SlowingoGramatika
C1 15 / 20

Advanced modals: That'll be, will have, he would say that, won't, may well i may as well – napredna značenja modalnih glagola

Advanced Modal Meanings

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Srpski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Upotreba
  6. Česte greške
  7. Zamke za govornike srpskog
  8. Ne mešajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vežbe

Cilj

Posle ove lekcije moći ćete da pomoću will i would izrazite sigurnu pretpostavku (That'll be the postman. You'll have heard the news.), tipično ponašanje i insistiranje (He would say that.) i odbijanje (The door won't open.); da koristite may/might/could well i may/might as well; i da birate između can i will be able to za budućnost.

Osnovna ideja

Modalni glagol pokazuje stav govornika: koliko je siguran, koliko je neko voljan, šta je tipično. Na nivoima B1–B2 naučili ste osnovne poslove glagola will i would. Na nivou C1 vidite jednu osnovnu ideju iza mnogih upotreba.

Zamislite will kao krug sigurnosti: „tako stoje stvari – siguran sam“. Ta sigurnost može da pokazuje na budućnost (It'll rain), na sadašnjost (That'll be Ella – siguran sam i bez provere), na prošlost (You'll have heard – siguran sam da se već desilo), na nečiji karakter (She'll talk for hours) ili na nečiju volju (He won't listen – odbija). Would je isti krug, korak dalje: u prošlosti ili malo manje siguran.

Zato ne učite dugačak spisak značenja. Pitajte se: u šta je govornik siguran – ili ko neće nešto da uradi?

Srpski i engleski

Ovde srpski pomaže više nego što mislite. I naš futur služi za pretpostavku („To će biti komšinica“, „Biće mu oko trideset godina“), a „neće“ i „nije hteo“ izražavaju odbijanje, čak i kod mašina („Auto neće da upali“). Problemi su u obliku. Srpsko „moći ću“ nema doslovan engleski parnjak – will can ne postoji. Posle „neće da“ i „možemo i da“ srpski ima „da“, a engleski posle won't i may as well nema to. A za pretpostavku o prošlosti srpski kaže „sigurno je već počeo“ (perfekat), dok engleski traži will have + particip prošli.

SrpskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
To će biti moja komšinica.That'll be my neighbour.ovde je isto: futur za pretpostavku o sadašnjosti
Biće mu sad oko trideset.Her son would be about thirty now.would = opreznija procena
Sigurno ste čuli da Marko odlazi.You'll have heard that Marco's leaving.perfekat → will have + particip prošli
Film je sigurno već počeo.The film will have started by now.nikad samo will start
On uvek ostavi mokre peškire na podu!He will leave his wet towels on the floor.srpski kaže „uvek“, engleski naglašava will
Pa šta bi drugo i rekao!Well, he would say that!naglašeno would = „baš tipično za njega“
Laptop neće da se upali.My laptop won't turn on.ovde je isto: „neće“ = won't, ali bez to
Nije hteo da mi kaže gde je bio.He wouldn't tell me where he'd been.odbijanje u prošlosti = wouldn't
Lako je moguće da će kasnije padati kiša.It may well rain later.may well + osnovni oblik
Otišao je poslednji autobus, možemo onda i peške.The last bus has gone, so we might as well walk.might as well + osnovni oblik, bez to
Posle kursa moći ćete da čitate ugovore.After this course, you'll be able to read contracts.„moći ću“ = will be able to, nikad will can

Ukratko: srpski futur i „neće“ već rade kao engleski krug sigurnosti; pazite samo na oblik – „moći ću“ je will be able to, „sigurno je već…“ je will have + particip prošli, a posle won't i may as well nema to.

Oblik

Will i would: sadašnjost i prošlost

ZnačenjeO sadašnjosti / uopšteO prošlosti
pretpostavkaThat'll be Ella.You'll have heard the news.
opreznija pretpostavkaShe'd be about forty now.That would have been in 2015.
tipično ponašanje / insistiranjeHe will interrupt people.She would keep calling me.
odbijanjeThe car won't start.He wouldn't tell me why.

