SlowingoSlovnica
B2 25 / 30

Whereas, nevertheless, much as: nasprotje in dopustnost v angleščini

Whereas, Nevertheless, Much As: Advanced Contrast

Na tej strani
  1. Cilj
  2. Glavna ideja
  3. Slovenščina in angleščina
  4. Oblika
  5. Raba
  6. Pogoste napake
  7. Pasti za govorce slovenščine
  8. Ne zamenjujte
  9. Pravopis in izgovorjava
  10. Zlato pravilo
  11. Vaje

Cilj

Po tej lekciji boste znali primerjati dve stvari z whereas / while, dodati nepričakovano misel z nevertheless, nonetheless, even so, all the same in that said ter izraziti dopustnost z much as, no matter how / what, however + pridevnik, still in yet.

Glavna ideja

Na ravni B1 ste spoznali although, despite in however B1-26. Zdaj je čas, da ločimo dve različni nalogi, ki ju te besede opravljajo.

Nasprotje (contrast) postavi dve dejstvi drugo ob drugo in pokaže, da sta različni: My sister loves the city, whereas I prefer the countryside. Nič ni presenetljivo; stvari sta preprosto različni.

Dopustnost (concession) eno dejstvo sprejme, nato pa pove nekaj nepričakovanega, kljub temu dejstvu: It was expensive. Nevertheless, we bought it. Točko priznate – jo sprejmete – in greste vseeno naprej.

Predstavljajte si tehtnico. Nasprotje na tehtnico položi dve uteži in ju primerja. Dopustnost položi eno utež, nato pa reče: „Pa vendar druga stran še vedno zmaga.“

Orodja iz te lekcije obe nalogi naredijo natančnejši – od formalnih veznikov v pisanju do toplih govornih zvez, kot je Much as I love him…

Slovenščina in angleščina

Slovenščina ima za obe nalogi dobre ustreznice. „Medtem ko“ ima, tako kot while, dva pomena: čas in primerjavo. Tu je enako. „Kljub temu“, „pa vendar“ in „vseeno“ ustrezajo zvezam nevertheless, even so in all the same.

Razlike so drugje. Prvič, slovenščina po odvisniku s „čeprav“ ali „še tako“ rada doda še „a“, „pa“ ali „vendar“: „Še tako rad bi pomagal, a nimam časa.“ Angleški much as in while tega ne preneseta – drugi del začnete brez but. Drugič, „kljub temu“ je pri nas prislov („Kljub temu smo šli“) in del veznika („kljub temu, da“). Angleški nevertheless in even so pa sta samo prislova: ne moreta uvesti odvisnika. Tretjič, v „ne glede na to, kako sem utrujen“ stoji „sem“ med „kako“ in pridevnikom; angleščina pridevnik prilepi k how: no matter how tired I am. In četrtič, slovenska vejica lahko loči dve samostojni povedi („Deževalo je, kljub temu smo šli ven“), angleška pred nevertheless pa ne.

SlovenščinaAngleščinaV čem je razlika?
Brat je športen, medtem ko jaz raje berem.My brother is sporty, whereas I'd rather read.primerjava; tu je enako
Čeprav razumem, se ne strinjam.While I understand, I can't agree.while na začetku = although
Izpit je bil težak. Kljub temu so ga opravili.The exam was hard. Nevertheless, they passed.prislov med dvema povedma
Kljub temu, da je bil hotel skromen, …Although the hotel was basic, …odvisnik: although, ne nevertheless
Še tako rad bi pomagal, a nimam časa.Much as I'd like to help, I don't have time.brez but v drugem delu
Ne glede na to, kako sem utrujen, …No matter how tired I am, …pridevnik takoj za how
Je milijonarka, pa vendar živi skromno.She's a millionaire, yet she lives modestly.yet = „pa vendar“
Deževalo je, kljub temu smo šli ven.It was raining; nevertheless, we went out.v angleščini podpičje ali pika, ne vejica

Na kratko: whereas primerja, nevertheless in even so povezujeta dve povedi, much as nima but, how in however pa pridevnik držita takoj ob sebi.

