SlowingoGramatika
B1 9 / 39

Should have, could have, might have: mal som, mohol som… po anglicky

Should Have, Could Have, Might Have

Na tejto stránke
  1. Cieľ
  2. Hlavná myšlienka
  3. Slovenčina a angličtina
  4. Tvar
  5. Použitie
  6. Časté chyby
  7. Pasce pre hovoriacich po slovensky
  8. Nepleťte si
  9. Pravopis a výslovnosť
  10. Zlaté pravidlo
  11. Cvičenia

Cieľ

Po tejto lekcii budete vedieť hovoriť o tom, čo v minulosti ľutujete a čo ste urobili zle (I should have left earlier), o premárnených šanciach (We could have won), vyčítať niečo iným (You could have told me!) a povedať, čo ste boli ochotní urobiť (I would have helped, but…).

Hlavná myšlienka

Po futbalovom zápase si hráči pozerajú záznam. Zastavia video a hovoria: „Tu som mal prihrať.“ „Tu sme mohli dať gól.“ Zápas je odohraný. Nič sa už nedá zmeniť. Ale porovnávajú to, čo sa stalo, s tým, čo bolo správne alebo čo bolo možné.

Presne to robí modálne sloveso + have + príčastie minulé. Pozerá sa späť na minulosť a porovnáva ju s inou verziou – zvyčajne s takou, ktorá sa nestala:

  • You should have called. → Zavolať bolo správne. Nezavolal si.
  • You could have called. → Zavolať bolo možné. Nezavolal si.
  • I would have called, but… → Bol som ochotný. Niečo mi zabránilo.

Tvar je vždy rovnaký. Modálne sloveso hovorí, aký úsudok robíte: správna vec, možná vec, alebo niečo, čo ste boli ochotní urobiť. S I tieto vety často vyjadrujú ľútosť. S you často vyčítajú.

Slovenčina a angličtina

Po slovensky tu najčastejšie použijeme minulý čas slovies „mať“ a „môcť“: „Mal som si nabiť mobil.“ „Mohol si mi zavolať!“ Angličtina má iný vzorec: modálne sloveso + have + príčastie minulé. Najväčšia pasca je „mal som“: nie je to I had to (to je povinnosť, ktorú ste splnili), ale I should have. A „nemal som“ nie je I didn't have to („nemusel som“), ale I shouldn't have. Dobrá správa: slovenčina rozlišuje „nemal som“ a „nemusel som“ rovnako ako angličtina shouldn't have a didn't have to.

„Mohol si mi zavolať“ je You could have called me – samotné You could call me hovorí o súčasnosti alebo budúcnosti. A ochotu, ktorej niečo zabránilo, vyjadríme spisovne „bol by som prišiel“, hovorovo len „prišiel by som“ – v angličtine je to vždy would have come.

SlovenčinaAngličtinaV čom je rozdiel?
Mal som si včera večer nabiť mobil.I should have charged my phone last night.„mal som“ + neurčitok → should have, nie had to
Nemali sme pred skúškou tak dlho ponocovať.We shouldn't have stayed up so late before the exam.„nemali sme“ → shouldn't have, nie didn't have to
Mohli sme ísť po diaľnici, ale vybrali sme si cestu pri pobreží.We could have taken the motorway, but we chose the coast road.„mohli sme“ → could have + príčastie minulé
Mohol si mi zavolať!You could have called me!výčitka → could have
Bol by som prišiel na tvoju oslavu, ale zasekol som sa v práci.I would have come to your party, but I was stuck at work.ochota v minulosti → would have
Mal by si jej zavolať.You should call her.rada teraz – tu je to rovnaké ako v A2-21
Mal si jej zavolať.You should have called her.„mal si“ (minulosť) → should have

Stručne: „mal som / nemal som / mohol som / bol by som“ = should have / shouldn't have / could have / would have + príčastie minulé.

Tvar

modálne sloveso + have + príčastie minulé

TvarVýznamČo sa naozaj staloPríklad
should have / ought to havebolo to správne („mal som“)zvyčajne: nestalo sa toYou should have warned me.
shouldn't have / ought not to havebolo to zlé („nemal som“)stalo sa toI shouldn't have eaten so much.
could havebolo to možné („mohol som“)zvyčajne: nestalo sa toWe could have won.
might have (výčitka)bolo by to bývalo milé / zdvorilénestalo sa toYou might have said thank you!
would havebol som ochotný („bol by som“)nestalo sa toI would have helped, but I was away.

