SlowingoGramatika
B2 13 / 30

It is said that i he is said to: „smatra se da“ i „navodno“ na engleskom

It Is Said That… / He Is Said To…: The Reporting Passive

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete prenijeti ono što ljudi općenito govore, vjeruju ili očekuju, a da ih ne imenujete – It is believed that…, She is said to be…, He is thought to have left…, There are reported to be… – i upotrebljavati te strukture u vijestima i stručnim tekstovima.

Osnovna ideja

Često želimo podijeliti informaciju, a ne reći tko ju je rekao. Izvor su „ljudi općenito“, nije poznat ili ne želimo osobno jamčiti za tvrdnju. Usporedite:

People say that the house is haunted. – neformalno; people je neodređeno. It is said that the house is haunted. / The house is said to be haunted. – neutralno, bezlično, oprezno.

Izvještajni pasiv (reporting passive) drži tvrdnju na distanci. Kaže: „To se govori ili vjeruje – ja to prenosim, ne jamčim da je istina.“ Zato ga novinari, znanstvenici i povjesničari upotrebljavaju stalno.

Postoje dva obrasca. Obrazac 1 počinje praznim it i zadržava cijelu rečenicu s that. Obrazac 2 osobu ili stvar o kojoj je riječ stavlja na početak i upotrebljava infinitiv s to. Oblik infinitiva tada pokazuje vrijeme prenesene radnje.

Hrvatski i engleski

Obrazac 1 ima dobar hrvatski parnjak: „Kaže se da…“, „Vjeruje se da…“, „Smatra se da…“, „Očekuje se da…“. Razlika je u subjektu: hrvatska rečenica sa „se“ nema riječ koja odgovara engleskom it, a engleska rečenica bez it nije moguća: It is believed that…

Obrazac 2 hrvatski nema. Mi kažemo „Za nju se kaže da je…“, „O njemu se priča da…“ ili jednostavno „Navodno je…“. Zato učenici miješaju obrasce ili prijedlog prenose u engleski. U engleskom osoba postaje subjekt: She is said to be…

Hrvatski ima samo jedan oblik infinitiva („pobjeći“), pa se prošlost vidi tek u rečenici s „da“: „Smatra se da su lopovi pobjegli.“ Engleski za raniju radnju ima posebni infinitiv: to have + particip prošli – The thieves are thought to have escaped.

I pazite na „ima“: „Navodno ima duh u hotelu“, „Smatra se da ima manje od 400 tigrova“. Hrvatsko „ima“ ne mijenja se, a u engleskom there is / there are slaže se s imenicom iza sebe.

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Kaže se da je stari hrast star više od 800 godina.It is said that the old oak tree is over 800 years old.za englesko it u „kaže se“ nema riječi → It is said
Očekuje se da će nova linija proraditi 2028.It is expected that the new line will open in 2028.ovdje je isto: rečenica s „da“ → that + normalno vrijeme
Za nju se smatra da je jedna od najbogatijih žena u zemlji.She is believed to be one of the richest women in the country.osoba postaje subjekt + to
Navodno predsjednik razmatra novi plan.The president is reported to be considering a new plan.radnja u tijeku → to be + -ing
Smatra se da je osumnjičeni napustio zemlju.The suspect is believed to have left the country.ranija radnja → to have + particip prošli
Vjeruje se da u regiji ima manje od 400 tigrova.There are believed to be fewer than 400 tigers left in the region.„ima“ → there are uz množinu
Nekad se mislilo da se Sunce okreće oko Zemlje.It was once thought that the sun went around the earth.prošlo vjerovanje → was thought

Ukratko: „kaže se / smatra se da…“ = It is said / thought that…; „za njega se kaže da…“ i „navodno…“ = He is said to…; „smatra se da je učinio…“ = is thought to have done; „ima“ = there is / there are prema imenici.

