SlowingoGramatika
B1 13 / 39

Reported speech: neupravni govor na engleskom (izjave i slaganje vremena)

Reported Speech: Statements

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete prenijeti što je netko rekao – She said (that) she was tired – pravilno mijenjajući vremena, zamjenice i riječi za vrijeme, i znat ćete kad se vrijeme ne mora mijenjati.

Osnovna ideja

Kad prenosite nečije riječi, ne puštate snimku. Prenosite poruku – sa svojeg stajališta: iz svojeg vremena, svojeg mjesta, svojeg gledišta.

Zamislite da je Maria u ponedjeljak rekla: "I'm tired. I'll call you tomorrow." U petak to pričate prijatelju. Ponedjeljak je sada prošlost, pa se cijeli razgovor pomakne jedan korak unatrag u vremenu: Maria said she was tired and would call me the next day. Taj pomak unatrag zove se backshift (slaganje vremena).

I sve ostalo prelazi na vaše gledište. Njezin I postaje she; njezin you postaje me; njezin tomorrow postaje the next day, jer „sutra“ iz ponedjeljka nije „sutra“ iz petka.

Ali backshift nije pravilo za robote. Ako je ono što je rekla još istina ili prenosite nešto što je rečeno maloprije, možete zadržati izvorno vrijeme. Uvijek se pitajte: kako to izgleda odande gdje sam sada?

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski u neupravnom govoru zadržava vrijeme izvorne rečenice: „Umorna sam“ → „Rekla je da je umorna.“ „Nazvat ću te“ → „Rekao je da će me nazvati.“ Iza „rekao je da“ vrijeme se ne pomiče. Engleski iza prošlog glagola said obično pomiče vrijeme jedan korak unatrag: She said she was tired, He said he would call me.

Zamjenice i riječi za vrijeme i mjesto i na hrvatskom prilagođavamo gledištu onoga tko prenosi („Rekla je da će doći sutradan“) – tu je engleski vrlo sličan. Ali pazite na „rekao mi je“: na hrvatskom osoba stoji odmah uz glagol, a englesko say je ne može imati iza sebe. Uz osobu upotrijebite tell: He told me…

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Rekla je da je jako zauzeta.She said she was really busy.hrvatski zadržava prezent → engleski Past Simple
Rekli su da traže novi stan.They said they were looking for a new flat.prezent → Past Continuous
Rekao je da nikad nije bio u Aziji.He said he had never been to Asia.perfekt → had + particip prošli
Rekao je da će mi poslati pojedinosti.He said he would send me the details.„će“ → would
Rekla je da ne može doći na zabavu.She said she couldn't come to the party.„može“ → could
Rekao je da sam mu najbolji prijatelj.He said I was his best friend.ovdje je isto: zamjenice prema gledištu onoga tko prenosi
Rekla mi je da je umorna.She told me she was tired.„rekao mi je“ → told me, nikad said me
Jake kaže da kasni.Jake says he's running late.ovdje je isto: glagol u sadašnjem vremenu → nema pomaka

Ukratko: hrvatsko „rekao je da“ zadržava izvorno vrijeme, a englesko said obično ga pomiče korak unatrag; „rekao mi je“ → told me.

Oblik

Osnovni obrazac

Glagol izvještavanja(that)prenesena rečenica
She said(that)she was hungry.
He told me(that)he had lost his keys.

That nije obavezan i u govoru se često izostavlja, dok hrvatsko „da“ uvijek stoji. Say i tell imaju različite obrasce: pogledajte B1-13.

Backshift – promjena vremena iza prošlog glagola izvještavanja

Upravni govorNeupravni govor
Present Simple: "I work in a bank."Past Simple: She said she worked in a bank.
Present Continuous: "I'm leaving."Past Continuous: He said he was leaving.
Present Perfect: "I've finished."Past Perfect: She said she had finished.
Past Simple: "I saw it."Past Perfect: He said he had seen it. (moguće je i saw)
will: "I'll help."would: She said she would help.
can: "I can swim."could: He said he could swim.
may: "It may rain."might: She said it might rain.
must (obveza): "I must go."had to: He said he had to go. (moguće je i must)
am / is / are going to: "We're going to move."was / were going to: They said they were going to move.

Bez promjene: would, could, should, might, ought to i Past Perfect ostaju isti.

