SlowingoSlovnica
B2 9 / 30

Reduced relative clauses: krajšanje oziralnih odvisnikov v angleščini

Reduced Relative Clauses: The Man Standing There

Na tej strani
  1. Cilj
  2. Glavna ideja
  3. Slovenščina in angleščina
  4. Oblika
  5. Raba
  6. Pogoste napake
  7. Pasti za govorce slovenščine
  8. Ne zamenjujte
  9. Pravopis in izgovorjava
  10. Zlato pravilo
  11. Vaje

Cilj

Po tej lekciji boste znali skrajšati oziralne odvisnike – the people living next door, the car stolen last night, the first person to arrive – in prepoznati, kdaj odvisnika ne moremo skrajšati.

Glavna ideja

Dobri govorci in pisci ne marajo odvečnih besed. V the woman who is standing by the door besedi who is ne dodata nič novega. Poslušalec poved razume tudi brez njiju. Zato ju angleščina dovoli odrezati: the woman standing by the door.

Predstavljajte si vrtnarja z vrtnimi škarjami. Odreže tisto, česar rastlina ne potrebuje – tu oziralni zaimek in pomožni glagol – in ohrani del, ki nosi pomen. Kar ostane, pove razmerje:

  • -ing oblika → samostalnik dejanje opravlja: the people living next door (oni tam živijo).
  • pretekli deležnik → nekaj se samostalniku zgodi: the car stolen last night (nekdo ga je ukradel).
  • nedoločnik s to → za the first / the last / the only / the next ali presežnikom: the first person to arrive (prvi, ki je prišel).

Rezultat je krajši in bolj tekoč. Zelo pogost je v novicah, obvestilih, navodilih in strokovnih besedilih.

Slovenščina in angleščina

V vsakdanji slovenščini skoraj vedno rečemo cel odvisnik s „ki“: „ljudje, ki živijo zraven“, „avto, ki so ga ukradli“. Krajše oblike poznamo predvsem iz pisnega jezika: „sedeči moški“, „ukradeni avto“, „avto, ukraden včeraj“. Pri tem slovenščina deležniško zvezo rada postavi pred samostalnik („včeraj ukradeni avto“). Angleščina daljšo zvezo vedno postavi za samostalnik: the car stolen yesterday.

Pazite še na trpnik s „se“. „Zelenjava, ki se prodaja na tržnici“ je trpna, čeprav je videti kot dejanje. V angleščini je to pretekli deležnik: the vegetables sold at the market. Za „prvi, ki …“, „edini, ki …“ slovenščina nima nedoločnika; angleščina pa tu rabi to + osnovna oblika: the first to go.

SlovenščinaAngleščinaV čem je razlika?
ženska, ki se pogovarja s tvojim očetomthe woman talking to your dadosebek dela → -ing
zelenjava, ki se prodaja na tržnicithe vegetables sold at the market„se“-trpnik → pretekli deležnik
včeraj ukradeni avtothe car stolen yesterdayzveza stoji za samostalnikom
prva v družini, ki je šla na fakultetothe first in her family to go to university„prvi, ki …“ → to + osnovna oblika
moški, ki je klical včerajthe man who called yesterdayenkratno preteklo dejanje: cel odvisnik
torta, ki sem jo speklathe cake (that) I madeTu je enako: predmetni odvisnik ne dobi -ing

Na kratko: kar samostalnik dela, je -ing; kar se mu zgodi (tudi „se prodaja“), je pretekli deležnik; „prvi / edini, ki …“ je to + glagol; zveza pa vedno stoji za samostalnikom.

