SlowingoGramatika
B1 13 / 39

Reported speech: indirektni govor na engleskom (said, told, slaganje vremena)

Reported Speech: Statements

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Srpski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Upotreba
  6. Česte greške
  7. Zamke za govornike srpskog
  8. Ne mešajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vežbe

Cilj

Posle ove lekcije moći ćete da prenesete šta je neko rekao – She said (that) she was tired – pravilno menjajući vremena, zamenice i reči za vreme, i znaćete kada vreme ne mora da se menja.

Osnovna ideja

Kada prenosite nečije reči, ne puštate snimak. Prenosite poruku – sa svog mesta: iz svog vremena, svog mesta i svog ugla.

Zamislite da je Marija u ponedeljak rekla: "I'm tired. I'll call you tomorrow." U petak to pričate drugarici. Ponedeljak je sada u prošlosti, pa se ceo razgovor pomera jedan korak unazad u vremenu: Maria said she was tired and would call me the next day. Taj korak unazad zove se backshift (pomeranje vremena unazad).

I sve ostalo prelazi na vaš ugao. Njeno I postaje she, njeno you postaje me, njeno tomorrow postaje the next day – jer „sutra“ iz ponedeljka nije „sutra“ iz petka.

Ali backshift nije pravilo za robote. Ako je ono što je rekla i dalje tačno, ili prenosite nešto što je rečeno pre trenutak, možete da zadržite prvobitno vreme. Uvek se pitajte: kako to izgleda odavde, gde sam sada?

Srpski i engleski

U srpskom indirektnom govoru vreme ostaje kakvo je bilo u originalu: „Umorna sam“ → „Rekla je da je umorna“; „Pozvaću te“ → „Rekao je da će me pozvati.“ Engleski posle said obično pomera vreme jedan korak unazad: she was tired, he would call me. Zato govornicima srpskog backshift ne dolazi prirodno. Dobra vest: zamenice i reči za vreme menjamo i na srpskom („sutra“ → „sutradan“, „ovde“ → „tamo“). I još jedna sličnost: ni srpski ni engleski ne stavljaju zarez ispred „da“ / that. Razlika je kod glagola: srpsko „rekao mi je“ ima osobu odmah posle glagola, a englesko said ne može – tu je told me.

SrpskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Rekla je da je baš zauzeta.She said she was really busy.srpski zadržava vreme; engleski pomera unazad
Rekao je da će mi poslati detalje.He said he would send me the details.„da će“ → would
Rekla je da ne može da dođe na žurku.She said she couldn't come to the party.„ne može“ → couldn't
Rekao je da nikad nije bio u Aziji.He said he had never been to Asia.srpski perfekat → Past Perfect; samo jedna negacija
Instruktor je rekao da moramo da nosimo kacigu.The instructor said we had to wear a helmet.„moramo“ → had to
Lekar je rekao da treba da odmaram.The doctor said I should rest.ovde je isto: should se ne menja
Rekla je da će se videti sa mnom sutradan.She said she would see me the next day.ovde je slično: i srpski menja „sutra“ u „sutradan“
Rekao je da je počeo da radi dve godine ranije.He said he had started the job two years before.„ranije“ → before; „pre“ računato od danas → ago
Rekla mi je da je umorna.She told me she was tired.„rekla mi je“ → told me, ne said me
Džejk kaže da kasni.Jake says he's running late.ovde je isto: says → vreme se ne menja

Ukratko: posle said engleski obično pomera vreme unazad, iako srpski zadržava ono iz originala. „Rekao mi je“ = told me.

Oblik

Osnovna šema

Glagol govorenja(that)prenesena rečenica
She said(that)she was hungry.
He told me(that)he had lost his keys.

That nije obavezno i u govoru se često izostavlja. Say i tell imaju različite šeme: pogledajte B1-13.

Backshift – promena vremena posle glagola govorenja u prošlosti

Direktni govorIndirektni govor
Present Simple: "I work in a bank."Past Simple: She said she worked in a bank.
Present Continuous: "I'm leaving."Past Continuous: He said he was leaving.
Present Perfect: "I've finished."Past Perfect: She said she had finished.
Past Simple: "I saw it."Past Perfect: He said he had seen it. (moguće je i saw)
will: "I'll help."would: She said she would help.
can: "I can swim."could: He said he could swim.
may: "It may rain."might: She said it might rain.
must (obaveza): "I must go."had to: He said he had to go. (moguće je i must)
am / is / are going to: "We're going to move."was / were going to: They said they were going to move.

