SlowingoSlovnica
C1 16 / 20

Advanced relative clauses: to whom, whereby, in which case in whatever v angleščini

Advanced Relative Clauses

Na tej strani
  1. Cilj
  2. Glavna ideja
  3. Slovenščina in angleščina
  4. Oblika
  5. Raba
  6. Pogoste napake
  7. Pasti za govorce slovenščine
  8. Ne zamenjujte
  9. Pravopis in izgovorjava
  10. Zlato pravilo
  11. Vaje

Cilj

Po tej lekciji boste znali uporabljati formalne oziralne zgradbe – to whom, the extent to which, whereby, in which case, by which time, at which point – in samostalniške oziralne odvisnike, kot so what, whatever in whoever, ter oziralne odvisnike povezovati z nedoločnikom in s količinskimi izrazi.

Glavna ideja

Oziralni odvisnik (relative clause) je kavelj: na samostalnik obesi dodatno informacijo. V vsakdanji angleščini predlog visi na koncu kavlja: the person I spoke to. V formalni angleščini se predlog premakne naprej in se oprime oziralnega zaimka: the person to whom I spoke. Pomen je enak, spremeni se le slog.

Nekateri formalni oziralni izrazi se ne obesijo na en samostalnik, ampak na celo misel: The train may be cancelled, in which case we'll drive. Tu which kaže nazaj na ves položaj – na to, da vlak morda ne bo vozil.

Drugi oziralni izrazi nosijo samostalnik v sebi. What pomeni the thing that; whoever pomeni any person who. Pri teh samostalniških oziralnih odvisnikih ves odvisnik deluje kot samostalnik: What she said surprised me.

Slovenščina in angleščina

Pri predlogu ima slovenščina en sam vrstni red, in to formalnega: predlog vedno stoji pred „katerim“ – „oseba, s katero sem govoril“, „raziskava, na kateri temelji teorija“. Zato vam formalni angleški vzorec the person to whom I spoke ne bo delal težav. Novo je drugo: v vsakdanji angleščini predlog ostane na koncu (the person I spoke to), in to je povsem pravilno.

Največja past je slovenski „kar“. Prevedemo ga lahko na tri načine. Ko pomeni „tisto, kar“, je what (What I need is sleep). Ko stoji za „vse“, „nekaj“ ali „nič“, pa je that ali nič (Everything he said), nikoli what. Ko se nanaša na ves prejšnji stavek („Zamudil je, kar je vse razjezilo“), je which. Tudi „kdor“ ima natančen par: ni who, ampak whoever. Za „kar koli“, „kdor koli“ in „kjer koli“ slovenščina rada uporabi prihodnjik („kar koli se boste odločili“), angleščina pa sedanjik.

SlovenščinaAngleščinaV čem je razlika?
oseba, s katero sem govorilthe person to whom I spoke / the person I spoke toslovenščina ima predlog vedno spredaj; angleščina ga v govoru pusti na koncu
program, s katerim lahko zaposleni kupijo delnicea scheme whereby staff can buy shares„s katerim“ (način) → whereby
Let bo morda zamudil, v tem primeru ……, in which case we'll miss the connectionena poved z vejico → in which case
…, do takrat pa je bila restavracija že zaprta…, by which time the restaurant had closed„do takrat“ → by which time
Kar me je presenetilo, …What surprised me …„tisto, kar“ → what
Vse, kar je rekel, je bilo res.Everything (that) he said was true.za „vse“: that ali nič, nikoli what
Zamudil je, kar je vse razjezilo.He was late, which annoyed everyone.„kar“ za vejico (vsa misel) → which
Kdor prvi konča, zmaga.Whoever finishes first wins.„kdor“ → whoever, ne who
trije bratje, od katerih vsi živijo v tujinithree brothers, all of whom live abroad„od katerih“ → of whom / of which, ne from

Na kratko: predlog pred whom / which je za vas domač vzorec; „kar“ je what, that ali which – odvisno od tega, kaj pomeni –, „kdor“ pa je whoever.

