SlowingoGramatika
B2 25 / 30

Whereas, nevertheless, much as: napredni izrazi za suprotnost i dopuštanje na engleskom

Whereas, Nevertheless, Much As: Advanced Contrast

Na ovoj stranici
  1. Cilj
  2. Osnovna ideja
  3. Srpski i engleski
  4. Oblik
  5. Upotreba
  6. Česte greške
  7. Zamke za govornike srpskog
  8. Ne mešajte
  9. Pravopis i izgovor
  10. Zlatno pravilo
  11. Vežbe

Cilj

Posle ove lekcije moći ćete da poredite dve stvari sa whereas / while, da dodate neočekivanu tvrdnju sa nevertheless, nonetheless, even so, all the same i that said i da izrazite dopuštanje (concession) sa much as, no matter how / what, however + pridev, still i yet.

Osnovna ideja

Na nivou B1 naučili ste although, despite i however B1-26. Sada je vreme da razdvojimo dva različita posla koja ove reči obavljaju.

Suprotnost (contrast) stavlja dve činjenice jednu pored druge da bi pokazala da su različite: My sister loves the city, whereas I prefer the countryside. Ništa nije iznenađujuće; stvari su jednostavno različite.

Dopuštanje (concession) prihvata jednu činjenicu, a zatim kaže nešto neočekivano uprkos njoj: It was expensive. Nevertheless, we bought it. Priznajete jednu stvar – prihvatate je – i ipak idete dalje.

Zamislite vagu. Suprotnost stavlja dva tega na vagu i poredi ih. Dopuštanje spusti jedan teg i kaže: „Pa ipak, druga strana i dalje preteže.“

Izrazi iz ove lekcije oba posla čine preciznijim – od formalnih veznika za pisanje do toplih izraza iz govora kao što je Much as I love him…

Srpski i engleski

Srpski za oba posla ima dobre reči. Za suprotnost kažemo „dok“ ili „a“ – i to radi isto kao englesko while / whereas. Za dopuštanje srpski ima jednu reč za skoro sve: „ipak“. Ona pokriva nevertheless, nonetheless, even so, all the same, still i yet, pa na engleskom treba birati prema položaju i stilu. Isto tako, „koliko god“ pokriva much as, no matter how i however + pridev. Dve stvari prave probleme: posle „iako“ i „koliko god“ u govoru često dodajemo „ali“, a „ipak“ stavljamo posle zareza usred rečenice – na engleskom to ne ide.

SrpskiEngleskiU čemu je razlika?
Kafa me razbudi, dok me čaj opusti.Coffee wakes me up, while tea helps me relax.ovde je isto: „dok“ = while
Iako razumem šta hoćeš da kažeš, ne mogu da se složim.While I understand your point, I can't agree with it.„iako“ na početku → i while
Ispit je bio težak. Ipak, većina je položila.The exam was extremely difficult. Nevertheless, most students passed.formalno „ipak“ → nevertheless
Stan je mali. Ipak, ne bih živeo nigde drugde.The flat is tiny. Even so, I wouldn't want to live anywhere else.razgovorno „ipak“ → even so
Karte su bile skupe. Ipak smo se lepo proveli.The tickets were expensive. We still had a great time.„ipak“ u sredini → still
Koliko god da volim svoj posao, treba mi odmor.Much as I love my job, I need a break.uz osećanja → much as; bez but
Koliko god da se trudim, ne mogu da ustanem pre sedam.No matter how hard I try, I can't get up before seven.how + prilog zajedno
Koliko god da si umoran…However tired you are…srpski pridev na kraju; engleski odmah posle however
Šta god da ljudi kažu…No matter what people say…ovde je isto: red reči kao u izjavnoj rečenici
Milionerka je, a ipak živi u malom stanu.She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.„a ipak“ → yet

Ukratko: „dok“ = whereas / while; „ipak“ = nevertheless / even so / still / yet prema položaju; „koliko god“ = much as / no matter how / however + pridev – i nikad sa but u nastavku.

