Advanced modal meanings: will za domnevo, would za navado, won't za zavrnitev
Advanced Modal Meanings
Na tej strani
Cilj
Po tej lekciji boste z will in would znali izraziti samozavestno domnevo (That'll be the postman. You'll have heard the news.), značilno vedenje in vztrajanje (He would say that.) ter zavrnitev (The door won't open.); uporabljali boste may / might / could well in may / might as well, za prihodnost pa izbirali med can in will be able to.
Glavna ideja
Naklonski glagol pokaže govorčev odnos: kako prepričan je, kako pripravljen je kdo kaj narediti, kaj je za koga značilno. Na ravneh B1–B2 ste spoznali osnovne naloge will in would. Na ravni C1 za mnogimi rabami vidite eno samo jedro.
Predstavljajte si will kot krog gotovosti: „tako je – prepričan sem“. Ta gotovost lahko kaže v prihodnost (It'll rain), v sedanjost (That'll be Ella – prepričan sem, ne da bi preveril), v preteklost (You'll have heard – prepričan sem, da se je že zgodilo), na značaj (She'll talk for hours) ali na voljo (He won't listen – noče). Would je isti krog, le korak dlje: v preteklosti ali malo manj gotovo.
Zato se ne učite dolgega seznama pomenov. Vprašajte se: o čem je govorec prepričan – ali kdo česa noče narediti?
Slovenščina in angleščina
Tu imate prednost: tudi slovenski prihodnjik izraža domnevo o sedanjosti. „Nekdo zvoni. To bo soseda.“ „Zdaj bo že spal.“ „Stara bo kakih štirideset let.“ Tu je enako: That'll be my neighbour. He'll be asleep now. She'd be about forty. Domnevo o preteklosti slovenščina navadno izrazi s prihodnjikom dovršnega glagola in prislovom „že“: „Film se bo že začel“, „Paket bo že prišel“. Prav tu je past: „bo prišel“ je oblika, ki jo poznamo kot prihodnjik, zato mnogi rečejo will arrive. Za končano dejanje angleščina potrebuje will have + pretekli deležnik.
Pri zavrnitvi rečemo „noče“ – za ljudi in za stroje: „Otroci nočejo jesti zelenjave“, „Računalnik se noče prižgati.“ Angleščina v obeh primerih reče won't, za preteklost wouldn't. „Bom lahko“ pa ni will can: can nima prihodnjika, zato je will be able to. Značilno vedenje slovenščina izrazi s sedanjikom in prislovom („Vedno pusti mokre brisače na tleh“), ogorčenje pa z intonacijo („Seveda, kaj pa drugega bi rekel!“).
| Slovenščina | Angleščina | V čem je razlika? |
|---|---|---|
| Nekdo zvoni. To bo soseda. | That'll be my neighbour. | domneva o sedanjosti s prihodnjikom; tu je enako |
| Ura je pol desetih, film se bo že začel. | The film will have started by now. | „bo že“ + dovršni glagol → will have + pretekli deležnik |
| Moj prenosnik se noče prižgati. | My laptop won't turn on. | „noče“ (tudi za stroje) → won't, ne doesn't want to |
| Trikrat sem ga vprašal, pa mi ni hotel povedati. | … he wouldn't tell me. | „ni hotel“ (zavrnitev) → wouldn't |
| Seveda, kaj pa drugega bi rekel! | Well, he would say that, wouldn't he? | poudarjeni would: tipično zanj |
| Pozneje bo zelo verjetno deževalo. | It may well rain later. | „zelo verjetno“ → may / might / could well |
| Zadnji avtobus je odpeljal, lahko kar gremo peš. | We might as well walk. | „lahko kar“ (ni boljše možnosti) → might as well |
| Po tem tečaju boste lahko brali pogodbe. | You'll be able to read contracts. | „bom lahko“ → will be able to, nikoli will can |
Na kratko: slovenski „bo“ za domnevo deluje kot will, „bo že prišel“ pa je will have arrived; „noče“ je won't, „bom lahko“ je will be able to.
