SlowingoGramatika
B2 13 / 30

It is said that i He is said to: „kaže se da“ i „veruje se da“ na engleskom

It Is Said That… / He Is Said To…: The Reporting Passive

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Srpski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Upotreba
  6. Česte greške
  7. Zamke za govornike srpskog
  8. Ne mešajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vežbe

Cilj

Posle ove lekcije moći ćete da prenesete šta ljudi uopšte kažu, veruju ili očekuju, a da ih ne imenujete – It is believed that…, She is said to be…, He is thought to have left…, There are reported to be… – i da ove strukture koristite u vestima i stručnim tekstovima.

Osnovna ideja

Često želimo da podelimo informaciju, a da ne kažemo ko ju je rekao. Izvor su „ljudi uopšte“, ili je nepoznat, ili ne želimo da lično garantujemo za tvrdnju. Uporedite:

People say that the house is haunted. – neformalno; people je neodređeno. It is said that the house is haunted. / The house is said to be haunted. – neutralno, bezlično, oprezno.

Ovaj pasiv drži tvrdnju na distanci, kao na ispruženoj ruci. On kaže: „Ovo se priča ili veruje – ja to prenosim, ne garantujem da je tačno.“ Zato ga novinari, naučnici i istoričari stalno koriste.

Postoje dve šeme. Šema 1 počinje praznim it i zadržava celu rečenicu sa that. Šema 2 stavlja osobu ili stvar o kojoj je reč na početak i koristi infinitiv sa to. Oblik infinitiva tada pokazuje vreme radnje o kojoj se priča.

Srpski i engleski

Šema 1 ima savršen srpski parnjak: „Kaže se da“, „Veruje se da“, „Smatra se da“, „Očekuje se da“. Razlika je samo u jednoj reči: srpski nema reč kao it, a engleski mora da ima it kao subjekat. Šema 2 na srpskom ne postoji – kažemo „Za nju se priča da je bogata“ ili „Navodno je bogata“ – pa je engleski She is said to be rich nov obrazac: osoba postaje subjekat, a posle glagola dolazi to. Treća razlika je vreme: srpski perfekat u „veruje se da je pobegao“ na engleskom postaje to have escaped. I četvrta: srpsko „ima“ („kaže se da u hotelu ima duhova“) na engleskom je there is / there are … to be.

SrpskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Kaže se da je zamak uklet.It is said that the castle is haunted.srpski nema reč kao it → engleski It
Veruje se da će firma biti prodata.It is believed that the company will be sold.ovde je isto: „veruje se da“ = It is believed that
Za nju se priča da je jako bogata.She is said to be very rich.srpski nema ovu šemu: osoba je subjekat + to
Veruje se da se krije u planinama.He is believed to be hiding in the mountains.radnja u toku → to be + -ing
Smatra se da su lopovi pobegli kolima.The thieves are thought to have escaped by car.srpski perfekat → to have + particip prošli
Kaže se da ispod grada ima tajni tunel.There is said to be a hidden tunnel under the city.„ima“ → there is … to be
Očekuje se da ministar podnese ostavku.The minister is expected to resign.„da“ + prezent → to + osnovni oblik
Nekad se mislilo da se Sunce okreće oko Zemlje.It was once thought that the sun went around the earth.srpski prezent posle „da“ → engleski oblik za prošlost
Ljudi kažu da odlično kuva.People say he's a brilliant cook.ovde je isto: neformalno

Ukratko: „kaže se / veruje se da“ = It is said / believed that; „za njega se kaže da je“ = He is said to be; „veruje se da je uradio“ = is believed to have done; „kaže se da ima“ = There is said to be.

Oblik

Šema 1: It + glagol izveštavanja u pasivu + rečenica sa that

Itbe + particip prošlirečenica sa that
Itis saidthat the castle is haunted.
Itis believedthat the suspect has left the country.
Itwas thoughtthat the disease was spread by insects.
Itis expectedthat prices will rise.

Česti glagoli: say, believe, think, report, know, expect, claim, consider, understand, allege, estimate.

Šema 2: Subjekat + glagol izveštavanja u pasivu + infinitiv sa to

Vreme radnje o kojoj se pričaOblik infinitivaPrimer
isto vreme (stanje / navika)to + osnovni oblikShe is said to be very rich.
isto vreme (u toku)to be + -ingHe is believed to be hiding in the mountains.
ranijeto have + particip prošliThe thieves are thought to have escaped by car.
ranije, tokom nekog periodato have been + -ingShe is reported to have been living abroad for years.
kasnije (sa expect)to + osnovni oblikThe minister is expected to resign.

There + glagol izveštavanja u pasivu + to be

Primer
jedninaThere is said to be a hidden tunnel under the city.
množinaThere are believed to be over 2,000 species in the park.
prošlostThere were thought to be no survivors.