Oblika

Predlog + whom / which

Neformalno (predlog na koncu)Formalno (predlog spredaj)
the person (who) I spoke tothe person to whom I spoke
the company (that) she works forthe company for which she works
the colleagues (who) he relies onthe colleagues on whom he relies
the way (that) the system worksthe way in which the system works

Za predlogom uporabite whom (ljudje) ali which (stvari) ali whose + samostalnik (the writer to whose work I referred). That tu ni nikoli mogoč, who za predlogom pa se v skrbni angleščini izogibamo.

Oziralni izrazi, ki se navežejo na način, čas ali ves položaj

IzrazPomenNanaša se na
wherebys katerim / prek kateregasistem, način ali dogovor
in which casein če se to zgodives prejšnji stavek
by which timein do takratčas ali dogodek
at which pointin v tistem trenutkutrenutek ali dogodek

Samostalniški oziralni odvisniki (samostalnik je v njih)

IzrazPomenPrimer
whattisto, karWhat I need is sleep.
whateverkar koliTake whatever you want.
whoeverkdor koli / tisti, kiWhoever finishes first wins.
whicheverkateri koli (iz omejene izbire)Choose whichever room you like.
wherever / wheneverkjer koli / kadar koliSit wherever you like.

Oziralni odvisniki z nedoločnikom in s količinskimi izrazi (ponovitev)

VzorecPrimer
samostalnik + nedoločnik s tothe person to contact
samostalnik + predlog + which / whom + nedoločnik s to (formalno)a place in which to live
količinski izraz + of + whom / whichall of which, neither of whom

Raba

1Predlog + whom / which

V formalnem pisanju postavite predlog pred whom ali which – tako kot v slovenščini pred „katerim“. Nekateri izrazi skoraj vedno uporabljajo ta vzorec: the extent to which, the speed at which, the way in which, the basis on which. Frazni glagoli tega ne zmorejo: njihov členek ostane ob glagolu (the problem I came across). Oba vrstna reda sta pravilna; izbirate po slogu (C2-02).

The person to whom this letter is addressed no longer works here.
Oseba, ki ji je pismo naslovljeno, tu ne dela več.
predlog spredaj: formalno
This is the research on which the whole theory is based.
To je raziskava, na kateri temelji vsa teorija.
kot „na kateri“
She thanked the colleagues with whom she had worked for twenty years.
Zahvalila se je sodelavcem, s katerimi je delala dvajset let.
The study measures the extent to which sleep affects memory.
Raziskava meri, v kolikšni meri spanec vpliva na spomin.
stalni vzorec
The speed at which technology changes can be overwhelming.
Hitrost, s katero se tehnologija spreminja, je lahko prav obremenjujoča.

2Whereby

Whereby pomeni by which ali through which („s katerim“, „po katerem“). Uvede način ali ureditev sistema, programa, dogovora ali postopka. Je formalen in pogost v poslovnem in akademskem pisanju.

The company has introduced a scheme whereby staff can buy shares at a discount.
Podjetje je uvedlo program, s katerim lahko zaposleni kupijo delnice po znižani ceni.
način
The two sides reached an agreement whereby each would pay half the costs.
Strani sta sklenili dogovor, po katerem bo vsaka plačala polovico stroškov.
dogovor
Photosynthesis is the process whereby plants turn light into energy.
Fotosinteza je proces, pri katerem rastline svetlobo spreminjajo v energijo.
postopek

3In which case, by which time, at which point

Te zveze se navežejo na ves položaj in dodajo, kar iz njega sledi. Stojijo za vejico. In which case = če se to zgodi; by which time = in do takrat (pogosto s Past Perfect (predpreteklik)); at which point = in natanko v tistem trenutku. V slovenščini navadno začnemo nov stavek („v tem primeru“, „takrat pa“), angleščina pa vse poveže v eno poved.