Oblik

IzrazŠta spajaPoložaj / interpunkcijaPrimer
whereas / whiledve rečenice u istoj rečenici (suprotnost)na početku ili u sredini; ispred whereas obično zarezI'm an early bird, whereas my partner works best at night.
while (= although)dve rečenice (dopuštanje)obično na početkuWhile I agree with you, I think we should wait.
nevertheless / nonethelessdve rečenice (dopuštanje)na početku druge rečenice + zarez, ili posle tačke i zareza; i u sredini ili na krajuIt was risky. Nevertheless, they went ahead.
even so / all the same / that saiddve rečenice (dopuštanje, više u govoru)na početku druge rečenice + zarez (all the same i na kraju)The hotel was basic. Even so, we loved it.
much as + rečenicazavisna + glavna rečenicana početku; zarez posle zavisne rečeniceMuch as I like him, I don't trust him.
no matter how / what / who / where + rečenicazavisna + glavna rečenicana početku ili na krajuNo matter what you do, don't press that button.
however + pridev / prilog + subjekat + glagolzavisna + glavna rečenicana početku ili na krajuHowever hard I try, I can't remember her name.
stillunutar glavne rečeniceu sredini: ispred glavnog glagola, posle beIt was raining. We still went for a walk.
yetdve rečenicekao but, malo formalnije i iznenađujućeThe plan was simple, yet it worked.

Upotreba

1Whereas / while – direktno poređenje

Whereas ili while koristite da uporedite dve činjenice koje su različite. Whereas je malo formalnije i služi samo za ovo. While može da znači i during ili although, pa kontekst odlučuje. Srpsko „dok“ radi isto.

My brother is very sporty, whereas I'd rather read a book.
Moj brat se mnogo bavi sportom, dok ja više volim da čitam knjigu.
„dok“ = whereas
Some people learn best by listening, while others need to see things written down.
Neki ljudi najbolje uče slušajući, dok drugi moraju da vide stvari napisane.
Whereas most of the city is modern, the old town dates from the 14th century.
Dok je veći deo grada moderan, stari grad potiče iz 14. veka.
Coffee wakes me up, while tea helps me relax.
Kafa me razbudi, dok me čaj opusti.
ovde je isto

2While za dopuštanje

Na početku rečenice while često znači although: prihvata jednu tvrdnju pre nego što iznese drugu. Često je u raspravama i u učtivom neslaganju. Na srpskom je to „iako“ ili „mada“.

While I understand your point, I can't agree with it.
Iako razumem šta hoćete da kažete, ne mogu da se složim.
while = iako
While the film is long, it never feels slow.
Iako je film dugačak, nijednog trenutka ne deluje razvučeno.
While I'd love to come, I really can't afford it this month.
Iako bih rado došla, ovog meseca stvarno nemam para za to.
bez but u drugom delu

3Nevertheless, nonetheless, even so, all the same, that said

Ovi izrazi povezuju dve rečenice (ili dva dela rečenice sa tačkom i zarezom). Druga rečenica kaže nešto iznenađujuće s obzirom na prvu. Nevertheless / nonetheless su formalni. Even so i all the same su neutralni do razgovorni. That said uvodi suprotnu tvrdnju posle onoga što ste upravo rekli. Na srpskom je za većinu njih prevod „ipak“ ili „pa ipak“; that said je „s druge strane“ ili „doduše“. Formalniji izrazi kao conversely i admittedly su u C1-12 i C1-13.

The exam was extremely difficult. Nevertheless, most students passed.
Ispit je bio izuzetno težak. Ipak, većina studenata je položila.
formalno
The report contains some errors; nonetheless, it is a useful starting point.
Izveštaj sadrži neke greške; ipak, to je korisna polazna tačka.
formalno; tačka i zarez
The flat is tiny. Even so, I wouldn't want to live anywhere else.
Stan je sićušan. Pa ipak, ne bih želeo da živim nigde drugde.
flat (UK), apartment (US)
I know it's not your fault. All the same, I'm disappointed.
Znam da nisi ti kriv. Ipak, razočaran sam.
The restaurant is overpriced. That said, the desserts are amazing.
Restoran je preskup. S druge strane, deserti su fantastični.
Thanks for the offer. I'll say no, all the same.
Hvala na ponudi. Ipak ću odbiti.
na kraju: razgovorno

4Much as – dopuštanje uz osećanja

Much as + rečenica znači although… very much – „koliko god da…“. Koristi se sa glagolima osećanja kao što su like, love, want, admire, enjoy, respect. Zvuči uglađeno i često dolazi pre neprijatne odluke. Druga rečenica ne počinje sa but.

