SlowingoGramatika
C1 16 / 20

Advanced relative clauses: to whom, whereby, in which case, whatever, all of whom – napredne odnosne rečenice

Advanced Relative Clauses

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Srpski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Upotreba
  6. Česte greške
  7. Zamke za govornike srpskog
  8. Ne mešajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vežbe

Cilj

Posle ove lekcije moći ćete da koristite formalne odnosne strukture – to whom, the extent to which, whereby, in which case, by which time, at which point – i odnosne rečenice koje rade kao imenica, kao što su what, whatever i whoever, i da odnosne rečenice kombinujete sa infinitivom i rečima za količinu.

Osnovna ideja

Odnosna rečenica je kukica: na imenicu kači dodatnu informaciju. U svakodnevnom engleskom predlog visi na kraju kukice: the person I spoke to. U formalnom engleskom predlog prelazi napred i drži se za odnosnu zamenicu: the person to whom I spoke. Značenje je isto; menja se samo stil.

Neke formalne odnosne reči kače se za celu ideju, a ne samo za jednu imenicu: The train may be cancelled, in which case we'll drive. Ovde which pokazuje unazad na celu situaciju – na to da voz bude otkazan.

Druge odnosne reči nose imenicu u sebi. What znači the thing that („ono što“); whoever znači any person who („ko god“). Kod ovih odnosnih rečenica cela rečenica radi kao imenica: What she said surprised me.

Srpski i engleski

Ovde srpski ima jednu veliku prednost: kod nas predlog uvek stoji ispred odnosne zamenice („ljudi s kojima radim“, „kuća u kojoj živimo“). Formalni engleski red reči (to whom, in which) zato vam zvuči prirodno. Problemi su drugde. Srpsko „koji“ ide i uz ljude i uz stvari, a engleski bira whom za ljude i which za stvari. Srpsko „što“ u „sve što“ i „ono što“ lako postane what tamo gde engleski traži that ili ništa. I navika da predlog ide napred lako se prenese na frazne glagole, gde engleski to ne dozvoljava.

SrpskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
osoba kojoj je pismo upućenothe person to whom this letter is addressedsrpski: padežni nastavak (dativ); engleski: to + whom napred
koleginice s kojima je radilathe colleagues with whom she had workedovde je isto: predlog napred; za ljude whom
istraživanje na kojem se zasniva teorijathe research on which the theory is based„koji“ za stvari → which
u kojoj meri san utiče na pamćenjethe extent to which sleep affects memoryustaljen izraz
program po kojem zaposleni mogu da kupe akcijea scheme whereby staff can buy sharesnačin, sistem → whereby
Let može da kasni, a u tom slučaju …The flight might be delayed, in which case …jedna rečenica, posle zareza
Stigli smo u ponoć, a do tada je restoran već zatvorio.We got there at midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed.by which time + često Past Perfect
Ono što me je iznenadilo…What surprised me…„ono što“ = what, nikad that what
Sve što je rekao bilo je tačno.Everything (that) he said was true.posle everything: that ili ništa, ne what
Ko god je napravio ovu aplikaciju…Whoever designed this app…ovde je isto
tri brata, od kojih svi žive u inostranstvuthree brothers, all of whom live abroadovde je isto: „od kojih“ = of whom / of which
problem na koji sam naišaothe problem (that) I came acrossfrazni glagol: rečca ostaje uz glagol

Ukratko: srpski red reči („s kojima“, „u kojoj“) je isti kao formalni engleski; samo izaberite whom za ljude i which za stvari, ne prevodite „sve što“ kao everything what, a rečcu fraznog glagola ostavite uz glagol.

Oblik

Predlog + whom / which

Neformalno (predlog na kraju)Formalno (predlog napred)
the person (who) I spoke tothe person to whom I spoke
the company (that) she works forthe company for which she works
the colleagues (who) he relies onthe colleagues on whom he relies
the way (that) the system worksthe way in which the system works

Posle predloga koristite whom (ljudi) ili which (stvari), ili whose + imenica (the writer to whose work I referred). That ovde nikad nije moguće, a who posle predloga se izbegava u pažljivom engleskom.

Odnosne reči koje se kače za način, vreme ili celu situaciju

Odnosna rečZnačenjeOdnosi se na
wherebypo kojem / putem kojegsistem, način ili dogovor
in which casea ako se to desi, u tom slučajucelu prethodnu rečenicu
by which timea do tadavreme ili događaj
at which pointi u tom trenutkutrenutak ili događaj

Odnosne rečenice koje rade kao imenica (imenica je unutra)

Odnosna rečZnačenjePrimer
whatono štoWhat I need is sleep.
whateverbilo šta što, šta godTake whatever you want.
whoeverko god / onaj koWhoever finishes first wins.
whicheverkoji god (od ograničenog izbora)Choose whichever room you like.
wherever / whenevergde god / kad godSit wherever you like.