Ustaljeni modalni izrazi

IzrazZnačenjeProšli oblik
may / might / could well + osnovni oblikprilično je verovatnomay/might/could well have + particip prošli
may / might as well + osnovni obliknema boljeg izbora, pa…might as well have + particip prošli (= bilo je uzalud)

Can i be able to za budućnost

OblikUpotreba
candogovori i odluke donete sada: I can see you on Friday.
will be able tonova sposobnost ili mogućnost u budućnosti: You'll be able to drive.
modalni glagol + be able toposle drugog modalnog glagola: I might be able to come.

Upotreba

1Pretpostavka o sadašnjosti: will + osnovni oblik

Pomoću will (obično 'll) kažete šta sigurno mislite da je tačno sada, na osnovu onoga što znate, bez provere. Zvuči smireno i logično, kao srpsko „to će biti…“. Would pretpostavku čini opreznijom, često za procene („biće mu oko…“). Ovo je jedina lekcija u kojoj se uči will za pretpostavku.

Someone's at the door. That'll be my neighbour; she said she'd pop round.
Neko je na vratima. To će biti moja komšinica, rekla je da će svratiti.
pop round (UK, neformalno) = svratiti nakratko
It's three in the morning in Sydney, so Tom will be asleep.
U Sidneju su sad tri ujutru, pa Tom sigurno spava.
o sadašnjosti, ne o budućnosti
Ask Sam. He'll know the password.
Pitaj Sema. On će znati lozinku.
Don't call her now; she'll be putting the kids to bed.
Ne zovi je sad, sigurno uspavljuje decu.
will be + -ing: upravo traje
Her son would be about thirty now, I think.
Njen sin bi sad trebalo da ima tridesetak godina, mislim.
opreznije

2Pretpostavka o prošlosti: will have + particip prošli

Will have + particip prošli izražava sigurno uverenje da se nešto već desilo, često sa by now ili already. Srpski ovde kaže „sigurno je već…“ ili „mora da je već…“ sa perfektom. Would have je opreznija verzija za procene. (Future Perfect (budući perfekat) za budućnost je u B2-01.)

You'll have heard that Marco's leaving.
Sigurno ste čuli da Marko odlazi.
pretpostavljam da ste čuli
It's half past nine, so the film will have started by now.
Pola je deset, pa je film sigurno već počeo.
Don't worry about the parcel. It will have arrived at the office.
Ne brini za paket. Sigurno je već stigao u kancelariju.
You won't have met my sister; she's been abroad for years.
Vi sigurno niste upoznali moju sestru, godinama živi u inostranstvu.
odrična pretpostavka
"When did they move to Leeds?" "That would have been around 2015."
„Kad su se preselili u Lids?“ „To je moralo biti negde 2015.“
procena

3Tipično ponašanje i insistiranje: will i would

Will opisuje tipično ponašanje u sadašnjosti, a would u prošlosti (B2-17) – kao srpsko „ume da“ ili „znao je da“. Kad je will ili would naglašeno, to je kritika: osoba uporno radi nešto što nervira. Srpski to kaže rečima „uvek“, „stalno“ ili intonacijom. He would say that (naglašeno would) znači „baš to se od njega i očekuje, s obzirom na to kakav je“. You would! znači „baš tipično za tebe“.