Oblik

Obrazac 1: It + pasivni izvještajni glagol + rečenica s that

Itbe + particip prošlirečenica s that
Itis saidthat the castle is haunted.
Itis believedthat the suspect has left the country.
Itwas thoughtthat the disease was spread by insects.
Itis expectedthat prices will rise.

Česti glagoli: say, believe, think, report, know, expect, claim, consider, understand, allege, estimate.

Obrazac 2: Subjekt + pasivni izvještajni glagol + infinitiv s to

Vrijeme prenesene radnjeOblik infinitivaPrimjer
isto vrijeme (stanje / navika)to + osnovni oblikShe is said to be very rich.
isto vrijeme (u tijeku)to be + -ingHe is believed to be hiding in the mountains.
ranijeto have + particip prošliThe thieves are thought to have escaped by car.
ranije, kroz neko razdobljeto have been + -ingShe is reported to have been living abroad for years.
kasnije (uz expect)to + osnovni oblikThe minister is expected to resign.

There + pasivni izvještajni glagol + to be

Primjer
jedninaThere is said to be a hidden tunnel under the city.
množinaThere are believed to be over 2,000 species in the park.
prošlostThere were thought to be no survivors.

Izvještajni glagol u prošlosti

ObrazacPrimjer
It was + particip prošli + that…It was believed that the earth was flat.
Subjekt + was / were + particip prošli + infinitiv s toThe ship was thought to have sunk near the coast.

Uporaba

1It is said / believed / thought that…

It + pasivni izvještajni glagol + that upotrijebite da prenesete opće mišljenje, vjerovanje ili tvrdnju, a da ne imenujete izvor. Rečenica s that zadržava svoje normalno vrijeme – kao hrvatska rečenica s „da“.

It is said that the old oak tree is over 800 years old.
Kaže se da je stari hrast star više od 800 godina.
„kaže se“ → It is said
It is widely believed that the company will be sold.
Općenito se vjeruje da će tvrtka biti prodana.
It has been reported that three people were injured.
Javljeno je da su tri osobe ozlijeđene.
moguć je i pasiv u Present Perfect
It is known that regular exercise reduces stress.
Poznato je da redovita tjelovježba smanjuje stres.
„poznato je“ → It is known
It is expected that the new line will open in 2028.
Očekuje se da će nova linija proraditi 2028.

2Subjekt + is said to + osnovni oblik – sadašnja stanja i navike

Osobu ili stvar stavite na početak i upotrijebite to + osnovni oblik kad je prenesena situacija istinita sada ili općenito. Za nešto što je sada u tijeku upotrijebite to be + -ing. Uz expect infinitiv se odnosi na budućnost. Na hrvatskom tu kažemo „za nju se kaže da…“ ili „navodno“.

The new café on Mill Street is said to serve the best coffee in town.
Za novi kafić u Mill Streetu kažu da ima najbolju kavu u gradu.
kafić je subjekt + to serve
She is believed to be one of the richest women in the country.
Vjeruje se da je jedna od najbogatijih žena u zemlji.
The president is reported to be considering a new plan.
Predsjednik navodno razmatra novi plan.
u tijeku: to be + -ing
Wolves are known to travel long distances in search of food.
Poznato je da vukovi u potrazi za hranom prelaze velike udaljenosti.
The film is expected to break box-office records.
Očekuje se da će film srušiti rekorde gledanosti.
buduće značenje

3Subjekt + is said to have + particip prošli – ranije radnje

To have + particip prošli upotrijebite kad se prenesena radnja dogodila prije trenutka izvještavanja. Hrvatski infinitiv nema prošli oblik, pa ovdje pazite. Za pasivnu radnju upotrijebite to have been + particip prošli, a za dugotrajnu aktivnost to have been + -ing.

