The subjunctive: I suggest that he go, It is essential that she be – konjunktiv na engleskom
The Subjunctive and Formal Structures
Na ovoj stranici
Cilj
Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete upotrijebiti konjunktiv (subjunctive) iza glagola, pridjeva i imenica zahtjeva, prijedloga i važnosti (We recommend that he apply early. It is essential that she be present.), birati između konjunktiva, should i običnog vremena te prepoznati were, lest i stalne izraze s konjunktivom.
Osnovna ideja
Većina glagola opisuje ono što jest istina: He arrives at nine. Ali ponekad govorimo o onome što netko želi da bude istina: o zahtjevu, preporuci, pravilu. Za to značenje „traženo, još nije stvarno“ formalni engleski ima poseban oblik: konjunktiv.
Lako ga je složiti. To je jednostavno osnovni oblik glagola, za svaki subjekt i u svakom vremenu: bez -s, bez -ed, bez am/is/are. I insist that he leave. They demanded that she be told.
Zamislite glagol s lokotom. Oko njega glavni se glagol može mijenjati – suggest, suggested, will suggest – ali zaključani glagol u surečenici s that nikad se ne pomiče. Taj nepromjenjivi oblik čitatelju kaže: ovo je zahtjev, a ne izvještaj o činjenici. Zato She insisted that he stay (zahtjev) i She insisted that he stayed (tvrdnja o činjenici) znače različite stvari.
Hrvatski i engleski
Hrvatski za zahtjeve i prijedloge upotrebljava „da“ + prezent: „Predlažem da odgodimo glasovanje“, „Važno je da svi dođu na vrijeme“. Dobra vijest: kao i engleski konjunktiv, taj se oblik ne mijenja kad je glavni glagol u prošlosti („Predložio je da ostane“) – ovdje je isto. Razlika je u tome što se hrvatski glagol slaže s osobom („da on dođe“, „da ona bude“), a engleski konjunktiv nema -s ni is: that he come, that she be.
Glavna zamka je glagol prije „da“. U hrvatskom se predlaže i zahtijeva nekome / od nekoga: „predložila nam je da…“, „tražili su od hotela da…“. U engleskom iza suggest, propose, insist i demand ne dolazi objekt + infinitiv, nego that + subjekt + osnovni oblik.
| Hrvatski | Engleski | U čemu je razlika? |
|---|---|---|
| Liječnik je preporučio da smanji sol. | The doctor recommended that he cut down on salt. | „da“ + prezent → that + osnovni oblik |
| Predložio je da ostane. (prošlost) | He suggested that she stay. | ovdje je isto: oblik se ne pomiče |
| Nužno je da svaki putnik veže pojas. | It is essential that every passenger wear a seat belt. | hrvatski ima nastavak za osobu; engleski bez -s |
| Predložila nam je da se nađemo. | She proposed that we meet. | ne proposed us to meet |
| Tražili su od hotela da vrati novac. | They demanded that the hotel refund the money. | ne demanded from the hotel |
| Molimo da se mobiteli ne upotrebljavaju. | We request that phones not be used. | not + osnovni oblik, bez don't |
| Inzistirala je da ostane. / Tvrdila je da je ostao. | She insisted that he stay. / She insisted that he stayed. | zahtjev / tvrdnja: hrvatski mijenja glagol, engleski oblik |
Ukratko: „predlažem da on dođe“ = I suggest that he come; bez -s, bez to, bez objekta ispred; niječno not + osnovni oblik.