Zápor a otázky

Príklad
Záporná vetaYou shouldn't have said that. / We couldn't have done more.
OtázkaShould I have told her? / What could we have done?
Krátke odpovedeShould I have called? — Yes, you should (have). / No, you shouldn't (have).

Skrátené a slabé tvary (v reči)

PísanéAko to často znie
should have / should've/ˈʃʊdəv/
could have / could've/ˈkʊdəv/
would have / would've/ˈwʊdəv/
shouldn't have/ˈʃʊdntəv/

Použitie

1Should have – ľútosť a výčitka

Should have použite pri správnej veci, ktorá sa nestala, a shouldn't have pri zlej veci, ktorá sa stala. S I alebo we vyjadruje ľútosť; s you alebo inými osobami výčitku. Ought to have znamená to isté, ale je menej časté a formálnejšie.

I should have charged my phone last night.
Mal som si včera večer nabiť mobil.
nenabil som ho; „mal som“ → should have
You should have asked me before you took my car.
Mal si sa ma opýtať, skôr ako si si zobral moje auto.
výčitka
We shouldn't have stayed up so late before the exam.
Nemali sme pred skúškou tak dlho ponocovať.
ponocovali sme; „nemali sme“ → shouldn't have
He shouldn't have shouted at the waiter.
Nemal na čašníka kričať.
The council ought to have repaired the road years ago.
Mesto malo tú cestu opraviť už pred rokmi.
formálnejšie: ought to have

2Could have – možnosť, ktorú nikto nevyužil

Could have použite pri niečom, čo bolo možné, ale nestalo sa: premárnená šanca alebo nebezpečenstvo, ktoré sa nenaplnilo.

We could have taken the motorway, but we chose the coast road.
Mohli sme ísť po diaľnici, ale vybrali sme si cestu pri pobreží.
motorway (UK) = highway (US)
She could have been a professional tennis player.
Mohla byť profesionálnou tenistkou.
mala talent, ale nestala sa ňou
It could have been much worse — at least nobody was hurt.
Mohlo to dopadnúť oveľa horšie. Aspoň sa nikomu nič nestalo.
nebezpečenstvo, ktoré sa nenaplnilo
I couldn't have done it without your help.
Bez tvojej pomoci by som to nebol zvládol.
pomohol si mi; bez pomoci by to nešlo

3Could have a might have – nahnevaná výčitka

S you často znamená could have „mal si šancu a nevyužil si ju“. Might have sa používa rovnako, najmä v britskej angličtine, keď niekto neurobil niečo zdvorilé alebo milé. Dôraz dajte na modálne sloveso.

You could have called me!
Mohol si mi zavolať!
„mohol si“ → could have
They could have cleaned the kitchen before they left.
Mohli upratať kuchyňu, skôr ako odišli.
You might have warned me about the dog!
Mohol si ma varovať pred tým psom!
najmä UK
He might have said thank you, at least.
Mohol aspoň poďakovať.

4Would have – bol by som ochotný, ale niečo tomu zabránilo

Would have použite, keď hovoríte, že ste boli ochotní alebo ste plánovali niečo urobiť, ale niečo vám zabránilo. Často nasleduje but alebo časť s if B1-07.

I would have come to your party, but I was stuck at work.
Bol by som prišiel na tvoju oslavu, ale zasekol som sa v práci.
hovorovo „prišiel by som“; v angličtine would have
She would have lent you the money — why didn't you ask her?
Bola by ti tie peniaze požičala. Prečo si ju nepoprosil?
We would have stayed longer, but the hotel was full.
Boli by sme zostali dlhšie, ale hotel bol plný.
I'd have called you if I'd had your number.
Bol by som ti zavolal, keby som mal tvoje číslo.
I'd have = I would have

5Pýtame sa na rozhodnutia v minulosti

Should I have…? a What could I have…? použite, keď sa pýtate na správnu voľbu alebo iné možnosti. Po slovensky: „Mal som…?“, „Čo som mohol…?“

Should I have told her the truth?
Mal som jej povedať pravdu?
What else could we have done?
Čo iné sme mohli urobiť?
Do you think I should have accepted the offer?
Myslíš, že som mal tú ponuku prijať?

Časté chyby

❌You should called me.
✅You should have called me.
Minulosť: should + have + príčastie minulé.
❌I should have went to bed earlier.
✅I should have gone to bed earlier.
Príčastie minulé (gone), nie tvar Past Simple (went).
❌I should of known.
✅I should have known.
should've znie ako „should of“, ale slovo je have.
❌You shouldn't have tell him.
✅You shouldn't have told him.
have + príčastie minulé.
❌We could to have won.
✅We could have won.
could + have + príčastie minulé, bez to.
⚠️You could tell me! (about a past situation)
✅You could have told me!
Gramaticky je to správne, ale „You could tell me“ znamená, že mi to môžeš povedať teraz. Pri premárnenej šanci v minulosti použite could have.

