SlowingoSlovnica
B1 13 / 39

Reported Speech: odvisni govor v angleščini – časovni zamik (backshift), razloženo v slovenščini

Reported Speech: Statements

Na tej strani
  1. Cilj
  2. Glavna ideja
  3. Slovenščina in angleščina
  4. Oblika
  5. Raba
  6. Pogoste napake
  7. Pasti za govorce slovenščine
  8. Ne zamenjujte
  9. Pravopis in izgovorjava
  10. Zlato pravilo
  11. Vaje

Cilj

Po tej lekciji boste znali poročati, kaj je kdo rekel – She said (that) she was tired –, pri tem pravilno spremeniti čas, zaimke in časovne besede in vedeli boste, kdaj se čas ne spremeni.

Glavna ideja

Ko poročate o tujih besedah, ne predvajate posnetka. Sporočilo predajate naprej – s svojega stališča: iz svojega časa, svojega kraja in svojega zornega kota.

Recimo, da je Maria v ponedeljek rekla: "I'm tired. I'll call you tomorrow." V petek o tem pripovedujete prijatelju. Ponedeljek je zdaj v preteklosti, zato se ves pogovor premakne korak nazaj v času: Maria said she was tired and would call me the next day. Temu koraku nazaj rečemo časovni zamik (backshift).

Tudi vse drugo se prilagodi vašemu zornemu kotu. Njen I postane she, njen you postane me, njen tomorrow pa the next day, saj „jutri“, gledano s ponedeljka, ni „jutri“, gledano s petka.

A časovni zamik ni pravilo za robote. Če to, kar je rekla, še vedno drži, ali če poročate o nečem, kar je bilo rečeno pred trenutkom, lahko obdržite prvotni čas. Vedno se vprašajte: kako je to videti od tam, kjer sem zdaj?

Slovenščina in angleščina

V slovenščini se čas v odvisnem govoru ne spremeni: „Rekla je, da je utrujena in da me bo poklicala.“ Angleščina pa za preteklim glagolom poročanja (said, told) čas navadno premakne korak nazaj: She said she was tired and would call me. Ker je slovenski vzorec tako naraven, se v angleščini rad pojavi she is, she will, she can tudi takrat, ko to ne velja več.

Zaimke in časovne besede pa tudi slovenščina prilagaja („Rekla je, da bo prišla naslednji dan“) – tu je enako. Pazite še na dve slovenski navadi: „rekla mi je“ ima dajalnik, angleški said pa za sabo ne prenese osebe (She told me… ali She said…); in pred „da“ v slovenščini pišemo vejico, pred angleškim that pa vejice ni.

SlovenščinaAngleščinaV čem je razlika?
Rekla je, da je zelo zaposlena.She said she was really busy.v slovenščini sedanjik; v angleščini korak nazaj
Rekel je, da mi bo poslal podrobnosti.He said he would send me the details.„bo“ → would
Rekla je, da ne more priti na zabavo.She said she couldn't come to the party.„ne more“ → couldn't
Rekel je, da je paket prišel dan prej.He said the parcel had arrived the day before.časovne besede: tu je enako
Rekla mi je, da je lačna.She told me / She said she was hungry.dajalnik „mi“ → told me, ne said me
Rekla je, da živi v Glasgowu.She said she lives in Glasgow.vejica pred „da“; pred that ni vejice; še vedno drži → brez zamika

Na kratko: slovenski odvisni govor obdrži čas, angleški za said navadno naredi korak nazaj; „rekel mi je“ je told me, in pred that ni vejice.

Oblika

Osnovni vzorec

Glagol poročanja(that)poročani del
She said(that)she was hungry.
He told me(that)he had lost his keys.

That ni obvezen in ga v govoru pogosto izpustimo. Say in tell imata različna vzorca: glejte B1-13.

Časovni zamik – spremembe časa za preteklim glagolom poročanja

Premi govorOdvisni govor
Present Simple: "I work in a bank."Past Simple: She said she worked in a bank.
Present Continuous: "I'm leaving."Past Continuous: He said he was leaving.
Present Perfect: "I've finished."Past Perfect: She said she had finished.
Past Simple: "I saw it."Past Perfect: He said he had seen it. (mogoče je tudi saw)
will: "I'll help."would: She said she would help.
can: "I can swim."could: He said he could swim.
may: "It may rain."might: She said it might rain.
must (obveznost): "I must go."had to: He said he had to go. (mogoče je tudi must)
am / is / are going to: "We're going to move."was / were going to: They said they were going to move.