The suspect is believed to have left the country.
Smatra se da je osumnjičeni napustio zemlju.
„je napustio“ → to have left
The old king is said to have written his poems in a single winter.
Kaže se da je stari kralj svoje pjesme napisao u jednoj zimi.
The two leaders are reported to have had a heated argument.
Dvojica čelnika navodno su se žestoko posvađala.
The painting is thought to have been stolen in the 1970s.
Smatra se da je slika ukradena sedamdesetih godina 20. stoljeća.
pasiv: to have been + particip prošli
He is alleged to have been taking bribes for years.
Navodno je godinama primao mito.
kroz razdoblje: to have been + -ing

4There is said to be…

There + pasivni izvještajni glagol + to be upotrijebite da prenesete što prema ljudima, izvješćima ili procjenama postoji – naše „navodno ima“, „smatra se da ima“. Be se slaže s imenicom koja slijedi, iako se hrvatsko „ima“ ne mijenja.

There is said to be a ghost in the east wing of the hotel.
Navodno u istočnom krilu hotela ima duh.
jednina: there is
There are believed to be fewer than 400 tigers left in the region.
Vjeruje se da je u regiji ostalo manje od 400 tigrova.
množina: there are
There are thought to be several reasons for the delay.
Smatra se da za kašnjenje ima nekoliko razloga.
„ima“ → there are
There is reported to have been an explosion at the factory.
Javljeno je da je u tvornici došlo do eksplozije.
ranije: to have been

5Izvještajni glagol u prošlosti

Kad vjerovanje ili tvrdnja pripadaju prošlosti, izvještajni glagol stavite u prošlost. Oblik infinitiva birajte tako da prenesenu radnju usporedite s tim prošlim trenutkom.

It was once thought that the sun went around the earth.
Nekad se mislilo da se Sunce okreće oko Zemlje.
hrvatski u rečenici s „da“ ima prezent
At the time, the drug was considered to be completely safe.
U to se vrijeme lijek smatrao potpuno sigurnim.
The ship was believed to have sunk during the storm.
Vjerovalo se da je brod potonuo za oluje.
ranije od vjerovanja
It was reported that the talks had broken down.
Javljeno je da su pregovori propali.
Past Perfect u rečenici s that

6U vijestima i stručnim tekstovima

Ove su strukture tipične za formalno, neutralno pisanje. Piscima omogućuju da oprezno prenesu tvrdnje, bez osobnih tvrdnji koje ne mogu potkrijepiti. Na hrvatskom isti posao rade „doznaje se“, „procjenjuje se“, „općenito je prihvaćeno“.

The fire is understood to have started in the kitchen.
Doznaje se da je požar izbio u kuhinji.
„doznaje se“ → is understood
The economy is expected to grow by 2% next year.
Očekuje se da će gospodarstvo iduće godine porasti za 2 %.
It is generally accepted that sleep affects memory.
Općenito je prihvaćeno da san utječe na pamćenje.
The vaccine is estimated to have saved millions of lives.
Procjenjuje se da je cjepivo spasilo milijune života.

Ne radi svaki izvještajni glagol u oba obrasca. Suggest i propose, na primjer, upotrebljavaju samo obrazac 1: It was suggested that the meeting should be postponed (ne The meeting was suggested to be postponed). Kad niste sigurni, obrazac 1 je sigurniji izbor.

Česte pogreške

❌He is said that he is very rich.
✅He is said to be very rich. ili It is said that he is very rich.
Nemojte miješati dva obrasca.
❌It is said him to be rich.
✅He is said to be rich.
Uz infinitiv s to osoba je subjekt.
❌The thief is believed to escape yesterday.
✅The thief is believed to have escaped yesterday.
Ranija radnja → to have + particip prošli.
❌They say him to be a genius.
✅He is said to be a genius. ili They say (that) he is a genius.
say + objekt + infinitiv s to ne upotrebljava se u aktivu.
❌There is believed to be many problems.
✅There are believed to be many problems.
be se slaže s imenicom iza sebe.
❌It is know that smoking is harmful.
✅It is known that smoking is harmful.
Upotrijebite particip prošli: known.
❌She is reported to be resigned last week.
✅She is reported to have resigned last week.
Prošli događaj: to have + particip prošli.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Smatra se da…“ → Is thought that… Hrvatska rečenica sa „se“ nema riječ koja odgovara engleskom it, pa se on lako izgubi. Engleska izjavna rečenica mora imati subjekt: It is thought / believed / said that…

