SlowingoGramatika
B2 25 / 30

Whereas, nevertheless, much as: „dok“, „ipak“ i „koliko god“ na engleskom

Whereas, Nevertheless, Much As: Advanced Contrast

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Hrvatski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Uporaba
  6. Česte pogreške
  7. Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga
  8. Ne miješajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vježbe

Cilj

Nakon ove lekcije znat ćete usporediti dvije stvari s whereas / while, dodati neočekivanu misao s nevertheless, nonetheless, even so, all the same i that said te izraziti dopuštanje s much as, no matter how / what, however + pridjev, still i yet.

Osnovna ideja

Na razini B1 naučili ste although, despite i however B1-26. Sad je vrijeme da razdvojimo dva različita posla koja te riječi rade.

Kontrast stavlja dvije činjenice jednu uz drugu da pokaže da su različite: My sister loves the city, whereas I prefer the countryside. Ništa nije iznenađujuće; dvije su stvari samo različite.

Dopuštanje (concession) prihvaća jednu činjenicu, a zatim kaže nešto neočekivano unatoč njoj: It was expensive. Nevertheless, we bought it. Priznate jednu stvar – prihvatite je – i ipak idete dalje.

Zamislite vagu. Kontrast stavlja dva utega na vagu i uspoređuje ih. Dopuštanje stavi jedan uteg i kaže: „Pa ipak, druga strana i dalje pobjeđuje.“

Riječi iz ove lekcije oba posla čine preciznijima – od formalnih pisanih veznika do toplih govornih izraza kao Much as I love him…

Hrvatski i engleski

Hrvatski za kontrast ima „dok“ i „a“: „Brat voli sport, dok ja radije čitam.“ To se dobro poklapa s while / whereas. Za dopuštanje imamo „ipak“, „unatoč tome“, „svejedno“ i „koliko god“ – jedna riječ „ipak“ pokriva nevertheless, even so, still i yet, pa u engleskom morate odabrati prema položaju i stilu.

Dvije stvari prave probleme. Prvo, u razgovornom hrvatskom često čujemo „Iako je bilo skupo, ali smo ga kupili.“ U engleskom rečenica s much as / while / although nikad nema još i but. Drugo, hrvatsko „koliko god“ stoji ispred cijele rečenice („koliko god bio umoran“), a engleski however / no matter how odmah iza sebe traži pridjev ili prilog: However tired you are…

HrvatskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Brat je vrlo sportski tip, dok ja radije čitam knjigu.My brother is very sporty, whereas I'd rather read a book.ovdje je isto: „dok“ → whereas / while
Ispit je bio iznimno težak. Ipak, većina je prošla.The exam was extremely difficult. Nevertheless, most students passed.„ipak“ između dviju rečenica → Nevertheless,
Koliko god volim svoj posao, treba mi odmor.Much as I love my job, I need a break.bez „ali“ u drugom dijelu
Koliko god bili umorni, uvijek skinite šminku prije spavanja.However tired you are, always take your make-up off before bed.however + pridjev odmah zajedno
Što god ljudi govorili, slijedit ću svoj san.No matter what people say, I'm going to follow my dream.„što god“ → no matter what + izjavni red riječi
Ulaznice su bile skupe. Svejedno smo se super proveli.The tickets were expensive. We still had a great time.„svejedno / ipak“ u sredini rečenice → still

Ukratko: „dok / a“ = whereas / while; „ipak“ između rečenica = Nevertheless, / Even so,; „koliko god volim“ = Much as I love (bez but); „koliko god umoran“ = However tired.