Brez spremembe: would, could, should, might, ought to in Past Perfect ostanejo enaki.

Zaimki in svojilni zaimki – prilagodite jih zornemu kotu tistega, ki poroča.

Premi govorOdvisni govor
"I love my job." (Tom)Tom said he loved his job.
"We'll meet you at our house." (vaši starši vam)They said they would meet me at their house.

Časovne in krajevne besede (ko sta čas ali kraj zdaj drugačna)

Premi govorOdvisni govor
now (zdaj)then, at that time (takrat)
today / tonight (danes / nocoj)that day / that night (tisti dan / tisto noč)
yesterday (včeraj)the day before, the previous day (dan prej)
tomorrow (jutri)the next day, the following day (naslednji dan)
last week (prejšnji teden)the week before, the previous week (teden prej)
next month (prihodnji mesec)the following month (naslednji mesec)
… ago (pred …)… before, … earlier (… prej)
here (tukaj)there (tam)
this / thesethat / those (ali the)

Raba

1Časovni zamik za said

Ko je glagol poročanja v preteklosti (said, told), premaknite čas korak nazaj.

She said she was really busy.
Rekla je, da je zelo zaposlena.
prvotno: "I'm really busy."; slovenščina obdrži sedanjik
They said they were looking for a new flat.
Rekli so, da iščejo novo stanovanje.
prvotno: "We're looking for a new flat."
He said he had never been to Asia.
Rekel je, da še nikoli ni bil v Aziji.
prvotno: "I've never been to Asia."
She said she had missed the train.
Rekla je, da je zamudila vlak.
prvotno: "I missed the train."; mogoče je tudi „she missed“

2Naklonski glagoli v odvisnem govoru

Will → would, can → could, may → might, must (obveznost) → had to. Would, could, should, might in ought to se ne spremenijo.

He said he would send me the details.
Rekel je, da mi bo poslal podrobnosti.
„bo“ → would
She said she couldn't come to the party.
Rekla je, da ne more priti na zabavo.
„ne more“ → couldn't
He said the shop might be closed.
Rekel je, da je trgovina morda zaprta.
prvotno: "The shop may be closed."
The instructor said we had to wear a helmet.
Inštruktor je rekel, da moramo nositi čelado.
prvotno: "You must wear a helmet."
The doctor said I should rest.
Zdravnik je rekel, naj počivam.
should se ne spremeni; v slovenščini pogosto „naj“

3Sprememba zaimkov in svojilnih zaimkov

Poročajte s svojega zornega kota. Vprašajte se: kdo zdaj govori in kdo posluša?

My boss said she liked my haircut.
Šefica je rekla, da ji je všeč moja pričeska.
prvotno: "I like your haircut."
Our neighbours said they had sold their car.
Sosedje so rekli, da so prodali avto.
prvotno: "We've sold our car."
He said I was his best friend.
Rekel je, da sem njegov najboljši prijatelj.
prvotno: "You're my best friend."

4Sprememba časovnih in krajevnih besed

Če sta čas ali kraj ob poročanju drugačna, spremenite besede, kot so today, tomorrow, ago, here.

She said she would see me the next day.
Rekla je, da se vidiva naslednji dan.
prvotno: "I'll see you tomorrow."; dvojina „se vidiva“
He said he had started the job two years before.
Rekel je, da je v službo prišel dve leti prej.
prvotno: "I started this job two years ago."
She said she was staying there that night.
Rekla je, da bo tisto noč prespala tam.
prvotno: "I'm staying here tonight."
He said the parcel had arrived the day before.
Rekel je, da je paket prišel dan prej.
prvotno: "The parcel arrived yesterday."

5Brez zamika – še vedno drži ali pravkar rečeno

Če informacija še vedno drži, lahko obdržite prvotni čas. To je v govoru zelo pogosto. Tudi časovni zamik je pravilen.