Odnosne rečenice sa infinitivom i rečima za količinu (ponavljanje)

ObrazacPrimer
imenica + infinitiv sa tothe person to contact
imenica + predlog + which/whom + infinitiv sa to (formalno)a place in which to live
reč za količinu + of + whom / whichall of which, neither of whom

Upotreba

1Predlog + whom / which

U formalnom pisanju predlog stavite ispred whom ili which – tačno kao u srpskom („s kojima“, „na kojem“). Neki izrazi gotovo uvek koriste ovaj obrazac: the extent to which, the speed at which, the way in which, the basis on which. Frazni glagoli to ne mogu: njihova rečca ostaje uz glagol (the problem I came across). Oba reda reči su tačna; birate prema stilu (C2-02).

The person to whom this letter is addressed no longer works here.
Osoba kojoj je ovo pismo upućeno više ne radi ovde.
This is the research on which the whole theory is based.
Ovo je istraživanje na kojem se zasniva cela teorija.
stvar → which
She thanked the colleagues with whom she had worked for twenty years.
Zahvalila se kolegama s kojima je radila dvadeset godina.
ljudi → whom
The study measures the extent to which sleep affects memory.
Studija meri u kojoj meri san utiče na pamćenje.
The speed at which technology changes can be overwhelming.
Brzina kojom se tehnologija menja ume da bude zastrašujuća.

2Whereby

Whereby znači by which ili through which – „po kojem“, „putem kojeg“. Uvodi način ili dogovor u okviru nekog sistema, programa, sporazuma ili procesa. Formalno je i često u poslovnom i akademskom pisanju.

The company has introduced a scheme whereby staff can buy shares at a discount.
Firma je uvela program po kojem zaposleni mogu da kupe akcije po povlašćenoj ceni.
The two sides reached an agreement whereby each would pay half the costs.
Dve strane su postigle dogovor po kojem će svaka platiti polovinu troškova.
Photosynthesis is the process whereby plants turn light into energy.
Fotosinteza je proces kojim biljke pretvaraju svetlost u energiju.

3In which case, by which time, at which point

Ovi izrazi pokazuju unazad na celu situaciju i dodaju ono što iz nje sledi. Dolaze posle zareza. In which case = ako se to desi („a u tom slučaju“); by which time = a pre tog trenutka („a do tada“, često sa Past Perfect (pluskvamperfekat)); at which point = i tačno u tom trenutku („i tada“, „na šta“). Srpski ovde obično počinje novu rečenicu ili dodaje „a“; engleski sve drži u jednoj rečenici.

The flight might be delayed, in which case we'll miss the connection.
Let može da kasni, a u tom slučaju ćemo propustiti presedanje.
You may find an error on the form, in which case please contact us immediately.
Ako na obrascu primetite grešku, u tom slučaju nas odmah kontaktirajte.
We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed.
Stigli smo tek u ponoć, a do tada je restoran već zatvorio.
Past Perfect: zatvorio je pre našeg dolaska
The talks went on until 3 a.m., by which time everyone was exhausted.
Pregovori su trajali do tri ujutru, a do tada su svi već bili iscrpljeni.
He started shouting, at which point security asked him to leave.
Počeo je da viče, na šta ga je obezbeđenje zamolilo da izađe.

4Odnosne rečenice kao imenice: what i reči na -ever

Ovakva odnosna rečenica sadrži sopstvenu imenicu, pa cela rečenica može da bude subjekat ili objekat. What = the thing(s) that, srpsko „ono što“ (B2-20). Oblici na -ever dodaju „bilo koji – nije važno koji“: „šta god“, „ko god“, „gde god“. Whichever je za ograničen izbor. Na početku rečenice whatever, whoever i wherever mogu da znače i no matter what / who / where (B2-23).

What surprised me most was how calm she stayed.
Ono što me je najviše iznenadilo bilo je koliko je ostala smirena.
what = ono što
I'll do what I can to help.
Uradiću sve što mogu da pomognem.
You can order whatever you like; it's my treat.
Naručite šta god želite, ja častim.
Whoever designed this app deserves an award.
Ko god je napravio ovu aplikaciju, zaslužuje nagradu.
Take whichever seat you prefer.
Sedite na koje god mesto želite.
od slobodnih mesta
Our dog follows me wherever I go.
Naš pas me prati gde god da idem.
Whatever happens, don't panic.
Šta god da se desi, ne paničite.
= no matter what happens

5Odnosne rečenice sa infinitivom (ponavljanje)

Odnosna rečenica može da se skrati na infinitiv sa to, naročito posle imenica koje izražavaju svrhu i posle first, last, only i superlativa (B2-09). U formalnom stilu ispred infinitiva može da stoji predlog + which / whom. Who i that nikad ne stoje ispred infinitiva.