Oblika

Od celega do skrajšanega odvisnika

VrstaCel oziralni odvisnikSkrajšano
Tvornothe people who live next doorthe people living next door
Tvorno (v teku)the man who is sitting therethe man sitting there
Trpnothe car which was stolen last nightthe car stolen last night
Trpno (v teku)the issues that are being discussedthe issues being discussed
Za first / last / only / next / presežnikomthe first person who arrivedthe first person to arrive
Isto, trpnothe last person who was toldthe last person to be told

Kako skrajšamo

KorakKaj naredimo
1Preverite: oziralni zaimek mora biti osebek odvisnika.
2Tvorno → odstranite oziralni zaimek (in be, če je) → uporabite -ing obliko.
3Trpno → odstranite oziralni zaimek + be → ohranite pretekli deležnik.
4Za first / last / only / next ali presežnikom → uporabite nedoločnik s to.

Kdaj ne moremo skrajšati

Položaj✅ Cel odvisnik❌ Skrajšano
Enkratno, končano dejanje v preteklosti (tvorno)the man who called yesterdaythe man calling yesterday
Oziralni zaimek je predmetthe film that I watchedthe film watching
Glagol ima naklonski glagol ali perfektno oblikopeople who can drive / the man who has lived here for yearspeople driving (drug pomen) / the man having lived here for years

Raba

1Tvorni pomen: -ing oblika

-ing obliko uporabite, ko samostalnik dejanje opravlja. Nadomesti lahko glagol v teku (who is talking) in tudi preprost glagol za splošno dejstvo ali stanje (who live, which contains). Pri glagolih stanja je -ing oblika tu pravilna, čeprav sicer ne stojijo v obliki v teku.

Who's the woman talking to your dad?
Kdo je ženska, ki se pogovarja s tvojim očetom?
= who is talking
Passengers travelling to Manchester should change at Crewe.
Potniki, ki potujejo v Manchester, naj prestopijo v Crewu.
= who are travelling
I've found a website selling second-hand textbooks.
Našel sem spletno stran, ki prodaja rabljene učbenike.
= which sells
The man sitting next to me on the plane snored all night.
Moški, ki je sedel poleg mene na letalu, je vso noč smrčal.
= who was sitting
We need a box containing all the cables.
Potrebujemo škatlo, v kateri so vsi kabli.
= which contains: glagol stanja
Anyone wishing to leave early should speak to the organiser.
Kdor želi oditi prej, naj se oglasi pri organizatorju.

2Trpni pomen: pretekli deležnik

Pretekli deležnik uporabite, ko se nekaj samostalniku zgodi. Nadomesti who / which / that + be + pretekli deležnik v vseh časih, tudi za enkratno dejanje v preteklosti. V slovenščini je tu pogosto „se“-trpnik.

The car stolen from outside our house was found in a car park.
Avto, ki so ga ukradli pred našo hišo, so našli na parkirišču.
= which was stolen; car park (UK) = parking lot (US)
Most of the vegetables sold at the market are grown locally.
Večina zelenjave, ki se prodaja na tržnici, zraste v okolici.
„ki se prodaja“ → sold, ne selling
Is this the photo taken at Grandma's 80th birthday?
Je to fotografija z babičinega 80. rojstnega dne?
= which was taken
Applications received after 30 June will not be accepted.
Prijav, prispelih po 30. juniju, ne bomo upoštevali.
slovenski deležnik za samostalnikom: enako kot v angleščini
The issues being discussed today affect everyone.
Vprašanja, o katerih danes razpravljamo, zadevajo vse.
trpnik v teku: being + pretekli deležnik

3Nedoločnik s to za first, last, only, next in presežniki

Za the first, the second, the last, the next, the only in presežniki (the youngest, the best) namesto oziralnega odvisnika uporabite nedoločnik s to. Lahko je tvoren ali trpen, to have + pretekli deležnik pa pokaže prejšnje dejanje. Slovenščina tu ohrani „ki“.