Oblik
Konjunktiv zahtjeva: okidač + that + subjekt + osnovni oblik
| Okidač | Primjer | Napomena |
|---|---|---|
| glagoli: suggest, recommend, propose, insist, demand, request, require, ask, urge | We recommend that she take the course. | bez -s za he/she/it |
| pridjevi: essential, vital, important, crucial, imperative, necessary, advisable | It is essential that everyone arrive on time. | iza It is/was… |
| imenice: suggestion, recommendation, requirement, demand, insistence, proposal | the requirement that each applicant submit a CV | formalno |
Zaključani glagol ne prati glavni glagol
| Glavni glagol | Surečenica s that |
|---|---|
| I suggest | that he apply now. |
| I suggested | that he apply now. (ne applied) |
| I will suggest | that he apply now. |
Niječni oblik i pasiv
| Vrsta | Oblik | Primjer |
|---|---|---|
| niječno | not + osnovni oblik (bez do/does/did) | They asked that he not be disturbed. |
| pasiv | be + particip prošli | It is vital that the data be protected. |
Tri načina da se kaže isto
| Stil | Primjer | Gdje se upotrebljava |
|---|---|---|
| konjunktiv | I suggest that he talk to HR. | (US) u svim stilovima; (UK) formalno |
| should + osnovni oblik | I suggest that he should talk to HR. | uglavnom (UK), neutralno i formalno |
| obično vrijeme | I suggest that he talks to HR. | uglavnom (UK), neformalno i neutralno |
Uporaba
1Iza glagola prijedloga i zahtjeva
Iza suggest, recommend, propose, insist, demand, request, require, ask, urge + that upotrijebite subjekt + osnovni oblik za ono što netko želi da se dogodi. Za druge obrasce tih glagola (suggest doing, ask someone to do) pogledajte B2-14.
2Iza pridjeva i imenica važnosti i nužnosti
Iza It is / was + essential, vital, important, crucial, imperative, necessary, advisable + that konjunktiv izražava zahtjev. Isti obrazac dolazi iza imenica kao što su requirement, recommendation, proposal.
3Should i obično vrijeme kao zamjena
U britanskom engleskom should + osnovni oblik česta je, neutralna zamjena. U neformalnom i svakodnevnom britanskom engleskom mnogi umjesto toga upotrebljavaju obično sadašnje ili prošlo vrijeme. U američkom engleskom konjunktiv je normalan i u svakodnevnom govoru. Sva su tri oblika točna u svojem stilu.
4Niječni i pasivni konjunktiv
Za niječni oblik not stavite izravno ispred osnovnog oblika, bez do/does/did. Za pasiv upotrijebite be + particip prošli za svaki subjekt.
5Konjunktiv were (ponavljanje)
Za nestvarne situacije formalni engleski upotrebljava were za svaki subjekt iza if, as if, as though, wish, if only, suppose. Neformalni engleski često ima was, ali were je standardni pisani oblik, a If I were you je stalni izraz. Pogledajte B2-21 i B1-08; za Were I to… pogledajte C1-03.
6Lest i stalni izrazi s konjunktivom
Lest (formalno i prilično zastarjelo) znači „da ne bi“ ili „za slučaj da“. Iza njega dolazi konjunktiv ili should. Nekoliko stalnih izraza čuva stari oblik konjunktiva; naučite ih kao cjeline. Obrađeni su u C2-09.
Česte pogreške
Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
1. „Predložila nam je da…“ → She proposed us to… Hrvatski kaže kome se nešto predlaže (dativ) i onda dodaje „da“. Iza propose i suggest engleski ne podnosi objekt + infinitiv: treba that + subjekt + osnovni oblik (ili should).
2. „Tražili su od hotela da…“ → demanded from the hotel. U hrvatskom se zahtijeva od nekoga, pa se doslovno prevede demand from somebody to do. Engleski demand nema takav obrazac: demand that + subjekt + osnovni oblik ili demand something.
3. „Nužno je da svatko donese…“ → that everyone brings. Hrvatski glagol u surečenici s „da“ dobiva nastavak za osobu („donese“), pa u engleskom dodajemo -s. U neformalnom britanskom engleskom to je prihvatljivo, ali u formalnom tekstu – mailu, pravilniku, eseju – treba osnovni oblik ili should.
4. „Da se ne…“ → that they don't… Hrvatsku niječnicu „ne“ prirodno prevodimo s don't / doesn't. U formalnom konjunktivu nema pomoćnog glagola: not + osnovni oblik.
Ne miješajte
insist that + konjunktiv i insist that + obično vrijeme – S konjunktivom insist je zahtjev. S običnim vremenom znači „uporno tvrditi da je nešto činjenica“. Hrvatski za to obično upotrebljava dva glagola: „inzistirati da“ i „tvrditi da“.
suggest that + konjunktiv i suggest that + obično vrijeme – S konjunktivom suggest znači „predložiti“. S običnim vremenom može značiti i „pokazivati, upućivati na“.
Konjunktiv i pomak vremena u neupravnom govoru – U neupravnom govoru glagoli se obično pomiču jedno vrijeme unatrag (B1-12). Konjunktiv nikad. (Hrvatski ne pomiče ni jedno ni drugo.)