Oblik

RiječPovezujePoložaj / interpunkcijaPrimjer
whereas / whiledvije surečenice (kontrast)na početku ili u sredini; obično zarez ispred whereasI'm an early bird, whereas my partner works best at night.
while (= although)dvije surečenice (dopuštanje)obično na početkuWhile I agree with you, I think we should wait.
nevertheless / nonethelessdvije rečenice (dopuštanje)početak druge rečenice + zarez, ili iza točke sa zarezom; i u sredini ili na krajuIt was risky. Nevertheless, they went ahead.
even so / all the same / that saiddvije rečenice (dopuštanje, više u govoru)početak druge rečenice + zarez (all the same i na kraju)The hotel was basic. Even so, we loved it.
much as + surečenicasurečenica + glavna rečenicana početku; zarez iza surečeniceMuch as I like him, I don't trust him.
no matter how / what / who / where + surečenicasurečenica + glavna rečenicana početku ili na krajuNo matter what you do, don't press that button.
however + pridjev / prilog + subjekt + glagolsurečenica + glavna rečenicana početku ili na krajuHowever hard I try, I can't remember her name.
stillunutar glavne rečeniceu sredini: ispred glavnog glagola, iza beIt was raining. We still went for a walk.
yetdvije surečenice ili rečenicekao but, malo formalnije i više iznenađujeThe plan was simple, yet it worked.

Uporaba

1Whereas / while – izravna usporedba

Whereas ili while upotrijebite da usporedite dvije činjenice koje su različite. Whereas je malo formalniji i služi samo za taj posao. While može značiti i „dok“ (u vremenu) ili „iako“, pa je važan kontekst.

My brother is very sporty, whereas I'd rather read a book.
Brat je vrlo sportski tip, dok ja radije čitam knjigu.
„dok“ → whereas
Some people learn best by listening, while others need to see things written down.
Neki najbolje uče slušanjem, a drugi moraju vidjeti napisano.
Whereas most of the city is modern, the old town dates from the 14th century.
Dok je veći dio grada moderan, stari grad potječe iz 14. stoljeća.
Coffee wakes me up, while tea helps me relax.
Kava me razbudi, a čaj mi pomaže da se opustim.
„a“ → while

2While za dopuštanje

Na početku rečenice while često znači although, „iako“: prihvaća jednu misao prije nego što iznese drugu. Čest je u raspravama i u pristojnom neslaganju.

While I understand your point, I can't agree with it.
Iako razumijem što želite reći, ne mogu se složiti.
bez „ali“ u drugom dijelu
While the film is long, it never feels slow.
Iako je film dug, nikad se ne čini sporim.
While I'd love to come, I really can't afford it this month.
Iako bih rado došla, ovaj mjesec si to stvarno ne mogu priuštiti.

3Nevertheless, nonetheless, even so, all the same, that said

Ove riječi povezuju dvije rečenice (ili dvije surečenice s točkom sa zarezom). Druga kaže nešto iznenađujuće s obzirom na prvu. Nevertheless / nonetheless su formalni. Even so i all the same su neutralni do neformalni. That said uvodi suprotnu misao nakon onoga što ste upravo rekli. Formalnije riječi kao conversely i admittedly obrađuju se u C1-12 i C1-13.

The exam was extremely difficult. Nevertheless, most students passed.
Ispit je bio iznimno težak. Ipak, većina je studenata prošla.
formalno „ipak“
The report contains some errors; nonetheless, it is a useful starting point.
Izvješće sadrži neke pogreške; unatoč tome, dobra je polazna točka.
točka sa zarezom, ne samo zarez
The flat is tiny. Even so, I wouldn't want to live anywhere else.
Stan je sićušan. Pa ipak, ne bih želio živjeti nigdje drugdje.
flat (UK), apartment (US)
I know it's not your fault. All the same, I'm disappointed.
Znam da nisi ti kriva. Svejedno sam razočaran.
„svejedno“ → all the same
The restaurant is overpriced. That said, the desserts are amazing.
Restoran je preskup. S druge strane, deserti su fantastični.
Thanks for the offer. I'll say no, all the same.
Hvala na ponudi. Ipak ću reći ne.
na kraju: neformalno

4Much as – dopuštanje uz osjećaje

Much as + surečenica znači „iako… jako“, naše „koliko god“. Upotrebljava se s glagolima osjećaja kao like, love, want, admire, enjoy, respect. Zvuči uglađeno i često dolazi ispred razočaravajuće odluke.

