SlowingoGramatika
B2 23 / 30

As if, as though, suppose i it's time: „kao da“ i „zamisli da“ na engleskom

As If, As Though, Suppose: Hypothetical Meaning

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete opisati kako se nešto čini s as if / as though / like, zamišljati situacije sa suppose, supposing, what if i imagine, reći da bi se nešto trebalo dogoditi sada s it's time te prepoznati „nestvarnu prošlost“ koja povezuje sve te strukture.

Osnovna ideja

Engleski ima pametan trik za ono što nije stvarno: glagol pomakne jedan korak unatrag, u prošlost. If I had a car… (nemam ga). I wish I knew (ne znam). Ovdje prošli oblik ne znači prošlo vrijeme. Znači udaljenost od stvarnosti.

Ova lekcija pokazuje isti trik na novim mjestima. Iza as if i as though opisujete dojam. Ako dojam može biti istinit, upotrijebite normalno vrijeme: She looks as if she is tired (možda i jest). Ako znate da nije istinit, zakoračite u prošlost: He talks as if he knew everything (ne zna).

Zamislite oblačić sanjarenja iznad nečije glave. Normalno vrijeme ostaje na zemlji, u stvarnom svijetu. Nestvarna prošlost odlebdi u oblačić: izgleda kao stvarna situacija, ali svi znaju da nije stvarna.

Suppose, what if, imagine i it's time upotrebljavaju isti oblačić.

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatsko „kao da“ odgovara engleskom as if, ali hrvatski iza njega ne mijenja vrijeme. „Priča kao da sve zna“ ima prezent, iako znamo da ne zna. Engleski tu nestvarnost pokazuje prošlim oblikom: as if he knew. Za nestvarnu prošlost hrvatski ima perfekt („kao da se ništa nije dogodilo“), a engleski Past Perfect (pluskvamperfekt): as if nothing had happened.

Za zamišljanje hrvatski kaže „zamisli da“, „recimo da“ ili „kad bi“, s kondicionalom. Taj kondicional lako postane would, ali iza suppose, imagine i what if engleski nikad nema would: ondje stoji prošli oblik, a would ide u odgovor. A hrvatsko „vrijeme je da idemo“ ima „da“ + prezent, dok engleski s osobom traži prošli oblik: It's time we went.

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Izgledaš kao da cijeli tjedan nisi spavao.You look as if you haven't slept all week.ovdje je isto: moguće je istinito → normalno vrijeme
Priča kao da sve zna.He talks as if he knew everything.hrvatski prezent → engleski past za nestvarno
Ponašali su se kao da se ništa nije dogodilo.They acted as if nothing had happened.perfekt → past perfect za nestvarnu prošlost
Zamisli da možeš živjeti bilo gdje na svijetu.Suppose you could live anywhere in the world.„zamisli da / kad bi“ → past, bez would
Što ako vlak zakasni?What if the train is late?ovdje je isto: stvarna mogućnost → prezent
Vrijeme je da idemo kući.It's time we went home.„da“ + prezent → past simple
Krajnje je vrijeme da grad nešto poduzme.It's high time the city did something.nestrpljenje → high / about time + past

Ukratko: „kao da“ + istinito = as if + normalno vrijeme; „kao da“ + neistinito = as if + past / past perfect; „zamisli da / kad bi“ = suppose / imagine + past (bez would); „vrijeme je da idemo“ = it's time we went.

Oblik

Glagoli dojma + as if / as though

DojamGlagol iza as if / as thoughPrimjer
možda je istinitnormalno vrijemeIt looks as if it's going to rain.
nije istinit (sadašnjost)Past Simple (were / was)He acts as if he owned the place.
nije istinit (prošlost)Past PerfectShe looked at me as if I had said something terrible.

As if I / he / she / it were je formalnije; was je čest u svakodnevnom govoru.

Like (neformalno)

Neutralno / formalnoNeformalno (vrlo često, osobito u američkom engleskom)
It looks as if it's going to snow.It looks like it's going to snow.