Pravopis i izgovor
- Konjunktiv nema -s, pa ga je u govoru lako previdjeti: that he leave /ðət hiː liːv/ završava glasom /v/, bez /s/ ili /z/ na kraju.
- U niječnom obliku not je obično naglašen: that he not be disturbed.
- Lest /lest/ rimuje se s best; samoglasnik je kao naše kratko „e“. Uglavnom se piše, a rijetko izgovara.
- That se u manje formalnom stilu može izostaviti (I suggest he call), ali u formalnom pisanju obično ostaje. Kao ni ispred našega „da“, ispred that nema zareza: We request that….
- Imperative /ɪmˈperətɪv/ ima naglasak na drugom slogu; zadnja dva sloga su slaba.
- Pravopis: apologise, organise (UK); apologize, organize (US, a upotrebljava se i u UK-u).
Zlatno pravilo
Kad surečenica s that izražava zahtjev, prijedlog ili nužnost, formalni engleski upotrebljava subjekt + osnovni oblik za svaki subjekt i svako vrijeme, a za niječni oblik not + osnovni oblik. Should + osnovni oblik česta je britanska zamjena, a obično vrijeme u redu je u neformalnom britanskom engleskom. I nikad suggest / propose / insist someone to, ni demand from someone.
Vježbe
A. Oblik
Preoblikujte svaku rečenicu u formalnom stilu uz zadane riječi. Upotrijebite konjunktiv (osnovni oblik) osim ako zadatak traži should.
-
Preoblikujte uz "insisted that": The coach told every player firmly that they had to train on Sunday.
-
Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "It is essential that": The room must be cleaned before the guests arrive.
-
Preoblikujte uz "recommended that" i niječni oblik: We advised her, "Don't sign the contract."
-
Preoblikujte uz "requires that" i pasiv: Under the landlord's rules, the rent must be paid by the first of each month.
-
Preoblikujte uz "should": I propose that the meeting start at nine.
-
Preoblikujte za formalno pisanje: It is vital that the patient doesn't drink alcohol before the operation.
-
Preoblikujte tako da rečenica počinje s "There is a requirement": Every applicant must submit two references.
-
Preoblikujte uz "lest": She wrote everything down so that she would not forget it.
B. Značenje
Odaberite rečenicu koja odgovara kontekstu. Napomena objašnjava zašto.
-
Prenosite da je ona uporno tvrdila kako je činjenica da je on bio kod kuće. Koja rečenica?insist + obično vrijeme = tvrdnja o činjenici; + konjunktiv = zahtjev
-
Ugovor o najmu. Što je primjerenije?formalno pisanje traži konjunktiv; keeps je neformalno (UK)
-
Istraživačko izvješće opisuje što podaci pokazuju, a ne iznosi prijedlog. Koja rečenica?suggest = upućivati na činjenicu, pa obično vrijeme
-
Poruka među prijateljima u Velikoj Britaniji. Što zvuči prirodnije?obično vrijeme normalno je u neformalnom britanskom engleskom
-
Formalno sudsko izvješće na suvremenom engleskom. Što je bolje?suvremeni red riječi je not + be; be not je zastarjelo
-
Formalno pismo sa savjetom. Što je bolje?were je standardni pisani oblik
C. Pronađite pogrešku
U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite cijelu ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.
-
The teacher suggested me to read more widely before the exam, especially books on modern history.
-
After the scandal, the shareholders demanded that the chairman not to speak to the press until the inquiry was over.
-
The judge ordered that the reporters should not to film any part of the trial, including the reading of the verdict.
-
I insist him to come with us to the airport, because he doesn't know the way and his phone is broken.
-
The board recommended that the chief executive step down immediately and that an independent review be carried out.
D. U kontekstu
Pročitajte nacrt i napomenu voditelja. Preoblikujte svaku označenu rečenicu u formalnom stilu prema uputi.
Welcome to the Harbour View Hotel. We hope you enjoy your stay. Breakfast is served from 7 to 10 a.m. in the garden restaurant. (20) All rooms really have to be empty by 11 a.m. (21) Please don't smoke on the balconies — we're asking everyone. (22) We think it's a good idea to leave your valuables in the safe. (23) If you want to stay longer, please call reception the day before. (24) We need someone to tell the front desk about any damage. (25) Pets must not come into the restaurant, and that's really important. Thank you for helping us keep the hotel safe and comfortable for everyone.