Much as I love my job, I need a break.
Koliko god volim svoj posao, treba mi odmor.
„koliko god“ → much as; bez but
Much as I'd like to help, I really don't have time this week.
Koliko god vam želio pomoći, ovaj tjedan stvarno nemam vremena.
Much as we admire his talent, we can't accept his behaviour.
Koliko god se divimo njegovu talentu, ne možemo prihvatiti njegovo ponašanje.

5No matter how / what / who; however + pridjev

No matter + upitna riječ znači „svejedno je kako / što / tko…“. However + pridjev / prilog + subjekt + glagol znači „koliko god“. Glavna rečenica pokazuje da se rezultat ne mijenja. Iza obaju izraza dolazi izjavni red riječi.

No matter how hard I try, I can't get up before seven.
Koliko god se trudio, ne mogu ustati prije sedam.
how + hard zajedno
No matter what people say, I'm going to follow my dream.
Što god ljudi govorili, slijedit ću svoj san.
„što god“ → no matter what
Don't open the door, no matter who knocks.
Ne otvaraj vrata, tko god kucao.
„tko god“ → no matter who
However tired you are, always take your make-up off before bed.
Koliko god bili umorni, uvijek skinite šminku prije spavanja.
however + pridjev odmah zajedno
However carefully you plan, something always goes wrong.
Koliko god pažljivo planirali, uvijek nešto pođe po zlu.

6Still i yet kao znakovi kontrasta

Still pokazuje da je nešto istina unatoč onome što je rečeno; stoji u sredini rečenice (ispred glavnog glagola, iza be ili prvog pomoćnog glagola B1-33). Yet radi kao but, ali više iznenađuje i malo je formalniji.

He's lived in London for ten years, and he still gets lost on the Underground.
Već deset godina živi u Londonu, a još se uvijek gubi u podzemnoj.
hrvatski: prezent „živi“; engleski: Present Perfect
The tickets were expensive. We still had a great time.
Ulaznice su bile skupe. Svejedno smo se super proveli.
„svejedno“ → still u sredini
She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.
Milijunašica je, a ipak živi u sićušnom stanu.
„a ipak“ → yet
It's a simple idea, yet nobody has thought of it before.
Ideja je jednostavna, a ipak se nitko prije nije sjetio.

Česte pogreške

❌Much as I like him, but I don't trust him.
✅Much as I like him, I don't trust him.
Ne dodajte but iza surečenice dopuštanja.
❌No matter how I am tired, I go to the gym.
✅No matter how tired I am, I go to the gym.
how + pridjev stoje zajedno.
❌However I try hard, I can't do it.
✅However hard I try, I can't do it.
however + pridjev / prilog + subjekt + glagol.
❌No matter what do you say, I won't change my mind.
✅No matter what you say, I won't change my mind.
Izjavni red riječi; bez do.
❌Even so the hotel was basic, we loved it.
✅The hotel was basic. Even so, we loved it.
even so povezuje dvije rečenice; ne može uvesti surečenicu kao although.
❌It was raining, nevertheless we went out.
✅It was raining; nevertheless, we went out. ili It was raining. Nevertheless, we went out.
U pisanju nevertheless ne može povezati dvije surečenice samo zarezom; pogledajte B2-27.

Zamke za govornike hrvatskoga

1. „Iako… / Koliko god…, ali…“ → While / No matter how…, but… U razgovornom hrvatskom često se kaže „Iako je skupo, ali vrijedi“ ili „Koliko god ga volim, ali…“. Engleski to ne dopušta: rečenica koja počinje s much as, while, although ili no matter how već nosi kontrast, pa drugi dio počinje bez but.