Zamišljanje: suppose / supposing / what if / imagine

Oblik glagolaZnačenjePrimjer
+ prezentstvarna mogućnostWhat if it rains? We'll need a plan B.
+ Past Simplenestvarno ili manje vjerojatnoSuppose you won the lottery. What would you do?
+ Past Perfectnestvarna prošlostWhat if nobody had come?

It's time

ObrazacZnačenjePrimjer
it's time + infinitiv s topravi je trenutakIt's time to go.
it's time + for sb + infinitiv s topravi trenutak za nekogaIt's time for you to decide.
it's time + subjekt + Past Simpletrebalo bi se dogoditi sada (i već je pomalo kasno)It's time we left.
it's about time / it's high time + subjekt + Past Simplekasno je: trebalo se već dogoditiIt's high time the city did something.

Uporaba

1Look / sound / feel / seem as if – stvarna mogućnost

Kad dojam vrlo vjerojatno jest istinit, iza as if / as though upotrijebite vrijeme koje odgovara stvarnom vremenu.

You look as if you haven't slept all week.
Izgledaš kao da cijeli tjedan nisi spavao.
vjerojatno istina: normalno vrijeme
It sounds as though they're having a party next door.
Zvuči kao da susjedi imaju zabavu.
It seems as if prices go up every month.
Čini se kao da cijene rastu svaki mjesec.
I feel as though I'm coming down with something.
Osjećam se kao da me nešto hvata.
The traffic looks as if it's getting worse.
Izgleda kao da je promet sve gori.

2As if / as though + prošlo vrijeme – nestvarne usporedbe

Kad je usporedba zamišljena ili očito nije istinita, zakoračite unatrag u Past Simple (sadašnja situacija) ili Past Perfect (prošla situacija). To je često uz act, behave, talk i treat someone. U neformalnom govoru čuje se i sadašnje vrijeme (He talks as if he knows everything), ali prošli oblik jasno pokazuje nestvarnost.

He talks as if he knew everything.
Priča kao da sve zna.
ne zna; hrvatski ima prezent
She treats me as if I were a child.
Ponaša se prema meni kao da sam dijete.
nisam; čest je i was
My legs feel as if they were made of jelly.
Noge su mi kao od želea.
They acted as if nothing had happened.
Ponašali su se kao da se ništa nije dogodilo.
nešto se dogodilo
Don't look at me as though I'd broken your phone! I didn't touch it.
Ne gledaj me kao da sam ti razbio mobitel! Nisam ga ni taknuo.
hrvatski perfekt → Past Perfect

3Like kao neformalna zamjena

U neformalnom govoru, osobito u američkom engleskom, ispred rečenice vrlo se često upotrebljava like umjesto as if / as though. Izbjegavajte ga u formalnom pisanju. (Like + imenica za sličnost obrađuje se u B1-24.)

It looks like it's going to rain.
Izgleda da će kiša.
You sound like you need a holiday.
Zvučiš kao da ti treba godišnji odmor.
holiday (UK), vacation (US)
It feels like I've known you for years.
Imam osjećaj kao da te znam godinama.
hrvatski: prezent
He was running like his life depended on it.
Trčao je kao da mu život ovisi o tome.

4Suppose, supposing, what if, imagine – stvarno ili nestvarno

Ove riječi pozivaju nekoga da zamisli situaciju. Uz sadašnje vrijeme situacija je stvarna mogućnost, a u odgovoru je često will. Uz prošlo vrijeme ona je nestvarna ili manje vjerojatna, a u odgovoru je would. Uz Past Perfect zamišljate drukčiju prošlost. Suppose i supposing znače isto; what if je najčešći u govoru.