-
Rečenica (20): počnite s "It is essential that".
-
Rečenica (21): počnite s "Management requests that guests".
-
Rečenica (22): počnite s "It is recommended that" i upotrijebite pasiv.
-
Rečenica (23): počnite sa "Should a guest wish to stay longer, we ask that".
-
Rečenica (24): počnite s "It is important that the front desk" i upotrijebite pasiv.
-
Rečenica (25): počnite s "It is imperative that pets".
E. Vaš red
Pišite na engleskom formalne preporuke, obavijesti i kratke usporedbe.
-
Napišite 2–3 formalne preporuke za priručnik za nove zaposlenike. Upotrijebite barem jedan pridjev okidač (It is essential / vital that…), jedan glagol okidač (We recommend / request that…) i jedan niječni konjunktiv.
-
Preoblikujte ovu neformalnu poruku u formalnu obavijest od 1–2 rečenice, barem dvaput s konjunktivom: "We'd like everyone to turn up early, and please nobody bring food."
-
Napišite dvije rečenice u situaciji po vlastitom izboru koje pokazuju razliku između insist + konjunktiv (zahtjev) i insist + obično vrijeme (tvrdnja o činjenici).
F. Miješano ponavljanje
Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.
-
B2-14 Reporting verbs na hrvatskom: suggest, deny, admit, accuse i njihovi obrasci Preoblikujte uz "suggested" + -ing: He said, "Let's go home early."
-
C1-03 Formal conditionals: Should you need, Were I to, Had I known, But for – formalne pogodbene rečenice Preoblikujte bez "if": If I were to accept the job, I'd have to move to another city.
Rješenja
A. Oblik
- The coach insisted that every player train on Sunday.
- It is essential that the room be cleaned before the guests arrive.
- We recommended that she not sign the contract.
- The landlord requires that the rent be paid by the first of each month.
- I propose that the meeting should start at nine.
- It is vital that the patient not drink alcohol before the operation.
- There is a requirement that every applicant submit two references.
- She wrote everything down lest she forget it. / She wrote everything down lest she should forget it.
B. Značenje
- She insisted that he stayed at home all evening.
- It is essential that the tenant keep the flat clean.
- The results suggest that the drug is effective in older patients.
- It's important that she's at the station by six.
- The judge ordered that the witness's name not be published.
- If I were in your position, I would consult a lawyer.
C. Pronađite pogrešku
- The teacher suggested that I read more widely before the exam, especially books on modern history. / The teacher suggested that I should read more widely before the exam, especially books on modern history. / The teacher suggested reading more widely before the exam, especially books on modern history.
- After the scandal, the shareholders demanded that the chairman not speak to the press until the inquiry was over. / After the scandal, the shareholders demanded that the chairman should not speak to the press until the inquiry was over.
- The judge ordered that the reporters should not film any part of the trial, including the reading of the verdict. / The judge ordered that the reporters not film any part of the trial, including the reading of the verdict.
- I insist that he come with us to the airport, because he doesn't know the way and his phone is broken. / I insist that he should come with us to the airport, because he doesn't know the way and his phone is broken.
- ✓ The board recommended that the chief executive step down immediately and that an independent review be carried out.
D. U kontekstu
- It is essential that all rooms be vacated by 11 a.m. / It is essential that all rooms be empty by 11 a.m.
- Management requests that guests not smoke on the balconies.
- It is recommended that valuables be left in the safe.
- Should a guest wish to stay longer, we ask that he or she contact reception the day before. / Should a guest wish to stay longer, we ask that they contact reception the day before.
- It is important that the front desk be informed of any damage.
- It is imperative that pets not enter the restaurant. / It is imperative that pets not be brought into the restaurant.
E. Vaš red
- It is essential that every new employee complete the safety training in the first week. We recommend that you meet your mentor before starting any project. We request that confidential documents not be taken out of the building.
- We request that all participants arrive early and that no food be brought into the hall.
- My grandmother insisted that we stay for dinner. My brother insisted that he had locked the door, but it was wide open.
F. Miješano ponavljanje
- He suggested going home early.
- Were I to accept the job, I'd have to move to another city.
