SlowingoSlovnica
B1 14 / 39

Reported Questions: odvisna vprašanja, prošnje in ukazi ter say ali tell

Reported Questions, Requests and Commands; Say or Tell?

Na tej strani
  1. Cilj
  2. Glavna ideja
  3. Slovenščina in angleščina
  4. Oblika
  5. Raba
  6. Pogoste napake
  7. Pasti za govorce slovenščine
  8. Ne zamenjujte
  9. Pravopis in izgovorjava
  10. Zlato pravilo
  11. Vaje

Cilj

Po tej lekciji boste znali poročati, kaj vas je kdo vprašal (She asked if I was free, He asked where I lived), za kaj vas je prosil in kaj vam je naročil (She asked me to wait, He told us not to touch it). Znali boste tudi izbrati med say in tell.

Glavna ideja

Ko poročate o vprašanju, to ni več vprašanje. Ničesar ne sprašujete – nekomu pripovedujete o vprašanju. Zato vprašaj odpade, besedni red pa se vrne v navadni red trdilne povedi: najprej osebek, nato glagol. "Where do you live?" → He asked me where I lived. Ni do in ni vprašaja.

Vprašanje da / ne nima vprašalnice, zato angleščina doda majhno vezno besedo: if ali whether. To je naš „ali“. "Are you hungry?" → She asked if I was hungry.

Prošnje in ukazi govorijo o dejanjih, ki si jih kdo želi. Imajo najpreprostejši vzorec: ask / tell + oseba + to + glagol. "Please wait." → She asked me to wait.

In še say in tell: pomenita podobno, slovnico pa imata različno. Tell se navadno mora oprijeti osebe: tell someone. Say je ne potrebuje.

Slovenščina in angleščina

Pri odvisnem vprašanju z vprašalnico je slovenščina angleščini bližje, kot se zdi: „Kje živiš?“ → „Vprašal me je, kje živim.“ Pomožnega glagola ni ne v enem ne v drugem jeziku – tu je enako. Težava je drugje: ker se v slovenščini vprašanje ob poročanju skoraj ne spremeni, rado ostane tudi angleško vprašanje nespremenjeno, z did in obrnjenim besednim redom. Vprašanje da / ne v slovenščini poročamo z „ali“, angleščina pa z if / whether.

Prošnje in ukaze slovenščina poroča z „naj“ in sedanjikom: „Rekla mi je, naj počakam.“ Angleščina tu ne potrebuje odvisnika, ampak oseba + to + glagol: She told me to wait. Slovenski „reči“ ima osebo v dajalniku („rekel mi je“), angleški say pa osebe neposredno za sabo ne prenese. „Povedati“ pa je obratno: v slovenščini ga lahko rabimo brez osebe („Povedal je, da …“), angleški tell pa osebo navadno potrebuje.

SlovenščinaAngleščinaV čem je razlika?
Vprašal me je, kje živim.He asked me where I lived.Tu je enako: brez pomožnega glagola; angleščina naredi še korak nazaj
Vprašala je, ali sem lačen.She asked if / whether I was hungry.„ali“ → if / whether
Prosila me je, naj zaprem okno.She asked me to close the window.„naj“ + sedanjik → oseba + to + glagol
Rekel nam je, naj ne zamujamo.He told us not to be late.„naj ne“ → not to
Rekla mi je, da je utrujena.She told me / She said she was tired.dajalnik „mi“ → told me, ne said me
Povedal je, da ima novo službo.He said / He told us he had a new job.„povedati“ brez osebe → said; tell potrebuje osebo

Na kratko: odvisno vprašanje ima red trdilne povedi brez do / did, „ali“ je if / whether, „naj“ je ask / tell + oseba + to, osebo pa ima ob sebi tell, ne say.

Oblika

Poročana vprašanja da / ne – asked (+ oseba) + if / whether + red trdilne povedi

Premi govorOdvisni govor
"Are you ready?"She asked (me) if I was ready.
"Do you like jazz?"He asked whether I liked jazz.
"Have you seen my keys?"She asked if I had seen her keys.
"Can you drive?"They asked if I could drive.

Poročana vprašanja z vprašalnico – asked (+ oseba) + vprašalnica + red trdilne povedi

Premi govorOdvisni govor
"Where do you live?"He asked me where I lived.
"What time does the film start?"She asked what time the film started.
"Why did you leave?"They asked why I had left.
"Who is that man?"I asked who that man was.
"Who called?" (vprašanje po osebku)She asked who had called.

Časi, zaimki in časovne besede se spreminjajo enako kot pri izjavah B1-12. Kadar je who ali what osebek, se besedni red ne spremeni A2-33.