If you have questions, the person to contact is Ms Patel.
Ako imate pitanja, obratite se gospođi Patel.
They're looking for a quiet place in which to live.
Traže mirno mesto za život.
formalno = a quiet place to live in
She felt she had nobody with whom to share her worries.
Osećala je da nema s kim da podeli svoje brige.
formalno = nobody to share them with
He was the last person to leave the building.
Poslednji je izašao iz zgrade.

6Reč za količinu + of whom / of which (ponavljanje)

Pomoću reči za količinu (all, some, most, many, neither, none, both, half) ili broja + of whom (ljudi) ili of which (stvari) govorite o delu grupe – kao srpsko „od kojih“. Ove odnosne rečenice ne određuju imenicu, pa stoje posle zareza (B2-08).

She has three brothers, all of whom live abroad.
Ima tri brata, od kojih svi žive u inostranstvu.
We received over 200 applications, most of which were excellent.
Dobili smo preko 200 prijava, od kojih je većina bila odlična.
I asked two mechanics, neither of whom could find the problem.
Pitao sam dvojicu automehaničara, a nijedan nije mogao da pronađe kvar.
The museum owns thousands of paintings, many of which have never been shown.
Muzej poseduje hiljade slika, od kojih mnoge nikad nisu bile izložene.

Česte greške

⚠️The man to who I spoke was very helpful.
✅The man to whom I spoke was very helpful. ili The man (who) I spoke to was very helpful.
who posle predloga ponekad se čuje u govoru, ali meša stilove: formalni obrazac traži whom.
❌The flat in that we live is rented.
✅The flat in which we live is rented. ili The flat (that) we live in is rented.
that ne može da stoji posle predloga.
❌This is the problem about which I came across.
✅This is the problem (that) I came across.
Frazni glagol zadržava svoju rečcu.
❌I have two sisters, both of them are doctors.
✅I have two sisters, both of whom are doctors. ili …sisters, and both of them are doctors.
Da biste spojili rečenice, upotrebite of whom.
❌Everything what he said was true.
✅Everything (that) he said was true.
Posle everything/all/something koristite that ili ništa, ne what.
❌The bus may be late, which case we'll walk.
✅The bus may be late, in which case we'll walk.
Ustaljeni izraz je in which case.
❌She needs a friend who to talk to.
✅She needs a friend to talk to. ili …a friend with whom to talk.
Nikad who ispred infinitiva.
❌Whatever you will decide, I'll support you.
✅Whatever you decide, I'll support you.
Posle whatever/whenever/wherever prezent za buduće značenje.

Zamke za govornike srpskog

1. „Koji“ za ljude → which. Srpsko „koji / kojoj / s kojima“ ide i uz ljude i uz stvari. U engleskom posle predloga za ljude dolazi whom, a za stvari which. Which za ljude je greška, i u formalnom i u neformalnom stilu.

❌The friends with which I share a flat are both medical students.
✅The friends with whom I share a flat are both medical students. ili The friends (who) I share a flat with are both medical students.
ljudi → whom
❌Our new neighbour, which moved in last week, is a piano teacher.
✅Our new neighbour, who moved in last week, is a piano teacher.
ljudi → who / whom, nikad which

2. „Sve što“, „ono što“ → everything what, that what. Srpsko „što“ posle „sve“ i „ono“ lako se prevede kao what. Ali posle all, everything, something, nothing engleski koristi that ili ništa, a „ono što“ je samo what – bez that ispred.

❌Luka spends all what he earns on concert tickets.
✅Luka spends all (that) he earns on concert tickets. ili Luka spends everything he earns on concert tickets.
posle all: that ili ništa
❌That what impressed the judges was her confidence on stage.
✅What impressed the judges was her confidence on stage.
„ono što“ = what

3. „Na koji sam naišao“ → predlog fraznog glagola napred. U srpskom predlog uvek ide ispred „koji“, pa se ta navika prenese i na frazne glagole. Ali rečca fraznog glagola (run into, come across, put up with) ne može da se odvoji od glagola i pređe napred.