What if the train is late? How will we get to the airport?
Što ako vlak zakasni? Kako ćemo stići do zračne luke?
stvarna mogućnost: prezent
Suppose you lose your job — what will you do?
Recimo da izgubiš posao – što ćeš učiniti?
stvarna mogućnost
Suppose you could live anywhere in the world. Where would you go?
Zamisli da možeš živjeti bilo gdje na svijetu. Kamo bi otišao?
nestvarno: prošlo vrijeme
Supposing your boss found out — what would you say?
Kad bi šef saznao, što bi rekao?
„kad bi“ → found, ne would find
Imagine you had a whole year off work. How would you spend it?
Zamisli da imaš cijelu godinu slobodno od posla. Kako bi je proveo?
What if we hadn't missed that bus? We'd never have met!
Što da nismo propustili onaj autobus? Nikad se ne bismo upoznali!
nestvarna prošlost: Past Perfect

5It's time / it's about time / it's high time

It's time + infinitiv s to upotrijebite za pravi trenutak. It's time + subjekt + Past Simple upotrijebite da kažete da bi se nešto trebalo dogoditi sada i da je već pomalo kasno. About time i high time dodaju nestrpljenje ili kritiku. Prošli oblik je nestvaran: riječ je o sadašnjosti. U neformalnom govoru iza it's time we… ponekad se čuje sadašnje vrijeme, ali standardan je prošli oblik.

It's time to say goodbye.
Vrijeme je da se oprostimo.
It's time for the kids to go to bed.
Vrijeme je da djeca idu spavati.
for + osoba + to
It's time we went home.
Vrijeme je da idemo kući.
„da idemo“ → we went
It's about time you got a job!
Bilo bi već vrijeme da nađeš posao!
It's high time the city did something about the traffic.
Krajnje je vrijeme da grad nešto poduzme u vezi s prometom.

6Sažetak – obitelj nestvarne prošlosti

Ista logika vrijedi iza if, wish, would rather, as if, suppose i it's time: Past Simple za nestvarnu sadašnjost ili budućnost i – osim iza it's time – Past Perfect za nestvarnu prošlost.

If I had more time, I'd learn the guitar.
Da imam više vremena, naučio bih svirati gitaru.
pogodbena rečenica tipa 2 B1-06
I wish I lived closer to the sea.
Volio bih živjeti bliže moru.
wish B1-08
I'd rather you didn't smoke in here.
Radije bih da ovdje ne pušiš.
would rather B2-05
He behaves as if he were the boss.
Ponaša se kao da je on šef.
as if
I wish I had listened to you.
Žao mi je što te nisam poslušao.
wish + Past Perfect B2-04

Česte pogreške

❌You look as if tired.
✅You look tired. ili You look as if you're tired.
as if traži cijelu rečenicu sa subjektom i glagolom.
❌Suppose you would win a million.
✅Suppose you won a million.
Iza suppose nema would; would ide u odgovor.
❌It seems as there is a problem.
✅It seems as if there is a problem. ili It seems as though there is a problem.
as if, ne samo as.
❌It looks like as if it'll snow.
✅It looks like it'll snow. ili It looks as if it'll snow.
Upotrijebite like ili as if, ne oboje.
❌It's time for you go to bed.
✅It's time for you to go to bed.
for + osoba + infinitiv s to.
⚠️It's time we go home.
✅It's time we went home. ili It's time to go home.
Gramatički je ispravno (ponekad se čuje u neformalnom govoru), ali iza it's time + subjekt standardan je prošli oblik.
⚠️She looked at me as if I said something rude.
✅She looked at me as if I'd said something rude.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali Past Perfect jasno pokazuje da je zamišljena radnja bila ranije.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Priča kao da je kapetan…“ → as if + prezent za nestvarno. Za sadašnjost hrvatski iza „kao da“ ima prezent, bez obzira na to vjerujemo li u ono što kažemo. Engleski prezent tada zvuči kao da bi to mogla biti istina. Kad je jasno da nije, upotrijebite as if + Past Simple (were / was).