The flight might be delayed, in which case we'll miss the connection.
Let bo morda zamudil; v tem primeru bomo zamudili zvezo.
če se to zgodi
You may find an error on the form, in which case please contact us immediately.
Če na obrazcu najdete napako, se nam takoj oglasite.
formalno navodilo
We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed.
Tja smo prišli šele opolnoči, ko je bila restavracija že zaprta.
do takrat
The talks went on until 3 a.m., by which time everyone was exhausted.
Pogajanja so trajala do treh zjutraj, takrat pa so bili že vsi izčrpani.
He started shouting, at which point security asked him to leave.
Začel je kričati, nakar so ga varnostniki prosili, naj odide.
v tistem trenutku

4Samostalniški oziralni odvisniki: what in besede na -ever

Samostalniški oziralni odvisnik vsebuje svoj samostalnik, zato je ves odvisnik lahko osebek ali predmet. What = the thing(s) that, slovenski „(tisto,) kar“ (B2-20). Oblike na -ever dodajo „kateri koli – vseeno je, kateri“, kot slovenski „koli“. Whichever je za omejeno izbiro. Na začetku povedi lahko whatever, whoever in wherever pomenijo tudi no matter what / who / where (B2-23).

What surprised me most was how calm she stayed.
Najbolj me je presenetilo, kako mirna je ostala.
what = tisto, kar
I'll do what I can to help.
Naredil bom, kar bo v moji moči, da pomagam.
„kar“ → what
You can order whatever you like; it's my treat.
Naroči, kar koli želiš, jaz častim.
kar koli
Whoever designed this app deserves an award.
Kdor koli je oblikoval to aplikacijo, si zasluži nagrado.
„kdor“ → whoever
Take whichever seat you prefer.
Izberite sedež, ki vam je najbolj všeč.
izmed prostih sedežev
Our dog follows me wherever I go.
Naš pes mi sledi, kamor koli grem.
Whatever happens, don't panic.
Kar koli se zgodi, ne paničarite.
= ne glede na to, kaj se zgodi; v slovenščini tudi „kar koli se bo zgodilo“

5Oziralni odvisniki z nedoločnikom (ponovitev)

Oziralni odvisnik se lahko skrči v nedoločnik s to, zlasti za samostalniki, ki izražajo namen, in za first, last, only ter presežniki (B2-09). V formalnem slogu lahko pred nedoločnikom stoji predlog + which / whom. Who in that pred nedoločnikom nikoli ne stojita.

If you have questions, the person to contact is Ms Patel.
Če imate vprašanja, se obrnite na gospo Patel.
the person to contact = oseba, na katero se obrnete
They're looking for a quiet place in which to live.
Iščeta miren kraj za življenje.
formalno = a quiet place to live in
She felt she had nobody with whom to share her worries.
Zdelo se ji je, da nima nikogar, s komer bi delila skrbi.
formalno = nobody to share them with
He was the last person to leave the building.
Stavbo je zapustil zadnji.
za last: nedoločnik

6Količinski izraz + of whom / of which (ponovitev)

S količinskim izrazom (all, some, most, many, neither, none, both, half) ali številom + of whom (ljudje) ali of which (stvari) govorimo o delu skupine. Slovenski „od katerih“ je tu of, ne from. Ti odvisniki so nedoločujoči, zato stojijo za vejico (B2-08).

She has three brothers, all of whom live abroad.
Ima tri brate, ki vsi živijo v tujini.
all of whom
We received over 200 applications, most of which were excellent.
Prejeli smo več kot 200 prijav, od katerih je bila večina odličnih.
„od katerih“ → of which
I asked two mechanics, neither of whom could find the problem.
Vprašal sem dva mehanika, a nobeden ni našel napake.
neither of whom
The museum owns thousands of paintings, many of which have never been shown.
Muzej ima na tisoče slik, od katerih mnoge še nikoli niso bile razstavljene.