Bez promene: would, could, should, might, ought to i Past Perfect ostaju isti.

Zamenice i prisvojni oblici – promenite ih tako da odgovaraju uglu onoga ko prenosi.

Direktni govorIndirektni govor
"I love my job." (Tom)Tom said he loved his job.
"We'll meet you at our house." (vaši roditelji, vama)They said they would meet me at their house.

Reči za vreme i mesto (kada su vreme ili mesto sada drugačiji)

Direktni govorIndirektni govor
nowthen, at that time
today / tonightthat day / that night
yesterdaythe day before, the previous day
tomorrowthe next day, the following day
last weekthe week before, the previous week
next monththe following month
… ago… before, … earlier
herethere
this / thesethat / those (ili the)

Upotreba

1Backshift posle said

Kada je glagol govorenja u prošlosti (said, told), pomerite vreme jedan korak unazad. Srpski tu zadržava vreme iz originala.

She said she was really busy.
Rekla je da je baš zauzeta.
srpski „je“, engleski was
They said they were looking for a new flat.
Rekli su da traže novi stan.
„traže“ → were looking
He said he had never been to Asia.
Rekao je da nikad nije bio u Aziji.
srpski perfekat → had been; samo jedna negacija
She said she had missed the train.
Rekla je da je propustila voz.
moguće je i „she missed“

2Modalni glagoli u indirektnom govoru

Will → would, can → could, may → might, a must (obaveza) → had to. Would, could, should, might i ought to se ne menjaju.

He said he would send me the details.
Rekao je da će mi poslati detalje.
„da će“ → would
She said she couldn't come to the party.
Rekla je da ne može da dođe na žurku.
„ne može“ → couldn't
He said the shop might be closed.
Rekao je da je prodavnica možda zatvorena.
may → might
The instructor said we had to wear a helmet.
Instruktor je rekao da moramo da nosimo kacigu.
„moramo“ → had to
The doctor said I should rest.
Lekar je rekao da treba da odmaram.
should se ne menja

3Promena zamenica i prisvojnih oblika

Prenosite iz svog ugla. Pitajte se: ko sada govori, a ko sluša? Ovo radi isto kao na srpskom.

My boss said she liked my haircut.
Šefica je rekla da joj se sviđa moja frizura.
"I like your haircut." → she liked my haircut
Our neighbours said they had sold their car.
Komšije su rekle da su prodale auto.
"We've sold our car."
He said I was his best friend.
Rekao je da sam mu ja najbolji prijatelj.
"You're my best friend."

4Promena reči za vreme i mesto

Ako su vreme ili mesto drugačiji kada prenosite, promenite reči kao što su today, tomorrow, ago, here. Srpski i tu menja reči („sutradan“, „tamo“), ali „pre“ lako ostane.

She said she would see me the next day.
Rekla je da će se videti sa mnom sutradan.
tomorrow → the next day
He said he had started the job two years before.
Rekao je da je na tom poslu počeo dve godine ranije.
ago → before
She said she was staying there that night.
Rekla je da te noći ostaje tamo.
here → there, tonight → that night
He said the parcel had arrived the day before.
Rekao je da je paket stigao dan ranije.
yesterday → the day before

5Bez backshift – i dalje važi, ili je upravo rečeno

Ako je informacija i sada tačna, možete da zadržite prvobitno vreme. To je vrlo često u govoru – i tu engleski radi kao srpski. I backshift je tačan.

She said she lives in Glasgow.
Rekla je da živi u Glazgovu.
i dalje živi tamo
Our teacher said the Earth goes round the Sun.
Nastavnik je rekao da se Zemlja okreće oko Sunca.
opšta istina
I said it's at three!
Rekao sam da je u tri!
ponavljamo ono što je rečeno pre trenutak

6Glagol govorenja u sadašnjem vremenu – bez backshift

Ako je glagol govorenja u sadašnjem vremenu (says, has said), vremena se ne menjaju. To je često kod poruka i beležaka.