Poročane prošnje in ukazi – ask / tell + oseba + (not) to + osnovna oblika glagola

Premi govorOdvisni govor
"Please close the door."She asked me to close the door.
"Could you help me?"She asked me to help her.
"Sit down!"The teacher told us to sit down.
"Don't be late."He told me not to be late.

say ali tell

GlagolVzorecPrimer
saysay (that) + odvisnikShe said (that) she was tired.
saysay + nekaj + to + osebaHe said goodbye to everyone.
telltell + oseba + (that) + odvisnikShe told me (that) she was tired.
telltell + oseba + to + glagolHe told us to wait.
tellstalne zveze: tell the truth, tell a lie, tell a story, tell a jokeTell me the truth.

Raba

1Poročanje vprašanj da / ne z if / whether

If ali whether uporabite, kadar prvotno vprašanje nima vprašalnice. To je slovenski „ali“. Whether je malo bolj formalen.

The receptionist asked if we had a reservation.
Receptorka nas je vprašala, ali imamo rezervacijo.
„ali“ → if; v angleščini korak nazaj: had
My dad asked whether I needed any money.
Oče me je vprašal, ali potrebujem kaj denarja.
whether je malo bolj formalen
She wanted to know if the shop was open on Sundays.
Zanimalo jo je, ali je trgovina ob nedeljah odprta.
He asked me if I could lend him my charger.
Vprašal me je, ali mu lahko posodim polnilnik.
„lahko“ → could

2Poročanje vprašanj z vprašalnico

Vprašalnico obdržite, nato uporabite red trdilne povedi: osebek + glagol. Ne dodajajte do, does, did, da bi naredili vprašanje (zanikani didn't pa lahko ostane: She asked why I didn't call.).

The officer asked me where I was going.
Policist me je vprašal, kam grem.
osebek I pred glagolom
My friend asked what I had done at the weekend.
Prijatelj me je vprašal, kaj sem počel med vikendom.
v odvisnem vprašanju ni did
She asked how much the tickets cost.
Vprašala je, koliko stanejo vstopnice.
vprašalnica how much, nato osebek the tickets
They wanted to know why the train was late.
Zanimalo jih je, zakaj vlak zamuja.
red trdilne povedi: the train was

3Poročanje prošenj z ask + to

Vljudne prošnje (Please…, Can you…?, Could you…?) poročamo z ask + oseba + to. V slovenščini rečemo „prosil me je, naj …“.

She asked me to pick up some bread.
Prosila me je, naj kupim kruh.
„naj kupim“ → to pick up
The waiter asked us to wait at the bar.
Natakar nas je prosil, naj počakamo za šankom.
I asked him to turn the music down.
Prosil sem ga, naj utiša glasbo.
They asked us not to park in front of the gate.
Prosili so nas, naj ne parkiramo pred vrati.
„naj ne“ → not to

4Poročanje ukazov in navodil s tell + to

Ukaze in navodila poročamo s tell + oseba + to. Zanikana oblika je not to.

The doctor told me to stay in bed for two days.
Zdravnik mi je rekel, naj dva dni ostanem v postelji.
„rekel mi je, naj“ → told me to
My boss told us to finish the report by Friday.
Šef nam je naročil, naj poročilo dokončamo do petka.
The guide told everyone not to touch the paintings.
Vodnik je vsem rekel, naj se ne dotikajo slik.
not to, ne don't
Mum told me not to talk to strangers.
Mama mi je rekla, naj se ne pogovarjam z neznanci.

5say ali tell

Tell potrebuje osebo neposredno za sabo (razen v stalnih zvezah, kot je tell the truth). Say je ne potrebuje; če osebo želite omeniti, uporabite say … to + oseba.

She said she was sorry.
Rekla je, da ji je žal.
brez osebe → said
She told me she was sorry.
Rekla mi je, da ji je žal.
„mi“ → told me
He said goodbye to his colleagues and left.
Poslovil se je od sodelavcev in odšel.
say + nekaj + to + oseba
Can you tell me the time?
Mi lahko poveste, koliko je ura?
Don't tell anyone, OK?
Nikomur ne povej, prav?
v slovenščini dvojno zanikanje, v angleščini anyone

Pogoste napake

❌She asked me where did I live.
✅She asked me where I lived.
Red trdilne povedi; brez did.
❌He asked me what time was it.
✅He asked me what time it was.
V odvisnem vprašanju stoji osebek pred glagolom.
❌They asked me do I like pizza.
✅They asked me if I liked pizza.
Vprašanje da / ne → if / whether.
❌She asked if I was hungry?
✅She asked if I was hungry.
Poročano vprašanje je izjava: na koncu je pika.
❌He said me to wait.
✅He told me to wait.
Za say ne more neposredno stati oseba.
❌She told that she was busy.
✅She said that she was busy.
Tell + odvisnik potrebuje osebo (ali: She told me that she was busy).
❌He told me don't go.
✅He told me not to go.
Zanikan ukaz → not to.
❌She asked me that I close the window.
✅She asked me to close the window.
Prošnja → ask + oseba + to.