Pogoste napake

⚠️The man to who I spoke was very helpful.
✅The man to whom I spoke was very helpful. ali The man (who) I spoke to was very helpful.
Who za predlogom se v govoru včasih sliši, vendar meša sloga: formalni vzorec zahteva whom.
❌The flat in that we live is rented.
✅The flat in which we live is rented. ali The flat (that) we live in is rented.
that ne more stati za predlogom.
❌This is the problem about which I came across.
✅This is the problem (that) I came across.
Fraznemu glagolu členek ostane.
❌I have two sisters, both of them are doctors.
✅I have two sisters, both of whom are doctors. ali …sisters, and both of them are doctors.
Za povezavo stavkov uporabite of whom.
❌Everything what he said was true.
✅Everything (that) he said was true.
Za everything / all / something stoji that ali nič, ne what.
❌The bus may be late, which case we'll walk.
✅The bus may be late, in which case we'll walk.
Stalna zveza je in which case.
❌She needs a friend who to talk to.
✅She needs a friend to talk to. ali …a friend with whom to talk.
Pred nedoločnikom nikoli who.
❌Whatever you will decide, I'll support you.
✅Whatever you decide, I'll support you.
Za whatever / whenever / wherever stoji sedanjik s prihodnjim pomenom.

Pasti za govorce slovenščine

1. „Nič od tega, kar“ → what za nič / vse / nekaj. Slovenščina za „vse“, „nič“ in „nekaj“ redno uporabi „kar“, ki ga poznamo kot what. V angleščini za everything, nothing, something, all, anything stoji that ali nič.

❌None of the guides at Postojna Cave could tell us anything what we hadn't already read on the leaflet at the entrance.
✅None of the guides at Postojna Cave could tell us anything that we hadn't already read on the leaflet at the entrance. ali None of the guides at Postojna Cave could tell us anything we hadn't already read on the leaflet at the entrance.
za anything: that ali nič

2. „…, kar je vse presenetilo“ → what za vejico. Ko se slovenski „kar“ nanaša na ves prejšnji stavek, angleščina uporabi which, ne what.

❌The head teacher of our school in Novo Mesto cycled to work every day for a whole month, what surprised even the youngest pupils.
✅The head teacher of our school in Novo Mesto cycled to work every day for a whole month, which surprised even the youngest pupils.
vsa prejšnja misel: which

3. „Kdor zamudi, …“ → who na začetku. Slovenski „kdor“ sam pomeni „tisti, ki“. Angleški who tega ne zmore: potrebuje samostalnik pred sabo (the person who) ali obliko whoever.

❌Who leaves the staff kitchen in a mess on Friday afternoon has to clean the fridge on Monday morning.
✅Whoever leaves the staff kitchen in a mess on Friday afternoon has to clean the fridge on Monday morning. ali The person who leaves the staff kitchen in a mess on Friday afternoon has to clean the fridge on Monday morning.
„kdor“ → whoever

4. „Od katerih“ → from which. Slovenski „od“ je v vsakdanji rabi from, zato nastane most from which. Za delež skupine angleščina uporabi of whom / of which.

❌When we cleared out Grandma's attic in Ptuj, we found a box of old photographs, most from which nobody in the family had ever seen.
✅When we cleared out Grandma's attic in Ptuj, we found a box of old photographs, most of which nobody in the family had ever seen.
delež skupine: of which

5. „Kjer koli boste parkirali“ → wherever + will. Slovenščina ima za „kar koli“, „kadar koli“ in „kjer koli“ pogosto prihodnjik. Angleščina za whatever, whenever, wherever uporabi sedanjik, tudi ko gre za prihodnost.

❌Wherever you will park in the old town of Ljubljana on a Saturday, you'll have to pay at least three euros an hour.
✅Wherever you park in the old town of Ljubljana on a Saturday, you'll have to pay at least three euros an hour.
za wherever sedanjik

Ne zamenjujte

what in which (ves stavek) – What vsebuje svoj samostalnik (= tisto, kar). Which za vejico komentira ves prejšnji stavek (B2-08). V slovenščini je oboje „kar“.

What she said made everyone laugh.
To, kar je rekla, je vse nasmejalo.
what = tisto, kar
She told a joke, which made everyone laugh.
Povedala je šalo, kar je vse nasmejalo.
which = in to

whereby in where – Where govori o kraju (resničnem ali prenesenem); whereby o načinu ali ureditvi.

This is the office where I first worked.
To je pisarna, kjer sem prvič delal.
kraj
We have a system whereby new staff are paired with a mentor.
Imamo sistem, po katerem vsak novi zaposleni dobi mentorja.
način

whoever in who – Who potrebuje samostalnik pred sabo (the person who…). Whoever ga vsebuje, tako kot slovenski „kdor“.