She said she lives in Glasgow.
Rekla je, da živi v Glasgowu.
tam še vedno živi
Our teacher said the Earth goes round the Sun.
Učiteljica je rekla, da se Zemlja vrti okoli Sonca.
splošna resnica
I said it's at three!
Rekel sem, da je ob treh!
ponavljam, kar sem rekel pred trenutkom

6Glagol poročanja v sedanjiku – brez zamika

Če je glagol poročanja v sedanjiku (says, has said), se časi ne spremenijo. To je pogosto pri sporočilih in listkih.

Jake says he's running late.
Jake pravi, da bo zamudil.
„pravi“ → says: čas ostane
The weather forecast says it'll be sunny all week.
Vremenska napoved pravi, da bo ves teden sončno.
Mum has said she can't come this weekend.
Mama je rekla, da ta vikend ne more priti.
Mum (UK) = Mom (US)

Pogoste napake

❌She said me she was tired.
✅She told me she was tired.
Za say ne stoji oseba: She said she was tired. Glejte B1-13.
❌He said he has finished it last week.
✅He said he had finished it last week. ali He said he finished it last week.
Končan pretekli čas (last week) nikoli ne gre s Present Perfect: premaknite v Past Perfect ali obdržite Past Simple.
❌He said that he will call me, but he never did.
✅He said that he would call me, but he never did.
will → would; klic ni več v prihodnosti.
❌They said they must to leave.
✅They said they had to leave.
must → had to; nikoli „must to“.
❌A year ago he said he had started the job two years ago.
✅A year ago he said he had started the job two years before.
ago šteje nazaj od zdaj; before šteje nazaj od trenutka v preteklosti.
❌Last month she said she would come tomorrow.
✅Last month she said she would come the next day.
Njen „jutri“ ni jutri, gledano od zdaj.
❌She said, she was hungry.
✅She said she was hungry.
Pred poročanim delom ni vejice.

Pasti za govorce slovenščine

1. „Rekel nam je“ → said us. Slovenski „reči“ ima osebo v dajalniku („rekla mi je“, „rekel nam je“). Angleški say pa osebe neposredno za sabo ne prenese: povejte told us ali samo said.

❌In September my Spanish teacher said us that the oral part of the matura would be harder than the written one, so we started practising in pairs.
✅In September my Spanish teacher told us that the oral part of the matura would be harder than the written one, so we started practising in pairs. ali In September my Spanish teacher said that the oral part of the matura would be harder than the written one, so we started practising in pairs.
„rekel nam je“ → told us / said

2. „Rekla je, da …“ → said, that. V slovenščini pred „da“ stoji vejica. Angleščina pred poročanim delom (s that ali brez njega) vejice ne postavi.

❌Our geography teacher said, that the Soca is the most beautiful river in Europe and that we should all see it at least once.
✅Our geography teacher said that the Soca is the most beautiful river in Europe and that we should all see it at least once.
pred that ni vejice

3. „Rekla je, da se seli“ → said she is moving. Slovenščina v odvisnem govoru obdrži sedanjik in prihodnjik. Ko je trenutek že mimo ali izjava ne drži več, angleščina potrebuje korak nazaj: is → was, can → could.

❌Last December Zala told me at the bus station in Celje that she is moving to Vienna in the spring, and she has been living there since April.
✅Last December Zala told me at the bus station in Celje that she was moving to Vienna in the spring, and she has been living there since April.
selitev je že za njo → was moving
❌In March our landlord in Maribor said we can keep the cat, but in May he suddenly changed his mind.
✅In March our landlord in Maribor said we could keep the cat, but in May he suddenly changed his mind.
ne drži več → could

Ne zamenjujte

Premi ali odvisni govor – Premi govor ponovi natančne besede v narekovajih; odvisni govor jih pove po svoje, s spremembami.

Ana said, "I'm hungry."
Ana je rekla: „Lačna sem.“
premi govor
Ana said she was hungry.
Ana je rekla, da je lačna.
odvisni govor; v angleščini brez vejice

Z zamikom ali brez njega – Oboje je lahko pravilno. Zamik samo poroča; brez zamika pokažete, da po vašem še vedno drži.

He said he was a vegetarian.
Rekel je, da je vegetarijanec.
poročam, kaj je takrat rekel
He said he's a vegetarian, so let's not cook meat.
Rekel je, da je vegetarijanec, zato ne kuhajmo mesa.
drži še zdaj in je pomembno

must (obveznost) ali must (sklepanje) – Must za obveznost pogosto postane had to. Must za sklepanje B1-16 ostane must.