Glagol izveštavanja u prošlosti

ŠemaPrimer
It was + particip prošli + that…It was believed that the earth was flat.
Subjekat + was / were + particip prošli + infinitiv sa toThe ship was thought to have sunk near the coast.

Upotreba

1It is said / believed / thought that…

It + glagol izveštavanja u pasivu + that koristite da prenesete opšte mišljenje, verovanje ili tvrdnju bez navođenja izvora. Rečenica sa that zadržava svoje uobičajeno vreme. Ovo je srpsko „kaže se da“, „veruje se da“ – samo sa it.

It is said that the old oak tree is over 800 years old.
Kaže se da stari hrast ima preko 800 godina.
„kaže se da“ → It is said that
It is widely believed that the company will be sold.
Mnogi veruju da će firma biti prodata.
It has been reported that three people were injured.
Javljeno je da su tri osobe povređene.
moguć je i Present Perfect u pasivu
It is known that regular exercise reduces stress.
Poznato je da redovno vežbanje smanjuje stres.
srpski nema reč kao it, engleski mora da ga ima
It is expected that the new line will open in 2028.
Očekuje se da će nova linija biti otvorena 2028. godine.

2Subjekat + is said to + osnovni oblik – stanja i navike sada

Stavite osobu ili stvar na početak i koristite to + osnovni oblik kada je ono o čemu se priča tačno sada ili uopšte. Za nešto što je sada u toku koristite to be + -ing. Sa expect infinitiv se odnosi na budućnost. Srpski tu kaže „za X se kaže da…“, „navodno“ ili „smatra se da…“.

The new café on Mill Street is said to serve the best coffee in town.
Za novi kafić u Ulici Mil kažu da služi najbolju kafu u gradu.
kafić je subjekat + to serve
She is believed to be one of the richest women in the country.
Smatra se da je jedna od najbogatijih žena u zemlji.
The president is reported to be considering a new plan.
Prema izveštajima, predsednik razmatra novi plan.
u toku: to be + -ing
Wolves are known to travel long distances in search of food.
Poznato je da vukovi u potrazi za hranom prelaze velike razdaljine.
The film is expected to break box-office records.
Očekuje se da će film oboriti rekorde po zaradi.
značenje budućnosti

3Subjekat + is said to have + particip prošli – ranije radnje

To have + particip prošli koristite kada se radnja o kojoj se priča desila pre trenutka izveštavanja. Za pasivnu radnju koristite to have been + particip prošli, a za dugu aktivnost to have been + -ing. Srpski tu ima perfekat posle „da“: „veruje se da je napustio“.

The suspect is believed to have left the country.
Veruje se da je osumnjičeni napustio zemlju.
„je napustio“ → to have left
The old king is said to have written his poems in a single winter.
Priča se da je stari kralj napisao svoje pesme za samo jednu zimu.
The two leaders are reported to have had a heated argument.
Javlja se da su se dvojica lidera žestoko posvađala.
The painting is thought to have been stolen in the 1970s.
Smatra se da je slika ukradena sedamdesetih godina prošlog veka.
pasiv: to have been + particip prošli
He is alleged to have been taking bribes for years.
Navodno je godinama primao mito.
tokom nekog perioda: to have been + -ing

4There is said to be…

There + glagol izveštavanja u pasivu + to be koristite da prenesete šta postoji, prema onome što ljudi kažu, izveštajima ili procenama. Be se slaže sa imenicom koja sledi. Srpski tu kaže „kaže se da ima“ ili „smatra se da postoji“.

There is said to be a ghost in the east wing of the hotel.
Kaže se da u istočnom krilu hotela ima duhova.
„ima“ → there is … to be
There are believed to be fewer than 400 tigers left in the region.
Veruje se da je u regionu ostalo manje od 400 tigrova.
množina: there are
There are thought to be several reasons for the delay.
Smatra se da postoji nekoliko razloga za kašnjenje.
There is reported to have been an explosion at the factory.
Javlja se da je u fabrici došlo do eksplozije.
ranije: to have been

5Glagol izveštavanja u prošlosti

Kada verovanje ili tvrdnja pripadaju prošlosti, glagol izveštavanja stavite u prošlo vreme. Oblik infinitiva birajte tako što radnju o kojoj se priča uporedite sa tim trenutkom u prošlosti. Pazite: srpski posle „mislilo se da“ obično zadržava prezent („da se Sunce okreće“), a engleski pomera vreme unazad.