The person who wins gets a free trip.
Oseba, ki zmaga, dobi brezplačno potovanje.
Whoever wins gets a free trip.
Kdor zmaga, dobi brezplačno potovanje.
„kdor“ → whoever

Pravopis in izgovorjava

  • Whom /huːm/ se izgovori kot who + „m“. Angleški h je le rahel izdih, ne slovenski h s šumom; w se ne izgovori.
  • Whereby je ena beseda z naglasom na drugem zlogu: /weəˈbaɪ/ (UK), /werˈbaɪ/ (US). Na začetku zaokrožite ustnice kot za u – ne izgovorite slovenskega v.
  • Whatever, whoever, whichever, wherever, whenever so po ena beseda; naglas je na -ev-: whatever. (Slovenski „kar koli“, „kdor koli“ pa pišemo narazen.)
  • What ever kot dve besedi je poudarjeno vprašanje (What ever happened to him?), ne samostalniški oziralni odvisnik – glejte C1-06.
  • Pred in which case, by which time in at which point naredimo kratek premor, ki ga v pisavi kaže vejica.
  • V most of which, neither of whom je naglas na količinskem izrazu: most of which. Of je šibek: /əv/, s polglasnikom in zvenečim v.

Zlato pravilo

V formalni angleščini lahko predlog premaknete naprej; za njim stoji whom ali which – nikoli that. What in besede na -ever uporabite, ko je oziralni odvisnik sam samostalnik. Z in which case, by which time in at which point obesite nov stavek na ves položaj. In slovenski „kar“ prevedite po pomenu: what, that ali which; „kdor“ pa je whoever.

Vaje

A. Oblika

Vsako poved prepišite z dano zgradbo. Ohranite pomen.

  1. Prepišite formalno, s predlogom pred oziralnim zaimkom: The woman I sent the email to is my manager.
  2. Prepišite kot eno poved z "whereby": The company has a new scheme. Under this scheme, staff can buy shares at a discount.
  3. Prepišite kot eno poved z "in which case": The flight might be delayed. If that happens, we'll miss our connection.
  4. Prepišite kot eno poved z "by which time": We didn't get there until midnight. The restaurant had already closed then.
  5. Prepišite kot eno poved z "of whom": I asked two mechanics. Neither of them could find the problem.
  6. Prepišite tako, da začnete z "Whoever": The person who designed this app deserves an award.
  7. Prepišite formalno, s predlogom + "whom" + nedoločnikom s to: She felt she had nobody to share her worries with.

B. Pomen

Preberite opis položaja in izberite boljšo poved.

  1. Formalno priporočilo. Katera poved bolje ustreza slogu?
  2. SMS prijatelju. Katera poved je bolj naravna?
  3. Formalni pravilnik opisuje program mentorstva. Katera ubeseditev je natančnejša?
  4. Novica opisuje, kaj se je zgodilo na sestanku. Katera poved ustreza?
  5. Gostitelj gostu pokaže tri proste sobe. Katera poved najbolj ustreza?

C. Poiščite napako

V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.

  1. We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, most of them had several years of experience in the industry.
  2. Everything what the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers.
  3. The house in that my grandparents lived for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family.
  4. Whatever you will decide about the job offer, your family and friends will support you all the way.
  5. The study measures the extent to which regular exercise improves sleep in adults over the age of sixty.

D. V kontekstu

Preberite e-sporočilo in oštevilčene dele prepišite v bolj formalnem, povezanem slogu.