Oblika

OrodjePovezujePoložaj / ločilaPrimer
whereas / whiledva stavka (nasprotje)na začetku ali v sredini; pred whereas navadno vejicaI'm an early bird, whereas my partner works best at night.
while (= although)dva stavka (dopustnost)navadno na začetkuWhile I agree with you, I think we should wait.
nevertheless / nonethelessdve povedi (dopustnost)na začetku druge povedi + vejica ali za podpičjem; tudi v sredini ali na koncuIt was risky. Nevertheless, they went ahead.
even so / all the same / that saiddve povedi (dopustnost, bolj govorno)na začetku druge povedi + vejica (all the same tudi na koncu)The hotel was basic. Even so, we loved it.
much as + stavekodvisnik + glavni stavekna začetku; za odvisnikom vejicaMuch as I like him, I don't trust him.
no matter how / what / who / where + stavekodvisnik + glavni stavekna začetku ali na koncuNo matter what you do, don't press that button.
however + pridevnik / prislov + osebek + glagolodvisnik + glavni stavekna začetku ali na koncuHowever hard I try, I can't remember her name.
stillznotraj glavnega stavkav sredini: pred glavnim glagolom, za beIt was raining. We still went for a walk.
yetdva stavka ali povedikot but, malo formalnejši in bolj presenetljivThe plan was simple, yet it worked.

Raba

1Whereas / while – neposredna primerjava

Whereas ali while uporabite, ko primerjate dve različni dejstvi. Whereas je malo formalnejši in ima samo to nalogo. While lahko pomeni tudi med tem ko (čas) ali although, zato odloča sobesedilo. Slovenščina razliko pogosto pove kar s „pa“: „Kava me prebudi, čaj pa me pomiri.“

My brother is very sporty, whereas I'd rather read a book.
Moj brat je zelo športen, medtem ko jaz raje berem knjigo.
„medtem ko“ kot primerjava → whereas
Some people learn best by listening, while others need to see things written down.
Nekateri se najbolje učijo s poslušanjem, drugi pa morajo stvari videti zapisane.
primerjava s „pa“ → while
Whereas most of the city is modern, the old town dates from the 14th century.
Večina mesta je sodobna, staro mestno jedro pa je iz 14. stoletja.
whereas lahko stoji tudi na začetku
Coffee wakes me up, while tea helps me relax.
Kava me prebudi, čaj pa me pomiri.
„pa“ → while

2While za dopustnost

Na začetku povedi while pogosto pomeni although: eno točko sprejme, preden pove drugo. Pogost je v razpravah in pri vljudnem nestrinjanju. V slovenščini tu rečemo „čeprav“ ali „sicer … vendar“; v angleščini pa drugi del začnete brez but.

While I understand your point, I can't agree with it.
Čeprav razumem, kaj želiš povedati, se s tem ne morem strinjati.
while na začetku = although
While the film is long, it never feels slow.
Film je sicer dolg, vendar se nikoli ne vleče.
„sicer … vendar“ → While …, brez but
While I'd love to come, I really can't afford it this month.
Z veseljem bi prišel, ampak si ta mesec tega res ne morem privoščiti.
slovenščina doda „ampak“; angleščina ne

3Nevertheless, nonetheless, even so, all the same, that said

Te zveze povezujejo dve povedi (ali dva stavka s podpičjem). Druga pove nekaj presenetljivega glede na prvo. Nevertheless / nonetheless sta formalna. Even so in all the same sta nevtralna do neformalna. That said uvede nasprotno misel k temu, kar ste pravkar povedali. Formalnejši zvezi conversely in admittedly sta v C1-12 in C1-13. Vse so prislovi, ne vezniki: odvisnika ne morejo uvesti, kot ga „kljub temu, da“.

The exam was extremely difficult. Nevertheless, most students passed.
Izpit je bil izjemno težak. Kljub temu ga je večina študentov opravila.
„kljub temu“ (prislov) → nevertheless
The report contains some errors; nonetheless, it is a useful starting point.
Poročilo vsebuje nekaj napak, je pa kljub temu koristno izhodišče.
v slovenščini vejica; v angleščini podpičje
The flat is tiny. Even so, I wouldn't want to live anywhere else.
Stanovanje je majhno. Pa vendar ne bi hotel živeti nikjer drugje.
even so = „pa vendar“
I know it's not your fault. All the same, I'm disappointed.
Vem, da nisi ti kriv. Vseeno sem razočarana.
all the same = „vseeno“
The restaurant is overpriced. That said, the desserts are amazing.
Restavracija je predraga. Moram pa priznati, da so sladice odlične.
that said = „moram pa priznati“
Thanks for the offer. I'll say no, all the same.
Hvala za ponudbo. Bom pa vseeno odklonil.
all the same na koncu: neformalno

4Much as – dopustnost z občutki

Much as + stavek pomeni although… very much, nekako „čeprav … še tako (rad)“. Uporabljamo ga z glagoli občutkov, kot so like, love, want, admire, enjoy, respect. Zveni izbrano in pogosto stoji pred razočarljivo odločitvijo. Slovenski „še tako rad …, a …“ ima v drugem delu „a“; angleški much as ga nima.