Zamjenice i posvojne zamjenice – promijenite ih prema gledištu onoga tko prenosi.

Upravni govorNeupravni govor
"I love my job." (Tom)Tom said he loved his job.
"We'll meet you at our house." (vaši roditelji, vama)They said they would meet me at their house.

Riječi za vrijeme i mjesto (kad su vrijeme ili mjesto sada drukčiji)

Upravni govorNeupravni govor
nowthen, at that time
today / tonightthat day / that night
yesterdaythe day before, the previous day
tomorrowthe next day, the following day
last weekthe week before, the previous week
next monththe following month
… ago… before, … earlier
herethere
this / thesethat / those (ili the)

Uporaba

1Backshift iza said

Kad je glagol izvještavanja u prošlosti (said, told), pomaknite vrijeme jedan korak unatrag. Hrvatski tu zadržava izvorno vrijeme.

She said she was really busy.
Rekla je da je jako zauzeta.
„je zauzeta“ (prezent) → was
They said they were looking for a new flat.
Rekli su da traže novi stan.
„traže“ → were looking
He said he had never been to Asia.
Rekao je da nikad nije bio u Aziji.
„nije bio“ → had never been
She said she had missed the train.
Rekla je da je propustila vlak.
moguće je i she missed

2Modalni glagoli u neupravnom govoru

Will → would, can → could, may → might, a must (obveza) → had to. Would, could, should, might i ought to se ne mijenjaju.

He said he would send me the details.
Rekao je da će mi poslati pojedinosti.
„će“ → would
She said she couldn't come to the party.
Rekla je da ne može doći na zabavu.
„ne može“ → couldn't
He said the shop might be closed.
Rekao je da bi trgovina mogla biti zatvorena.
The instructor said we had to wear a helmet.
Instruktor je rekao da moramo nositi kacigu.
„moramo“ → had to
The doctor said I should rest.
Liječnica je rekla da bih se trebao odmarati.
should se ne mijenja

3Promjena zamjenica i posvojnih zamjenica

Prenosite sa svojeg gledišta. Pitajte se: tko sada govori, a tko sluša? Hrvatski to radi isto.

My boss said she liked my haircut.
Šefica je rekla da joj se sviđa moja frizura.
"your haircut" → my haircut
Our neighbours said they had sold their car.
Susjedi su rekli da su prodali auto.
"we" → they, "our" → their
He said I was his best friend.
Rekao je da sam mu najbolji prijatelj.
"you" → I

4Promjena riječi za vrijeme i mjesto

Ako su vrijeme ili mjesto drukčiji kad prenosite, promijenite riječi kao today, tomorrow, ago, here.

She said she would see me the next day.
Rekla je da ćemo se vidjeti sutradan.
"tomorrow" → the next day
He said he had started the job two years before.
Rekao je da je na tom poslu počeo dvije godine prije toga.
„prije dvije godine“ → two years before, a ne ago
She said she was staying there that night.
Rekla je da te noći ostaje ondje.
"here" → there, "tonight" → that night
He said the parcel had arrived the day before.
Rekao je da je paket stigao dan prije.
"yesterday" → the day before

5Bez backshifta – još je istina ili je upravo rečeno

Ako je informacija još istinita, možete zadržati izvorno vrijeme. To je vrlo često u govoru – i blisko hrvatskom. Backshift je također ispravan.

She said she lives in Glasgow.
Rekla je da živi u Glasgowu.
još uvijek ondje živi
Our teacher said the Earth goes round the Sun.
Učiteljica je rekla da se Zemlja okreće oko Sunca.
opća istina
I said it's at three!
Rekao sam da je u tri!
ponavljam ono što sam maloprije rekao

6Glagol izvještavanja u sadašnjem vremenu – bez backshifta

Ako je glagol izvještavanja u sadašnjem vremenu (says, has said), vremena se ne mijenjaju. To je često kod poruka i bilješki.