❌Is generally thought that the Roman walls under the old part of Split are much older than the palace itself.
✅It is generally thought that the Roman walls under the old part of Split are much older than the palace itself.
obavezan je it

2. „O njemu se priča da…“ → About him is said that… Hrvatski temu tvrdnje uvodi prijedlogom („o njemu“, „za tu plažu“), a ono što se tvrdi stoji u rečenici s „da“. Doslovni prijevod nije engleski: engleskoj rečenici nedostaje subjekt. Odaberite jedan engleski obrazac: osoba ili stvar kao subjekt + is said to, ili It is said that.

❌About the new head chef at the hotel in Opatija is said that he once cooked for a famous Hollywood actor.
✅The new head chef at the hotel in Opatija is said to have once cooked for a famous Hollywood actor. ili It is said that the new head chef at the hotel in Opatija once cooked for a famous Hollywood actor.
osoba je subjekt ili It is said that
❌For that little beach near Rovinj is said that the sea there is the cleanest on the whole peninsula.
✅That little beach near Rovinj is said to have the cleanest sea on the whole peninsula. ili It is said that the sea at that little beach near Rovinj is the cleanest on the whole peninsula.
„za tu plažu se kaže“ → the beach is said to

3. „Za njega se priča da je izvukao…“ → to + osnovni oblik za raniju radnju. Hrvatski infinitiv nema prošli oblik, a prošlost nosi perfekt u rečenici s „da“. Kad se prijeđe na engleski obrazac 2, lako ostane običan infinitiv. Za radnju koja se dogodila prije izvještavanja treba to have + particip prošli.

❌People in Nin still talk about the old fisherman who is said to pull a Roman anchor out of the sea with his bare hands back in 1968.
✅People in Nin still talk about the old fisherman who is said to have pulled a Roman anchor out of the sea with his bare hands back in 1968.
ranije: to have pulled

4. „Smatralo se da su ostala samo dva para…“ → there was + množina. Hrvatsko „ima / bilo je“ ne slaže se s onim što slijedi („bilo je jedno gnijezdo“, „bilo je malo gnijezda“). U engleskom be se slaže s imenicom iza sebe: there is / was + jednina, there are / were + množina.

❌Thirty years ago there was thought to be only a few pairs of griffon vultures left on the cliffs of Cres, so the island started a rescue centre.
✅Thirty years ago there were thought to be only a few pairs of griffon vultures left on the cliffs of Cres, so the island started a rescue centre.
množina: there were

Ne miješajte

People say… i It is said… i He is said to… – ista poruka, različit stil.

People say he's a brilliant cook.
Ljudi kažu da odlično kuha.
neformalno
It is said that he is a brilliant cook.
Kaže se da odlično kuha.
formalno, bezlično
He is said to be a brilliant cook.
Za njega se kaže da odlično kuha.
formalno, naglasak na osobi

to be (sada) i to have been (prije)

The building is thought to be unsafe.
Smatra se da zgrada nije sigurna.
nesigurna je sada
The building is thought to have been unsafe for years.
Smatra se da zgrada već godinama nije sigurna.
stanje do sada; hrvatski ima prezent

be supposed to – This café is supposed to be very good također može značiti „kažu da…“, ali u B2-07 naučili ste njegovo češće značenje: očekivanje ili pravilo.