❌Jelena is the old school friend into whom I ran at the station yesterday.
✅Jelena is the old school friend (who) I ran into at the station yesterday.
run into: rečca ostaje uz glagol

4. „Šta god budeš odlučio“ → whatever + will. Srpski posle „šta god“, „ko god“, „kad god“ za budućnost često koristi futur II („bude došao“, „budeš odlučio“). Engleski posle whatever, whoever, whenever, wherever za budućnost koristi prezent.

❌Whoever will arrive first tomorrow should switch on the heating.
✅Whoever arrives first tomorrow should switch on the heating.
whoever + prezent za budućnost

Ne mešajte

what i which (za celu rečenicu) – What sadrži svoju imenicu (= „ono što“). Which posle zareza komentariše celu prethodnu rečenicu („što je…“, „a to je…“) (B2-08).

What she said made everyone laugh.
Ono što je rekla nasmejalo je sve.
what = ono što
She told a joke, which made everyone laugh.
Ispričala je vic, što je sve nasmejalo.
which = a to

whereby i where – Where je za mesto (stvarno ili apstraktno); whereby je za način ili dogovor.

This is the office where I first worked.
Ovo je kancelarija u kojoj sam prvi put radio.
mesto
We have a system whereby new staff are paired with a mentor.
Imamo sistem po kojem novi zaposleni dobijaju mentora.
način

whoever i who – Who traži imenicu ispred sebe (the person who…). Whoever sadrži imenicu u sebi, kao srpsko „ko god“.

The person who wins gets a free trip.
Osoba koja pobedi dobija besplatno putovanje.
Whoever wins gets a free trip.
Ko god pobedi, dobija besplatno putovanje.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • Whom /huːm/ zvuči kao who + m. Englesko h je mnogo slabije od srpskog h – samo lagan dah, bez trenja u grlu. Slovo w se ne izgovara.
  • Whereby je jedna reč, sa naglaskom na drugom slogu: /weəˈbaɪ/ (UK), /werˈbaɪ/ (US). Na početku je /w/: zaokružite usne, nije srpsko v.
  • Whatever, whoever, whichever, wherever, whenever pišu se kao jedna reč; naglasak je na -ev-: whatever.
  • What ever kao dve reči je naglašeno pitanje (What ever happened to him?), a ne odnosna rečenica – pogledajte C1-06.
  • Ispred in which case, by which time i at which point je kratka pauza, a u pisanju zarez.
  • U most of which, neither of whom naglasak je na reči za količinu: most of which; of je slabo /əv/.

Zlatno pravilo

U formalnom engleskom predlog možete da stavite napred, kao u srpskom; posle njega dolazi whom (ljudi) ili which (stvari) – nikad that. What i reči na -ever koristite kada je sama odnosna rečenica imenica („ono što“, „ko god“), ali posle everything nema what. Pomoću in which case, by which time i at which point novu rečenicu kačite za celu situaciju.

Vežbe

A. Oblik

Preoblikujte svaku rečenicu pomoću date strukture. Zadržite značenje.

  1. Preoblikujte formalno, sa predlogom ispred odnosne zamenice: The woman I sent the email to is my manager.
  2. Spojite u jednu rečenicu pomoću "whereby": The company has a new scheme. Under this scheme, staff can buy shares at a discount.
  3. Spojite u jednu rečenicu pomoću "in which case": The flight might be delayed. If that happens, we'll miss our connection.
  4. Spojite u jednu rečenicu pomoću "by which time": We didn't get there until midnight. The restaurant had already closed then.
  5. Spojite u jednu rečenicu pomoću "of whom": I asked two mechanics. Neither of them could find the problem.
  6. Počnite sa "Whoever": The person who designed this app deserves an award.
  7. Preoblikujte formalno, pomoću predloga + "whom" + infinitiv sa to: She felt she had nobody to share her worries with.

B. Značenje

Pročitajte situaciju i izaberite bolju rečenicu.

  1. Formalno pismo preporuke. Koja rečenica bolje odgovara stilu?
  2. Poruka prijatelju. Šta je prirodnije?
  3. Formalni dokument opisuje program mentorstva. Koja formulacija je preciznija?
  4. Novinski izveštaj opisuje šta se desilo na sastanku. Koja rečenica odgovara?
  5. Domaćin gostu pokazuje tri slobodne sobe. Koja rečenica najbolje odgovara?

C. Pronađite grešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna greška ili je rečenica tačna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, most of them had several years of experience in the industry.
  2. Everything what the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers.
  3. The house in that my grandparents lived for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family.
  4. Whatever you will decide about the job offer, your family and friends will support you all the way.
  5. The study measures the extent to which regular exercise improves sleep in adults over the age of sixty.