It was once thought that the sun went around the earth.
Nekada se mislilo da se Sunce okreće oko Zemlje.
srpski prezent, engleski went
At the time, the drug was considered to be completely safe.
U to vreme lek se smatrao potpuno bezbednim.
The ship was believed to have sunk during the storm.
Verovalo se da je brod potonuo tokom oluje.
ranije od verovanja
It was reported that the talks had broken down.
Javljeno je da su pregovori propali.
Past Perfect u rečenici sa that

6U vestima i stručnim tekstovima

Ove strukture su tipične za formalno, neutralno pisanje. Omogućavaju piscu da oprezno prenese tvrdnje, bez ličnih izjava koje ne može da potkrepi.

The fire is understood to have started in the kitchen.
Kako saznajemo, požar je izbio u kuhinji.
The economy is expected to grow by 2% next year.
Očekuje se da privreda sledeće godine poraste za 2 odsto.
It is generally accepted that sleep affects memory.
Opšte je prihvaćeno da san utiče na pamćenje.
The vaccine is estimated to have saved millions of lives.
Procenjuje se da je vakcina spasla milione života.

Ne rade svi glagoli izveštavanja u obe šeme. Suggest i propose, na primer, koriste samo šemu 1: It was suggested that the meeting should be postponed (ne The meeting was suggested to be postponed). Kada niste sigurni, šema 1 je sigurniji izbor.

Česte greške

❌He is said that he is very rich.
✅He is said to be very rich. ili It is said that he is very rich.
Ne mešajte dve šeme.
❌It is said him to be rich.
✅He is said to be rich.
Uz infinitiv sa to osoba je subjekat.
❌The thief is believed to escape yesterday.
✅The thief is believed to have escaped yesterday.
Ranija radnja → to have + particip prošli.
❌They say him to be a genius.
✅He is said to be a genius. ili They say (that) he is a genius.
say + objekat + infinitiv sa to se ne koristi u aktivu.
❌There is believed to be many problems.
✅There are believed to be many problems.
be se slaže sa imenicom posle njega.
❌It is know that smoking is harmful.
✅It is known that smoking is harmful.
Koristite particip prošli: known.
❌She is reported to be resigned last week.
✅She is reported to have resigned last week.
Događaj u prošlosti: to have + particip prošli.

Zamke za govornike srpskog

1. „Kaže se da“ → bez it. Srpske rečenice „kaže se da“, „očekuje se da“ nemaju reč kao it. Engleska rečenica mora da ima izrečen subjekat, a ovde je to prazno it.

❌Is said that the water from this spring cures headaches.
✅It is said that the water from this spring cures headaches.
nedostaje subjekat it
❌Is expected that most students will pass the entrance exam this year.
✅It is expected that most students will pass the entrance exam this year. ili Most students are expected to pass the entrance exam this year.
„očekuje se da“ → It is expected that

2. „Za novog komšiju se kaže“ → for … it is said. Srpsko „za nekoga se kaže da…“ doslovno daje for X it is said. Na engleskom osoba postaje subjekat (X is said to…) ili ostaje u rečenici sa that.

❌For our new neighbour it is said that he grows the best tomatoes in the village.
✅Our new neighbour is said to grow the best tomatoes in the village. ili It is said that our new neighbour grows the best tomatoes in the village.
„za komšiju se kaže“ → Our neighbour is said to

3. „Kaže se da je mlela“ → to + osnovni oblik za prošlost. Posle srpskog „kaže se da“ perfekat jasno pokazuje prošlost: „Kaže se da je stara vodenica pre sto godina mlela brašno za celu dolinu.“ U šemi 2 prošlost nosi to have + particip prošli; samo to grind zvuči kao sadašnjost.

❌The old mill by the river is said to grind flour for the whole valley a hundred years ago.
✅The old mill by the river is said to have ground flour for the whole valley a hundred years ago.
ranija radnja → to have ground

4. „Smatra se da ima“ → It is thought to be. Srpsko „ima“ nema subjekat: „Smatra se da u ovoj planini ima preko sto pećina.“ Na engleskom postojanje kažemo sa there, a be se slaže sa imenicom: There are thought to be…

❌It is thought to be over a hundred caves in this mountain.
✅There are thought to be over a hundred caves in this mountain. ili It is thought that there are over a hundred caves in this mountain.
„ima“ → there are

Ne mešajte

People say…, It is said… i He is said to… – ista poruka, različit stil.

People say he's a brilliant cook.
Ljudi kažu da odlično kuva.
neformalno
It is said that he is a brilliant cook.
Kaže se da odlično kuva.
formalno, bezlično
He is said to be a brilliant cook.
Za njega kažu da je odličan kuvar.
formalno, u fokusu je osoba

to be (sada) i to have been (ranije)

The building is thought to be unsafe.
Smatra se da zgrada nije bezbedna.
nije bezbedna sada
The building is thought to have been unsafe for years.
Smatra se da zgrada već godinama nije bezbedna.
stanje do sada; srpski prezent za trajanje, engleski to have been

be supposed to – This café is supposed to be very good može da znači i „kažu da“, ali u B2-07 ste naučili njegovo češće značenje: očekivanje ili pravilo.