Our cat will sit by the window for hours, watching the birds.
Naša mačka ume satima da sedi kraj prozora i posmatra ptice.
tipično ponašanje
He will leave his wet towels on the floor.
On uvek ostavi mokre peškire na podu!
naglašeno will: uporna navika koja nervira
She would keep asking me the same question.
Stalno me je pitala jedno te isto.
naglašeno would: insistiranje u prošlosti
The manager says the delay wasn't his fault.
Menadžer kaže da kašnjenje nije njegova krivica.
Well, he would say that, wouldn't he?
Pa šta bi drugo i rekao?
naglašeno would: to se od njega očekuje
"I've locked myself out again." "You would!"
„Opet sam se zaključao napolju.“ „Baš tipično za tebe!“
to je tipično za tebe

4Odbijanje: won't i wouldn't

Won't (sadašnjost) i wouldn't (prošlost, jednom ili više puta) pokazuju da neko odbija da nešto uradi. I mašine i predmeti mogu da „odbiju“, kao da imaju volju – isto kao srpsko „neće da“. Ali posle won't i wouldn't dolazi osnovni oblik, bez to.

My laptop won't turn on.
Laptop neće da se upali.
The kids won't eat anything green.
Deca neće da jedu ništa zeleno.
„ništa“ uz „neće“, ali anything uz won't
I asked him three times, but he wouldn't tell me where he'd been.
Pitala sam ga tri puta, ali nije hteo da mi kaže gde je bio.
The lid wouldn't come off, however hard I tried.
Poklopac nikako nije hteo da se skine, koliko god da sam se trudio.

5May / might / could well i may / might as well

May well, might well i could well znače „prilično je verovatno“ – jače od samog may. May as well i might as well znače „nema boljeg izbora, pa hajde da“ – pomalo nevoljan predlog, kao srpsko „možemo onda i…“, „bolje i da…“. Might as well have + particip prošli kaže da je nešto u prošlosti bilo uzalud. Za druge izraze verovatnoće pogledajte B2-26.

Take an umbrella; it may well rain later.
Ponesi kišobran, lako je moguće da će kasnije padati kiša.
prilično verovatno
The new rules could well affect small businesses.
Nova pravila bi vrlo lako mogla da pogode male firme.
She might well have missed the email; it went to spam.
Lako je moguće da nije videla mejl, završio je u spamu.
verovatno u prošlosti
The last bus has gone, so we might as well walk.
Otišao je poslednji autobus, možemo onda i peške.
nema boljeg izbora
Nobody listened. I might as well have stayed at home.
Niko nije slušao. Mogao sam isto tako i da ostanem kod kuće.
bilo je uzalud

6Can i will be able to za budućnost

Can koristite za budućnost kada nešto dogovarate ili odlučujete sada. Will be able to koristite za sposobnost ili mogućnost koja još ne postoji, ali će postojati – srpsko „moći ću“. Posle drugog modalnog glagola uvek koristite be able to. Za be able to u drugim vremenima pogledajte A2-24.

I can see you on Thursday at ten.
Mogu da se vidim s vama u četvrtak u deset.
dogovor napravljen sada
Can you come to the meeting tomorrow?
Možete li da dođete na sastanak sutra?
dogovor
After this course, you'll be able to read contracts in English.
Posle ovog kursa moći ćete da čitate ugovore na engleskom.
nova sposobnost u budućnosti
Once the new bridge opens, we'll be able to cross the river in five minutes.
Kad se otvori novi most, moći ćemo da pređemo reku za pet minuta.
I might be able to leave early on Friday.
Možda ću moći da odem ranije u petak.
posle modalnog glagola: be able to

Česte greške

❌They will arrive by now.
✅They'll have arrived by now.
Za završenu radnju koju pretpostavljate: will have + particip prošli.
❌You'll have hear the news.
✅You'll have heard the news.
will have + particip prošli.
❌We may as well to take a taxi.
✅We may as well take a taxi.
Modalni izrazi traže osnovni oblik, bez to.
❌I will can drive next year.
✅I'll be able to drive next year.
Dva modalna glagola ne mogu da stoje zajedno.
⚠️The door doesn't want to open.
✅The door won't open.
Razumljivo i koristi se u šali, ali won't je uobičajen način da se to kaže.
⚠️Next year I can play the piano well.
✅Next year I'll be able to play the piano well.
can za budućnost je za dogovore; nova sposobnost traži will be able to.