Jake says he's running late.
Džejk kaže da kasni.
says → bez promene
The weather forecast says it'll be sunny all week.
Prognoza kaže da će cele nedelje biti sunčano.
Mum has said she can't come this weekend.
Mama je javila da ne može da dođe ovog vikenda.

Česte greške

❌She said me she was tired.
✅She told me she was tired.
Posle say ne dolazi osoba: She said she was tired. Pogledajte B1-13.
❌He said he has finished it last week.
✅He said he had finished it last week. ili He said he finished it last week.
Završeno vreme (last week) nikad ne ide sa Present Perfect: pomerite u Past Perfect ili zadržite Past Simple.
❌He said that he will call me, but he never did.
✅He said that he would call me, but he never did.
will → would; poziv više nije u budućnosti.
❌They said they must to leave.
✅They said they had to leave.
must → had to; nikad „must to“.
❌A year ago he said he had started the job two years ago.
✅A year ago he said he had started the job two years before.
ago se računa od sada; before se računa od trenutka u prošlosti.
❌Last month she said she would come tomorrow.
✅Last month she said she would come the next day.
Njeno „sutra“ nije sutra od danas.
❌She said, she was hungry.
✅She said she was hungry.
Bez zareza ispred prenesene rečenice.

Zamke za govornike srpskog

1. Srpski zadržava vreme → will posle said. Na srpskom kažemo: „U hotelu su nam rekli da će soba biti spremna u dva, pa smo do tada čekali u holu.“ „Da će“ ostaje, pa se na engleskom lako pojavi will. Kada to više nije u budućnosti, engleski traži would. Isto važi za druge glagole: ako nešto više nije tačno, vreme se pomera unazad.

❌The hotel said the room will be ready at two, so we waited in the lobby until then.
✅The hotel said the room would be ready at two, so we waited in the lobby until then.
will → would
⚠️When we met in 2018, Jelena told me she lives with her parents. Now she has her own flat.
✅When we met in 2018, Jelena told me she lived with her parents. Now she has her own flat.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali lives znači da to i sada važi, a više ne važi.

2. „Da li ti je rekla?“ → say + osoba. Srpski glagol „reći“ ima osobu odmah uz sebe: „Da li ti je Teodora rekla zašto je otišla sa žurke tako rano?“ Engleski say ne može da ima osobu posle sebe. Koristite tell + osoba, ili say bez osobe (ili sa to).

❌Did Teodora say you why she left the party so early?
✅Did Teodora tell you why she left the party so early? ili Did Teodora say why she left the party so early?
„rekla ti je“ → told you

3. „Pre dve godine“ u prenesenom govoru → ago. Srpsko „pre“ znači i ago i before. Ali ago se uvek računa od današnjeg dana. Kada prenosite nešto rečeno ili napisano davno, za vreme računato od tog trenutka koristite before ili earlier.

❌In her diary from 1990, my grandmother wrote that she had met my grandfather two years ago.
✅In her diary from 1990, my grandmother wrote that she had met my grandfather two years before. ili …two years earlier.
računamo od 1990. godine → before

Ne mešajte

Direktni i indirektni govor – Direktni govor ponavlja tačne reči pod navodnicima; indirektni ih prepričava sa promenama. Obratite pažnju na interpunkciju: srpski ima dve tačke i „…“, a engleski zarez i "…".

Ana said, "I'm hungry."
Ana je rekla: „Gladna sam.“
direktni govor
Ana said she was hungry.
Ana je rekla da je gladna.
indirektni govor

Backshift ili bez backshift – Oba mogu da budu tačna. Backshift samo prenosi; bez backshift pokazujete da verujete da je to i sada tačno.

He said he was a vegetarian.
Rekao je da je vegetarijanac.
prenosimo šta je tada rekao
He said he's a vegetarian, so let's not cook meat.
Rekao je da je vegetarijanac, pa hajde da ne kuvamo meso.
i sada važi, i važno je

must (obaveza) i must (zaključak) – Must kao obaveza često postaje had to. Must kao zaključak B1-16 ostaje must. Na srpskom: „mora da ide“ i „mora da je umoran“.