Pasce pre hovoriacich po slovensky

1. „Mala si ma zobudiť!“ → had to. „Mal som / mala si“ je minulý čas slovesa „mať“, preto sa ponúka had to. Lenže had to znamená „musel som (a urobil som to)“. Keď vyčítate alebo ľutujete, že sa správna vec nestala, použite should have.

⚠️You had to wake me up! Now I've missed the bus.
✅You should have woken me up! Now I've missed the bus.
Gramaticky je to správne, ale had to znamená povinnosť, ktorú ste splnili, nie výčitku.

2. „Nemal som si kupovať…“ → didn't have to. „Nemal som“ a „nemusel som“ sú v slovenčine dve rôzne veci – presne ako v angličtine. „Nemal som“ (bola to chyba) je shouldn't have; didn't have to je „nemusel som“ (nebolo to nutné).

⚠️I didn't have to buy those cheap shoes. They fell apart in a week.
✅I shouldn't have bought those cheap shoes. They fell apart in a week.
Gramaticky je to správne, ale didn't have to znamená „nebolo to nutné“, nie „bola to chyba“.

3. „Mohol si mi napísať“ → could + základný tvar. Po slovensky stačí minulý čas „mohol si“. Anglické could + základný tvar však hovorí o tom, čo je možné teraz alebo v budúcnosti. O premárnenej šanci v minulosti hovorí could have + príčastie minulé.

⚠️You could text me that the train was late! I waited for an hour.
✅You could have texted me that the train was late! I waited for an hour.
Gramaticky je to správne, ale could text neznamená výčitku za minulosť.

4. „Prišiel by som, ale…“ → would + základný tvar. V hovorenej slovenčine nahradíme „bol by som prišiel“ jednoduchým „prišiel by som“. V angličtine potrebuje ochota v minulosti would have + príčastie minulé.

⚠️I would come to the barbecue, but my car broke down.
✅I would have come to the barbecue, but my car broke down.
Gramaticky je to správne, ale would come nehovorí o jednej situácii v minulosti.

Nepleťte si

should have a should – should + základný tvar dáva radu teraz alebo do budúcnosti („mal by si“) A2-21; should have + príčastie minulé sa pozerá späť („mal si“).

You should call her.
Mal by si jej zavolať.
rada teraz
You should have called her.
Mal si jej zavolať.
neskoro: nezavolal si

should have ako výčitka a should have ako očakávanie – should have môže znamenať aj „to sa očakávalo a pravdepodobne sa to už stalo (alebo sa čudujem, že nie)“. Rozhoduje situácia.

You should have checked the dates.
Mal si si skontrolovať dátumy.
výčitka: neskontroloval si
The parcel should have arrived by now.
Balík už mal prísť.
očakávanie: myslím, že prišiel, alebo sa čudujem, že nie

could have (premárnená šanca) a could have (odhad o minulosti) – could have a might have môžu tiež odhadovať, čo sa možno stalo. To sa učíte v B2-06.

You could have died!
Mohol si zomrieť!
bolo to možné, ale nestalo sa
He could have taken the bus — I don't know how he got here.
Možno prišiel autobusom, neviem, ako sa sem dostal.
odhad: pozrite B2-06

I should have… a I wish I had… – obe vyjadrujú ľútosť. I wish I had… sa učíte v B2-04.

I should have saved more money.
Mal som viac šetriť.
bola to správna vec
I wish I had saved more money.
Škoda, že som nešetril viac.
ľutujem, že som to neurobil: pozrite B2-04

Pravopis a výslovnosť

  • have je vo všetkých týchto tvaroch zvyčajne slabé: should have /ˈʃʊdəv/, could have /ˈkʊdəv/, would have /ˈwʊdəv/, might have /ˈmaɪtəv/. Slovenčina vyslovuje každú samohlásku naplno, ale tu je /ə/ krátke a uvoľnené a h zmizne.
  • should, could, would: l je nemé. Zvyk „píš, ako počuješ“ (a čítaj, ako je napísané) tu nefunguje.
  • shouldn't have /ˈʃʊdntəv/ – v rýchlej reči sa t často úplne neuvoľní.
  • Nikdy nepíšte should of, could of, would of, might of. Píšte should have alebo should've.
  • Pri výčitke dajte dôraz na modálne sloveso: You COULD have told me! You SHOULD have asked. Slovenčina dáva prízvuk na prvú slabiku slova, anglický dôraz vo vete však padá na slovo, ktoré je dôležité.