She said she had to leave early.
Rekla je, da mora oditi prej.
prvotno: "I must leave early."
He said I must be tired.
Rekel je, da sem gotovo utrujen.
prvotno: "You must be tired."

Pravopis in izgovorjava

  • V odvisnem govoru ni narekovajev in ni vejice: She said she was tired. Slovenska vejica pred „da“ se v angleščino ne prenese.
  • V premem govoru pred narekovaji stoji vejica, končna pika pa je znotraj narekovajev: She said, "I'm tired."
  • said izgovorite /sed/, s kratkim e – ne kot „sejd“.
  • that je nenaglašen: /ðət/, s polglasnikom. Za /ð/ postavite konico jezika med zobe in glas naj zveni – ni ne d ne z.
  • 'd je lahko would ali had: She said she'd help (would) / She said she'd helped (had). Poglejte glagol za njim.

Zlato pravilo

Poročajte iz svojega časa in kraja: za preteklim glagolom poročanja čas navadno premaknite korak nazaj, zaimke in časovne besede pa prilagodite. Če še drži ali če je glagol poročanja v sedanjiku, lahko obdržite prvotni čas. Slovenski „rekla je, da je“ vam tu ne pomaga – in pred that ni vejice.

Vaje

A. Oblika

Pri 1–6 premaknite čas korak nazaj. Pri 7 poročajte s said.

  1. "I'm cold." → She said she cold.
  2. "We've finished the project." → They said they the project.
  3. "I'll text you." → He said he me.
  4. "I can't find my keys." → She said she her keys.
  5. "I may be late." → He said he late.
  6. "I'm watching a film." → She said she a film.
  7. Poročajte s said: "I love my new job." (your sister)

B. Pomen

Dopolnite ali izberite pravilni odgovor.

  1. V ponedeljek je Tom rekel: "I'll do it tomorrow." Zdaj je petek. Dopolnite: Tom said he would do it .
  2. Prijateljica je to rekla pred petimi minutami: "The film starts at eight." Dopolnite: She said the film at eight.
  3. "I'm a vegetarian," je lani rekel Sam, in to je še vedno. Katero poročanje je pravilno?
  4. "You must be tired," mi je rekla medicinska sestra. Poročajte: The nurse said I tired.

C. Poiščite napako

V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.

  1. He said me that he was ill.
  2. She said she will come, but she didn't.
  3. They said they must to go home.
  4. The forecast says it will rain tomorrow.

D. V kontekstu

Dopolnite besedilo z glagoli iz oklepaja. Povsod premaknite čas korak nazaj.

Lunch with Clara
I had lunch with Clara yesterday. She said she 16 (be) really happy at her new company. She told me she 17 (just / get) a promotion! She said they 18 (send) her to New York the following month, and that she 19 (can) take her family with her. She also said she 20 (call) me when she got there.

E. Na vrsti ste vi

Pišite v angleščini.

  1. Pomislite na nekaj, kar vam je prijatelj povedal prejšnji teden. Poročajte s said.
  2. Poročajte o današnjem sporočilu s says.
Rešitve

A. Oblika

  1. was
  2. had finished / 'd finished
  3. would text / 'd text
  4. couldn't find / could not find
  5. might be
  6. was watching
  7. My sister said she loved her new job. / My sister said that she loved her new job. / My sister said she loves her new job. / My sister said that she loves her new job.

B. Pomen

  1. the next day / the following day / on Tuesday
  2. starts / started
  3. both
  4. must be

C. Poiščite napako

  1. He told me that he was ill. / He said that he was ill. / He told me he was ill. / He said he was ill.
  2. She said she would come, but she didn't. / She said she'd come, but she didn't.
  3. They said they had to go home. / They said they must go home.
  4. ✓ The forecast says it will rain tomorrow.

D. V kontekstu

  1. was
  2. had just got / had just gotten / 'd just got / 'd just gotten
  3. were sending / were going to send / would send
  4. could
  5. would call / 'd call

E. Na vrsti ste vi

  1. My friend Leo said he was going to move to Madrid.
  2. My brother says he can't come to dinner tonight.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

  1. had already left / 'd already left
  2. did you call
  3. was built
  4. were
Aplikacija za AndroidUčite se na poti Google Play