D. U kontekstu

Pročitajte mejl i preoblikujte delove sa brojevima u formalnijem, povezanijem stilu.

Interview invitation
Dear Ms Kovac,
(18) Thank you for your application. We received it on 3 May. (19) The panel has five members. All of them were impressed by your experience, and we would like to invite you to an interview. (20) We use a system. In this system, each candidate gives a ten-minute presentation. (21) Interviews end on 20 May. At that moment the panel will make its decision. (22) Please let us know if you cannot attend. If that happens, we will offer you another date. (23) You may bring any materials that you find useful. (24) The person you should send questions to is Mr Adebayo.
Yours sincerely,
Hana Iqbal
  1. Spojite (18) u jednu rečenicu sa odnosnom rečenicom koja ne određuje imenicu.
  2. Spojite prve dve rečenice u (19) pomoću "all of whom".
  3. Spojite (20) u jednu rečenicu pomoću "whereby".
  4. Spojite (21) pomoću "at which point".
  5. Spojite (22) pomoću "in which case".
  6. Preoblikujte (23) pomoću odnosne reči na -ever.
  7. Preoblikujte (24) formalno, pomoću "to whom".

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom formalne zahvalnice, planove i opise grupa.

  1. Napišite formalnu zahvalnicu nastavniku ili mentoru u 2–3 rečenice. Jednom upotrebite predlog + whom, a jednom the extent to which ili the way in which.
  2. Opišite u 2–3 rečenice plan koji bi mogao da propadne. Jednom upotrebite in which case, a jednom by which time ili at which point.
  3. Opišite u 2–3 rečenice grupu ljudi ili stvari koju poznajete. Upotrebite jednu reč za količinu + of whom / of which i jednu reč na -ever (whoever, whatever ili whichever).

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

Ponovite prethodne lekcije.

  1. B2-08 Non-defining relative clauses: odnosne rečenice sa zarezima na engleskom
    Spojite pomoću odnosne rečenice koja ne određuje imenicu: My sister is a chef. She lives in Rome.
  2. B2-20 Imeničke rečenice na engleskom: that, whether i what objašnjeno na srpskom
    Počnite sa "What": The thing that surprised me was her calm reaction.
  3. C1-13 Discourse markers: given that, hence, namely, albeit, in conclusion – uzrok, primer, dopuštanje i zaključak na engleskom
    Preoblikujte pomoću "albeit": The project was a success, although it was an expensive one.
Решења

A. Oblik

  1. The woman to whom I sent the email is my manager.
  2. The company has a new scheme whereby staff can buy shares at a discount.
  3. The flight might be delayed, in which case we'll miss our connection.
  4. We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed. / We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had already closed.
  5. I asked two mechanics, neither of whom could find the problem.
  6. Whoever designed this app deserves an award.
  7. She felt she had nobody with whom to share her worries.

B. Značenje

  1. She is someone on whom I have always been able to rely.
  2. Is that the guy you were telling me about?
  3. We have a system whereby new staff are paired with a mentor.
  4. The speaker began shouting, at which point security asked him to leave.
  5. You can take whichever room you prefer tonight.

C. Pronađite grešku

  1. We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, most of whom had several years of experience in the industry. / We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, and most of them had several years of experience in the industry.
  2. Everything the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers. / Everything that the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers.
  3. The house in which my grandparents lived for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family. / The house that my grandparents lived in for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family.
  4. Whatever you decide about the job offer, your family and friends will support you all the way.
  5. ✓ The study measures the extent to which regular exercise improves sleep in adults over the age of sixty.

D. U kontekstu

  1. Thank you for your application, which we received on 3 May.
  2. The panel has five members, all of whom were impressed by your experience, and we would like to invite you to an interview.
  3. We use a system whereby each candidate gives a ten-minute presentation.
  4. Interviews end on 20 May, at which point the panel will make its decision.
  5. Please let us know if you cannot attend, in which case we will offer you another date.
  6. You may bring whatever materials you find useful.
  7. The person to whom you should send questions is Mr Adebayo.

E. Vaš red

  1. I would like to thank Dr Novak, without whom I would never have finished this project. Her advice has changed the way in which I approach research.
  2. We're planning to leave at six, but the traffic may be heavy, in which case we'll take the train. Either way, we should arrive by eight, by which time the speeches will have started.
  3. Our team has six members, most of whom work from home. Whoever comes into the office first on Monday makes the coffee.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

  1. My sister, who lives in Rome, is a chef.
  2. What surprised me was her calm reaction.
  3. The project was a success, albeit an expensive one.
Android апликацијаУчите у покрету Google Play