❌While the apartment we rented in Makarska was a bit far from the beach, but the view from the balcony made up for it.
✅While the apartment we rented in Makarska was a bit far from the beach, the view from the balcony made up for it.
bez but u drugom dijelu
❌No matter how early we leave Zagreb on a Saturday in July, but we always get stuck in traffic before the tunnel at Sveti Rok.
✅No matter how early we leave Zagreb on a Saturday in July, we always get stuck in traffic before the tunnel at Sveti Rok.
no matter how + surečenica, zatim izravno glavna rečenica

2. „Koliko god umoran…“ → however much tired. „Koliko god“ doslovno je how much, pa se lako napravi however much ili no matter how much + pridjev. Uz pridjev ili prilog engleski upotrebljava samo however / no matter how + pridjev; however much ide uz glagol ili imenicu (however much I eat).

❌However much nervous Lucija gets before a presentation, the clients never notice anything.
✅However nervous Lucija gets before a presentation, the clients never notice anything.
however + pridjev, bez much
❌No matter how much expensive the tickets for the festival in Pula are, Karlo always finds a way to go.
✅No matter how expensive the tickets for the festival in Pula are, Karlo always finds a way to go.
how + pridjev

3. „Dok sam čekao…“ → whereas za vrijeme. Hrvatsko „dok“ znači i „za vrijeme“ i kontrast. Engleski while također radi oba posla, ali whereas služi samo za kontrast. Tko je naučio „dok = whereas“, lako ga upotrijebi i za vrijeme.

⚠️Whereas Matej was queueing for the ferry in Jablanac, his phone battery suddenly died.
✅While Matej was queueing for the ferry in Jablanac, his phone battery suddenly died.
Gramatički je ispravno, ali whereas znači samo kontrast, a ovdje je riječ o vremenu: while

Ne miješajte

whereas i although – Whereas uspoređuje dvije različite činjenice (kontrast). Although uvodi činjenicu zbog koje je druga iznenađujuća (dopuštanje). Whereas za iznenađujući rezultat zvuči pogrešno: recite Although the weather was bad, we enjoyed the trip. Pogledajte B1-26.

Tom likes jazz, whereas Ella prefers rock.
Tom voli jazz, a Ella radije sluša rock.
samo različito
Although Tom likes jazz, he's never been to a jazz club.
Iako Tom voli jazz, nikad nije bio u jazz klubu.
iznenađujuće

however (veznik) i however + pridjev – Kao veznik however ima zarez iza sebe. Kao riječ dopuštanja, iza njega odmah dolazi pridjev ili prilog.

The plan is good. However, it's expensive.
Plan je dobar. Međutim, skup je.
veznik
However good the plan is, it's too expensive.
Koliko god plan bio dobar, preskup je.
„koliko god“

while (vrijeme) i while (kontrast)

While I was cooking, the phone rang.
Dok sam kuhala, zazvonio je telefon.
„dok“, u vremenu
While Lisbon is hilly, Amsterdam is completely flat.
Lisabon je brdovit, a Amsterdam potpuno ravan.
kontrast

Pridjev + as + surečenica – Tired as she was, she finished the report srodan je emfatički obrazac koji se obrađuje u C1-06.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • nevertheless i nonetheless pišu se kao jedna riječ. Naglasak je na zadnjem slogu: /ˌnevəðəˈles/ (UK), /ˌnevərðəˈles/ (US); /ˌnʌnðəˈles/. U hrvatskom naglasak nikad nije na zadnjem slogu, pa ovo vježbajte: never-the-LESS. Glas /ð/ u sredini nije d: vrh jezika lagano između zuba, uz glas.
  • whereas /weərˈæz/ (UK), /werˈæz/ (US): jedna riječ, naglasak na drugom slogu. Glas /æ/ hrvatski nema – usta otvorite šire nego za e.
  • Iza Nevertheless, / Even so, / That said, napravite kratku stanku – zarez u pisanju stanka je u govoru.
  • U Much as I like him naglasite much i like. U much je glas /ʌ/: kratak i opušten, bliži hrvatskom a nego o.

Zlatno pravilo

Whereas / while upotrijebite da pokažete da su dvije stvari različite. Nevertheless, even so, that said, much as, no matter how, however + pridjev, still i yet upotrijebite kad je nešto istina unatoč onome što ste upravo rekli. I zapamtite: iza much as i while nema but, a „koliko god umoran“ je however tired.