Zamke za govornike srpskog

1. „Moći ću“ → will can. Srpski ima futur glagola „moći“ („moći ću“, „moći ćeš“), pa se lako prevede reč po reč. U engleskom can nema budući oblik i ne može da stoji posle will ni posle drugog modalnog glagola. Koristite will be able to (ili might be able to, should be able to).

❌Will you can help me move on Saturday?
✅Will you be able to help me move on Saturday?
„Hoćeš li moći“ = Will you be able to
❌Jelena thinks she might can join us after the concert.
✅Jelena thinks she might be able to join us after the concert.
posle modalnog glagola: be able to

2. „Sigurno je već stigao“ → will + osnovni oblik. Za pretpostavku o prošlosti srpski koristi perfekat sa „sigurno“ ili „mora da“. Ko je naučio da je will „ono za pretpostavku“, lako izostavi have. Ali will + osnovni oblik govori o sadašnjosti ili budućnosti; za ono što se već desilo treba will have + particip prošli.

❌Call Dušan at home, not at work. He will leave the office already.
✅Call Dušan at home, not at work. He will have left the office already. ili Call Dušan at home, not at work. He'll already have left the office.
već se desilo → will have + particip prošli

3. „Neće da…“, „nije hteo da…“ → won't to, wouldn't to. Srpski posle „neće“ i „nije hteo“ (kao i posle „možemo onda i“) stavlja „da“, pa se u engleskom pojavi to. Posle won't, wouldn't, may as well i might as well dolazi samo osnovni oblik.

❌The printer won't to print anything in colour today.
✅The printer won't print anything in colour today.
won't + osnovni oblik
❌My brother wouldn't to lend me his car last weekend.
✅My brother wouldn't lend me his car last weekend.
wouldn't + osnovni oblik

Ne mešajte

may well i may as well – May well = prilično je verovatno („lako je moguće“). May as well = nema ništa bolje, pa hajde da („možemo onda i“).

It may well snow tonight.
Lako je moguće da večeras padne sneg.
verovatno
The shops are shut, so we may as well go home.
Prodavnice su zatvorene, možemo onda i kući.
nema boljeg izbora

will za pretpostavku i will za budućnost – Will za pretpostavku govori o sadašnjosti ili prošlosti; will za budućnost govori o tome šta će biti kasnije (A2-04). U srpskom „biće“ ima obe uloge, pa vam kontekst kaže koja je.

Don't phone Ana now; she'll be at work.
Ne zovi Anu sad, sigurno je na poslu.
pretpostavka o sadašnjosti
Ana will be at work tomorrow.
Ana će sutra biti na poslu.
budućnost

won't (budućnost) i won't (odbijanje) – Kontekst i naglasak vam govore koje je. Won't za odbijanje obično je naglašeno i često ide uz žalbu.

I won't be home until late tonight.
Večeras neću biti kod kuće do kasno.
obična budućnost
She won't answer her phone; I've called five times.
Neće da se javi na telefon, zvao sam je pet puta.
odbijanje

Pravopis i izgovor

  • That'll /ˈðætl/ i it'll /ˈɪtl/ uobičajeni su u govoru; u pisanju su neformalni. U that'll je /ð/ (vrh jezika između zuba, sa glasom, nije srpsko d) i /æ/ – usta otvorenija nego za srpsko e. Drugi slog nema samoglasnik: /tl/.
  • Will have se u govoru obično skraćuje: You'll have heard /juːl əv hɜːd/. have postaje kratko /əv/, a u heard je /ɜː/ – samoglasnik koji srpski nema: usne opuštene, jezik u sredini usta.
  • Naglasak menja značenje: He'll leave his towels on the floor (neutralna navika) i He will leave his towels on the floor (kritika). Naglašeni oblik se nikad ne skraćuje.
  • Won't /wəʊnt/ (UK), /woʊnt/ (US) rimuje se sa don't i razlikuje se od want /wɒnt/ (UK), /wɑːnt/ (US). Na početku je /w/: zaokružite usne, ne izgovarajte srpsko v.
  • U may as well i might as well reč as je slaba: /əz/, sa kratkim, neodređenim samoglasnikom.

