SlowingoSlovnica
A2 32 / 38

Who, which, that in where: oziralni odvisniki v angleščini razloženi v slovenščini

Who, Which, That: Defining Relative Clauses

Na tej strani
  1. Cilj
  2. Glavna ideja
  3. Slovenščina in angleščina
  4. Oblika
  5. Raba
  6. Pogoste napake
  7. Pasti za govorce slovenščine
  8. Ne zamenjujte
  9. Pravopis in izgovorjava
  10. Zlato pravilo
  11. Vaje

Cilj

Po tej lekciji boste znali združiti dve povedi in natančno povedati, katero osebo, stvar ali kraj imate v mislih. Uporabljali boste who, which, that in where ter sestavili preproste razlage besed, na primer A nurse is someone who looks after sick people.

Glavna ideja

Včasih samostalnik sam ne zadošča. The woman is my teacher. Katera ženska? V sobi jih je deset! Poslušalcu moramo dati več podatkov, da bo vedel, na koga kažemo: The woman who is wearing the red coat is my teacher.

Ta dodatni del je oziralni odvisnik (relative clause). Predstavljajte si lijak. Na vrhu gre vanj vseh deset žensk, na dnu pa pride ven samo ena: tista v rdečem plašču. Odvisnik poslušalcu natančno pove, katero mislite.

Odvisnik se začne z oziralno besedo: who za ljudi, which za stvari, that za ljudi in stvari ter where za kraje. Ta beseda opravi dve nalogi hkrati. Poveže povedi in zasede mesto besede v odvisniku (he, she, it, them, there). Zato ne dodajate še enega he, she ali it: oziralna beseda je že ta oseba ali stvar.

Slovenščina in angleščina

Slovenščina ima za večino teh primerov eno samo besedico: „ki“. Rečemo „moški, ki živi zraven“ in „avtobus, ki pelje na letališče“ – „ki“ velja za ljudi in stvari. Angleščina pa izbira: who za ljudi, which za stvari, that za oboje. Za kraje imamo „kjer“, kar je angleški where, za „nekaj, kar“ in „nekdo, ki“ pa angleščina uporabi something that in someone who.

Največja razlika je pri predmetu. Ko oziralni odvisnik govori o predmetu, slovenščina za „ki“ doda še zaimek v pravem sklonu: „knjiga, ki sem jo kupil“, „mesto, ki sem ga obiskal“. Angleška oziralna beseda pa sama zasede to mesto, zato zaimka ni: the book that I bought. Še ena razlika je v zapisu: sredi povedi pred „ki“ in „kjer“ v slovenščini vedno stoji vejica, v angleščini pred takim odvisnikom vejice ni.

SlovenščinaAngleščinaV čem je razlika?
Dekle, ki sedi poleg mene, je iz Kanade.The girl who sits next to me is from Canada.oseba → who / that; brez vejice
Imamo psa, ki se boji mačk.We have a dog that is scared of cats.stvar ali žival → which / that
Telefon, ki sem ga kupil, ne dela več.The phone that I bought has stopped working.„ga“ v angleščini odpade
Knjiga, ki jo zdaj berem, je res dobra.The book that I'm reading at the moment is really good.„jo“ v angleščini odpade
To je restavracija, kjer sva imela prvi zmenek.This is the restaurant where we had our first date.„kjer“ → where; there ne dodamo
Pomivalni stroj je naprava, ki pomiva krožnike.A dishwasher is a machine that washes plates.razlaga besede: something / a machine that
Kdo živi zraven? / Moški, ki živi zraven, je pilot.Who lives next door? / The man who lives next door is a pilot.slovenščina loči „kdo“ in „ki“, angleščina ima obakrat who

Na kratko: „ki“ je za ljudi who / that, za stvari which / that, „kjer“ je where; slovenski zaimek „ga, jo, jih“ za „ki“ v angleščini odpade, vejice pa ni.

Oblika

Izbira oziralne besede

SamostalnikOziralna besedaPrimer
osebawho / thatthe man who / that lives next door
stvar ali živalwhich / thatthe bus which / that goes to the airport
kraj (+ popoln odvisnik)wherethe café where we met

Oziralna beseda nadomesti osebek

Dve povediEna poved
I have a friend. She speaks four languages.I have a friend who speaks four languages.
This is the train. It goes to Oxford.This is the train that goes to Oxford.

Oziralna beseda nadomesti predmet

Dve povediEna poved
The film was great. We saw it last night.The film that we saw last night was great.
The man is my uncle. You met him at the party.The man who you met at the party is my uncle.

Where nadomesti there (na tem kraju)

Dve povediEna poved
That's the hotel. We stayed there.That's the hotel where we stayed.