⚠️Ever since he bought a small boat, our neighbour on Šolta talks about the sea as if he is a captain with thirty years of experience.
✅Ever since he bought a small boat, our neighbour on Šolta talks about the sea as if he were a captain with thirty years of experience. ili Ever since he bought a small boat, our neighbour on Šolta talks about the sea as if he was a captain with thirty years of experience.
Gramatički je ispravno (čuje se u neformalnom govoru), ali prošli oblik jasno pokazuje da nije kapetan.

2. „Kad bi…, zamisli da bi…“ → suppose / imagine + would. Hrvatski za zamišljenu situaciju ima kondicional („kad bi ti netko ponudio…“), pa učenici would stave i iza suppose, imagine ili what if. U engleskom je ondje prošli oblik, a would dolazi tek u odgovoru.

❌Imagine a big hotel chain would offer to buy your grandparents' old stone house on Korčula. Would you sell it?
✅Imagine a big hotel chain offered to buy your grandparents' old stone house on Korčula. Would you sell it?
imagine + Past Simple; would samo u pitanju

3. „Vrijeme je da tvoj brat nađe…“ → it's time + prezent. Hrvatsko „vrijeme je da“ ima „da“ + prezent. Kad iza it's time dođe subjekt, engleski standardno traži Past Simple. Druga mogućnost je it's time for + osoba + to + osnovni oblik.

⚠️Don't you think it's time your brother finds a proper job instead of spending every summer selling ice cream on the beach in Bol?
✅Don't you think it's time your brother found a proper job instead of spending every summer selling ice cream on the beach in Bol? ili Don't you think it's time for your brother to find a proper job instead of spending every summer selling ice cream on the beach in Bol?
Gramatički je ispravno (ponekad se čuje), ali standardno je it's time + subjekt + Past Simple.

4. „Izgleda kao da…“ → looks like that / as that. Hrvatsko „kao da“ ima dvije riječi, pa učenici prevedu obje: „kao“ s like ili as, a „da“ s that. Engleski ima jednu cjelinu: as if, as though ili neformalno like – bez that.

❌Judging by all those dark clouds over Učka, it looks like that we'll have a storm before lunch.
✅Judging by all those dark clouds over Učka, it looks as if we'll have a storm before lunch. ili Judging by all those dark clouds over Učka, it looks like we'll have a storm before lunch.
as if / like, bez that

Ne miješajte

look like + imenica i look as if + rečenica – Look like + imenica = sličiti nekomu. Look as if (ili neformalno look like) + rečenica = činiti se.

She looks like her mother.
Sliči na majku.
sličnost
She looks as if she's had good news.
Izgleda kao da je dobila dobre vijesti.
dojam

as (način) i as if (usporedba) – As + rečenica znači „onako kako“; as if znači „kao da“.

Do it as I showed you.
Napravi to onako kako sam ti pokazao.
na isti način
He looked at me as if I were mad.
Pogledao me kao da sam lud.
usporedba, nije stvarno

suppose (zamisliti) i be supposed to (očekivanje) – različita značenja. Be supposed to obrađuje se u B2-07.

Suppose we missed the flight.
Recimo da propustimo let.
zamišljanje
We're supposed to be at the gate by seven.
Trebali bismo biti na izlazu do sedam.
očekuje se

Pravopis i izgovor

  • though /ðəʊ/ (UK), /ðoʊ/ (US) rimuje se s go. Ne miješajte ga s through /θruː/ ni s thought /θɔːt/. /ð/ i /θ/ hrvatski nema: vrh jezika lagano stavite između zuba; /ð/ je zvučan, /θ/ bezvučan. Nije ni d ni t.
  • U as if i as though riječ as je slaba: /əz ɪf/, /əz ðəʊ/, s kratkim mutnim samoglasnikom i zvučnim z.
  • supposing /səˈpəʊzɪŋ/ (UK), /səˈpoʊzɪŋ/ (US): naglasak na drugom slogu. Slovo s ovdje se izgovara kao z.
  • U It's high time naglasite high: It's high time we left. h je lagan dah, ne hrvatsko h.
  • I'd može biti I had ili I would. U as if I'd said to je I had: iza njega slušajte particip prošli.