Zlatno pravilo

Will i would izražavaju sigurnost i volju: sigurnu pretpostavku o sadašnjosti (will) ili prošlosti (will have + particip prošli), tipičnu naviku, insistiranje ili odbijanje. Would je udaljenija ili opreznija verzija. May well = verovatno; may as well = nema boljeg izbora. „Moći ću“ je will be able to, a posle won't i may as well nema to.

Vežbe

A. Oblik

Preoblikujte svaku rečenicu pomoću datog modalnog glagola ili izraza. Zadržite značenje.

  1. Preoblikujte pomoću "will" za pretpostavku: I'm sure that's the postman at the door.
  2. Preoblikujte pomoću "will have": I assume you've heard that Marco is leaving.
  3. Preoblikujte pomoću "won't": The car refuses to start, however often I try.
  4. Preoblikujte pomoću "might as well": There's no better option than walking, because the last bus has gone.
  5. Preoblikujte pomoću "could well": It's quite likely that the new rules will affect small businesses.
  6. Preoblikujte pomoću "might as well": Nobody listened to me, so it was pointless for me to go to the meeting.
  7. Preoblikujte pomoću "might" i "be able to": Perhaps it will be possible for me to leave early on Friday.

B. Značenje

Pročitajte situaciju i izaberite bolju rečenicu.

  1. Prijatelj vam kaže da je menadžer za kašnjenje okrivio nekog drugog. Mislite da je to tipično za njega. Koji odgovor odgovara?
  2. Prodavnice su zatvorene i nema ništa drugo da se radi. Koji predlog odgovara?
  3. Upozoravate prijatelja da je kiša prilično verovatna. Koja rečenica to kaže?
  4. Nastavnik opisuje novu veštinu koju će polaznici imati posle kursa. Koja rečenica je tačna za ovo značenje?
  5. Koja rečenica opisuje odbijanje, a ne običnu budućnost?

C. Pronađite grešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna greška ili je rečenica tačna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. When I finish this course next summer, I will can read most technical documents in English without a dictionary.
  2. It's already half past nine, so the film will start by now; let's wait for the next showing instead.
  3. The kids are bored and it's still raining, so we may as well to take them to the cinema this afternoon.
  4. I'm sure you'll have see the plans for the new office, so I won't go through them in detail today.
  5. I can meet you for lunch on Friday, but I'll need to leave by two for a meeting with a client.

D. U kontekstu

Pročitajte mejl i preoblikujte rečenice sa brojevima pomoću modalnih značenja iz ove lekcije.

Re: Where is the delivery?
Hi Nadia,
(18) I'm sure you have already heard that we've changed suppliers. (19) The new company has an annoying habit: it sends things late every single month. (20) I phoned them twice this morning, but they refused to give me a delivery date. (21) I'm confident that the van is stuck in traffic at this moment, as the motorway is closed. (22) It's quite likely that the delivery will be delayed until next week. (23) There's no better option, so let's postpone the training session. (24) Once the new system is set up, it will be possible for us to track every order online.
Best,
Owen
  1. Preoblikujte (18) pomoću "will have".
  2. Preoblikujte (19) u jednu rečenicu sa naglašenim "will" za naviku koja nervira.
  3. Preoblikujte (20) pomoću "wouldn't".
  4. Preoblikujte (21) pomoću "will" za pretpostavku.
  5. Preoblikujte (22) pomoću "may well", "might well" ili "could well".
  6. Preoblikujte (23) pomoću "might as well" ili "may as well".
  7. Preoblikujte (24) pomoću "be able to".