Zlaté pravidlo

should / could / might / would + have + príčastie minulé sa pozerá späť a porovnáva skutočnú minulosť s inou verziou: so správnou vecou (should), s možnou vecou (could), so zdvorilou vecou (might) alebo s niečím, čo ste boli ochotní urobiť (would). Tá iná verzia sa zvyčajne nestala; pri shouldn't have sa zlá vec stala. A „mal som“ je should have, nie had to.

Cvičenia

A. Tvar

Dajte slovesá v zátvorkách do správneho tvaru alebo prepíšte vety.

  1. I failed the test. I (should / study) more.
  2. You (could / tell) me the meeting was cancelled!
  3. I (would / help) you, but I was abroad.
  4. My head hurts. I (shouldn't / drink) so much coffee.
  5. Prepíšte vetu so shouldn't have: It was a mistake to eat that third piece of cake.
  6. Prepíšte vetu so should have: It was a mistake not to bring a coat.

B. Význam

Odpovedzte na otázku alebo vyberte správnu možnosť.

  1. "We could have won." Vyhrali? Odpovedzte Yes alebo No.
  2. "I shouldn't have said that." Povedal to hovoriaci? Odpovedzte Yes alebo No.
  3. Veľmi ste tam chceli byť. Vyberte správnu možnosť: I … come to your wedding, but I was in hospital.
  4. Vyberte správnu možnosť: You … see a doctor about that cough — go today.

C. Nájdite chybu

Každá veta obsahuje jednu chybu alebo je správna. Napíšte opravenú vetu alebo napíšte correct.

  1. You should have went to the meeting.
  2. She should of asked for directions.
  3. It could have been much worse.
  4. I would have call you, but my phone was dead.

D. V kontexte

Doplňte do rozhovoru slová, ktoré chýbajú. Použite slová v zátvorkách.

After the party
Jo: The party was a disaster. I 15 (shouldn't / invite) so many people. The flat was too small.
Max: Yes, and you 16 (should / buy) more food. It finished in an hour!
Jo: I know. And Tim was so rude. He 17 (might / say) thank you, at least.
Max: True. And you 18 (could / ask) me for help! I 19 (would / come) early.

E. Teraz vy

Píšte po anglicky o minulom týždni a o iných ľuďoch.

  1. Napíšte o jednej veci z minulého týždňa, ktorú ľutujete. Použite should have alebo shouldn't have.
  2. Kamarát vám nepovedal o skvelom koncerte. Napíšte výčitku s could have.
  3. Napíšte vetu o niečom, čo ste boli ochotní urobiť, ale nemohli ste.

F. Zmiešané opakovanie

Zopakujte si predchádzajúce lekcie.

  1. B1-07 Third Conditional: keby som bol vedel… (if + had, would have) po anglicky
    If I (know) about the traffic, I would have taken the train.
  2. A2-21 Should a ought to: ako dať radu po anglicky
    I think you ___ talk to your boss about it. …
  3. A2-16 Present Perfect: Have you ever…? Skúsenosti zo života po anglicky
    Have you ever (break) a bone?
  4. B1-08 I wish a if only: kiež by som mal… po anglicky (wish alebo hope)
    I wish I (can) speak Japanese.
Riešenia

A. Tvar

  1. should have studied / should've studied
  2. could have told / could've told
  3. would have helped / 'd have helped / would've helped
  4. shouldn't have drunk / should not have drunk
  5. I shouldn't have eaten that third piece of cake.
  6. I should have brought a coat. / We should have brought a coat.

B. Význam

  1. No
  2. Yes
  3. would have
  4. should

C. Nájdite chybu

  1. You should have gone to the meeting.
  2. She should have asked for directions. / She should've asked for directions.
  3. ✓ It could have been much worse.
  4. I would have called you, but my phone was dead. / I'd have called you, but my phone was dead.

D. V kontexte

  1. shouldn't have invited
  2. should have bought / should've bought
  3. might have said / might've said
  4. could have asked / could've asked
  5. would have come / 'd have come / would've come

E. Teraz vy

  1. I shouldn't have stayed up so late on Sunday. I should have gone to bed at ten.
  2. You could have told me about the concert! I would have loved to go.
  3. I would have helped you move, but I was working all weekend.

F. Zmiešané opakovanie

  1. had known / 'd known
  2. should
  3. broken
  4. could
Aplikácia pre AndroidUčte sa na cestách Google Play