Much as I love my job, I need a break.
Čeprav imam svojo službo zelo rad, potrebujem odmor.
much as = „čeprav … zelo“
Much as I'd like to help, I really don't have time this week.
Še tako rada bi pomagala, a ta teden res nimam časa.
slovenščina doda „a“; za much as ni but
Much as we admire his talent, we can't accept his behaviour.
Njegov talent zelo cenimo, njegovega vedenja pa ne moremo sprejeti.
„pa“ v slovenščini; v angleščini samo vejica

5No matter how / what / who; however + pridevnik

No matter + vprašalnica pomeni „ni pomembno, kako / kaj / kdo …“ – „ne glede na to, kako …“. However + pridevnik / prislov + osebek + glagol pomeni „še tako“. Glavni stavek pokaže, da se izid ne spremeni. Za obema stoji besedni red trdilne povedi. Pazite: pridevnik ali prislov stoji takoj za how / however, v slovenščini pa se med njiju rad vrine „sem“, „je“ ali „smo“ („kako sem utrujen“).

No matter how hard I try, I can't get up before seven.
Ne glede na to, kako zelo se trudim, pred sedmo ne morem vstati.
how hard skupaj, nato osebek
No matter what people say, I'm going to follow my dream.
Ne glede na to, kaj pravijo ljudje, bom sledil svojim sanjam.
besedni red trdilne povedi, brez do
Don't open the door, no matter who knocks.
Ne odpiraj vrat, pa naj trka kdor koli.
„kdor koli“ → no matter who
However tired you are, always take your make-up off before bed.
Pa naj si še tako utrujena, pred spanjem vedno odstrani ličila.
„še tako utrujen“ → however tired
However carefully you plan, something always goes wrong.
Še tako skrbno lahko načrtuješ, vedno gre kaj narobe.
however + prislov skupaj

6Still in yet kot znaka nasprotja

Still pokaže, da nekaj velja kljub povedanemu; stoji v sredini stavka (pred glavnim glagolom, za be ali prvim pomožnim glagolom B1-33). V slovenščini je to „še vedno“ ali „vseeno“. Yet deluje kot but, vendar zveni bolj presenetljivo in malo formalno, kot naš „pa vendar“.

He's lived in London for ten years, and he still gets lost on the Underground.
V Londonu živi že deset let, pa se v podzemni železnici še vedno izgubi.
„živi že deset let“ → he's lived (Present Perfect); still = „še vedno“
The tickets were expensive. We still had a great time.
Vstopnice so bile drage. Vseeno smo se imeli odlično.
still = „vseeno“
She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.
Je milijonarka, pa vendar živi v majhnem stanovanju.
yet = „pa vendar“
It's a simple idea, yet nobody has thought of it before.
Zamisel je preprosta, pa se je doslej ni domislil še nihče.
slovenščina zanika dvakrat; v angleščini nobody brez not

Pogoste napake

❌Much as I like him, but I don't trust him.
✅Much as I like him, I don't trust him.
Za dopustnim odvisnikom ne dodajte but.
❌No matter how I am tired, I go to the gym.
✅No matter how tired I am, I go to the gym.
How in pridevnik ostaneta skupaj.
❌However I try hard, I can't do it.
✅However hard I try, I can't do it.
however + pridevnik/prislov + osebek + glagol.
❌No matter what do you say, I won't change my mind.
✅No matter what you say, I won't change my mind.
Besedni red trdilne povedi; brez do.
❌Even so the hotel was basic, we loved it.
✅The hotel was basic. Even so, we loved it.
Even so povezuje dve povedi; ne more uvesti odvisnika kot although.
❌It was raining, nevertheless we went out.
✅It was raining; nevertheless, we went out. ali It was raining. Nevertheless, we went out.
V pisanju nevertheless ne more povezati dveh stavkov samo z vejico; glejte B2-27.

Pasti za govorce slovenščine

1. „Še tako rad …, a …“ → much as …, but. Slovenščina po „čeprav“ ali „še tako“ v drugem delu rada doda „a“, „pa“ ali „vendar“. Angleški much as in dopustni while že sama izražata nasprotje, zato drugi del začnete brez but.