She said she had to leave early.
Rekla je da mora da ode ranije.
"I must leave early."
He said I must be tired.
Rekao je da mora da sam umoran.
"You must be tired."

Pravopis i izgovor

  • U indirektnom govoru nema navodnika ni zareza: She said she was tired. Isto kao na srpskom, gde ispred „da“ nema zareza.
  • U direktnom govoru engleski stavlja zarez ispred navodnika, a tačka ide unutar navodnika: She said, "I'm tired." Srpski ovde ima dve tačke: Rekla je: „Umorna sam.“
  • said se izgovara /sed/, sa kratkim e – ne čitajte ga kao „sejd“, kako je napisano.
  • that je u indirektnom govoru slabo: /ðət/. Glas /ð/ srpski nema: vrh jezika stavite između zuba i pustite glas. Nije ni d ni z.
  • 'd može da bude would ili had: She said she'd help (would) / She said she'd helped (had). Pogledajte glagol posle njega.

Zlatno pravilo

Prenosite iz svog vremena i mesta: posle glagola govorenja u prošlosti obično pomerite vreme jedan korak unazad i promenite zamenice i reči za vreme. Ako je i dalje tačno, ili je glagol govorenja u sadašnjem vremenu, možete da zadržite prvobitno vreme. I ne zaboravite: srpski ne pomera vreme – engleski obično da.

Vežbe

A. Oblik

U zadacima 1–6 pomerite vreme unazad (backshift).

  1. "I'm cold." → She said she cold.
  2. "We've finished the project." → They said they the project.
  3. "I'll text you." → He said he me.
  4. "I can't find my keys." → She said she her keys.
  5. "I may be late." → He said he late.
  6. "I'm watching a film." → She said she a film.
  7. Prenesite sa said: "I love my new job." (vaša sestra)

B. Značenje

Izaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. U ponedeljak je Tom rekao: "I'll do it tomorrow." Sada je petak. Dopunite: Tom said he would do it .
  2. Drugarica je ovo rekla pre pet minuta: "The film starts at eight." Dopunite: She said the film at eight.
  3. "I'm a vegetarian," said Sam last year, and he still is. Koji prenos je tačan?
  4. "You must be tired," the nurse said to me. Prenesite: The nurse said I tired.

C. Pronađite grešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna greška ili je rečenica tačna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. He said me that he was ill.
  2. She said she will come, but she didn't.
  3. They said they must to go home.
  4. The forecast says it will rain tomorrow.

D. U kontekstu

U svakom zadatku pomerite vreme unazad.

Lunch with Clara
I had lunch with Clara yesterday. She said she 16 (be) really happy at her new company. She told me she 17 (just / get) a promotion! She said they 18 (send) her to New York the following month, and that she 19 (can) take her family with her. She also said she 20 (call) me when she got there.

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom šta su vam drugi rekli.

  1. Setite se nečega što vam je prijatelj rekao prošle nedelje. Prenesite to sa said.
  2. Prenesite današnju poruku sa says.
Решења

A. Oblik

  1. was
  2. had finished / 'd finished
  3. would text / 'd text
  4. couldn't find / could not find
  5. might be
  6. was watching
  7. My sister said she loved her new job. / My sister said that she loved her new job. / My sister said she loves her new job. / My sister said that she loves her new job.

B. Značenje

  1. the next day / the following day / on Tuesday
  2. starts / started
  3. both
  4. must be

C. Pronađite grešku

  1. He told me that he was ill. / He said that he was ill. / He told me he was ill. / He said he was ill.
  2. She said she would come, but she didn't. / She said she'd come, but she didn't.
  3. They said they had to go home. / They said they must go home.
  4. ✓ The forecast says it will rain tomorrow.

D. U kontekstu

  1. was
  2. had just got / had just gotten / 'd just got / 'd just gotten
  3. were sending / were going to send / would send
  4. could
  5. would call / 'd call

E. Vaš red

  1. My friend Leo said he was going to move to Madrid.
  2. My brother says he can't come to dinner tonight.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

  1. had already left / 'd already left
  2. did you call
  3. was built
  4. were
Android апликацијаУчите у покрету Google Play