Much as I love my job, I need a break.
Koliko god da volim svoj posao, treba mi odmor.
„koliko god“ + osećanje → much as
Much as I'd like to help, I really don't have time this week.
Koliko god da bih voleo da pomognem, ove nedelje stvarno nemam vremena.
Much as we admire his talent, we can't accept his behaviour.
Koliko god da se divimo njegovom talentu, ne možemo da prihvatimo njegovo ponašanje.

5No matter how / what / who; however + pridev

No matter + upitna reč znači „nije važno kako / šta / ko…“. However + pridev / prilog + subjekat + glagol znači „u kojoj god meri“. Glavna rečenica pokazuje da se rezultat ne menja. Posle oba izraza red reči je kao u izjavnoj rečenici. Srpski ovde kaže „koliko god“, „šta god“, „ko god“ – ali pridev stavlja na kraj („koliko god da si umoran“), a na engleskom pridev ide odmah posle how / however.

No matter how hard I try, I can't get up before seven.
Koliko god da se trudim, ne mogu da ustanem pre sedam.
how hard zajedno
No matter what people say, I'm going to follow my dream.
Šta god da ljudi kažu, ja ću slediti svoj san.
Don't open the door, no matter who knocks.
Ne otvaraj vrata, ko god da kuca.
However tired you are, always take your make-up off before bed.
Koliko god da ste umorni, uvek skinite šminku pre spavanja.
srpski „umorni“ na kraju; engleski however tired
However carefully you plan, something always goes wrong.
Koliko god pažljivo da planirate, uvek nešto krene naopako.

6Still i yet kao znaci suprotnosti

Still pokazuje da nešto važi uprkos onome što je rečeno; stoji u sredini rečenice (ispred glavnog glagola, posle be ili prvog pomoćnog glagola B1-33). Yet radi kao but, ali zvuči iznenađujuće i malo formalnije. Na srpskom su oba često „ipak“, odnosno „a ipak“.

He's lived in London for ten years, and he still gets lost on the Underground.
Deset godina živi u Londonu, a i dalje se gubi u metrou.
srpski prezent; engleski Present Perfect
The tickets were expensive. We still had a great time.
Karte su bile skupe. Ipak smo se odlično proveli.
„ipak“ u sredini → still
She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.
Milionerka je, a ipak živi u malom stanu.
„a ipak“ → yet
It's a simple idea, yet nobody has thought of it before.
Ideja je jednostavna, a ipak niko ranije nije došao na nju.

Česte greške

❌Much as I like him, but I don't trust him.
✅Much as I like him, I don't trust him.
Posle rečenice sa much as ne dodajte but.
❌No matter how I am tired, I go to the gym.
✅No matter how tired I am, I go to the gym.
how + pridev idu zajedno.
❌However I try hard, I can't do it.
✅However hard I try, I can't do it.
however + pridev / prilog + subjekat + glagol.
❌No matter what do you say, I won't change my mind.
✅No matter what you say, I won't change my mind.
Red reči kao u izjavnoj rečenici; bez do.
❌Even so the hotel was basic, we loved it.
✅The hotel was basic. Even so, we loved it.
even so povezuje dve rečenice; ne može da uvede rečenicu kao although.
❌It was raining, nevertheless we went out.
✅It was raining; nevertheless, we went out. ili It was raining. Nevertheless, we went out.
U pisanju nevertheless ne može da spoji dve rečenice samo zarezom; pogledajte B2-27.

Zamke za govornike srpskog

1. „Iako…, ali…“ → Much as / While…, but. U srpskom govoru često čujemo „Iako je skupo, ali vredi“ ili „Koliko god da ga volim, ali…“. Na engleskom much as, while i although već nose suprotnost, pa drugi deo rečenice ne sme da počne sa but.