Slične strukture sa seem i appear (He seems to have left) nisu pasiv; obrađuju se zajedno s ublažavanjem tvrdnji (hedging) u C1-08.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • said se izgovara /sed/, s kratkim e – nemojte ga čitati kako je napisano.
  • It is se u neutralnim tekstovima i u govoru često skraćuje (It's said that…), ali u formalnom pisanju normalni su puni oblici.
  • to have je slab: is thought to have left → /ɪz ˈθɔːt tə həv ˈleft/ (UK), /ɪz ˈθɑːt tə həv ˈleft/ (US). /θ/ u thought nije t ni s: vrh jezika stavite lagano između zuba i pustite zrak.
  • Pisanje čestih participa: believed, thought, known, expected, reported, alleged (dvostruko l), understood.
  • Naglasak pada na particip i ključnu informaciju: She is SAID to be very RICH.

Zlatno pravilo

Dva obrasca: It is said that + rečenica ili subjekt + is said + infinitiv s to. U obrascu 2 oblik infinitiva birajte prema vremenu: to do / to be doing (isto vrijeme), to have done / to have been doing (ranije). I zapamtite: „smatra se da“ počinje s It, a „za njega se kaže“ je He is said to.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite rečenice glagolom iz zagrade u točnom obliku.

  1. It (believe) that the treasure is still buried on the island.
  2. The singer is said (be) very shy in real life.
  3. The robbers are thought (escape) through the back door last night.
  4. There (think) to be about a million words in English.
  5. The team is expected (win) easily on Saturday.
  6. The suspect is believed (stay) with friends at the moment.

B. Značenje

Odaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. Odaberite točan odgovor: The pilot is believed … the crash last night.
  2. Odaberite točan odgovor: The castle is said … haunted — people still see a ghost there today.
  3. Odaberite formalniju i bezličniju rečenicu:
  4. Odaberite točan odgovor: There … reported to be several injuries.
  5. Odaberite točan odgovor: It … that the lake has no bottom.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. She is said that she speaks five languages.
  2. The pilot is believed to survive the crash.
  3. There is reported to be several injuries.
  4. The bridge is thought to have been built by the Romans.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite vijest glagolom iz zagrade u točnom obliku.

News report
A rare painting has disappeared from the City Museum. The painting 16 (believe) to be worth over two million euros. The thieves 17 (think) to 18 (enter) the building through a window on Sunday night. It 19 (report) that the alarm system was not working. There 20 (say) to be no witnesses. Police are 21 (expect) to release more information tomorrow.

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom kratke rečenice u stilu vijesti.

  1. Napišite nešto o nekom mjestu u svom gradu, s is said to ili is believed to.
  2. Napišite kratku rečenicu u stilu vijesti o nečemu što se dogodilo ranije, s is thought to have + particip prošli.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. B1-11 Pasiv u svim vremenima i s modalnim glagolima: is being done, has been done, must be done
    The results (announce) tomorrow.
  2. B1-12 Reported speech: neupravni govor na engleskom (izjave i slaganje vremena)
    Prenesite rečenicu s pomakom vremena unatrag: "I'm tired," she said.
  3. B2-11 Have something done: kako reći „dao sam popraviti“ na engleskom
    I (have / my eyes / test) last week.
  4. B2-09 Reduced relative clauses: skraćene odnosne rečenice na engleskom
    Skratite rečenicu: The house which was built in 1900 is for sale.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. is believed
  2. to be
  3. to have escaped
  4. are thought
  5. to win
  6. to be staying

B. Značenje

  1. to have survived
  2. to be
  3. The CEO is expected to resign.
  4. are
  5. is said

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. She is said to speak five languages. / It is said that she speaks five languages.
  2. The pilot is believed to have survived the crash. / It is believed that the pilot survived the crash.
  3. There are reported to be several injuries.
  4. ✓ The bridge is thought to have been built by the Romans.

D. U kontekstu

  1. is believed
  2. are thought
  3. have entered
  4. is reported / has been reported / was reported
  5. are said
  6. expected

E. Vaš red

  1. The old bridge in my town is said to be over 500 years old.
  2. The fire is thought to have started in a restaurant kitchen.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. will be announced / are going to be announced / are being announced
  2. She said that she was tired. / She said she was tired.
  3. had my eyes tested
  4. The house built in 1900 is for sale.
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play