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o ljudima koje poznajete, o navikama koje nerviraju i o planovima koji su propali.

  1. Recite šta tri osobe koje poznajete verovatno upravo rade ili su uradile. Najmanje dva puta upotrebite will za pretpostavku (+ osnovni oblik ili + be + -ing), a jednom will have + particip prošli.
  2. Požalite se u 2–3 rečenice na nečiju naviku koja nervira. Jednom upotrebite naglašeno will za sadašnjost, a jednom naglašeno would za prošlost.
  3. Planovi su vam propali (otkazan voz, zatvoren restoran). Napišite 2–3 rečenice: jedan nevoljan predlog sa might as well, jedan verovatan ishod sa may well ili could well i jednu buduću mogućnost sa will be able to.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

Ponovite prethodne lekcije.

  1. B2-06 Must have, can't have, might have: „mora da je“ i „možda je“ o prošlosti na engleskom
    Preoblikujte pomoću modalnog glagola za zaključivanje o prošlosti: I'm almost certain she left her phone at home.
  2. B2-17 Navike na engleskom: would, used to, will i always + -ing objašnjeno na srpskom
    Koja rečenica opisuje toplu uspomenu na naviku iz prošlosti?
  3. C1-08 Hedging: It seems that, apparently, allegedly – oprezno izražavanje na engleskom
    Preoblikujte tako da zvuči manje sigurno, pomoću "appear": The results prove that the drug works.
Решења

A. Oblik

  1. That'll be the postman at the door.
  2. You'll have heard that Marco is leaving.
  3. The car won't start, however often I try.
  4. The last bus has gone, so we might as well walk. / We might as well walk, because the last bus has gone.
  5. The new rules could well affect small businesses.
  6. Nobody listened to me, so I might as well not have gone to the meeting. / Nobody listened to me, so I might as well have stayed at home.
  7. I might be able to leave early on Friday.

B. Značenje

  1. Well, he would say that, wouldn't he?
  2. The shops are shut, so we may as well go home.
  3. Take an umbrella; it might well rain later.
  4. After this course, you'll be able to read contracts in English.
  5. She won't answer her phone; I've called five times.

C. Pronađite grešku

  1. When I finish this course next summer, I'll be able to read most technical documents in English without a dictionary.
  2. It's already half past nine, so the film will have started by now; let's wait for the next showing instead. / It's already half past nine, so the film must have started by now; let's wait for the next showing instead.
  3. The kids are bored and it's still raining, so we may as well take them to the cinema this afternoon.
  4. I'm sure you'll have seen the plans for the new office, so I won't go through them in detail today.
  5. ✓ I can meet you for lunch on Friday, but I'll need to leave by two for a meeting with a client.

D. U kontekstu

  1. You'll have heard that we've changed suppliers. / You'll already have heard that we've changed suppliers.
  2. The new company will send things late every single month.
  3. I phoned them twice this morning, but they wouldn't give me a delivery date.
  4. The van will be stuck in traffic at the moment, as the motorway is closed.
  5. The delivery may well be delayed until next week. / The delivery might well be delayed until next week. / The delivery could well be delayed until next week.
  6. We might as well postpone the training session. / We may as well postpone the training session.
  7. Once the new system is set up, we'll be able to track every order online.

E. Vaš red

  1. It's nearly midnight in Seoul, so my cousin will be asleep. My parents will be watching the news, as they always do at this time. My sister will have finished her last exam by now.
  2. My flatmate will leave his dirty dishes in the sink for days. His last flatmate told me he would do exactly the same in their old place.
  3. Our train's been cancelled, so we might as well have dinner here at the station. The next one could well be full. If we book online now, though, we'll be able to get seats on the eight o'clock.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

  1. She must have left her phone at home.
  2. When I was a child, my grandfather would tell us stories every evening.
  3. The results appear to show that the drug works. / The results appear to suggest that the drug works. / It appears that the drug works.
Android апликацијаУчите у покрету Google Play