Brez dodatnega zaimka

PravilnoNapačno
the man who lives herethe man who he lives here
the book that I boughtthe book that I bought it
the town where I grew upthe town where I grew up there

Raba

1Who in that za ljudi

Z who ali that povemo, katero osebo mislimo. Za ljudi je who pogostejši, posebno v pisnem jeziku. Slovenski „ki“ je tu who ali that.

The girl who sits next to me in class is from Canada.
Dekle, ki pri pouku sedi poleg mene, je iz Kanade.
„ki“ za osebo → who
Do you know anyone who can fix a laptop?
Poznaš koga, ki zna popraviti prenosnik?
The doctor that I saw yesterday was very kind.
Zdravnik, pri katerem sem bil včeraj, je bil zelo prijazen.
v angleščini za that ni ne predloga ne zaimka
I have a cousin who works for a big tech company.
Imam bratranca, ki dela v velikem tehnološkem podjetju.

2Which in that za stvari

Za stvari in živali uporabite which ali that. V vsakdanjem govoru je that pogostejši. Pazite na predmet: slovenski „ga“, „jo“ ali „jih“ za „ki“ v angleščini izgine.

The phone that I bought last week has stopped working.
Telefon, ki sem ga kupil prejšnji teden, ne dela več.
„ga“ odpade: that I bought
Is this the bus which goes to the city centre?
Ali je to avtobus, ki pelje v središče mesta?
I found a website that has free recipes.
Našla sem spletno stran, ki ponuja brezplačne recepte.
We have a dog that is scared of cats.
Imamo psa, ki se boji mačk.
žival → which / that
The trains which leave from platform 2 don't go to the airport.
Vlaki, ki odpeljejo z drugega perona, ne peljejo na letališče.

3Where za kraje

Where uporabite, ko je odvisnik popoln že brez kraja: we stayed je popoln, zato the hotel where we stayed. Če glagol potrebuje predmet (I visited it), uporabite that ali which: the city that I visited. Slovenščina loči podobno: „kraj, kjer sem bil“, a „mesto, ki sem ga obiskal“.

This is the restaurant where we had our first date.
To je restavracija, kjer sva imela prvi zmenek.
„kjer“ → where
I'd like to live in a town where everyone knows each other.
Rad bi živel v kraju, kjer se vsi poznajo.
The office where my mum works is next to the river.
Pisarna, kjer dela moja mama, je ob reki.
mum (UK), mom (US)
Is there a shop near here where I can buy batteries?
Je tu blizu kakšna trgovina, kjer lahko kupim baterije?
Rome is the city that I want to visit next.
Rim je naslednje mesto, ki ga želim obiskati.
visit + predmet → that, ne where

4Razlage: someone who / something that / a place where

Oziralni odvisniki so zelo uporabni za razlago besed, posebno kadar besede ne poznate ali se je ne spomnite. Pazite: slovensko „nekaj, kar“ je v angleščini something that.

A nurse is someone who looks after sick people.
Medicinska sestra je nekdo, ki skrbi za bolnike.
„nekdo, ki“ → someone who
A dishwasher is a machine that washes plates and glasses.
Pomivalni stroj je naprava, ki pomiva krožnike in kozarce.
A library is a place where you can borrow books.
Knjižnica je kraj, kjer si lahko izposodite knjige.
„kraj, kjer“ → a place where
A vet is a doctor who looks after animals.
Veterinar je zdravnik, ki zdravi živali.
What do you call the thing that opens bottles?
Kako se reče stvari, s katero odpiramo steklenice?
uporabno, ko pozabite besedo

5Določanje: katero točno

Z oziralnim odvisnikom izberemo eno osebo ali stvar med mnogimi. Brez odvisnika poslušalec ne ve, katero mislite. Glagol v odvisniku se ujema s samostalnikom pred who / which / that.

The woman who is wearing the red coat is my teacher.
Ženska, ki ima na sebi rdeč plašč, je moja učiteljica.
The book that I'm reading at the moment is really good.
Knjiga, ki jo zdaj berem, je res dobra.
„jo“ odpade
Where are the keys that were on the table?
Kje so ključi, ki so bili na mizi?
The people who live upstairs are very noisy.
Ljudje, ki živijo nad nami, so zelo glasni.
people → live
I can't find the photo that you sent me.
Ne najdem fotografije, ki si mi jo poslal.
„jo“ odpade: that you sent me
The man who lives upstairs is a chef.
Moški, ki živi nad nami, je kuhar.
the man → lives