Interview invitation
Dear Ms Kovac,
(18) Thank you for your application. We received it on 3 May. (19) The panel has five members. All of them were impressed by your experience, and we would like to invite you to an interview. (20) We use a system. In this system, each candidate gives a ten-minute presentation. (21) Interviews end on 20 May. At that moment the panel will make its decision. (22) Please let us know if you cannot attend. If that happens, we will offer you another date. (23) You may bring any materials that you find useful. (24) The person you should send questions to is Mr Adebayo.
Yours sincerely,
Hana Iqbal
  1. Povedi v (18) združite v eno z nedoločujočim oziralnim odvisnikom.
  2. Prvi dve povedi v (19) združite z "all of whom".
  3. Povedi v (20) združite v eno z "whereby".
  4. Povedi v (21) združite z "at which point".
  5. Povedi v (22) združite z "in which case".
  6. Prepišite (23) s samostalniškim oziralnim odvisnikom na -ever.
  7. Prepišite (24) formalno, s "to whom".

E. Na vrsti ste vi

Pišite v angleščini.

  1. V 2–3 povedih napišite formalno zahvalo učitelju ali mentorju. Enkrat uporabite predlog + whom in enkrat the extent to which ali the way in which.
  2. V 2–3 povedih opišite načrt, ki se lahko zalomi. Enkrat uporabite in which case in enkrat by which time ali at which point.
  3. V 2–3 povedih opišite skupino ljudi ali stvari, ki jo poznate. Uporabite en količinski izraz + of whom / of which in eno besedo na -ever (whoever, whatever ali whichever).

F. Mešano ponavljanje

Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.

  1. B2-08 Non-defining relative clauses: oziralni odvisniki z vejicami v angleščini
    Povežite z nedoločujočim oziralnim odvisnikom: My sister is a chef. She lives in Rome.
  2. B2-20 Samostalniški odvisniki v angleščini: that, whether, what razloženi v slovenščini
    Prepišite tako, da začnete z "What": The thing that surprised me was her calm reaction.
  3. C1-13 Discourse markers II: vzrok, primer, priznanje in povzetek v angleškem besedilu
    Prepišite z "albeit": The project was a success, although it was an expensive one.
Rešitve

A. Oblika

  1. The woman to whom I sent the email is my manager.
  2. The company has a new scheme whereby staff can buy shares at a discount.
  3. The flight might be delayed, in which case we'll miss our connection.
  4. We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had closed. / We didn't get there until midnight, by which time the restaurant had already closed.
  5. I asked two mechanics, neither of whom could find the problem.
  6. Whoever designed this app deserves an award.
  7. She felt she had nobody with whom to share her worries.

B. Pomen

  1. She is someone on whom I have always been able to rely.
  2. Is that the guy you were telling me about?
  3. We have a system whereby new staff are paired with a mentor.
  4. The speaker began shouting, at which point security asked him to leave.
  5. You can take whichever room you prefer tonight.

C. Poiščite napako

  1. We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, most of whom had several years of experience in the industry. / We interviewed twelve candidates for the post, and most of them had several years of experience in the industry.
  2. Everything the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers. / Everything that the minister said in her speech last night had already been announced in the morning papers.
  3. The house in which my grandparents lived for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family. / The house that my grandparents lived in for over fifty years has finally been sold to a young family.
  4. Whatever you decide about the job offer, your family and friends will support you all the way.
  5. ✓ The study measures the extent to which regular exercise improves sleep in adults over the age of sixty.

D. V kontekstu

  1. Thank you for your application, which we received on 3 May.
  2. The panel has five members, all of whom were impressed by your experience, and we would like to invite you to an interview.
  3. We use a system whereby each candidate gives a ten-minute presentation.
  4. Interviews end on 20 May, at which point the panel will make its decision.
  5. Please let us know if you cannot attend, in which case we will offer you another date.
  6. You may bring whatever materials you find useful.
  7. The person to whom you should send questions is Mr Adebayo.

E. Na vrsti ste vi

  1. I would like to thank Dr Novak, without whom I would never have finished this project. Her advice has changed the way in which I approach research.
  2. We're planning to leave at six, but the traffic may be heavy, in which case we'll take the train. Either way, we should arrive by eight, by which time the speeches will have started.
  3. Our team has six members, most of whom work from home. Whoever comes into the office first on Monday makes the coffee.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

  1. My sister, who lives in Rome, is a chef.
  2. What surprised me was her calm reaction.
  3. The project was a success, albeit an expensive one.
Aplikacija za AndroidUčite se na poti Google Play