❌Much as my grandmother enjoys her little garden in Trnovo, but she can no longer carry the heavy watering cans herself.
✅Much as my grandmother enjoys her little garden in Trnovo, she can no longer carry the heavy watering cans herself.
za much as ni but
❌While the renovated library in Velenje has lovely quiet reading rooms, but it closes at five on weekdays, so students can hardly use it.
✅While the renovated library in Velenje has lovely quiet reading rooms, it closes at five on weekdays, so students can hardly use it.
dopustni while: brez but

2. „Kljub temu, da …“ → nevertheless + odvisnik. „Kljub temu“ je pri nas tudi del veznika „kljub temu, da“. Nevertheless in even so pa sta samo prislova in ne moreta uvesti odvisnika. Za odvisnik uporabite although ali even though.

❌Nevertheless the fog on Velika planina was thick all morning, we found the shepherds' huts without a map.
✅Although the fog on Velika planina was thick all morning, we found the shepherds' huts without a map. ali The fog on Velika planina was thick all morning. Nevertheless, we found the shepherds' huts without a map.
nevertheless ne uvaja odvisnika

3. „Ne glede na to, kako sem utrujen“ → no matter how I am tired. V slovenščini se „sem“, „smo“ ali „je“ postavi takoj za „kako“ in tako loči „kako“ od pridevnika. V angleščini pridevnik ali prislov stoji takoj za how oziroma however, šele nato prideta osebek in glagol.

❌No matter how we are exhausted after work, my husband and I walk our dog along the Ljubljanica every evening.
✅No matter how exhausted we are after work, my husband and I walk our dog along the Ljubljanica every evening.
how exhausted skupaj
❌However the lake is cold in early June, my grandfather from Bohinjska Bistrica swims out to the wooden buoy and back before breakfast.
✅However cold the lake is in early June, my grandfather from Bohinjska Bistrica swims out to the wooden buoy and back before breakfast.
however cold skupaj

4. „Bilo je drago, kljub temu smo ga kupili“ → vejica pred nevertheless. V slovenščini dve samostojni povedi s „kljub temu“ pogosto ločimo kar z vejico. V angleškem pisanju pa pred nevertheless, nonetheless in even so med dvema celima stavkoma potrebujete piko ali podpičje.

❌The cable car to Vogel was closed because of the strong wind, nonetheless we reached the top on foot by noon.
✅The cable car to Vogel was closed because of the strong wind; nonetheless, we reached the top on foot by noon. ali The cable car to Vogel was closed because of the strong wind. Nonetheless, we reached the top on foot by noon.
pred nonetheless: podpičje ali pika

Ne zamenjujte

whereas in although – Whereas primerja dve različni dejstvi (nasprotje). Although uvede dejstvo, zaradi katerega je drugo presenetljivo (dopustnost). Whereas za presenetljiv izid zveni napačno: recite Although the weather was bad, we enjoyed the trip. Glejte B1-26.

Tom likes jazz, whereas Ella prefers rock.
Tom ima rad jazz, Ella pa raje posluša rock.
samo različno
Although Tom likes jazz, he's never been to a jazz club.
Čeprav ima Tom rad jazz, ni bil še nikoli v jazz klubu.
presenetljivo

however (vezni prislov) in however + pridevnik – Kot vezni prislov ima however za sabo vejico. Kot izraz dopustnosti pa mu takoj sledi pridevnik ali prislov.

The plan is good. However, it's expensive.
Načrt je dober. Vendar je drag.
vezni prislov
However good the plan is, it's too expensive.
Naj bo načrt še tako dober, je predrag.
„še tako“

while (čas) in while (nasprotje) – tako kot slovenski „medtem ko“.

While I was cooking, the phone rang.
Medtem ko sem kuhala, je zazvonil telefon.
čas
While Lisbon is hilly, Amsterdam is completely flat.
Lizbona je hribovita, Amsterdam pa je povsem raven.
primerjava

Pridevnik + as + stavek – Tired as she was, she finished the report je soroden poudarjen vzorec, ki ga obravnava C1-06.

Pravopis in izgovorjava

  • nevertheless in nonetheless pišemo skupaj, kot eno besedo – čeprav slovenski „kljub temu“ pišemo narazen. Naglas je na zadnjem zlogu: /ˌnevəðəˈles/ (UK), /ˌnevərðəˈles/ (US); /ˌnʌnðəˈles/. Glas /ð/ naredite s konico jezika med zobmi, ne kot d ali z. Srednji zlog je šibek, s polglasnikom, ki ga poznate iz „pes“.
  • whereas /weərˈæz/ (UK), /werˈæz/ (US): ena beseda, naglas na drugem zlogu. /æ/ ni slovenski e: usta odprite kot za a, jezik pa potisnite naprej. Na koncu zveneči /z/ – ne razzvenite ga v s.
  • while in whereas se začneta z /w/: ustnice zaokrožite kot za u, ne izgovorite v.
  • Za Nevertheless, / Even so, / That said, naredite kratek premor – vejica v pisanju je premor v govoru.
  • V Much as I like him poudarite much in like.

