju.

  1. Izberite pravilni odgovor: … give me a lift to the station?
  2. Izberite pravilni odgovor: … carry that bag for you?
  3. Prijatelj vpraša: "Would you mind waiting five minutes?" Radi počakate. Odgovor:
  4. Katera poved je ponudba?
  5. Katera poved je najbolj vljudna?

C. Poiščite napako

V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.

  1. Would you mind to help me?
  2. Do you want that I call you later?
  3. May you pass me the salt?
  4. Could I ask you a question?

D. V kontekstu

Dopolnite pogovor z manjkajočimi besedami.

At a hotel
Guest: Good evening. 16 I check in, please?
Receptionist: Of course. 17 I see your passport, please?
Guest: Here you are. And 18 you mind giving me a room on a high floor?
Receptionist: Not at all. 19 I carry your bags to the lift?
Guest: Yes, please. That 20 be great.

E. Na vrsti ste vi

Pišite v angleščini vljudne prošnje in ponudbe.

  1. Napišite vljudno prošnjo sodelavcu, ki ga ne poznate dobro.
  2. Soseda nosi težke nakupovalne vrečke. Ponudite pomoč na dva različna načina.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.

  1. A2-04 Will in won't: odločitve, obljube in napovedi v angleščini
    The phone's ringing. "I answer it."
  2. A1-25 Like, want in would like v angleščini: I like cooking, I'd like a coffee
    … a cup of tea? I've just made some.
  3. A2-20 Must, have to, mustn't in don't have to: obveznost in prepoved v angleščini
    You smoke here. It's not allowed.
Rešitve

A. Oblika

  1. turning
  2. use
  3. to call
  4. Could you pass me the water, please? / Could you please pass me the water? / Could you pass me the water?
  5. May I come in?
  6. I was wondering if you could help me.

B. Pomen

  1. Could you
  2. Shall I
  3. No, not at all.
  4. Can I help you?
  5. I was wondering if you could check this.

C. Poiščite napako

  1. Would you mind helping me?
  2. Do you want me to call you later?
  3. Could you pass me the salt? / Can you pass me the salt? / Would you pass me the salt?
  4. ✓ Could I ask you a question?

D. V kontekstu

  1. Could / Can / May
  2. May / Could / Can
  3. would
  4. Shall / Can / Should
  5. would

E. Na vrsti ste vi

  1. Could you send me the report by Friday, please?
  2. Shall I carry one of those for you? Would you like me to open the door?

F. Mešano ponavljanje

  1. 'll / will
  2. Would you like
  3. mustn't / can't / must not / cannot
Aplikacija za AndroidUčite se na poti Google Play