Zlatno pravilo

Iza as if / as though upotrijebite normalno vrijeme ako dojam može biti istinit, a zakoračite u prošlost da pokažete da je nestvaran. Isti korak unatrag vrijedi iza suppose, what if, imagine i it's time + subjekt. Hrvatsko „kao da“ i „vrijeme je da“ ne mijenjaju vrijeme – engleski ga mijenja.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Dopunite rečenice glagolom iz zagrade u točnom obliku.

  1. You look as if you (need) a coffee. (you probably do)
  2. He spends money as if he (be) a millionaire. (he isn't)
  3. She looked as if she (see) a ghost.
  4. It's high time you (start) looking for a new flat.
  5. Imagine you (can) speak ten languages. What would you do?
  6. It's time for the children (go) to bed.

B. Značenje

Odaberite odgovor koji odgovara značenju.

  1. Koja rečenica opisuje nešto što nije istina?
  2. Odaberite točan odgovor (stvarna mogućnost): What if the train … late? We'll miss the flight.
  3. Odaberite točan odgovor (zamišljeno): Suppose you … a wallet in the street. What would you do?
  4. Odaberite točan odgovor: It sounds … they're arguing again.
  5. Odaberite točan odgovor: It's about time the council … this road.

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. Suppose you would lose your passport — what would you do?
  2. It looks like as if the shop is closed.
  3. It seems as there's nobody at home.
  4. They acted as if nothing had happened.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite razgovor glagolom iz zagrade u točnom obliku. Upotrijebite nestvarnu prošlost ondje gdje nešto očito nije istina.

Noisy neighbours
Kim: You look as if you 16 (not / sleep) for days.
Raj: I know. My neighbours had a party. It sounded as though they 17 (move) furniture all night!
Kim: Supposing you 18 (ask) them to keep the noise down — would they listen?
Raj: Maybe. But they act as if they 19 (own) the building.
Kim: Well, it's high time somebody 20 (say) something.
Raj: You're right. What if I 21 (write) them a polite note tonight?

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o zamišljenim situacijama i o svom životu.

  1. Postavite zamišljeno pitanje sa Suppose ili Imagine + prošlo vrijeme, a zatim odgovorite na njega.
  2. Napišite rečenicu s It's (high) time + prošlo vrijeme o nečemu u svom životu što bi se trebalo promijeniti.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. B1-08 I wish i If only: kako izraziti želju na engleskom (wish ili hope)
    I wish I (have) more free time.
  2. B2-05 Would rather, had better i prefer: radije bih i bolje da na engleskom
    I'd rather you (not / tell) anyone about this.
  3. B2-04 I wish I had… i regret: žaljenje za prošlošću na engleskom
    If only I (listen) to your advice last year.
  4. B2-20 Noun clauses na hrvatskom: that, whether i what (imeničke rečenice)
    I'm not sure … or not they're coming.
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. need
  2. were / was
  3. had seen
  4. started
  5. could
  6. to go

B. Značenje

  1. He acts as if he owned the place.
  2. is
  3. found
  4. like
  5. repaired

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. Suppose you lost your passport — what would you do? / Supposing you lost your passport — what would you do?
  2. It looks like the shop is closed. / It looks as if the shop is closed. / It looks as though the shop is closed.
  3. It seems as if there's nobody at home. / It seems as though there's nobody at home. / It seems like there's nobody at home.
  4. ✓ They acted as if nothing had happened.

D. U kontekstu

  1. haven't slept / have not slept
  2. were moving
  3. asked
  4. owned
  5. said
  6. write / wrote

E. Vaš red

  1. Suppose you could live anywhere in the world. Where would you go? I'd live by the sea.
  2. It's high time I cleaned out my wardrobe.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. had
  2. didn't tell
  3. had listened
  4. whether
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play