Oblika
Will in would: sedanjost in preteklost
| Pomen | O sedanjosti / na splošno | O preteklosti |
|---|---|---|
| domneva | That'll be Ella. | You'll have heard the news. |
| previdna domneva | She'd be about forty now. | That would have been in 2015. |
| značilno vedenje / vztrajanje | He will interrupt people. | She would keep calling me. |
| zavrnitev | The car won't start. | He wouldn't tell me why. |
Stalne zveze z naklonskimi glagoli
| Zveza | Pomen | Pretekla oblika |
|---|---|---|
| may / might / could well + osnovna oblika glagola | precej verjetno je | may/might/could well have + pretekli deležnik |
| may / might as well + osnovna oblika glagola | boljše možnosti ni, zato … | might as well have + pretekli deležnik (= bilo je zaman) |
Can in be able to za prihodnost
| Oblika | Raba |
|---|---|
| can | dogovori in odločitve, sprejete zdaj: I can see you on Friday. |
| will be able to | nova sposobnost ali možnost v prihodnosti: You'll be able to drive. |
| naklonski glagol + be able to | za drugim naklonskim glagolom: I might be able to come. |
Raba
1Domneva o sedanjosti: will + osnovna oblika glagola
Z will (navadno 'll) povemo, kaj samozavestno mislimo, da zdaj drži – na podlagi tega, kar vemo, ne da bi preverili. Zveni mirno in logično. Would domnevo omehča, pogosto pri ocenah. Samo ta lekcija uči domnevni will. Slovenski prihodnjik ima isto vlogo: „To bo soseda.“
2Domneva o preteklosti: will have + pretekli deležnik
Will have + pretekli deležnik izraža samozavestno prepričanje, da se je nekaj že zgodilo, pogosto z by now ali already. V slovenščini rečemo „bo že“ + dovršni glagol ali „gotovo je že“. Would have je previdnejša različica za ocene. (Future Perfect (prihodnji perfekt) za prihodnji čas je v B2-01.)
3Značilno vedenje in vztrajanje: will in would
Will opisuje značilno vedenje v sedanjosti, would v preteklosti (B2-17). Ko sta will ali would poudarjena, izražata kritiko: oseba vztraja pri nečem nadležnem. He would say that (poudarjeni would) pomeni „točno to bi od njega pričakovali, tak je pač“. You would! pomeni „to je čisto tebi podobno“. Slovenščina to izrazi s prislovi („vedno“, „pač“) in intonacijo.
4Zavrnitev: won't in wouldn't
Won't (sedanjost) in wouldn't (preteklost, enkrat ali večkrat) pokažeta, da oseba noče nečesa narediti. Tudi stroji in predmeti lahko „nočejo“, kot da bi imeli svojo voljo – tako kot v slovenščini.
5May / might / could well in may / might as well
May well, might well in could well pomenijo „precej verjetno je“ – močneje kot sam may. May as well in might as well pomenita „boljše možnosti ni, zato kar“ – malo nejevoljen predlog, kot naše „lahko kar“. Might as well have + pretekli deležnik pove, da je bilo preteklo dejanje zaman. Za druge izraze verjetnosti glejte B2-26.
6Can in will be able to za prihodnost
Can uporabite za prihodnost, ko se nečesa zdaj dogovorite ali odločite. Will be able to uporabite za sposobnost ali možnost, ki je še ni, a bo. Za drugim naklonskim glagolom vedno stoji be able to. V slovenščini je oboje „bom lahko“, zato se ravnajte po pomenu. Za be able to v drugih časih glejte A2-24.
Pogoste napake
Pasti za govorce slovenščine
1. „Bo že prišel“ → will arrive. Slovenska domneva o preteklosti ima obliko prihodnjika: „Vlak bo že prispel“, „Do zdaj bo že končala“. Ker „bo prispel“ poznamo kot prihodnost, mnogi rečejo will arrive. Toda dejanje je po vašem prepričanju že končano, zato angleščina potrebuje will have + pretekli deležnik.
2. „Bom lahko“ → will can. „Lahko“ je v slovenščini prislov, zato se „bom lahko“ zdi kot will + can. Can pa nima prihodnjika in ne stoji za drugim naklonskim glagolom. Za novo sposobnost ali možnost v prihodnosti rečemo will be able to.
3. „Ko bo …, bomo lahko“ → once … will. Slovenščina ima prihodnjik v obeh delih: „Ko bo prenova končana, bomo lahko …“. V angleščini za once, when, as soon as in if stoji sedanjik, will be able to pa samo v glavnem stavku.
4. „Zapornica se ni hotela dvigniti“ → didn't want to. Slovenski „noče“ uporabljamo za ljudi in stroje. Angleški doesn't want to govori o želji, zato pri stroju zveni kot šala. Ko se stroj ali predmet „ne da“, angleščina reče won't, za preteklost pa wouldn't.