She was the first woman in her family to go to university.
Bila je prva ženska v družini, ki je šla na fakulteto.
„prva, ki je šla“ → the first to go
The last person to leave the office should switch off the lights.
Kdor zadnji odide iz pisarne, naj ugasne luči.
At 19, she became the youngest player to win the title.
Pri 19 letih je postala najmlajša igralka, ki je osvojila naslov.
presežnik + to
I was the last to be told about the changes.
O spremembah so mi povedali zadnjemu.
trpno: to be + pretekli deležnik
He's the only one to have read the whole report.
Edini je, ki je prebral celotno poročilo.
to have + pretekli deležnik: prebral ga je

4Kdaj odvisnika ne moremo skrajšati

Odvisnik lahko skrajšate samo, ko je oziralni zaimek njegov osebek. Pri tvornem glagolu ne uporabljajte -ing oblike za enkratno, končano preteklo dejanje – ohranite cel odvisnik. Cel odvisnik ohranite tudi, ko ima glagol naklonski glagol (can, should, will) ali perfektno obliko (has lived): -ing oblika bi ta pomen izgubila. Ko je oziralni zaimek predmet, ga lahko le izpustite (B1-20).

The man who called yesterday left a message.
Moški, ki je včeraj klical, je pustil sporočilo.
ne „the man calling yesterday“
The student who won the prize last year is giving a speech.
Študent, ki je lani dobil nagrado, ima govor.
enkraten pretekli dogodek
The burglar who broke into our flat has been caught.
Vlomilca, ki je vlomil v naše stanovanje, so prijeli.
flat (UK) = apartment (US)
We need someone who can drive.
Potrebujemo nekoga, ki zna voziti.
naklonski glagol: „someone driving“ bi pomenilo nekaj drugega
The man who has lived next door for thirty years is moving out.
Moški, ki že trideset let živi zraven nas, se izseljuje.
perfekt: ohranite cel odvisnik
The cake that I made for the party was a disaster.
Torta, ki sem jo spekla za zabavo, je bila polom.
predmet: lahko rečete „the cake I made“, ne pa z -ing

Pogoste napake

❌The man calling you yesterday was my uncle.
✅The man who called you yesterday was my uncle.
Eno končano preteklo dejanje: uporabite cel odvisnik.
❌The book writing by my aunt is a bestseller.
✅The book written by my aunt is a bestseller.
Trpni pomen → pretekli deležnik.
❌The people lived next door are very noisy.
✅The people living next door are very noisy.
Tvorni skrajšani odvisnik → -ing, ne Past Simple.
❌The documents sending yesterday have arrived.
✅The documents sent yesterday have arrived.
Dokumenti ne pošiljajo; nekdo jih pošlje → sent.
❌The girl standing by the window she is my cousin.
✅The girl standing by the window is my cousin.
Osebka ne ponavljajte.
❌The film I watching last night was boring.
✅The film I watched last night was boring.
Predmetni odvisnik: oziralni zaimek samo izpustite (B1-20); -ing ne uporabite.
⚠️She was the first person arriving at the party.
✅She was the first person to arrive at the party.
Za the first / last / only je naravna izbira nedoločnik s to.

Pasti za govorce slovenščine

1. „Ki se streže“ → serving. Slovenski trpnik s „se“ je videti kot dejanje, ki ga osebek opravlja sam. Zato ga mnogi skrajšajo z -ing obliko. Ko pa se nekaj stvari zgodi (nekdo jo streže, okrasi, izdela), angleščina rabi pretekli deležnik.

❌The gingerbread hearts decorating by hand in a small workshop in Radovljica are sold at the Christmas fair in Ljubljana.
✅The gingerbread hearts decorated by hand in a small workshop in Radovljica are sold at the Christmas fair in Ljubljana.
„ki se okrašujejo“ → decorated
❌The trout serving in most restaurants along the Soca valley comes from fish farms near Tolmin.
✅The trout served in most restaurants along the Soca valley comes from fish farms near Tolmin.
postrv nekdo streže → served

2. „Lani obnovljeni grad“ → the last year renovated castle. V pisni slovenščini deležniško zvezo radi postavimo pred samostalnik. V angleščini pred samostalnikom stoji kvečjemu en sam deležnik (a renovated castle); zveza z dodatki stoji za samostalnikom.