Pogoste napake

❌The man who he lives next door is a pilot.
✅The man who lives next door is a pilot.
Who že nadomesti he.
❌This is the cake that I made it.
✅This is the cake that I made.
That že nadomesti it.
❌The woman which works here is nice.
✅The woman who works here is nice.
Za ljudi: who ali that, ne which.
❌That's the shop where I bought it there.
✅That's the shop where I bought it.
Where že nadomesti there.
❌The town where I live in is small.
✅The town where I live is small.
Where že vsebuje in. (Pravilno je tudi The town that I live in.)
❌The city where I visited was beautiful.
✅The city that I visited was beautiful.
Visit potrebuje predmet, zato odvisnik ni popoln: uporabite that ali which.
❌The people who works here are friendly.
✅The people who work here are friendly.
Glagol se ujema s samostalnikom pred who (people → work).
❌A teacher is someone what teaches.
✅A teacher is someone who teaches.
Za takim samostalnikom ne stoji what.

Pasti za govorce slovenščine

1. „Klop, ki jo je naredil dedek“ → the bench that my grandfather made it. Ko odvisnik govori o predmetu, slovenščina za „ki“ doda zaimek v pravem sklonu („ga“, „jo“, „jih“). Angleška oziralna beseda to mesto zasede sama, zato zaimek odpade – pri stvareh in pri ljudeh.

❌The wooden bench that my grandfather made it forty years ago still stands in front of our holiday cottage near Bohinj.
✅The wooden bench that my grandfather made forty years ago still stands in front of our holiday cottage near Bohinj.
that že nadomesti it
❌The ski instructor who we hired him for the children last winter at Krvavec was patient and very funny.
✅The ski instructor who we hired for the children last winter at Krvavec was patient and very funny.
who že nadomesti him

2. „Sosedje, ki…“ → the neighbours which. Slovenski „ki“ velja za ljudi in stvari, zato se which rad prikrade tudi k ljudem. Za ljudi uporabite who ali that.

❌The neighbours which feed our cat whenever we spend a week at the seaside in Piran are a retired couple from Celje.
✅The neighbours who feed our cat whenever we spend a week at the seaside in Piran are a retired couple from Celje. ali The neighbours that feed our cat whenever we spend a week at the seaside in Piran are a retired couple from Celje.
za ljudi who ali that

3. „Nekaj, kar…“ → something what. Po „nekaj“, „vse“ in „to“ slovenščina uporabi „kar“, ki ga radi prevedemo z what. Za samostalnikom ali za something v angleščini stoji that.

❌My aunt from Kranj sent me something what makes cold coffee in two minutes, but I have no idea what it is called in English.
✅My aunt from Kranj sent me something that makes cold coffee in two minutes, but I have no idea what it is called in English.
za something: that, ne what

4. Vejica pred „ki“ → commas in English. V slovenščini sredi povedi pred „ki“ in „kjer“ vedno stoji vejica. V angleščini odvisnik, ki določa, katerega mislimo, nima vejic. Z vejicama poved dobi drug pomen: odvisnik velja za vse.

⚠️Pupils, who finish the matura with excellent results, can choose almost any study programme at the University of Ljubljana.
✅Pupils who finish the matura with excellent results can choose almost any study programme at the University of Ljubljana.
Slovnično je pravilno, vendar vejici pomenita, da so odlično maturo opravili vsi dijaki.

Ne zamenjujte

who v vprašanju in who v oziralnem odvisniku – V vprašanju who sprašuje po podatku. V oziralnem odvisniku poveže dve misli, odvisnik za samostalnikom pa ima besedni red trdilne povedi. Slovenščina tu loči „kdo“ in „ki“, angleščina pa ima obakrat who. Glejte A1-16.

Who lives next door?
Kdo živi v sosednjem stanovanju?
vprašanje: „kdo“
The man who lives next door is a pilot.
Moški, ki živi v sosednjem stanovanju, je pilot.
oziralni odvisnik: „ki“
Where did you meet her?
Kje si jo spoznal?
vprašanje: did + osebek
That's the café where we met.
To je kavarna, kjer sva se spoznala.
oziralni odvisnik: brez did

where ali that / which za kraje – Where uporabite, ko je odvisnik popoln brez kraja (we saw the dinosaurs there). That / which uporabite, ko je kraj sam osebek ali predmet odvisnika.

That's the museum where we saw the dinosaurs.
To je muzej, kjer smo videli dinozavre.
tam smo jih videli
That's the museum that opened last year.
To je muzej, ki je lani odprl vrata.
muzej je osebek → that

Ta lekcija in naslednji koraki – whose, when in izpust who / that (the book I bought) so v B1-20. Odvisniki z vejicami, ki dodajo podatek (My brother, who lives in Rome, …), so v B2-08.