Pasti za govorce slovenščine

1. „Vprašala me je, kje sem kupil …“ → asked me where did I buy. V slovenščini se vprašanje ob poročanju skoraj ne spremeni, zato v angleščini rado ostane kar celo vprašanje, z did in obrnjenim besednim redom. V odvisnem vprašanju pa angleščina uporabi red trdilne povedi: osebek + glagol, brez do / does / did.

❌When I came back from the market in Ljubljana, my grandmother wanted to know where did I buy such cheap strawberries.
✅When I came back from the market in Ljubljana, my grandmother wanted to know where I had bought such cheap strawberries. ali When I came back from the market in Ljubljana, my grandmother wanted to know where I bought such cheap strawberries.
brez did; osebek pred glagolom
❌The ticket inspector on the train to Koper asked us which station were we getting off at.
✅The ticket inspector on the train to Koper asked us which station we were getting off at.
osebek we pred were

2. „Vprašal je, ali …“ → asked do you / are you. Slovenski „ali“ stoji v premem in v odvisnem vprašanju, zato se zdi, da angleško vprašanje kar ostane, kot je. V odvisnem vprašanju da / ne pa „ali“ postane if / whether, za njim pa red trdilne povedi.

❌At the end of the job interview in Novo Mesto, the HR manager asked me was I ready to work some weekends in the summer.
✅At the end of the job interview in Novo Mesto, the HR manager asked me if I was ready to work some weekends in the summer. ali At the end of the job interview in Novo Mesto, the HR manager asked me whether I was ready to work some weekends in the summer.
„ali“ → if / whether

3. „Prosil nas je, naj …“ → asked us that we. Slovenščina prošnje in ukaze poroča z odvisnikom („naj odnesemo smeti“). Angleščina pa uporabi oseba + to + glagol; „naj ne“ je not to.

❌When we moved into the flat in Celje, the landlord asked us that we take the rubbish out every Tuesday evening.
✅When we moved into the flat in Celje, the landlord asked us to take the rubbish out every Tuesday evening.
„naj“ → to + glagol
❌The ski instructor on Krvavec told the children don't go near the edge of the slope without him.
✅The ski instructor on Krvavec told the children not to go near the edge of the slope without him.
„naj ne“ → not to

4. „Povedal je, da …“ → told that. Slovenski „povedati“ lahko stoji brez osebe, angleški tell pa jo navadno potrebuje. Brez osebe uporabite said, z osebo pa told us / told me.

❌At Monday's meeting our project leader told that the new booking system for the hotels in Bohinj would be ready by March.
✅At Monday's meeting our project leader said that the new booking system for the hotels in Bohinj would be ready by March. ali At Monday's meeting our project leader told us that the new booking system for the hotels in Bohinj would be ready by March.
tell + oseba ali say brez osebe

Ne zamenjujte

Premo vprašanje in poročano vprašanje – Premo vprašanje ima obrnjeni besedni red in vprašaj; poročano ima red trdilne povedi in piko.

"Where is the station?" she asked.
„Kje je postaja?“ je vprašala.
premi govor
She asked where the station was.
Vprašala je, kje je postaja.
odvisni govor: red trdilne povedi

told me to in told me that – to + glagol poroča navodilo („rekla mi je, naj …“), that + odvisnik pa podatek („rekla mi je, da …“). Slovenščina razliko pokaže z „naj“ in „da“.

She told me to call the office.
Rekla mi je, naj pokličem v pisarno.
navodilo: „naj“
She told me that she had called the office.
Rekla mi je, da je poklicala v pisarno.
podatek: „da“

Poročano vprašanje in posredno vprašanje – Obe imata red trdilne povedi. Poročano vprašanje pove, kaj je kdo vprašal; posredno vprašanje je vljuden način, kako nekaj vprašati zdaj B1-14.