❌Much as I'd love to join you on Zlatibor, but I have to work that weekend.
✅Much as I'd love to join you on Zlatibor, I have to work that weekend.
posle much as nema but
❌While the new phone takes great photos, but its battery dies by lunchtime.
✅While the new phone takes great photos, its battery dies by lunchtime. ili The new phone takes great photos, but its battery dies by lunchtime.
ili while, ili but – ne oba

2. „Koliko god da sam gladan“ → no matter how I am hungry. Na srpskom pridev ili prilog stoji na kraju: „koliko god da smo gladni“, „koliko god da je kafa jaka“. Na engleskom pridev ide odmah posle how / however, a tek onda subjekat i glagol.

❌Grandma makes us eat soup first, no matter how we are hungry.
✅Grandma makes us eat soup first, no matter how hungry we are.
how + hungry zajedno
❌However the coffee is strong, it never keeps me awake.
✅However strong the coffee is, it never keeps me awake.
however + strong zajedno

3. „…, ipak…“ posle zareza → comma + nevertheless. Na srpskom bez problema pišemo „Recept je izgledao komplikovano, ipak je kolač uspeo.“ Na engleskom nevertheless, nonetheless i even so ne mogu da spoje dve rečenice samo zarezom: potrebna je tačka ili tačka i zarez. (Ako želite zarez, koristite but ili yet.)

❌The recipe looked complicated, nevertheless Luka's cake turned out perfect.
✅The recipe looked complicated. Nevertheless, Luka's cake turned out perfect. ili The recipe looked complicated; nevertheless, Luka's cake turned out perfect.
ispred nevertheless: tačka ili tačka i zarez

Ne mešajte

whereas i although – Whereas poredi dve različite činjenice (suprotnost). Although uvodi činjenicu zbog koje je druga iznenađujuća (dopuštanje). Whereas za iznenađujući rezultat zvuči pogrešno: recite Although the weather was bad, we enjoyed the trip. Pogledajte B1-26. Na srpskom je to razlika između „dok“ i „iako“.

Tom likes jazz, whereas Ella prefers rock.
Tom voli džez, dok Ela više voli rok.
samo različito
Although Tom likes jazz, he's never been to a jazz club.
Iako Tom voli džez, nikad nije bio u džez klubu.
iznenađujuće

however (veznik) i however + pridev – Kao veznik, however („međutim“) ima zarez posle sebe. Kao reč za dopuštanje („koliko god“), odmah posle njega dolazi pridev ili prilog.

The plan is good. However, it's expensive.
Plan je dobar. Međutim, skup je.
veznik
However good the plan is, it's too expensive.
Koliko god da je plan dobar, previše je skup.
„u kojoj god meri“

while (vreme) i while (suprotnost) – i srpsko „dok“ ima oba značenja.

While I was cooking, the phone rang.
Dok sam kuvala, zazvonio je telefon.
vreme
While Lisbon is hilly, Amsterdam is completely flat.
Dok je Lisabon brdovit, Amsterdam je potpuno ravan.
suprotnost

pridev + as + rečenica – Tired as she was, she finished the report je srodna emfatička konstrukcija iz C1-06.

Pravopis i izgovor

  • nevertheless i nonetheless pišu se kao jedna reč. Naglasak je na poslednjem slogu: /ˌnevəðəˈles/ (UK), /ˌnevərðəˈles/ (US); /ˌnʌnðəˈles/. Srpski naglasak nikad nije na poslednjem slogu, pa ovde treba vežbati. /ð/ je zvučni glas sa vrhom jezika između zuba – nije d ni z.
  • whereas /weərˈæz/ (UK), /werˈæz/ (US): jedna reč, naglasak na drugom slogu. Počinje zaobljenim usnama (/w/ nije srpsko v), a /æ/ je otvoreniji od srpskog e: usta otvorena kao za a, jezik napred kao za e.
  • Posle Nevertheless, / Even so, / That said, napravite kratku pauzu – zarez u pisanju je pauza u govoru.
  • U Much as I like him naglasite much i like. as je slabo: /əz/, sa kratkim, opuštenim samoglasnikom koji srpski nema.

Zlatno pravilo

Whereas / while koristite da pokažete da su dve stvari različite. Nevertheless, even so, that said, much as, no matter how, however + pridev, still i yet koristite kada nešto važi uprkos onome što ste upravo rekli. I zapamtite: posle much as ili while nema but, a pridev ide odmah posle how / however.