Vježbe

A. Oblik

Preoblikujte ili spojite rečenice prema uputi.

  1. Preoblikujte sa much as: Although I really love chocolate, I'm trying to eat less of it.
  2. Preoblikujte s however: It doesn't matter how hard I try — I can't remember her name.
  3. Preoblikujte s no matter: It doesn't matter what people say — I'm going to follow my dream.
  4. Spojite s whereas: My brother loves football. I can't stand it.
  5. Preoblikujte sa still: It was expensive, but we bought it anyway.
  6. Spojite s nevertheless: The test was hard. Most students passed.

B. Značenje

Odaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. Odaberite točan odgovor: My dad loves jazz, … my mum prefers pop.
  2. Odaberite točan odgovor: The test was hard. …, I think I passed.
  3. Odaberite točan odgovor: No matter … you choose, I'll support you.
  4. Odaberite točan odgovor: The hotel was cheap; …, it was very clean.
  5. U rečenici "While I understand your point, I can't agree" while znači: …

C. Pronađite pogrešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna pogreška ili je rečenica točna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. Much as I enjoy parties, but I'm staying home tonight.
  2. No matter how I am busy, I always call my mum on Sundays.
  3. However I try hard, I can't understand this.
  4. She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite recenziju riječima iz okvira. Svaku riječ upotrijebite jednom. Word box: whereas, that said, much as, however, still (use each word once)

Hotel review: The Harbour Inn
The rooms at the Harbour Inn are small, 16 the views are spectacular. The restaurant is overpriced. 17, the desserts are amazing. 18 we loved the staff, we found the noise from the bar hard to bear. 19 early you go to bed, you'll hear the music until midnight. The noise was bad, but we 20 had a great time.

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o sebi i ljudima koje poznajete.

  1. Usporedite sebe s nekim koga poznajete, s whereas ili while.
  2. Napišite rečenicu s much as ili no matter how o nekoj odluci koju ste donijeli.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

Ponovite gradivo prethodnih lekcija.

  1. B1-26 Although, despite ili however? Kako na engleskom reći „iako“, „unatoč“ i „međutim“
    … the rain, the match went ahead.
  2. B1-26 Although, despite ili however? Kako na engleskom reći „iako“, „unatoč“ i „međutim“
    She went to work … she felt ill.
  3. B2-22 Subject-verb agreement: news is, police are – slaganje glagola sa subjektom na engleskom
    Neither the manager nor the staff … happy.
  4. B2-21 As if, as though, suppose i it's time: „kao da“ i „zamisli da“ na engleskom
    It's high time we (leave).
Rješenja

A. Oblik

  1. Much as I love chocolate, I'm trying to eat less of it.
  2. However hard I try, I can't remember her name. / I can't remember her name, however hard I try.
  3. No matter what people say, I'm going to follow my dream. / I'm going to follow my dream, no matter what people say.
  4. My brother loves football, whereas I can't stand it. / Whereas my brother loves football, I can't stand it.
  5. It was expensive, but we still bought it. / It was expensive. We still bought it.
  6. The test was hard. Nevertheless, most students passed. / The test was hard; nevertheless, most students passed. / The test was hard. Most students nevertheless passed. / The test was hard. Most students passed nevertheless.

B. Značenje

  1. whereas
  2. Even so
  3. what
  4. nevertheless
  5. although

C. Pronađite pogrešku

  1. Much as I enjoy parties, I'm staying home tonight.
  2. No matter how busy I am, I always call my mum on Sundays.
  3. However hard I try, I can't understand this.
  4. ✓ She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.

D. U kontekstu

  1. whereas
  2. That said
  3. Much as
  4. However
  5. still

E. Vaš red

  1. My sister is very organised, whereas I'm always losing things.
  2. Much as I loved my old job, I needed a change.

F. Miješano ponavljanje

  1. Despite
  2. although
  3. were
  4. left
Android aplikacijaUčite u pokretu Google Play