Slične strukture sa seem i appear (He seems to have left) nisu pasiv; uče se zajedno sa ograđivanjem u C1-08.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • said se izgovara /sed/, a ne kao say + d.
  • It is se u neutralnim tekstovima i u govoru često skraćuje (It's said that…), ali su puni oblici uobičajeni u formalnom pisanju.
  • to have je slabo: is thought to have left → /ɪz ˈθɔːt tə həv ˈleft/ (UK), /ɪz ˈθɑːt tə həv ˈleft/ (US). Neutralni glas /ə/ srpski nema: kratak je i opušten, a usta poluotvorena.
  • thought počinje glasom /θ/: vrh jezika je između zuba i vazduh prolazi, bez glasa. Nije ni t ni s. gh se ne izgovara.
  • Pisanje čestih participa: believed, thought, known, expected, reported, alleged (dva l), understood.
  • Naglasak pada na particip i na ključnu informaciju: She is SAID to be very RICH.

Zlatno pravilo

Dve šeme: It is said that + rečenica („kaže se da“, ali sa it), ili Subjekat + is said + infinitiv sa to. U šemi 2 oblik infinitiva birajte prema vremenu: to do / to be doing (isto vreme), to have done / to have been doing (ranije). „Kaže se da ima“ = There is / are said to be.

Vežbe

A. Oblik

Stavite glagole iz zagrada u odgovarajući oblik.

  1. It (believe) that the treasure is still buried on the island.
  2. The singer is said (be) very shy in real life.
  3. The robbers are thought (escape) through the back door last night.
  4. There (think) to be about a million words in English.
  5. The team is expected (win) easily on Saturday.
  6. The suspect is believed (stay) with friends at the moment.

B. Značenje

Izaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. Izaberite tačan odgovor: The pilot is believed … the crash last night.
  2. Izaberite tačan odgovor: The castle is said … haunted — people still see a ghost there today.
  3. Izaberite formalniju i bezličniju rečenicu:
  4. Izaberite tačan odgovor: There … reported to be several injuries.
  5. Izaberite tačan odgovor: It … that the lake has no bottom.

C. Pronađite grešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna greška ili je rečenica tačna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. She is said that she speaks five languages.
  2. The pilot is believed to survive the crash.
  3. There is reported to be several injuries.
  4. The bridge is thought to have been built by the Romans.

D. U kontekstu

Stavite glagole iz zagrada u odgovarajući oblik.

News report
A rare painting has disappeared from the City Museum. The painting 16 (believe) to be worth over two million euros. The thieves 17 (think) to 18 (enter) the building through a window on Sunday night. It 19 (report) that the alarm system was not working. There 20 (say) to be no witnesses. Police are 21 (expect) to release more information tomorrow.

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o svom gradu i o vestima.

  1. Napišite nešto o jednom mestu u svom gradu, koristeći is said to ili is believed to.
  2. Napišite kratku rečenicu u stilu vesti o nečemu što se desilo ranije, sa is thought to have + particip prošli.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

Ponovite prethodne lekcije.

  1. B1-11 Pasiv u svim vremenima i sa modalnim glagolima (is being done, has been done, must be done)
    The results (announce) tomorrow.
  2. B1-12 Reported speech: indirektni govor na engleskom (said, told, slaganje vremena)
    Prenesite sa pomeranjem vremena unazad: "I'm tired," she said.
  3. B2-11 Have something done: kako se na engleskom kaže „ošišala sam se“ i „ukrali su mi telefon“
    I (have / my eyes / test) last week.
  4. B2-09 Reduced relative clauses: skraćene odnosne rečenice na engleskom (the man standing there)
    Napišite kraće: The house which was built in 1900 is for sale.
Решења

A. Oblik

  1. is believed
  2. to be
  3. to have escaped
  4. are thought
  5. to win
  6. to be staying

B. Značenje

  1. to have survived
  2. to be
  3. The CEO is expected to resign.
  4. are
  5. is said

C. Pronađite grešku

  1. She is said to speak five languages. / It is said that she speaks five languages.
  2. The pilot is believed to have survived the crash. / It is believed that the pilot survived the crash.
  3. There are reported to be several injuries.
  4. ✓ The bridge is thought to have been built by the Romans.

D. U kontekstu

  1. is believed
  2. are thought
  3. have entered
  4. is reported / has been reported / was reported
  5. are said
  6. expected

E. Vaš red

  1. The old bridge in my town is said to be over 500 years old.
  2. The fire is thought to have started in a restaurant kitchen.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

  1. will be announced / are going to be announced / are being announced
  2. She said that she was tired. / She said she was tired.
  3. had my eyes tested
  4. The house built in 1900 is for sale.
Android апликацијаУчите у покрету Google Play