Vežbe

A. Oblik

Prepišite ili spojite rečenice pomoću reči u kurzivu.

  1. Prepišite sa much as: Although I really love chocolate, I'm trying to eat less of it.
  2. Prepišite sa however: It doesn't matter how hard I try — I can't remember her name.
  3. Prepišite sa no matter: It doesn't matter what people say — I'm going to follow my dream.
  4. Spojite sa whereas: My brother loves football. I can't stand it.
  5. Prepišite sa still: It was expensive, but we bought it anyway.
  6. Spojite sa nevertheless: The test was hard. Most students passed.

B. Značenje

Izaberite odgovor koji odgovara situaciji.

  1. Izaberite tačan odgovor: My dad loves jazz, … my mum prefers pop.
  2. Izaberite tačan odgovor: The test was hard. …, I think I passed.
  3. Izaberite tačan odgovor: No matter … you choose, I'll support you.
  4. Izaberite tačan odgovor: The hotel was cheap; …, it was very clean.
  5. Šta znači while u rečenici "While I understand your point, I can't agree"? …

C. Pronađite grešku

U svakoj rečenici postoji jedna greška ili je rečenica tačna. Napišite ispravljenu rečenicu ili napišite correct.

  1. Much as I enjoy parties, but I'm staying home tonight.
  2. No matter how I am busy, I always call my mum on Sundays.
  3. However I try hard, I can't understand this.
  4. She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.

D. U kontekstu

Dopunite tekst rečima iz okvira: whereas, that said, much as, however, still (svaku upotrebite jednom).

Hotel review: The Harbour Inn
The rooms at the Harbour Inn are small, 16 the views are spectacular. The restaurant is overpriced. 17, the desserts are amazing. 18 we loved the staff, we found the noise from the bar hard to bear. 19 early you go to bed, you'll hear the music until midnight. The noise was bad, but we 20 had a great time.

E. Vaš red

Pišite na engleskom o sebi i svojim odlukama.

  1. Uporedite sebe sa nekim koga poznajete pomoću whereas ili while.
  2. Napišite rečenicu sa much as ili no matter how o odluci koju ste doneli.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

Ponovite prethodne lekcije.

  1. B1-26 Although, despite ili however? Suprotnost na engleskom (iako, uprkos, međutim)
    … the rain, the match went ahead.
  2. B1-26 Although, despite ili however? Suprotnost na engleskom (iako, uprkos, međutim)
    She went to work … she felt ill.
  3. B2-22 Subject-verb agreement: news is ili news are? Slaganje subjekta i glagola na engleskom
    Neither the manager nor the staff … happy.
  4. B2-21 As if, as though, suppose i it's time: zamišljene situacije na engleskom objašnjene na srpskom
    It's high time we (leave).
Решења

A. Oblik

  1. Much as I love chocolate, I'm trying to eat less of it.
  2. However hard I try, I can't remember her name. / I can't remember her name, however hard I try.
  3. No matter what people say, I'm going to follow my dream. / I'm going to follow my dream, no matter what people say.
  4. My brother loves football, whereas I can't stand it. / Whereas my brother loves football, I can't stand it.
  5. It was expensive, but we still bought it. / It was expensive. We still bought it.
  6. The test was hard. Nevertheless, most students passed. / The test was hard; nevertheless, most students passed. / The test was hard. Most students nevertheless passed. / The test was hard. Most students passed nevertheless.

B. Značenje

  1. whereas
  2. Even so
  3. what
  4. nevertheless
  5. although

C. Pronađite grešku

  1. Much as I enjoy parties, I'm staying home tonight.
  2. No matter how busy I am, I always call my mum on Sundays.
  3. However hard I try, I can't understand this.
  4. ✓ She's a millionaire, yet she lives in a tiny flat.

D. U kontekstu

  1. whereas
  2. That said
  3. Much as
  4. However
  5. still

E. Vaš red

  1. My sister is very organised, whereas I'm always losing things.
  2. Much as I loved my old job, I needed a change.

F. Mešovito ponavljanje

  1. Despite
  2. although
  3. were
  4. left
Android апликацијаУчите у покрету Google Play