Jake says he's running late.
Jake kaže da kasni.
The weather forecast says it'll be sunny all week.
Prognoza kaže da će cijeli tjedan biti sunčano.
Mum has said she can't come this weekend.
Mama je javila da ovaj vikend ne može doći.
Mum (UK) = Mom (US)

Česte pogreške

❌She said me she was tired.
✅She told me she was tired.
Iza say ne stoji izravno osoba: She said she was tired. Pogledajte B1-13.
❌He said he has finished it last week.
✅He said he had finished it last week. ili He said he finished it last week.
Uz završeno prošlo razdoblje (last week) nikad nema Present Perfect: pomaknite u Past Perfect ili zadržite Past Simple.
❌He said that he will call me, but he never did.
✅He said that he would call me, but he never did.
will → would; poziv više nije u budućnosti.
❌They said they must to leave.
✅They said they had to leave.
must → had to; nikad „must to“.
❌A year ago he said he had started the job two years ago.
✅A year ago he said he had started the job two years before.
ago se računa od sada; before od trenutka u prošlosti.
❌Last month she said she would come tomorrow.
✅Last month she said she would come the next day.
Njezino „tomorrow“ nije sutra od danas.
❌She said, she was hungry.
✅She said she was hungry.
Ispred prenesene rečenice nema zareza.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Rekao mi je“ → said me. Hrvatski uz „reći“ odmah stavlja osobu u dativu: „rekao mi je“, „rekla nam je“. Englesko say ne može imati osobu odmah iza sebe. Upotrijebite tell + osoba ili say bez osobe (ili say to me).

❌The receptionist in our hotel in Rovinj said us that breakfast was served on the terrace until eleven.
✅The receptionist in our hotel in Rovinj told us that breakfast was served on the terrace until eleven. ili The receptionist in our hotel in Rovinj said that breakfast was served on the terrace until eleven.
„rekla nam je“ → told us

2. „Rekao je da će…“ → he will. Hrvatski iza „rekao je da“ zadržava futur („da će donijeti“). U engleskom, kad je obećanje izrečeno u prošlosti, a taj je trenutak već prošao, will prelazi u would.

❌Luka told the whole class he will bring his guitar to the end-of-year picnic, so we were all disappointed when he turned up without it.
✅Luka told the whole class he would bring his guitar to the end-of-year picnic, so we were all disappointed when he turned up without it.
obećanje iz prošlosti → would

3. „Rekao je da je već rezervirao“ → he has booked. Hrvatski perfekt („je rezervirao“) lako postane englesko has booked. Iza prošlog said Present Perfect prelazi u Past Perfect: had booked.

❌When I called Filip on Monday, he said he has already booked the tickets for the concert in Zagreb, so I didn't need to worry.
✅When I called Filip on Monday, he said he had already booked the tickets for the concert in Zagreb, so I didn't need to worry.
backshift: has booked → had booked

4. „Rekao je da prodaje stan“ → bez pomaka, a nije više istina. Hrvatski ne pomiče vrijeme, pa se izvorni prezent lako zadrži i kad više ne vrijedi. Engleski bez backshifta znači „to je i sada istina“. Ako situacija više nije takva, pomaknite vrijeme.

⚠️Two years ago our landlord said he is selling the flat, but then he changed his mind and we're still living here.
✅Two years ago our landlord said he was selling the flat, but then he changed his mind and we're still living here.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali bez backshifta zvuči kao da ga i sada prodaje.

Ne miješajte

Upravni ili neupravni govor – upravni govor ponavlja točne riječi u navodnicima; neupravni ih prepričava s promjenama.

Ana said, "I'm hungry."
Ana je rekla: „Gladna sam.“
upravni govor
Ana said she was hungry.
Ana je rekla da je gladna.
neupravni govor

Backshift ili bez backshifta – oboje može biti ispravno. Backshift samo prenosi; bez backshifta pokazujete da vjerujete kako je to i sada istina.

He said he was a vegetarian.
Rekao je da je vegetarijanac.
prenosim što je tada rekao
He said he's a vegetarian, so let's not cook meat.
Rekao je da je vegetarijanac, zato nemojmo kuhati meso.
istina je i sada, i važno je

must (obveza) ili must (zaključak) – must kao obveza često postaje had to. Must kao zaključak B1-16 ostaje must.

She said she had to leave early.
Rekla je da mora otići ranije.
"I must leave early."
He said I must be tired.
Rekao je da sam sigurno umoran.
"You must be tired."