Ne zamenjujte
may well in may as well – May well = precej verjetno je. May as well = nič boljšega ne moremo narediti, zato kar.
domnevni will in prihodnji will – Domnevni will govori o sedanjosti ali preteklosti, prihodnji will o pozneje (A2-04). V slovenščini je oboje „bo“.
won't (prihodnost) in won't (zavrnitev) – Katero je katero, pove sobesedilo in naglas. Won't za zavrnitev je navadno poudarjen in pogosto ga spremlja pritožba.
Pravopis in izgovorjava
- That'll /ˈðætl/ in it'll /ˈɪtl/ sta v govoru običajna, v pisanju pa neformalna. Pri /ð/ je konica jezika med zobmi, ne izgovorite slovenskega d; /æ/ izgovorite z usti, odprtimi kot za a, in jezikom naprej kot za e.
- Will have je v govoru navadno skrčen: You'll have heard /juːl əv hɜːd/. Šibki /ə/ je slovenski polglasnik. /ɜː/ v heard je nov glas: jezik na sredini ust, ustnice sproščene.
- Naglas spremeni pomen: He'll leave his towels on the floor (nevtralna navada) in He will leave his towels on the floor (kritika). Poudarjene oblike nikoli ne skrajšamo.
- Won't /wəʊnt/ (UK), /woʊnt/ (US) se rima z don't; drugačen je want /wɒnt/ (UK), /wɑːnt/ (US). Na začetku zaokrožite ustnice kot za u – ne izgovorite slovenskega v.
- V may as well in might as well je as šibek: /əz/, z zvenečim z na koncu.
Zlato pravilo
Will in would izražata gotovost in voljo: zanesljivo domnevo o sedanjosti (will) ali preteklosti (will have + pretekli deležnik), značilno navado, vztrajanje ali zavrnitev. Would je bolj oddaljena ali previdnejša različica. May well = verjetno; may as well = boljše možnosti ni. In pozor: „bo že prišel“ je will have arrived, „bom lahko“ je will be able to.
Vaje
A. Oblika
Vsako poved prepišite z danim naklonskim glagolom ali zvezo. Ohranite pomen.
-
Prepišite z domnevnim "will": I'm sure that's the postman at the door.
-
Prepišite z "will have": I assume you've heard that Marco is leaving.
-
Prepišite z "won't": The car refuses to start, however often I try.
-
Prepišite z "might as well": There's no better option than walking, because the last bus has gone.
-
Prepišite s "could well": It's quite likely that the new rules will affect small businesses.
-
Prepišite z "might as well": Nobody listened to me, so it was pointless for me to go to the meeting.
-
Prepišite z "might" in "be able to": Perhaps it will be possible for me to leave early on Friday.
B. Pomen
Preberite opis položaja in izberite boljšo poved.
-
Prijatelj vam pove, da je vodja za zamudo okrivil nekoga drugega. Mislite, da je to zanj značilno. Kateri odgovor ustreza?poudarjeni would: točno to bi od njega pričakovali
-
Trgovine so zaprte in drugega ni za početi. Kateri predlog ustreza?may as well = ni boljše možnosti; may well = verjetno je
-
Prijatelja opozarjate, da je dež precej verjeten. Katera poved to pove?might well = precej verjetno
-
Učitelj opisuje novo znanje, ki ga bodo udeleženci imeli po tečaju. Katera poved ustreza temu pomenu?nova sposobnost v prihodnosti zahteva will be able to; can za prihodnost velja za dogovore
-
Katera poved opisuje zavrnitev in ne preproste prihodnosti?won't kot zavrnitev, s pritožbo
C. Poiščite napako
V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.
-
When I finish this course next summer, I will can read most technical documents in English without a dictionary.
-
It's already half past nine, so the film will start by now; let's wait for the next showing instead.
-
The kids are bored and it's still raining, so we may as well to take them to the cinema this afternoon.
-
I'm sure you'll have see the plans for the new office, so I won't go through them in detail today.
-
I can meet you for lunch on Friday, but I'll need to leave by two for a meeting with a client.
D. V kontekstu
Preberite e-sporočilo in oštevilčene povedi prepišite s pomeni naklonskih glagolov iz te lekcije.