Pravopis in izgovorjava

  • Brez vejic: odvisnik je del samostalnika. To je drugače kot v slovenščini, kjer pred „ki“ in „kjer“ vedno pišemo vejico. Vejice dajo drugo vrsto odvisnika z drugim pomenom – glejte B2-08.
  • that je v odvisniku navadno šibek: /ðət/ – the car that I bought. Samoglasnik je polglasnik, kot v „pes“. Glasu /ð/ slovenščina nima: konica jezika je rahlo med zobmi, glas je zveneč. Ne izgovarjajte ga kot d ali z.
  • who /huː/: w je nem. h je le rahel izdih, ne slovenski h s šumom.
  • which /wɪtʃ/ zveni enako kot witch. /w/ na začetku besede je za slovensko uho nov: ustnice zaokrožite kot za u in jih hitro razprite, brez stika z zobmi, zato to ni v. Končni /tʃ/ je slovenski č.
  • Samostalnik in odvisnik izgovorite kot eno skupino, brez premora: the woman who lives upstairs | is a doctor.

Zlato pravilo

Ljudje → who / that. Stvari → which / that. Kraji → where, ko je odvisnik popoln brez kraja. Oziralna beseda nadomesti osebo, stvar ali kraj, zato ne dodajajte še he, she, it ali there. In zapomnite si: slovenski „ki sem ga“ je angleški that I – brez it.

Vaje

A. Oblika

Dopolnite povedi z ustrezno oziralno besedo ali združite dve povedi v eno.

  1. A fridge is a machine keeps food cold.
  2. A dentist is someone takes care of your teeth.
  3. The people live next door are from Chile.
  4. Združite povedi: I met a man. He plays in a band.
  5. Združite povedi: This is the park. I go running there.
  6. Združite povedi: The pizza was delicious. We ordered it.

B. Pomen

Izberite pravilni odgovor.

  1. Izberite pravilni odgovor: The woman … runs the café is very friendly.
  2. Izberite pravilni odgovor: This is the hotel … we stayed last summer.
  3. Izberite pravilni odgovor: Paris is the city … I'd most like to visit.
  4. Izberite pravilni odgovor: I lost the umbrella … you gave me.
  5. Katera poved pove, za katerega sodelavca gre?

C. Poiščite napako

V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.

  1. The boy who he broke the window ran away.
  2. Here is the email that you wanted it.
  3. The students which passed the test got a certificate.
  4. A library is a place where you can borrow books.

D. V kontekstu

Dopolnite pogovor z manjkajočimi besedami.

Looking for a house
Agent: This is the house 16 has a big garden. It's on the street 17 the new market is.
Sara: It's lovely. Is there a supermarket 18 is open late?
Agent: Yes, and the woman 19 owns it lives upstairs. She's very friendly.
Sara: Great. And is that the bus stop 20 I can get the bus to the city centre?

E. Na vrsti ste vi

Pišite v angleščini.

  1. Razložite dve besedi, ne da bi ju izgovorili. Uporabite someone who, something that ali a place where.
  2. Napišite eno poved o osebi ali kraju, ki vam veliko pomeni.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.

  1. A1-16 Vprašalnice v angleščini (question words): what, where, who, how – besedni red
    Where you buy that jacket?
  2. A2-28 Used to: pretekle navade v angleščini (kako povemo „včasih sem“)
    I like vegetables, but now I love them. (zanikana oblika used to)
  3. A2-16 Present Perfect za izkušnje: Have you ever…? razloženo v slovenščini
    Have you ever (be) to the restaurant where they make that famous pizza?
Rešitve

A. Oblika

  1. that / which
  2. who / that
  3. who / that
  4. I met a man who plays in a band. / I met a man that plays in a band.
  5. This is the park where I go running. / This is the park that I go running in. / This is the park which I go running in.
  6. The pizza that we ordered was delicious. / The pizza which we ordered was delicious. / The pizza we ordered was delicious.

B. Pomen

  1. who
  2. where
  3. that
  4. that
  5. The colleague who sits next to me is ill.

C. Poiščite napako

  1. The boy who broke the window ran away. / The boy that broke the window ran away.
  2. Here is the email that you wanted. / Here is the email which you wanted. / Here is the email you wanted.
  3. The students who passed the test got a certificate. / The students that passed the test got a certificate.
  4. ✓ A library is a place where you can borrow books.

D. V kontekstu

  1. that / which
  2. where
  3. that / which
  4. who / that
  5. where

E. Na vrsti ste vi

  1. It's someone who cuts your hair. It's a place where you can watch films on a big screen.
  2. My grandmother is the person who taught me to cook.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

  1. did
  2. didn't use to / never used to
  3. been
Aplikacija za AndroidUčite se na poti Google Play