He asked me where the bank was.
Vprašal me je, kje je banka.
poročanje
Could you tell me where the bank is?
Mi lahko poveste, kje je banka?
vljudno vprašanje zdaj: glejte B1-14

Pravopis in izgovorjava

  • asked izgovorite /ɑːskt/ (UK) ali /æskt/ (US): končnica -ed tu ni nov zlog, ampak samo /t/. Skupine soglasnikov so vam domače, zato /skt/ ni težak. V hitrem govoru /k/ pogosto izgine, napišite pa vedno asked.
  • told me to izgovorite kot eno skupino, to je šibek, s polglasnikom /tə/: TOLD-me-tə. l v told je temen: zadnji del jezika se dvigne proti nebu.
  • V not to naglasite not: He told me NOT to go.
  • Za poročanim vprašanjem ni vprašaja, tudi če je dolgo. Prav tako ni vejice pred if ali where, čeprav v slovenščini pred „ali“ in „kje“ vejico pišemo.
  • whether in weather navadno zvenita enako: /ˈweðə/ (UK), /ˈweðɚ/ (US). Na začetku je /w/: ustnice zaokrožite in jih hitro razprite, ne izgovorite v. Za /ð/ postavite konico jezika med zobe in naj glas zveni.

Zlato pravilo

Poročana vprašanja imajo red trdilne povedi – brez do / does / did in brez vprašaja; za vprašanja da / ne uporabite if / whether (slovenski „ali“). Prošnje in ukazi: ask / tell + oseba + (not) to + glagol – to je slovenski „naj“. Tell se pove nekomu, say pa nekaj.

Vaje

A. Oblika

V nalogah 1–5 uporabite časovni zamik (backshift).

  1. "Are you tired?" → She asked me I was tired.
  2. "Where do you work?" → He asked me where .
  3. "What time does the train leave?" → I asked what time the train .
  4. "Please be quiet." → The librarian asked us quiet.
  5. "Don't open the window." → She told me the window.
  6. Poročajte: "Why did you leave early?" (my boss asked me)

B. Pomen

Izberite pravilni odgovor.

  1. Izberite pravilni odgovor: He … me he was leaving.
  2. Izberite pravilni odgovor: She … goodbye and left.
  3. Izberite pravilni odgovor: The teacher … us to open our books.
  4. Izberite pravilni odgovor: "She told me to call the office." This is ….

C. Poiščite napako

V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.

  1. She asked me where was the bathroom.
  2. He asked me did I want a drink.
  3. They said us to come early.
  4. She asked who had taken her pen.

D. V kontekstu

Dopolnite besedilo z manjkajočimi besedami. Besede iz oklepaja uporabite v pravilni obliki; kjer sta v oklepaju dve možnosti, izberite pravo.

First day at work
On my first day, my manager asked me 15 I had worked in a café before. I said no. Then she asked me 16 (how / I / get) to work. She 17 (say / tell) me to wear black shoes, and she asked me 18 (not / use) my phone in the café. At the end of the day, she 19 (say / tell) I had done well!

E. Na vrsti ste vi

Pišite v angleščini.

  1. Poročajte o dveh vprašanjih, ki vam jih je kdo zastavil ta teden.
  2. Poročajte o navodilu učitelja, zdravnika ali šefa.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.

  1. B1-12 Reported Speech: odvisni govor v angleščini – časovni zamik (backshift), razloženo v slovenščini
    "I'll call you tomorrow." (a week later) → She said she would call me .
  2. A2-33 Who called you ali Who did you call? Vprašanja po osebku in predmetu v angleščini
    Who (live) in that house?
  3. B1-11 Trpnik v vseh časih in z naklonskimi glagoli: is being done, has been done, must be done
    Sorry, the lift (repair) at the moment.
  4. B1-08 I wish in If only: želje o sedanjosti v angleščini (wish ali hope?)
    I wish I (have) more free time.
Rešitve

A. Oblika

  1. if / whether
  2. I worked
  3. left
  4. to be
  5. not to open
  6. My boss asked me why I had left early. / My boss asked me why I left early.

B. Pomen

  1. told
  2. said
  3. told
  4. an instruction

C. Poiščite napako

  1. She asked me where the bathroom was.
  2. He asked me if I wanted a drink. / He asked me whether I wanted a drink.
  3. They told us to come early. / They asked us to come early.
  4. ✓ She asked who had taken her pen.

D. V kontekstu

  1. if / whether
  2. how I got / how I get
  3. told
  4. not to use
  5. said

E. Na vrsti ste vi

  1. My neighbour asked me if I was going away for the weekend. My son asked me what we were having for dinner.
  2. My doctor told me to drink more water and not to work so late.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

  1. the next day / the following day / the day after
  2. lives
  3. is being repaired
  4. had
Aplikacija za AndroidUčite se na poti Google Play