Hi Nadia,
(18) I'm sure you have already heard that we've changed suppliers. (19) The new company has an annoying habit: it sends things late every single month. (20) I phoned them twice this morning, but they refused to give me a delivery date. (21) I'm confident that the van is stuck in traffic at this moment, as the motorway is closed. (22) It's quite likely that the delivery will be delayed until next week. (23) There's no better option, so let's postpone the training session. (24) Once the new system is set up, it will be possible for us to track every order online.
Best,
Owen
-
Prepišite (18) z "will have".
-
Prepišite (19) kot eno poved s poudarjenim "will" za nadležno navado.
-
Prepišite (20) z "wouldn't".
-
Prepišite (21) z domnevnim "will".
-
Prepišite (22) z "may well", "might well" ali "could well".
-
Prepišite (23) z "might as well" ali "may as well".
-
Prepišite (24) z "be able to".
E. Na vrsti ste vi
Pišite v angleščini.
-
Povejte, kaj trije ljudje, ki jih poznate, zdaj verjetno počnejo ali so že naredili. Vsaj dvakrat uporabite domnevni will (+ osnovna oblika ali + be + -ing) in enkrat will have + pretekli deležnik.
-
V 2–3 povedih se pritožite nad nadležno navado nekoga. Enkrat uporabite poudarjeni will za sedanjost in enkrat poudarjeni would za preteklost.
-
Načrti so vam padli v vodo (odpovedan vlak, zaprta restavracija). Napišite 2–3 povedi: en nejevoljen predlog z might as well, en verjeten izid z may well ali could well in eno prihodnjo možnost z will be able to.
F. Mešano ponavljanje
Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.
-
B2-06 Must have, can't have, might have: sklepanje o preteklosti v angleščini Prepišite s preteklim naklonskim glagolom za sklepanje: I'm almost certain she left her phone at home.
-
B2-17 Navade v angleščini: would, will, used to in always + -ing Katera poved opisuje prijeten spomin na preteklo navado?would + osnovna oblika za ponavljajoča se pretekla dejanja
-
C1-08 Hedging: It seems that, apparently, allegedly – previdno izražanje v angleščini Prepišite manj gotovo, z "appear": The results prove that the drug works.
Rešitve
A. Oblika
- That'll be the postman at the door.
- You'll have heard that Marco is leaving.
- The car won't start, however often I try.
- The last bus has gone, so we might as well walk. / We might as well walk, because the last bus has gone.
- The new rules could well affect small businesses.
- Nobody listened to me, so I might as well not have gone to the meeting. / Nobody listened to me, so I might as well have stayed at home.
- I might be able to leave early on Friday.
B. Pomen
- Well, he would say that, wouldn't he?
- The shops are shut, so we may as well go home.
- Take an umbrella; it might well rain later.
- After this course, you'll be able to read contracts in English.
- She won't answer her phone; I've called five times.
C. Poiščite napako
- When I finish this course next summer, I'll be able to read most technical documents in English without a dictionary.
- It's already half past nine, so the film will have started by now; let's wait for the next showing instead. / It's already half past nine, so the film must have started by now; let's wait for the next showing instead.
- The kids are bored and it's still raining, so we may as well take them to the cinema this afternoon.
- I'm sure you'll have seen the plans for the new office, so I won't go through them in detail today.
- ✓ I can meet you for lunch on Friday, but I'll need to leave by two for a meeting with a client.
D. V kontekstu
- You'll have heard that we've changed suppliers. / You'll already have heard that we've changed suppliers.
- The new company will send things late every single month.
- I phoned them twice this morning, but they wouldn't give me a delivery date.
- The van will be stuck in traffic at the moment, as the motorway is closed.
- The delivery may well be delayed until next week. / The delivery might well be delayed until next week. / The delivery could well be delayed until next week.
- We might as well postpone the training session. / We may as well postpone the training session.
- Once the new system is set up, we'll be able to track every order online.
E. Na vrsti ste vi
- It's nearly midnight in Seoul, so my cousin will be asleep. My parents will be watching the news, as they always do at this time. My sister will have finished her last exam by now.
- My flatmate will leave his dirty dishes in the sink for days. His last flatmate told me he would do exactly the same in their old place.
- Our train's been cancelled, so we might as well have dinner here at the station. The next one could well be full. If we book online now, though, we'll be able to get seats on the eight o'clock.
F. Mešano ponavljanje
- She must have left her phone at home.
- When I was a child, my grandfather would tell us stories every evening.
- The results appear to show that the drug works. / The results appear to suggest that the drug works. / It appears that the drug works.