Pravopis i izgovor

  • U neupravnom govoru nema navodnika ni zareza: She said she was tired. I hrvatski ispred „da“ u takvoj rečenici ne stavlja zarez.
  • U upravnom govoru engleski stavlja zarez ispred navodnika, a završnu točku unutar njih: She said, "I'm tired." (Hrvatski tu ima dvotočku: Rekla je: „Umorna sam.“)
  • said se izgovara /sed/, a ne „sejd“. Navika da čitamo kako je napisano ovdje vara.
  • that je, kad se upotrijebi, slab: /ðət/. Glasa /ð/ u hrvatskom nema: vrh jezika lagano stavite između zuba i pustite glas, bez d i bez z.
  • 'd može biti would ili had: She said she'd help (would) / She said she'd helped (had). Pogledajte glagol iza njega.

Zlatno pravilo

Prenosite iz svojeg vremena i mjesta: iza prošlog glagola izvještavanja vrijeme obično pomaknite jedan korak unatrag, a zamjenice i riječi za vrijeme prilagodite. Hrvatsko „rekao je da“ zadržava izvorno vrijeme – engleski said obično ne. Ako je to još istina ili je glagol izvještavanja u sadašnjem vremenu, možete zadržati izvorno vrijeme.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

U zadacima 1–6 upotrijebite backshift.

  1. "I'm cold." → She said she cold.
  2. "We've finished the project." → They said they the project.
  3. "I'll text you." → He said he me.
  4. "I can't find my keys." → She said she her keys.
  5. "I may be late." → He said he late.
  6. "I'm watching a film." → She said she a film.
  7. Prenesite sa said: "I love my new job." (vaša sestra)

B. Značenje

Odaberite odgovor ili dopunite rečenicu prema situaciji.

  1. U ponedjeljak je Tom rekao: "I'll do it tomorrow." Sada je petak. Dopunite: Tom said he would do it .
  2. Prijateljica je to rekla prije pet minuta: "The film starts at eight." Dopunite: She said the film at eight.
  3. "I'm a vegetarian," rekao je Sam prošle godine, i još je vegetarijanac. Koja je rečenica točna?
  4. "You must be tired," rekla mi je medicinska sestra. Prenesite: The nurse said I tired.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. He said me that he was ill.
  2. She said she will come, but she didn't.
  3. They said they must to go home.
  4. The forecast says it will rain tomorrow.

D. U kontekstu

U svako mjesto u tekstu upotrijebite backshift.

Lunch with Clara
I had lunch with Clara yesterday. She said she 16 (be) really happy at her new company. She told me she 17 (just / get) a promotion! She said they 18 (send) her to New York the following month, and that she 19 (can) take her family with her. She also said she 20 (call) me when she got there.

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o onome što su vam drugi rekli.

  1. Sjetite se nečega što vam je prijatelj rekao prošli tjedan. Prenesite to sa said.
  2. Prenesite današnju poruku sa says.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. B1-03 Past Perfect (pluskvamperfekt): I had already left objašnjeno na hrvatskom
    When I got to the station, the train (already / leave).
  2. A2-33 Who called you ili who did you call? Pitanja o subjektu i objektu na engleskom
    Who (you / call) last night?
  3. B1-10 Pasiv u engleskom (passive voice): is made, was built – objašnjeno na hrvatskom
    This house (build) in 1920.
  4. B1-06 Second Conditional: If I had…, I would… – pogodbene rečenice tipa 2 na hrvatskom
    If I (be) you, I'd say sorry.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. was
  2. had finished / 'd finished
  3. would text / 'd text
  4. couldn't find / could not find
  5. might be
  6. was watching
  7. My sister said she loved her new job. / My sister said that she loved her new job. / My sister said she loves her new job. / My sister said that she loves her new job.

B. Značenje

  1. the next day / the following day / on Tuesday
  2. starts / started
  3. both
  4. must be

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. He told me that he was ill. / He said that he was ill. / He told me he was ill. / He said he was ill.
  2. She said she would come, but she didn't. / She said she'd come, but she didn't.
  3. They said they had to go home. / They said they must go home.
  4. ✓ The forecast says it will rain tomorrow.

D. U kontekstu

  1. was
  2. had just got / had just gotten / 'd just got / 'd just gotten
  3. were sending / were going to send / would send
  4. could
  5. would call / 'd call

E. Vaš red

  1. My friend Leo said he was going to move to Madrid.
  2. My brother says he can't come to dinner tonight.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. had already left / 'd already left
  2. did you call
  3. was built
  4. were
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play