❌We booked a tour of the last year renovated castle above Celje for our class reunion in June.
✅We booked a tour of the castle above Celje renovated last year for our class reunion in June. ali We booked a tour of the castle above Celje, which was renovated last year, for our class reunion in June.
zveza stoji za samostalnikom
❌The by the storm damaged footbridge over the Krka near Kostanjevica will stay closed until the autumn.
✅The footbridge over the Krka near Kostanjevica damaged by the storm will stay closed until the autumn. ali The footbridge over the Krka near Kostanjevica, which was damaged by the storm, will stay closed until the autumn.
by + povzročitelj za samostalnikom

3. „Edini, ki je …“ → the only one knowing. Slovenščina za „prvi, zadnji, edini“ ohrani odvisnik s „ki“ in nima nedoločnika. Ko skrajšujete, mnogi zato posežejo po -ing obliki. Za the first / the last / the only in presežniki je naravna izbira nedoločnik s to.

⚠️My grandfather was the only one in our village owning a tractor, so all the neighbours borrowed it during the hay harvest.
✅My grandfather was the only one in our village to own a tractor, so all the neighbours borrowed it during the hay harvest. ali My grandfather was the only one in our village who owned a tractor, so all the neighbours borrowed it during the hay harvest.
Slovnično je pravilno, vendar je za the only naravna izbira nedoločnik s to.

Ne zamenjujte

-ing (tvorno) ali pretekli deležnik (trpno) – Kdo opravlja dejanje? Deluje kot boring / bored v A2-30.

There's a dog chasing a cat in the garden.
Na vrtu pes lovi mačko.
pes lovi
The cat chased by the dog is safe now.
Mačka, ki jo je lovil pes, je zdaj na varnem.
mačko lovijo

skrajšani odvisnik ali izpuščeni predmetni zaimek – dve različni bližnjici. Ko je oziralni zaimek predmet, ga lahko preprosto izpustite (B1-20); ko je osebek, odvisnik skrajšate z deležnikom.

The song she sang was beautiful.
Pesem, ki jo je zapela, je bila čudovita.
predmet: that je izpuščen
The woman singing that song is my sister.
Ženska, ki poje tisto pesem, je moja sestra.
osebek: who is singing → singing

skrajšani oziralni odvisnik ali deležniški stavek – Skrajšani odvisnik stoji takoj za samostalnikom in pove, katerega mislimo. Deležniški stavek na začetku povedi opiše, kaj je osebek delal; razložen je v B2-10.

The woman standing by the door is my aunt.
Ženska, ki stoji pri vratih, je moja teta.
katera ženska: skrajšani odvisnik
Standing by the door, my aunt waved goodbye.
Teta je stala pri vratih in mahala v slovo.
kaj je delala: deležniški stavek

Pravopis in izgovorjava

  • Skrajšani določujoči odvisniki nimajo vejic in premora: The man standing there is my boss. Slovenske navade, da pred odvisnikom stoji vejica, tu ne prenašajte. Skrajšani nedoločujoči odvisnik pa vejice obdrži (B2-08): The bridge, built in 1890, is still in use.
  • Pazite na nepravilne pretekle deležnike: written, taken, built, stolen, chosen, held, sold, sent.
  • Zapis -ing oblike: nemi e odpade (leave → leaving), za kratkim naglašenim samoglasnikom se končni soglasnik podvoji (sit → sitting), lie → lying.
  • Končnica -ing je /ɪŋ/: en sam nosni glas v zadnjem delu ust, brez dodanega g na koncu.
  • Deležnik ni bolj poudarjen od samostalnika: the people living next door izgovorimo tekoče, kot eno skupino, z glavnim naglasom na door /dɔː/ (UK), /dɔːr/ (US).

Zlato pravilo

Odrežite oziralni zaimek in pomožni glagol: samostalnik dejanje opravlja → -ing; nekaj se mu zgodi (tudi slovenski „se prodaja“) → pretekli deležnik; za first / last / only / next / presežnikom → nedoločnik s to. Skrajšajte samo, ko je oziralni zaimek osebek, in ne uporabljajte -ing za enkratno končano preteklo dejanje ali namesto naklonskega ali perfektnega glagola. Daljša zveza vedno stoji za samostalnikom.