Zlato pravilo

Whereas / while uporabite, ko pokažete, da sta stvari različni. Nevertheless, even so, that said, much as, no matter how, however + pridevnik, still in yet uporabite, ko nekaj velja kljub temu, kar ste pravkar povedali. In ne pozabite: za much as ni but, nevertheless ne uvaja odvisnika, how / however pa pridevnik drži takoj ob sebi.

Vaje

A. Oblika

Prepišite ali združite povedi z dano besedo.

  1. Prepišite z much as: Although I really love chocolate, I'm trying to eat less of it.
  2. Prepišite s however: It doesn't matter how hard I try — I can't remember her name.
  3. Prepišite z no matter: It doesn't matter what people say — I'm going to follow my dream.
  4. Združite z whereas: My brother loves football. I can't stand it.
  5. Prepišite s still: It was expensive, but we bought it anyway.
  6. Združite z nevertheless: The test was hard. Most students passed.

B. Pomen

Izberite pravilni odgovor.

  1. Izberite pravilni odgovor: My dad loves jazz, … my mum prefers pop.
  2. Izberite pravilni odgovor: The test was hard. …, I think I passed.
  3. Izberite pravilni odgovor: No matter … you choose, I'll support you.
  4. Izberite pravilni odgovor: The hotel was cheap; …, it was very clean.
  5. V povedi „While I understand your point, I can't agree“ while pomeni: …

C. Poiščite napako

V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.

  1. Much as I enjoy parties, but I'm staying home tonight.
  2. No matter how I am busy, I always call my mum on Sundays.
  3. However I try hard, I can't understand this.
  4. She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.

D. V kontekstu

Dopolnite oceno hotela z manjkajočimi besedami. Besede: whereas, that said, much as, however, still (vsako besedo uporabite enkrat).

Hotel review: The Harbour Inn
The rooms at the Harbour Inn are small, 16 the views are spectacular. The restaurant is overpriced. 17, the desserts are amazing. 18 we loved the staff, we found the noise from the bar hard to bear. 19 early you go to bed, you'll hear the music until midnight. The noise was bad, but we 20 had a great time.

E. Na vrsti ste vi

Pišite v angleščini o sebi in svojih odločitvah.

  1. Primerjajte se z nekom, ki ga poznate; uporabite whereas ali while.
  2. Napišite poved z much as ali no matter how o odločitvi, ki ste jo sprejeli.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.

  1. B1-26 Although, despite, however: kako v angleščini izraziti nasprotje
    … the rain, the match went ahead.
  2. B1-26 Although, despite, however: kako v angleščini izraziti nasprotje
    She went to work … she felt ill.
  3. B2-22 Subject-verb agreement: ujemanje glagola z osebkom v angleščini (news is, police are)
    Neither the manager nor the staff … happy.
  4. B2-21 As if, as though, suppose, it's time: „kot da“ in namišljeni položaji v angleščini
    It's high time we (leave).
Rešitve

A. Oblika

  1. Much as I love chocolate, I'm trying to eat less of it.
  2. However hard I try, I can't remember her name. / I can't remember her name, however hard I try.
  3. No matter what people say, I'm going to follow my dream. / I'm going to follow my dream, no matter what people say.
  4. My brother loves football, whereas I can't stand it. / Whereas my brother loves football, I can't stand it.
  5. It was expensive, but we still bought it. / It was expensive. We still bought it.
  6. The test was hard. Nevertheless, most students passed. / The test was hard; nevertheless, most students passed. / The test was hard. Most students nevertheless passed. / The test was hard. Most students passed nevertheless.

B. Pomen

  1. whereas
  2. Even so
  3. what
  4. nevertheless
  5. although

C. Poiščite napako

  1. Much as I enjoy parties, I'm staying home tonight.
  2. No matter how busy I am, I always call my mum on Sundays.
  3. However hard I try, I can't understand this.
  4. ✓ She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.

D. V kontekstu

  1. whereas
  2. That said
  3. Much as
  4. However
  5. still

E. Na vrsti ste vi

  1. My sister is very organised, whereas I'm always losing things.
  2. Much as I loved my old job, I needed a change.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

  1. Despite
  2. although
  3. were
  4. left
Aplikacija za AndroidUčite se na poti Google Play