Vaje

A. Oblika

Skrajšajte oziralne odvisnike.

  1. Skrajšajte: The girl who is playing the piano is only eight.
  2. Skrajšajte: The bridge which was built in 1890 is still in use.
  3. Skrajšajte: She was the first person in our town who drove an electric car.
  4. Skrajšajte: Students who want to join the trip should sign up today.
  5. Skrajšajte: The problems that are being discussed are serious.
  6. Skrajšajte: He was the only player who was chosen for both teams.

B. Pomen

Izberite pravilni odgovor.

  1. Izberite pravilni odgovor: The money … at the event went to charity.
  2. Izberite pravilni odgovor: Do you know the guy … the red jacket?
  3. Izberite pravilni odgovor: She was the only candidate … every question correctly.
  4. Ali lahko ta odvisnik skrajšamo? "the dress that she bought last week" …
  5. Ali lahko ta odvisnik skrajšamo? "the train that leaves at 9:15" …

C. Poiščite napako

V vsaki povedi je ena napaka ali pa je poved pravilna. Napišite popravljeno poved ali napišite correct.

  1. The email sending by the bank was a scam.
  2. The woman phoning the office this morning didn't leave her name.
  3. The people waiting outside have been there for an hour.
  4. The house built by my grandfather it is still standing.

D. V kontekstu

Dopolnite obvestilo z glagolom iz oklepaja v pravilni obliki.

Notice at the station
Passengers 16 (travel) to the airport should use platform 2. Trains 17 (leave) after 11 p.m. will stop at all stations. Luggage 18 (leave) unattended will be removed. The last train 19 (stop) at Hill Park tonight departs at 23:40. Tickets 20 (buy) on the train cost 50% more.

E. Na vrsti ste vi

Pišite v angleščini s skrajšanimi odvisniki.

  1. Z -ing obliko opišite dva človeka na fotografiji ali v prostoru, v katerem ste.
  2. Napišite nekaj o dosežku z the first / the only / the youngest + nedoločnik s to.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

Ponovite snov prejšnjih lekcij.

  1. B2-08 Non-defining relative clauses: oziralni odvisniki z vejicami v angleščini
    My sister, ___ lives in Madrid, is a doctor. …
  2. A2-30 Bored ali boring? Pridevniki na -ed in -ing v angleščini
    The film was really ….
  3. B1-11 Trpnik v vseh časih in z naklonskimi glagoli: is being done, has been done, must be done
    The new hospital (build) at the moment.
  4. B2-07 Need, needn't have in be supposed to: obveznost in nujnost v angleščini
    The bus (supposed to arrive) at eight, but it came at half past.
Rešitve

A. Oblika

  1. The girl playing the piano is only eight.
  2. The bridge built in 1890 is still in use.
  3. She was the first person in our town to drive an electric car.
  4. Students wanting to join the trip should sign up today.
  5. The problems being discussed are serious.
  6. He was the only player to be chosen for both teams. / He was the only player chosen for both teams.

B. Pomen

  1. raised
  2. wearing
  3. to answer
  4. No
  5. Yes

C. Poiščite napako

  1. The email sent by the bank was a scam.
  2. The woman who phoned the office this morning didn't leave her name. / The woman who called the office this morning didn't leave her name.
  3. ✓ The people waiting outside have been there for an hour.
  4. The house built by my grandfather is still standing.

D. V kontekstu

  1. travelling
  2. leaving
  3. left
  4. to stop / stopping
  5. bought

E. Na vrsti ste vi

  1. The man sitting by the window is reading a newspaper. The woman wearing a red coat is my neighbour.
  2. My grandmother was the first person in her village to go to university.

F. Mešano ponavljanje

  1. who
  2. boring
  3. is being built
  4. was supposed to arrive
Aplikacija za AndroidUčite se na poti Google Play